So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
I am still mystified at RW's thought process.

She is intellectually dishonest and has an integrity problem.

You can try to figure it out if you want, but that way lies madness. It's more productive to argue with a spastic colon or bang your head against a brick wall and look at the pretty red stain.
 
Last edited:
You would have thought Rebecca would have been cheered by this situation. She has been complaining about getting hit on over and over and over again. Now, she goes to a conference and is hit on one time only. This should have been a vblog about how her message is getting out there and thanking skeptical men for listening and doing such a good job of modifying their behavior.

Linda
 
I can guarantee you that I will never go to a TAM conference or other large skeptical gathering.

I don't think what EG did was a big deal. If it had happened to me, I would have forgotten about it five minutes later.

While I found it weird that this incident made a big enough impact in Rebecca's life that she thought to mention it at all, nevermind blog about it, I don't think what she did was a big deal either. It was a brief complaint about something that made her uncomfortable. Much like if I hypothetically had been the one in the elevator with EG, if I had hypothetically seen Rebecca's video blog in which she mentioned it prior to being aware of the resulting controversy, I wouldn't have given that a second thought either.

I thought Dawkin's response was overdramatic. Rebecca just complained briefly, and he made it seem like she had victimized herself and actually compared herself to a Muslim woman who had been genitally mutiliated, when she did no such thing. But I still didn't think that was so big a deal either.

I thought Dawkin's response was inappropriate, but not as inappropriate as Myer's and other bloggers, who seemed to make a way bigger deal out of the incident than Rebecca initially did herself and used way more inflammatory language - they were "freaked out" "appalled" at this "creep" who, in some cases, "made them ashamed to be a man."

And then, the responses to the responses, both from Rebecca and her supporting bloggers, as well as her attackers just strain the realms of credulity. Both sides increasingly villainizing the others like both the elevator incident, or Rebecca's response to it, or Dawkin's response to that, were about the worst things to ever happen to the skeptic community. And most of the attacks from both sides which are completely lying about what the other side is claiming. I see supporting bloggers claiming that Dawkins and others are pro rape - and that anyone who doesn't agree with Rebeccas is anti-woman, and I see attacking bloggers claiming that Rebecca & her supporters are calling EG (or in some cases, any man who propositions a woman) evil and twisted and wishing for his castration, incarceration, or even death (yes, I have seen blogs using those exact words and posing them as if this is what Rebecca and her supporters' actual position). This seems like it might be one of, if not, the biggest controversies in the skepitcal community, to the point that non skeptic online news sources have picked up the story.

And that's just really, really sad.

It's like skeptics are right now involved in a holy war to make outsiders thoroughly convinced that as a group, they have absolutely no lives and are completely unfamiliar with normal human interaction (I'm not speaking about just anyone commenting on the story, by the way, as in this thread, more like the main bloggers and personalities who are directing this drama). This whole drama has played out like a middle school clique fight.


I will never go to a TAM or any other similar conference after this. Not because of sexism. But because I might do something like saying "God Bless You" after someone sneezes, and the next morning there'll be a thousand blogs about it. It seems that many of the most vocal and prominent skeptics are way too petty for my taste, and I have no desire to be in their company.
 
Last edited:
If there are fewer women / more men at sceptical events (which seems in doubt) isn't it more likely to be for similar reasons to there being fewer men / more women at woo type events? Or to pick a less emotive example (I hope!) fewer women / more men at sports events and more women / fewer men at a Take That concert?
And perhaps fewer women with careers in the sciences, engineering, etc., which would seem to draw upon similar personal preferences to the ones that lead people into the skeptical/atheist communities.

Whether through nature or nurture there are gender based preferences and that is far more likely to be (at least) a partial cause, than men hitting on women (or whatever nonsense she was spouting). If the latter were the cause then why doesn't that put women off any event where men are gathered? I would have thought it extremely unlikely that the sceptical community, which by its very nature promotes and attracts rational thought, would suffer more than the average amount of sexist / misogynist behaviour and would venture to suggest it should be considerably below the average for that sort of behaviour.

Agreed on both counts. To the first, there are many possible factors: social pressures, traditional lifestyles (e.g. childrearing over breadwinning), surely many others. These must be considered to be factors in the makeup of not just this community, but any predominantly male community. To the second, I'd guess that the skeptical community is more enlightened and less traditional, but that doesn't mean that those old factors won't manifest at all--just to a lesser degree.
 
After so many pages I'm surprised by two things:

1. That people are still distracted by the question of whether EG was creepy or not; and

2. That you keep saying things I feel the need to quote.

However, this is not an honest discussion. Watson does not seem to intend it to be. If it is in fact the case that women are under-represented (which can be questioned, given that TAM 9 reportedly had half female speakers and about 40% female attendees), not only must sexism be the answer, but it must be a pretty narrow view of sexism. Dissenters must be straw-manned and ridiculed (Kirby), accused of ignorance (McGraw), or dismissed as young (St. Clair). No actual discussion seems possible for Watson, and this happens before the discussion has even begun.

That's where the most important split. It isn't men vs. women, nor is is misogynists vs. whatever people call non-misogynists, if in fact they do. The split between people who focus on women's power v.s. people who focus on women's powerlessness exists, and it is important but secondary. The major split is between people who are willing to discuss their ideas and people who are solely interested in head-butting, straw-manning, back-pedalling, and histrionics.
 
I am still mystified at RW's thought process.

Step 1. I had an encounter which made me feel uncomfortable.

Step 3. I will therefore lecture all men on how to behave with all women, because I speak for all women!


Something is missing here. Who appointed Rebecca Watson the spokesperson for all women?

Nobody - not even her; which is what you're missing.
 
However, this is not an honest discussion. Watson does not seem to intend it to be. If it is in fact the case that women are under-represented (which can be questioned, given that TAM 9 reportedly had half female speakers and about 40% female attendees), not only must sexism be the answer, but it must be a pretty narrow view of sexism.

Well wait, though. The "Skepchicks" organization (such as it were) is a number of years old already. It's one thing to point out that females had a roughly 50% showing at this year's TAM, but it's relevant as a counterpoint to the Skepchicks' claims only if those claims were first put forward this year. Otherwise, I think it would be honest to assess the showings of the last several years' TAMs - since the "Skepchicks" came about, preferably - and see if the numbers trend in any particular direction. If there tend to be more female presenters and attendees each year, I think a discussion can be had as to whether there is a link between that fact and the Skepchicks' attempts at awareness-raising.

I'm just saying, they've been making noise for a long time already, and it's not fair play to say "well there were lots of women at this year's TAM, so obviously they're full of manure".
 
FWIW, I don't think it even matters. I mean, it matters if we want to get into the "sexism" business; but as I've said before, when someone stands up and says "I'm exhausted and have to go get some sleep", following her into the elevator and asking her to not go to bed, but instead come and keep you company because you still feel like talking manages to be rather inconsiderate.

Do we actually know that he heard her say that?

...or gamble on credit. Those things are why god invented stealing. I also found it dangerous to borrow money for hookers and strippers. Especially if the guy you borrow money from is Guido the killer pimp.

In fairness, "killer" was only meant to indicate that he's a really good pimp. He rarely actually kills people.


I will never go to a TAM or any other similar conference after this.

Don't you think you're overreacting? :duck:
 
I will never go to a TAM or any other similar conference after this. Not because of sexism. But because I might do something like saying "God Bless You" after someone sneezes, and the next morning there'll be a thousand blogs about it. It seems that many of the most vocal and prominent skeptics are way too petty for my taste, and I have no desire to be in their company.


I just wanted to say that I was pleasantly surprised at TAM in that I only heard this nonsense mentioned twice by any attendee (in one case, I brought it up myself over lunch with a few forumites to indicate my surprise at the lack of references), and not at all by the presenters. It just goes to show that people in real life can be very different from their on-line personas.

Granted, I didn't hear every word from every presenter, nor did I speak with every attendee, so it may have just been my personal experience there.
 
...or gamble on credit. Those things are why god invented stealing. I also found it dangerous to borrow money for hookers and strippers. Especially if the guy you borrow money from is Guido the killer pimp.

I think I was standing in front of him in the Deli queue at TAM last week. While I was was standing in line, the guy behind me made a phone call telling someone to go and collect a debt from someone who was four days overdue. Instructions included threatening the guy's wife and kids.
 
Don't you think you're overreacting? :duck:

Hehe. Actually, one of the things that really turns me off about skepticism is that they seem to, for whatever reason, have a lot higher percentage of people who are really socially inept. I think it's a minority of skeptics, and I appreciate that this behavior is almost always called out by others...but that small percentage is a way higher percentage than any other social group I personally interact with. Sometimes I can't believe the posts people put on skeptic websites - often by the more prominant members of the community. And by "socially inept" I don't mean shy and awkward. I mean people who act like they are spoiled 12 year olds.

