So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well wait, though. The "Skepchicks" organization (such as it were) is a number of years old already. It's one thing to point out that females had a roughly 50% showing at this year's TAM, but it's relevant as a counterpoint to the Skepchicks' claims only if those claims were first put forward this year. Otherwise, I think it would be honest to assess the showings of the last several years' TAMs - since the "Skepchicks" came about, preferably - and see if the numbers trend in any particular direction. If there tend to be more female presenters and attendees each year, I think a discussion can be had as to whether there is a link between that fact and the Skepchicks' attempts at awareness-raising.

Sure. The only problem with this is that Watson's bombastic feminist posturing is also a new thing. Watson freely admits this (do you want references?). If Skepchick played any role in getting more women there, then it was not because they were playing the sexism card heavy handed, because they weren't doing it.

Cyndi Lauper's biggest hit was "Girls Just Want to Have Fun." It wasn't "Wimmin Just Want to Gnash Their Teeth and Insult Other Women."

Do you see the difference between the approaches?
 
Here's another signature for comparison, NSFW:


2708158079_b11d944826.jpg

 
I think I use the 'skeptical community', and these forums specifically, as a stand in for an actual social life, which can lead to problems. Now I can see how those with severe social ineptitude doing the same thing for a similar reason.

Sometimes it seems like I come here because I believe people actually read (or listen to) what I have to say. Skepticism, by it's very nature, means people have to pay attention and not dismiss out of hand. This can lead to the, often false, perception that people are listening to what you have to say because they care about you. For people who are so socially poor that in general life people simply don't listen because they are annoyed, dislike, or otherwise just don't care about, this type of 'attention' can be addictive.

Then when this perceived attention becomes something they feel entitled to, even greater problems arise. Some other people have already speculated on miss Watson's psychological attitude, but I'm being just general. The dismissal of their opinions or denial of engagement on the narrow topic they feel entitled to debate happens, they can get very upset.

Cognitively I'm aware that very few people care what I have to say in the skeptical community, or in general life, because of me as a person. They don't care about the person; they care about the argument. Here, it is my arguments drawing attention, care, and consideration. It isn't me. Yet I still find myself checking these forums and posting more when I'm feeling ignored and neglected in general life. Much more in fact. I lurk otherwise because I'm genuinely interested in all these subjects. However, if someone like myself who is well aware consciously of this psychological motivation still falls for it, how much more powerful can the effect be on someone truly socially devoid and less self skeptical? No wonder those people are drawn to groups, like skepticism, which place higher value on externalities than internalities

As disappointed as a lot of this elevator thing, it has led to many interesting side discussions. Plus one can see who is willing to be truly self skeptical, and who is not.
 
Sure. The only problem with this is that Watson's bombastic feminist posturing is also a new thing. Watson freely admits this (do you want references?). If Skepchick played any role in getting more women there, then it was not because they were playing the sexism card heavy handed, because they weren't doing it.

Cyndi Lauper's biggest hit was "Girls Just Want to Have Fun." It wasn't "Wimmin Just Want to Gnash Their Teeth and Insult Other Women."

Do you see the difference between the approaches?

I certainly see the difference; I just noticed you and some others coming a bit close to dismissing the claim of "under-representation of females at events like TAM" itself, as a casualty of association with certain individuals' hypotheses of the cause of that under-representation, even though those are two different things. Although I didn't make a count of attendees, I do distinctly remember only one female presenter, and one single female panel member, at TAM 4.
 
Hehe. Actually, one of the things that really turns me off about skepticism is that they seem to, for whatever reason, have a lot higher percentage of people who are really socially inept. I think it's a minority of skeptics, and I appreciate that this behavior is almost always called out by others...but that small percentage is a way higher percentage than any other social group I personally interact with. Sometimes I can't believe the posts people put on skeptic websites - often by the more prominant members of the community. And by "socially inept" I don't mean shy and awkward. I mean people who act like they are spoiled 12 year olds.....

I am completely with you on this. I had only been to one TAM prior to this one as not-an-employee. I didn't have a good time at that one (TAM 5). I didn't have a good time at any of the ones I'm working, but kind of put it on the fact that I was working (even though that wasn't really the reason), and then had a godawful time at this one. And I'm never going to return. So, between you and me, SC, that's two women lost to TAM for reasons that have nothing to do with feminism.
 
I am completely with you on this. I had only been to one TAM prior to this one as not-an-employee. I didn't have a good time at that one (TAM 5). I didn't have a good time at any of the ones I'm working, but kind of put it on the fact that I was working (even though that wasn't really the reason), and then had a godawful time at this one. And I'm never going to return. So, between you and me, SC, that's two women lost to TAM for reasons that have nothing to do with feminism.

I left for both the feminism and the creeping disappointment!

Although I was truly, truly sorry to have missed Richard Wiseman and Eugenie Scott this year. It would be lovely if someone would set up a remote, virtual TAM using this here internet gadget. All of the lectures, none of the crap.
 
Hehe. Actually, one of the things that really turns me off about skepticism is that they seem to, for whatever reason, have a lot higher percentage of people who are really socially inept. I think it's a minority of skeptics, and I appreciate that this behavior is almost always called out by others...but that small percentage is a way higher percentage than any other social group I personally interact with. Sometimes I can't believe the posts people put on skeptic websites - often by the more prominant members of the community. And by "socially inept" I don't mean shy and awkward. I mean people who act like they are spoiled 12 year olds.

Incidentally, the reason I brought up the "saying God Bless you" example is because I have actually seen a thread in which a poster was called out by another poster for what a horrible person he was because he stated that he didn't particularly mind if someone says "God Bless You" if someone sneezes. I remember one of my very first posts on JREF was a "Happy Earth Day" post, to which I was ripped to shreds by someone who couldn't believe I would say "Happy Earth Day" when planet Earth sucks because natural disasters exist. Yet another post featured a poster who only has one hand being ripped apart by another poster for typing errors (and I don't mean these errors were simply pointed out to him, the complainer acted offended by them), and when the poster told him that he only had one hand, the complaining poster said that was no excuse and further ridiculed him. I could give many other examples. My own husband, who is a theist but doesn't have strong religious opinions, joined JREF briefly, but he soon became a lurker who doesn't post after he was mocked repeatedly and viciously for not being an atheist, with some people labeling him a fundamentalist even though he doesn't even prescribe to a particular religious belief, he just believes in God and reincarnation and the soul, and that's about it.

That's the kind of juvenile pettiness I have seen no where else but in skeptic circles. (again, amongst groups that I personally am involved in, I'm not saying skeptics have a monopoly on this kind of behavior).

It may be a minority, but it still stands out when you're not used to that sort of thing at all.


I've got a lot of interests, and a lot of those interests have big group activities/events. And even if this sort of thing doesn't happen often in skeptic circles, in all the other groups I participate with, this sort of ridiculousness never happens. And if I have to chose between investing myself in group A) socially well adjusted people who don't have members who act like they have never interacted with a live person, and group B) where a small - but noticable - percentage of people act that way, often people who tend to dominate discussions... I'm going spend my money and vacation days on group A.

I mean, if I had unlimited time and money, that would be different. But skepticism isn't a priority. And this "elevatorgate" only cemented this opinion in my mind.



well that's a relief at least.

Do you view these forums as socialization? I see them as a place where people match wits and advocate positions in an environment that seems to encourage a variety of positions and therefore to encourage conflict. Most of the skeptical blogs I see are similar in nature, often written in response (and opposition) to some outside event/argument, just like the threads started here. Your dismay could simply be the result of unrealistic expectations.

What are your experiences with face-to-face meetings of skeptics in a group setting?
 
I certainly see the difference; I just noticed you and some others coming a bit close to dismissing the claim of "under-representation of females at events like TAM" itself, as a casualty of association with certain individuals' hypotheses of the cause of that under-representation, even though those are two different things. Although I didn't make a count of attendees, I do distinctly remember only one female presenter, and one single female panel member, at TAM 4.

Well, I wasn't. (ETA: Trying to dismiss, that is.)

TAM 9 is one datum amongst many, and as far as I'm aware, nobody has done any kind of overall study--it's just anecdotal. (ETA: I'd really like to see such a study, but it's no good just assuming it and saying that everyone questions is "dismissing.")

Note, please, that one of the women who disagrees with Watson spent three years doing this stuff for the JREF, and it's possible that she knows more about how to attract women and has done more to attract women to TAM than Watson.

There are several layers of increasing importance, but I'll skip over them.

I don't object to Watson's neophyte feminist view that it's all on account of sexism. There are many people, including many women (including Kirby) who disagree with here, which is fine. Ultimately, though, it's a question that is primarily factual. That is, it's the kind of question more likely to be answered by someone like an anthropologist than by an ideologue.

This is where I find the greatest problem with Watson. She newly approaches this and other issues in a dogmatic fashion. She misrepresents Kirby, and she heaps a fair amount of abuse onto any woman (not to mention men, but she seems to target more women) who does not agree with her. They are all "parroting misogyny"; they are ignorant of Feminism 101; they may even at times be gender traitors.

Entirely apart from whether you or I think that women are underrepresented in skepticism, or what you or I think is the reason, the way that Watson conducts herself in this regard is extremely anti-skeptical, not to mention anti-rational.
 
Last edited:
** I think I put this on the wrong thread so I will put it here.

I visit a 10 story building with an elevator and a guard on the first floor. I've been very conscious of taking the elevator alone with woman who are strangers lately. I'm a fairly good looking average guy and I find myself wondering what would ever possess me to ask this stranger to my place for coffee if I lived there. I doubt very much any of them would ever accept as it would seem kinda slutty what with me being a stranger and maybe even possibly dangerous since they don't know me.

Then I factor in the time of day and I notice the later it is the worse it would be to the point that if I did this consistently to strangers there at 4am I'm certain one of them would report me to management for the above reasons. I'm certain I would feel kinda creepy doing it. If I want to meet one of the woman in the building I will find a better, less alarming, way then that.

The point of a blog is to write about one's personal experiences and so it's certainly within the norm for RW to blog on this event in her life and her impressions of it. That's what blogs are for. And it was pretty mild.

The rest of the event and accusations I have no opinion on.
 
Do you view these forums as socialization? I see them as a place where people match wits and advocate positions in an environment that seems to encourage a variety of positions and therefore to encourage conflict. Most of the skeptical blogs I see are similar in nature, often written in response (and opposition) to some outside event/argument, just like the threads started here. Your dismay could simply be the result of unrealistic expectations.

Much, much wailing and gnashing of teeth has been had over the concept of the forum as a "community", ever since some hapless fellow doing his job suggested that the JREF didn't get anything tangible out of it. He was promptly torn apart and eaten. Dismissing it as "merely a forum" is a shark tank you may not want to jump into.
 
I like to think the OP issue is a grey issue.

Having said that let me tell another Hojo story (home of my ass being groped when I was 16). I'm 17 now and around 2:45AM on a Saturday morning I
am leaving work (that's when busboys left on Saturdays) and I see a pretty waitress I worked with in the parking lot surrounded by helping fellows helping her get her car started. I leave the lot feeling fine. I've done nothing wrong because I know little of getting cars started and thinking a 27 year old waitress would wish to have the aid of adults over a 17 year old. The next time I see her I ask how her car is and she asked me if I saw what happened at that early morning hour and when I said yes she was pissed off (an understatement). She asked why I didn't come to her aid. I said she looked to me to have had plenty of aid. She said those men around her not only didn't start her car for her but threatened sexual assault. I completely misread the situation while driving by (I was a well intentioned idiot (The story of my life.) I vow that will never happen again but it is a double standard and I will not deny that female motorists who are in need should get your attention -- however males who look to be alright are on their own. It is a double standard.
 
...I find myself wondering what would ever possess me to ask this stranger to my place for coffee if I lived there.
Please forgive me but I think you have made the same error as so many others have. You demonstrate a degree of solipsism that is incapable of seeing the world from any view point other than yours. You have theory of mind so you are not that solipsistic. The problem is that while you can empathize with what you believe would be the response of these women you can't imagine that other people could do just than and be rather successful. It's an error in logic.
  • I can't imagine scaling sheer cliff walls.
  • I can't imagine finishing the seals 6 month training course.
  • I can't imagine asking lots of women out the way many alpha males do.
Therefore others can't imagine these things either and/or these things are bad or they are wrong?

What you can or can't imagine isn't a basis for moral judgement.
 
Please forgive me but I think you have made the same error as so many others have. You demonstrate a degree of solipsism that is incapable of seeing the world from any view point other than yours. You have theory of mind so you are not that solipsistic. The problem is that while you can empathize with what you believe would be the response of these women you can't imagine that other people could do just than and be rather successful. It's an error in logic.
  • I can't imagine scaling sheer cliff walls.
  • I can't imagine finishing the seals 6 month training course.
  • I can't imagine asking lots of women out the way many alpha males do.
Therefore others can't imagine these things either and/or these things are bad or they are wrong?

What you can or can't imagine isn't a basis for moral judgement.

Sorry I thought I made it clear I was speaking only for myself. That's why I was referencing myself and not you, or a set. Just communicating a personal opinion. I have no idea what you would do or some imagined set of people.

ETA But I stand by the conclusion that if you or an "alpha male" came to this 10 story building and did this at 4am, over the course of less then a week, someone would report you to the guard. But this is probably based on the classiness of the building, clientele, and neighborhood.
 
Last edited:
Sorry I thought I made it clear I was speaking only for myself. That's why I was referencing myself and not you, or a set. Just communicating a personal opinion. I have no idea what you would do or some imagined set of people.

ETA But I stand by the conclusion that if you or an "alpha male" came to this 10 story building and did this at 4am, over the course of less then a week, someone would report you to the guard.
You are sharing this with others. There must be some reason you offered the information. But fair enough.

I think a hotel with a bar is a little bit different than many other building i.e. apartments, businesses (I worked in a business building that was accesible 24 hours a day. I programmed graveyard), etc.

In any event, I'm guessing that George Clooney, Brad Pitt or most rock stars could pick up women pretty much anywhere any time.
 
The point of a blog is to write about one's personal experiences and so it's certainly within the norm for RW to blog on this event in her life and her impressions of it. That's what blogs are for. And it was pretty mild.

Very few people here have a serious disagreement with this.

The rest of the event and accusations I have no opinion on.

Yeah well, then you don't have an opinion on the primary points. Not a bad thing, just not all that relevant.
 
Well, I wasn't. (ETA: Trying to dismiss, that is.)

TAM 9 is one datum amongst many, and as far as I'm aware, nobody has done any kind of overall study--it's just anecdotal. (ETA: I'd really like to see such a study, but it's no good just assuming it and saying that everyone questions is "dismissing.")

Note, please, that one of the women who disagrees with Watson spent three years doing this stuff for the JREF, and it's possible that she knows more about how to attract women and has done more to attract women to TAM than Watson.

There are several layers of increasing importance, but I'll skip over them.

I don't object to Watson's neophyte feminist view that it's all on account of sexism. There are many people, including many women (including Kirby) who disagree with here, which is fine. Ultimately, though, it's a question that is primarily factual. That is, it's the kind of question more likely to be answered by someone like an anthropologist than by an ideologue.

This is where I find the greatest problem with Watson. She newly approaches this and other issues in a dogmatic fashion. She misrepresents Kirby, and she heaps a fair amount of abuse onto any woman (not to mention men, but she seems to target more women) who does not agree with her. They are all "parroting misogyny"; they are ignorant of Feminism 101; they may even at times be gender traitors.
The issue is not whether EG wanted sex or not. That is a side issue with a tad of sexism in the assumptions that "I find you interesting" is only "I want to screw". It is perfectly possible he was hoping for a romantic relationship and sex was not the primary goal.

But, EG's goals remain a side issue.

The dogmatic approach, my way or misogyny, was the larger issue.

Entirely apart from whether you or I think that women are underrepresented in skepticism, or what you or I think is the reason, the way that Watson conducts herself in this regard is extremely anti-skeptical, not to mention anti-rational.
Yes, this.
 
Yeah well, then you don't have an opinion on the primary points. Not a bad thing, just not all that relevant.

No, you're right. I was just trying to avoid getting sucked into the "but she called it this or said that" part as I haven't been following it that closely. Should have put it in a better way.
 
...

Note, please, that one of the women who disagrees with Watson spent three years doing this stuff for the JREF, and it's possible that she knows more about how to attract women and has done more to attract women to TAM than Watson.

When choosing speakers for TAM, each member of the staff made a list of 'A-list' speakers they personally wanted to see. There was one additional list (with tally marks) comprised of speakers requested on the feedback forms by attendees of the previous TAM. All these lists were collated, in order, from 'most requested' to 'least requested'. We'd then go down the lists, ten or so at a time, and send out invites in that order.

So, if twenty people from the previous TAM asked for Jon Stewart, and so did three staff members, Jon Stewart would be near the top of the collated list (with twenty-three 'votes'), and would be invited early on.

The reason there weren't as many female speakers at previous TAMs, in my view, is because that is how things were done. There was no particular effort to invite more females simply because they were female. Additionally, from what I've seen of female speakers since added, most have very specific areas of interest - not necessarily a broad 'skeptic' appeal.

For instance, Michael Shermer, Ben Radford, James Randi, Penn Jillette, Barry Karr, and Joe Nickell can all be called 'broad skeptics'. Give them any topic related to the paranormal and skepticism, and they'll be fine on presenting. And the attendees of TAM chose those people more than, say, a random astrophysicist because those are the names that opened the world of skepticism to them in the first place. There just aren't as many women that fit the bill. In fact, I think it's pretty much just Mary Roach (who, by the way, I ensured was invited to every TAM that happened while I was employed by the JREF).

It is also important to note that TAM is now themed.

So, let me see if I'm explaining this correctly.

At the point at which TAM attendees filled out their feedback forms with speakers they hoped to see the next year, no theme had been chosen. People were, therefore, choosing speaker hopefuls based on a principle of broad application to skepticism. Because of this, fewer female speakers were listed as hopefuls, because there aren't terribly many female speakers with broad skeptical application (and I don't mean just 'women in the skeptical movement'. I'm talking about published female skeptics - people with the same number of credentials as the male speakers I listed in the other paragraph). And, because the speaker invites were sent out based on the number of requests received for them, the proportion of women invited to speak was very small.

Now that speakers are chosen based on their application to a theme, though, and since most females in the skeptical movement have a particular area of expertise, the proportion will necessarily be larger.

At least, that's how I see it. I don't think this is a function of TAM becoming more diverse because someone is weighing the value of a speaker based on their gender. It would actually bug me if the JREF was seeking out female speakers because they were female instead of because they were experts in what was being discussed.
 
At least, that's how I see it. I don't think this is a function of TAM becoming more diverse because someone is weighing the value of a speaker based on their gender. It would actually bug me if the JREF was seeking out female speakers because they were female instead of because they were experts in what was being discussed.

{trying to give this sentiment my own personal spin}

I would be thrilled if Eugenie Scott appeared at every TAM because she's credentialed, topical and awesome. I'd be happy that she appeared because it's nice to have more women speakers.

{did that work?}
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom