Don't you think you're overreacting?
Hehe. Actually, one of the things that really turns me off about skepticism is that they seem to, for whatever reason, have a lot higher percentage of people who are really socially inept. I think it's a minority of skeptics, and I appreciate that this behavior is almost always called out by others...but that small percentage is a way higher percentage than any other social group I personally interact with. Sometimes I can't believe the posts people put on skeptic websites - often by the more prominant members of the community. And by "socially inept" I don't mean shy and awkward. I mean people who act like they are spoiled 12 year olds.
Incidentally, the reason I brought up the "saying God Bless you" example is because I have actually seen a thread in which a poster was called out by another poster for what a horrible person he was because he stated that he didn't particularly mind if someone says "God Bless You" if someone sneezes. I remember one of my very first posts on JREF was a "Happy Earth Day" post, to which I was ripped to shreds by someone who couldn't believe I would say "Happy Earth Day" when planet Earth sucks because natural disasters exist. Yet another post featured a poster who
only has one hand being ripped apart by another poster for typing errors (and I don't mean these errors were simply pointed out to him, the complainer acted offended by them), and when the poster
told him that he only had one hand, the complaining poster said that was no excuse and further ridiculed him. I could give many other examples. My own husband, who is a theist but doesn't have strong religious opinions, joined JREF briefly, but he soon became a lurker who doesn't post after he was mocked repeatedly and viciously for not being an atheist, with some people labeling him a fundamentalist even though he doesn't even prescribe to a particular religious belief, he just believes in God and reincarnation and the soul, and that's about it.
That's the kind of juvenile pettiness I have seen no where else but in skeptic circles. (again, amongst groups that I personally am involved in, I'm not saying skeptics have a monopoly on this kind of behavior).
It may be a minority, but it still stands out when you're not used to that sort of thing at
all.
I've got a lot of interests, and a lot of those interests have big group activities/events. And even if this sort of thing doesn't happen
often in skeptic circles, in all the other groups I participate with, this sort of ridiculousness
never happens. And if I have to chose between investing myself in group A) socially well adjusted people who don't have members who act like they have never interacted with a live person, and group B) where a small - but noticable - percentage of people act that way, often people who tend to dominate discussions... I'm going spend my money and vacation days on group A.
I mean, if I had unlimited time and money, that would be different. But skepticism isn't a priority. And this "elevatorgate" only cemented this opinion in my mind.
I just wanted to say that I was pleasantly surprised at TAM in that I only heard this nonsense mentioned twice by any attendee (in one case, I brought it up myself over lunch with a few forumites to indicate my surprise at the lack of references), and not at all by the presenters. It just goes to show that people in real life can be very different from their on-line personas.
Granted, I didn't hear every word from every presenter, nor did I speak with every attendee, so it may have just been my personal experience there.
well that's a relief at least.