Incidentally, the reason I brought up the "saying God Bless you" example is because I have actually seen a thread in which a poster was called out by another poster for what a horrible person he was because he stated that he didn't particularly mind if someone says "God Bless You" if someone sneezes. I remember one of my very first posts on JREF was a "Happy Earth Day" post, to which I was ripped to shreds by someone who couldn't believe I would say "Happy Earth Day" when planet Earth sucks because natural disasters exist. Yet another post featured a poster who only has one hand being ripped apart by another poster for typing errors (and I don't mean these errors were simply pointed out to him, the complainer acted offended by them), and when the poster told him that he only had one hand, the complaining poster said that was no excuse and further ridiculed him. I could give many other examples. My own husband, who is a theist but doesn't have strong religious opinions, joined JREF briefly, but he soon became a lurker who doesn't post after he was mocked repeatedly and viciously for not being an atheist, with some people labeling him a fundamentalist even though he doesn't even prescribe to a particular religious belief, he just believes in God and reincarnation and the soul, and that's about it.

That's the kind of juvenile pettiness I have seen no where else but in skeptic circles. (again, amongst groups that I personally am involved in, I'm not saying skeptics have a monopoly on this kind of behavior).

It may be a minority, but it still stands out when you're not used to that sort of thing at all.


I've got a lot of interests, and a lot of those interests have big group activities/events. And even if this sort of thing doesn't happen often in skeptic circles, in all the other groups I participate with, this sort of ridiculousness never happens. And if I have to chose between investing myself in group A) socially well adjusted people who don't have members who act like they have never interacted with a live person, and group B) where a small - but noticable - percentage of people act that way, often people who tend to dominate discussions... I'm going spend my money and vacation days on group A.

I mean, if I had unlimited time and money, that would be different. But skepticism isn't a priority. And this "elevatorgate" only cemented this opinion in my mind.

I just wanted to say that I was pleasantly surprised at TAM in that I only heard this nonsense mentioned twice by any attendee (in one case, I brought it up myself over lunch with a few forumites to indicate my surprise at the lack of references), and not at all by the presenters. It just goes to show that people in real life can be very different from their on-line personas.

Granted, I didn't hear every word from every presenter, nor did I speak with every attendee, so it may have just been my personal experience there.

well that's a relief at least.
 
Last edited:
I can guarantee you that I will never go to a TAM conference or other large skeptical gathering.

I don't think what EG did was a big deal. If it had happened to me, I would have forgotten about it five minutes later.

While I found it weird that this incident made a big enough impact in Rebecca's life that she thought to mention it at all, nevermind blog about it, I don't think what she did was a big deal either. It was a brief complaint about something that made her uncomfortable. Much like if I hypothetically had been the one in the elevator with EG, if I had hypothetically seen Rebecca's video blog in which she mentioned it prior to being aware of the resulting controversy, I wouldn't have given that a second thought either.

I thought Dawkin's response was overdramatic. Rebecca just complained briefly, and he made it seem like she had victimized herself and actually compared herself to a Muslim woman who had been genitally mutiliated, when she did no such thing. But I still didn't think that was so big a deal either.

I thought Dawkin's response was inappropriate, but not as inappropriate as Myer's and other bloggers, who seemed to make a way bigger deal out of the incident than Rebecca initially did herself and used way more inflammatory language - they were "freaked out" "appalled" at this "creep" who, in some cases, "made them ashamed to be a man."

And then, the responses to the responses, both from Rebecca and her supporting bloggers, as well as her attackers just strain the realms of credulity. Both sides increasingly villainizing the others like both the elevator incident, or Rebecca's response to it, or Dawkin's response to that, were about the worst things to ever happen to the skeptic community. And most of the attacks from both sides which are completely lying about what the other side is claiming. I see supporting bloggers claiming that Dawkins and others are pro rape - and that anyone who doesn't agree with Rebeccas is anti-woman, and I see attacking bloggers claiming that Rebecca & her supporters are calling EG (or in some cases, any man who propositions a woman) evil and twisted and wishing for his castration, incarceration, or even death (yes, I have seen blogs using those exact words and posing them as if this is what Rebecca and her supporters' actual position). This seems like it might be one of, if not, the biggest controversies in the skepitcal community, to the point that non skeptic online news sources have picked up the story.

And that's just really, really sad.

It's like skeptics are right now involved in a holy war to make outsiders thoroughly convinced that as a group, they have absolutely no lives and are completely unfamiliar with normal human interaction (I'm not speaking about just anyone commenting on the story, by the way, as in this thread, more like the main bloggers and personalities who are directing this drama). This whole drama has played out like a middle school clique fight.


I will never go to a TAM or any other similar conference after this. Not because of sexism. But because I might do something like saying "God Bless You" after someone sneezes, and the next morning there'll be a thousand blogs about it. It seems that many of the most vocal and prominent skeptics are way too petty for my taste, and I have no desire to be in their company.

This is one of the extremely few truly interesting comments to emerge from the entire debacle.

I have only one quibble: Anything that can make P.Z. Myers ashamed, or even stop to think that his testicles are not the size of the Andromeda galaxy, is a good thing. Though it's probably only rhetoric.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom