So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
I was thinking about this earlier. (And please, stop me if this has been addressed in the bazillion pages that precede this one.) What are Ms. Watson's grounds for claiming that sexism, misogyny, and objectification are to blame for the primarily male makeup of the skeptical/atheist community? Has she provided enough evidence to suggest this over the variety of other possible explanations? Not that there can't be or haven't been instances of these things occurring, but it just seems like a big leap to conclude that they're majorly responsible for low female attendance.

It isn't an argument. It's dogma.

Try Paula Kirby for some sense.

 
Last edited:
You'll have to excuse me. I am currently experiencing severe cognitive dissonance.

Sorry but after 2 weeks of this nonsense, that question seems a bit naive.

Because of course Watson can't prove anything without a careful poll of every woman who has left the skeptical movement and some of them are hard to find.

Every other women who mentioned that she's been made uncomfortable has been blown off and every attempt has been made to normalize anti-social behavior. Oh and by the way, only white males in first world countries are marginalized. Everyone else is just bitching.
 
I know that Watson and her ilk left a bad taste in my mouth, and left me skeptical about this skeptical community, but this thread has sealed it.

Props to fls and Skeptic Ginger for being the voice of reason.

A simple chastisement to a hypocritical attention whore has flailed open an entire community.
I'm embarrassed that I ever suggested that anyone should come to this site. This isn't critical thinking, it's reality TV.
Gotta go, The Real Housewives of Atlanta is on.
Thanks for the props. But don't judge the community by Rebecca or this event. In this thread a lot of people were reasonable after taking the time to look at the facts, even when they started out with the opposite opinion.
 
Because of course Watson can't prove anything without a careful poll of every woman who has left the skeptical movement and some of them are hard to find.
That would be a silly thing to attempt. What we could do, though, is try and come up with some alternate explanations for why there are more men than women in this community and come up with reasons why they might be right or wrong. At the very least, it will better contextualize Ms. Watson's theory within the marketplace of ideas.

Every other women who mentioned that she's been made uncomfortable has been blown off and every attempt has been made to normalize anti-social behavior.
They certainly shouldn't be ignored if we're discussing individual experiences, but they should be recognized as anecdotal evidence if we're trying to explain the phenomenon of the large male-to-female ratio in the community.

Oh and by the way, only white males in first world countries are marginalized. Everyone else is just bitching.
It's rare to find someone who doesn't have something to be marginalized about, or to bitch about, for that matter. That's life.

I suggest that while marginalization is possible and even probable, it shouldn't be taken for granted that marginalization is occurring. To observe any phenomenon and immediately peg it as marginalization, privilege, or whatever else is an easy invitation for confirmation bias. Particularly for Ms. Watson, who observed a high male-to-female ratio at the conferences she attends, which led her to a feminist-friendly explanation: that the men are doing something to keep women out. I'm not saying she's wrong, but I am saying that this explanation is ripe for inquiry. What are the other possible explanations, and why is this one the best?

See, now, I actually did want to talk about Star Trek (and Star Wars; I'm a fan of that, too), but here I am getting roped into an on-topic discussion. That's what I get for trying to keep at least part of my post relevant. Alas.
 
Last edited:
Sorry but after 2 weeks of this nonsense, that question seems a bit naive.

Because of course Watson can't prove anything without a careful poll of every woman who has left the skeptical movement and some of them are hard to find.

Every other women who mentioned that she's been made uncomfortable has been blown off and every attempt has been made to normalize anti-social behavior. Oh and by the way, only white males in first world countries are marginalized. Everyone else is just bitching.

Seriously. Enough with the straw. It only makes you look irrational (which, by the way, you have been throughout nearly this entire thread - I'm giving you the benefit of the doubt because I didn't bother reading all your strawmen/red herring/rants.)
 
That would be a silly thing to attempt. What we could do, though, is try and come up with some alternate explanations for why there are more men than women in this community and come up with reasons why they might be right or wrong. At the very least, it will better contextualize Ms. Watson's theory within the marketplace of ideas

For that, you can see the Women in Atheism talk, including the comments by Paula Kirby that Watson misrepresented. It's at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2_O33OsA-vM

What we have with Watson isn't simply an idea or an argument; it's a pre-conceived universal explanation, playing the role in some kinds of feminism that the concept of original sin does in some kinds of Christianity or that free will does in some kinds of philosophy, in this particular sense: it is not so much argued for but is assumed as a cause.

Now, its existence could be argued for, and that is part of feminist theory, but it is simply assumed to be the cause in this particular case, because it is viewed as a general-purpose solution. Really, though, the existence of sexism is not controvertible, and it would be perverse to deny that it exists. What is at issue, at least to people who can reason, is whether it is a significant causal factor. It would be stupid to deny that there is water in my gas tank, but while there may be a small secondary effect from steam, water is not primarily what makes the car go.

With any honestly debated idea, there are at least two things to consider: 1) whether it is accurate, and 2) whether it is of any use. Kirby questions both in http://whyevolutionistrue.wordpress...panel-women-atheist-activists/#comment-116920

However, this is not an honest discussion. Watson does not seem to intend it to be. If it is in fact the case that women are under-represented (which can be questioned, given that TAM 9 reportedly had half female speakers and about 40% female attendees), not only must sexism be the answer, but it must be a pretty narrow view of sexism. Dissenters must be straw-manned and ridiculed (Kirby), accused of ignorance (McGraw), or dismissed as young (St. Clair). No actual discussion seems possible for Watson, and this happens before the discussion has even begun.

That's where the most important split. It isn't men vs. women, nor is is misogynists vs. whatever people call non-misogynists, if in fact they do. The split between people who focus on women's power v.s. people who focus on women's powerlessness exists, and it is important but secondary. The major split is between people who are willing to discuss their ideas and people who are solely interested in head-butting, straw-manning, back-pedalling, and histrionics.
 
It's just occured to me, and apologies if this is already here soemwhere, but the cry of sexism went up because this woman wasn't treated differently due to her gender.

You know what, let's hang the whole thing, have the men on one continent, the women on another and we can send test tubes and turkey basters across for procreation. Anything else is just too risky.
 
If there are fewer women / more men at sceptical events (which seems in doubt) isn't it more likely to be for similar reasons to there being fewer men / more women at woo type events? Or to pick a less emotive example (I hope!) fewer women / more men at sports events and more women / fewer men at a Take That concert?

Whether through nature or nurture there are gender based preferences and that is far more likely to be (at least) a partial cause, than men hitting on women (or whatever nonsense she was spouting). If the latter were the cause then why doesn't that put women off any event where men are gathered? I would have thought it extremely unlikely that the sceptical community, which by its very nature promotes and attracts rational thought, would suffer more than the average amount of sexist / misogynist behaviour and would venture to suggest it should be considerably below the average for that sort of behaviour.
 
Props to fls and Skeptic Ginger for being the voice of reason.

I am sorry this may not be sexist but it is making sex a validation for the argument. Can you please point out where fls and Skeptic Ginger have stated any argument better than the men who disagreed with RW, throughout this thread? Are you patting them on the head and saying "atta girl, because they happen to be female and disagreeing? Is there any reason why epepke, Belz, or AvalonQX are not the champions of reason?
 
It's just occured to me, and apologies if this is already here soemwhere, but the cry of sexism went up because this woman wasn't treated differently due to her gender.

Yeah, I made comments on that early in the thread. The general comment has been made thousands of times in other contexts. I got told I had a "bizarre" view of equality. I pointed out that this kind of invitation happens all the time between men at conventions. It's happened to me plenty of times.

Of course, it's ambiguous. Which is why when men approach me, they often say "I'm not gay or anything" instead of "Don't take this the wrong way."

Anyway, as with other things, there isn't a split between people who think the predominant evidence is that it was a come-on versus that it wasn't. There is a split between people who are absolutely convinced that it was and everybody else. That is, on one side, people proudly and fixatedly hold onto the sexist position that every display of interest in a woman by a man is about poking her, and these are the people tossing around the term "sexist" to describe those on the other side, which consists of everybody else.
 
Yeah, I made comments on that early in the thread. The general comment has been made thousands of times in other contexts. I got told I had a "bizarre" view of equality. I pointed out that this kind of invitation happens all the time between men at conventions. It's happened to me plenty of times.

Of course, it's ambiguous. Which is why when men approach me, they often say "I'm not gay or anything" instead of "Don't take this the wrong way."

Anyway, as with other things, there isn't a split between people who think the predominant evidence is that it was a come-on versus that it wasn't. There is a split between people who are absolutely convinced that it was and everybody else. That is, on one side, people proudly and fixatedly hold onto the sexist position that every display of interest in a woman by a man is about poking her, and these are the people tossing around the term "sexist" to describe those on the other side, which consists of everybody else.

Apologies, I didn't see the points you'd made.

I'll be honest, I've skipped huge amounts of the thread. I'm only popping in to stir the pot occasionally. :)
 
If your son sees a speaker at a conference his club goes to. And a good chunk of that speaker's talk is "Don't hit on me at a conference, I'm here as a professional, and I don't like it". Then your son follows her into an elevator at 4 in the morning and asks her to his room, right then in the middle of the night, he has just made it clear that he desires sex with this woman and he is either incapable or unwilling to understand her very clearly stated boundaries.

Except, as has been pointed out, her talk wasn't about this.
 
If your son sees a speaker at a conference his club goes to. And a good chunk of that speaker's talk is "Don't hit on me at a conference, I'm here as a professional, and I don't like it". Then your son follows her into an elevator at 4 in the morning and asks her to his room, right then in the middle of the night, he has just made it clear that he desires sex with this woman and he is either incapable or unwilling to understand her very clearly stated boundaries.

That's likely to make her pretty uncomfortable.

Just a pro-tip.
To summarize the arguments:

You are expressing the side of the argument people adamantly on RW's side have made.

Many arguments have been made against this position, mainly that RW had no way to be sure EG heard and/or took her comments the way she is convinced he must have. She makes unsupported assertions that would require she have mind reading abilities for her to be as certain as she claims to be about EG's prior knowledge and intentions.

Then there were people convinced everyone should recognize how 'uncomfortable' any women would be alone in an elevator in a 5 star hotel at 4am "in a foreign country". Regardless that 'uncomfortable' may have been true for RW, it is not something universally believed. I, for one, would not find such a situation uncomfortable (as described by RW). Neither would a number of other women who have expressed their opinion, and, evidence was presented by a blogger demonstrating how relatively safe women were in such a situation. It is therefore false to say it should be universally obvious it would make a woman uncomfortable for a man to approach a woman alone in an elevator in this scenario. It is NOT a universal belief.


But even given that there is simply a difference of opinion about this aspect of the debate, the real problems didn't begin until RW started using severe ad homs against the first few people who did not agree with RW's perception of the incident and her assessment of EG. I suspect you've not looked beyond the first RW video.
 
To summarize the arguments:

You are expressing the side of the argument people adamantly on RW's side have made.

Many arguments have been made against this position, mainly that RW had no way to be sure EG heard and/or took her comments the way she is convinced he must have. She makes unsupported assertions that would require she have mind reading abilities for her to be as certain as she claims to be about EG's prior knowledge and intentions.

Then there were people convinced everyone should recognize how 'uncomfortable' any women would be alone in an elevator in a 5 star hotel at 4am "in a foreign country". Regardless that 'uncomfortable' may have been true for RW, it is not something universally believed. I, for one, would not find such a situation uncomfortable (as described by RW). Neither would a number of other women who have expressed their opinion, and, evidence was presented by a blogger demonstrating how relatively safe women were in such a situation. It is therefore false to say it should be universally obvious it would make a woman uncomfortable for a man to approach a woman alone in an elevator in this scenario. It is NOT a universal belief.


But even given that there is simply a difference of opinion about this aspect of the debate, the real problems didn't begin until RW started using severe ad homs against the first few people who did not agree with RW's perception of the incident and her assessment of EG. I suspect you've not looked beyond the first RW video.

I am still mystified at RW's thought process.

Step 1. I had an encounter which made me feel uncomfortable.

Step 3. I will therefore lecture all men on how to behave with all women, because I speak for all women!


Something is missing here. Who appointed Rebecca Watson the spokesperson for all women?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom