So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
When my walking along a street requires approval from a medical ethics committee you may have a point. I'm talking about normal social interaction, not any form of treatment.

Fair enough. From your answer to bookitty's question, I thought your proposal was to purposefully behave in the criticized way, to lower their anxiety-level.
 
Linda is asking for the criteria to distinguish between simply hitting on someone you are interested in and objectifying them. Neither Linda nor I see how this elevator encounter stood out as being the latter as opposed to the former.

Precisely...as I posted elsewhere, it is impossible for Rebecca to have known in advance which it was...so when she talks of rape and sexual assault, I stop listening.
 
Sucking up to Dani isn't going to get you anywhere Doctor.

But, but, that's all I got . . . why do you have to take that away?

Assuming you are in fact a doctor. I'm beginning to doubt that your name is even Keith.

Dr. Keith is neither a doctor nor a Keith; discuss!

I'll be watching you.

The ghost of John Candy is a scarey thought . . .
 
I haven't seen anyone mention TAM 9 specifics yet, but I think this is relevant since part of Rebecca's claim is that this issue is related to women wanting to attend skeptical or atheist conferences (and Paul Kirby talked about women presenters).

  • During the TAM 9 opening remarks, DJ Grothe claimed that 40% of attendees this year were female (I cannot confirm).
  • 50% of presenters were female (24 males, 24 females)*.
  • Dawkins did not accept the SGU invitation to join them on stage for one of their two live recordings (I do not know if he was even aware of the invitation).
  • I was on an elevator with a guy at 4am and made a joke about elevatorgate, but I'm not sure he got the reference.
*I made the list by counting all the presenters listed in the program. Actual presenters may have been different, as there were some last-minute substitutions. I only counted each presenter once, but some were on stage multiple times (lecture, panel). I didn't count the workshops or the Sunday papers (no names given), but I did count the SGU recording. This could also be skewed if more of one gender gave long lectures and more of the other gender sat on short panels with many other presenters, but from my quick review that doesn't seem to be the case.
 
I haven't seen anyone mention TAM 9 specifics yet, but I think this is relevant since part of Rebecca's claim is that this issue is related to women wanting to attend skeptical or atheist conferences (and Paul Kirby talked about women presenters).

  • During the TAM 9 opening remarks, DJ Grothe claimed that 40% of attendees this year were female (I cannot confirm).
  • 50% of presenters were female (24 males, 24 females)*.
  • Dawkins did not accept the SGU invitation to join them on stage for one of their two live recordings (I do not know if he was even aware of the invitation).
  • I was on an elevator with a guy at 4am and made a joke about elevatorgate, but I'm not sure he got the reference.
*I made the list by counting all the presenters listed in the program. Actual presenters may have been different, as there were some last-minute substitutions. I only counted each presenter once, but some were on stage multiple times (lecture, panel). I didn't count the workshops or the Sunday papers (no names given), but I did count the SGU recording. This could also be skewed if more of one gender gave long lectures and more of the other gender sat on short panels with many other presenters, but from my quick review that doesn't seem to be the case.

Thanks for the information. But what percentage of black people were there? I'm just asking this question in order to know whether there's racism or not within the skeptic community. :eek::D
 
Thanks for the information. But what percentage of black people were there? I'm just asking this question in order to know whether there's racism or not within the skeptic community. :eek::D

I don't know, but I can say the Star Trek to Star Wars fan ratio was very disappointing. I didn't know there was that kind of franchise-ism going on within our ranks.
 
I don't know, but I can say the Star Trek to Star Wars fan ratio was very disappointing. I didn't know there was that kind of franchise-ism going on within our ranks.

Can I ask which of them dominated?

Both champion pseudoscience, but Star Wars woo is far more blatant.
 
I sometimes just like to have a cup of coffee with a lady, but not usually at 4 AM. Does that make me wrong?

If one actually wishes to have an intellectual discussion at 0400, be it with a lady or otherwise, caffeine is a neccesity. Considering the lateness of the hour, offering coffee is more likely to be a courtesy and a literalism, not a euphemism for something sexual. (I've actually had more success in life asking for coffee when I wanted coffee and casual sex when I wanted casual sex. YMMV.)
 
If one actually wishes to have an intellectual discussion at 0400, be it with a lady or otherwise, caffeine is a neccesity. Considering the lateness of the hour, offering coffee is more likely to be a courtesy and a literalism, not a euphemism for something sexual. (I've actually had more success in life asking for coffee when I wanted coffee and casual sex when I wanted casual sex. YMMV.)

Maybe you're coming in late, but there's a lot of other stuff here, including Watson's treatment of Kirby, McGraw, and many others, as well as the SGU podcast which underscores her loose association with reality. So even if Watson's interpretation were correct, it would be dwarfed in the rest.
 
Maybe you're coming in late, but there's a lot of other stuff here, including Watson's treatment of Kirby, McGraw, and many others, as well as the SGU podcast which underscores her loose association with reality. So even if Watson's interpretation were correct, it would be dwarfed in the rest.

Not coming in late as much as standing on the sidelines watching a tempest in a teacup, and occasionally making comments for my own amusement.
 
Looking for love in all the wrong places.

What say we all get together for coffee? Wouldn't it be great to set up a coffee table in an elevator in Rebecca's hotel? God I would love to see her face. Yeah, it's a dick move but we are atheists.
 
I know that Watson and her ilk left a bad taste in my mouth, and left me skeptical about this skeptical community, but this thread has sealed it.

Props to fls and Skeptic Ginger for being the voice of reason.

A simple chastisement to a hypocritical attention whore has flailed open an entire community.
I'm embarrassed that I ever suggested that anyone should come to this site. This isn't critical thinking, it's reality TV.
Gotta go, The Real Housewives of Atlanta is on.
 
I was thinking about this earlier. (And please, stop me if this has been addressed in the bazillion pages that precede this one.) What are Ms. Watson's grounds for claiming that sexism, misogyny, and objectification are to blame for the primarily male makeup of the skeptical/atheist community? Has she provided enough evidence to suggest this over the variety of other possible explanations? Not that there can't be or haven't been instances of these things occurring, but it just seems like a big leap to conclude that they're majorly responsible for low female attendance.

As a Star Trek AND Star Wars fan, myself, I'm not sure this is correct. I don't follow much of the SW woo, but the Trek woo is... embarassing.

Star Trek incorporates themes of intellectual enlightenment and space exploration for its own sake, which go a long way toward redressing its scientific errors in my eyes. To trot out a cliche, its heart is in the right place. It can also be conceded that, as an adventure series, Star Trek has to make some deliberate errors for the sake of visual appeal. It's not very exciting to watch a space dogfight in which the two ships can't be effectively maneuvered and are too far apart to be seen together onscreen.

On the other hand, if Star Wars and science were Venn diagrammed, the two circles wouldn't even touch.
 
I was thinking about this earlier. (And please, stop me if this has been addressed in the bazillion pages that precede this one.) What are Ms. Watson's grounds for claiming that sexism, misogyny, and objectification are to blame for the primarily male makeup of the skeptical/atheist community? Has she provided enough evidence to suggest this over the variety of other possible explanations? Not that there can't be or haven't been instances of these things occurring, but it just seems like a big leap to conclude that they're majorly responsible for low female attendance.



Star Trek incorporates themes of intellectual enlightenment and space exploration for its own sake, which go a long way toward redressing its scientific errors in my eyes. To trot out a cliche, its heart is in the right place. It can also be conceded that, as an adventure series, Star Trek has to make some deliberate errors for the sake of visual appeal. It's not very exciting to watch a space dogfight in which the two ships can't be effectively maneuvered and are too far apart to be seen together onscreen.

On the other hand, if Star Wars and science were Venn diagrammed, the two circles wouldn't even touch.

Admit it, you don't really care about Watson's claim, you just wanted to talk Star Trek.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom