So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
First, just want to say welcome back to the forum RandFan! :) It's been a long time and its good to see you again.
Thanks. :)

My point is that AFAIK, its more difficult to do a controlled study in the "soft sciences" than in the hard sciences. If we were to treat people exactly like lab rats there would be legal problems, to say the least.
Conceded.

It makes it harder to control all the possible variables and I'm sure that a professional scientist could go into the problems in further detail.
I worked for 1 year full time and 3 years part time as a programmer generating statistical models for researchers at the UCLA's Jonsson Comprehensive Cancer Center. I have also been a consultant for UCLA's Simms Mann Cancer Center, UCLA's Pain Management center and others. Thanks for the suggestion to seek help from a specialist but I'm confident I understand statistical modeling and methodology.

In any event, I concede your premise.

That's is the basic function of statistics, but it was nicely put. If you take another look at my posts I think you'll see that we're on the same page on that. For example, I mentioned that we can't use the results from linguistic or cognitive behavior to know for sure what any one person is thinking, but we can use it as a guide.
Yes, I agree.

As an analogy I can use the weather records from the past to decide not to pack winter boots for a trip to Boston, MA in May as it's unlikely to snow. Is it a guarantee? No. It snowed in Boson during May 1977 , I got snowed in as a matter of fact. ;)
Agreed.

That's an extreme example. For another less extreme one I can use my experience to know that when most people ask a friend or acquaintance, "How are you?", they aren't really expecting a detailed answer. Most people are looking to hear a "Fine" or "Doing good. You?". Does that mean that that definitive answers are never given? No. Our expectations as to what we will hear when we ask someone "How are you?" are only guidelines.
Agreed. So, we are in agreement on all of that. Cool. Still, I've not a clue what it has to do with anything. Sorry.
 
I still don't think I quite grasp what the complaint is.

Don't hit on people at conventions? (Sexism because men are more likely to do it than women?)

Don't hit on me when I'm tired? (Sexism because men are more likely to do the hitting and therefore more likely to do it when it's not appreciated?)

Don't hit on me in an elevator? (Sexism because a man would not feel as vulnerable in an enclosed space?) Would the story not be told had he asked her outside the bar?

And I don't quite grok the difference between sexual attraction (okay) and sexual objectification (not okay) in this case, as it sounded like he was indicating an attraction to her (if anything). PZ Meyers said something about men thinking it's okay to make proposals which women are obliged to turn down, which would make sense if women never hit on men. But when is it hitting on someone and when is it indicating attraction?

I have to get this straight because I have a son in college and I'm likely to screw it up, otherwise. Just today I made the mistake of suggesting that if he wants to meet people that share his interests he should consider joining a club. I now realize that if he happens to meet a woman there who he was attracted to who shared his interests, he might do something horribly sexist like ask her on a date.

Linda
I'm going to publicly apologize to LInda. Not that I think she was necessarily right in our earlier discussion but because I'm confused and suspect that perhaps I didn't understand her fully. I've gone back and looked at her post and I'm still confused. Let's move on and I'll just retract what I said.

Sorry Linda.
 
<snip>

I worked for 1 year full time and 3 years part time as a programmer generating statistical models for researchers at the UCLA's Jonsson Comprehensive Cancer Center. I have also been a consultant for UCLA's Simms Mann Cancer Center, UCLA's Pain Management center and others.

That sounds like very cool work experience. :)

Thanks for the suggestion to seek help from a specialist but I'm confident I understand statistical modeling and methodology.

It wasn't a suggestion just another way for me to say IANAS.

<snip>

Agreed. So, we are in agreement on all of that. Cool. Still, I've not a clue what it has to do with anything. Sorry.

Well, that's the danger of a thread that has gone over 2500 posts in just a couple of weeks. :D

I think this thread now serves almost like a Rorschach test, but in this case it shows which issues are important to each poster. Due to shifting goal posts and conflation of terms and issues by some of the bloggers -- there are a lot of issues being touched upon by this thread and this has probably contributed to its popularity. If there's an issue that is important to you (generic you) ... you can probably find it here in this thread. But because of all those factors, often people are talking past each other.

So ... I'm going to bow out and focus on some of the other more narrowly defined threads at the forum.

Have fun y'all!
 
For the record, since I have trouble staying on topic, I thought I would state how I see this whole tempest:

I agree with RW's original unremarkable post. No big deal.

I quite agree. There are a couple of additional reasons underscoring this, which I don't think have been talked about much.

First, the whole vlog was just a simple, casual talk about what she had been up to.

Second, the quoted passage was all about "all you guys were great, except for this one guy." So, the natural interpretation was that it's a "there's one in every crowd" story. Not remarkable, as we know that there's one in every crowd.

There was no "this is a statement about all men," no feminist keywords like "objectify," (only "sexualize," which is far less loaded), nothing really to raise any sort of flag, just an anecdote of the kind that I'm sure most of us tell all the time.

I also found Stef's response unremarkable. A different view, but not earth shattering. Opinions differ, discussion is good. This could have been one of those cases at this point.

It was a little remarkable, because she starts off playing the feminist card, which is at least somewhat of an escalation. Perhaps she was trying to tie it into Watson's earlier talk, but in any event, it went beyond Watson's original, fairly simple statement.

RW's response to critics, Stef in particular, was remarkable. And, as time goes by it just looks worse. She doesn't want a discussion, she wants to preach and anyone who differs just needs to sit down and shut up. And that should fly in a skeptical community?

Quite. Also, it completely reversed the sense of her original casual, simple anecdote. Whereas EG was just this guy, you know, he now became emblematic of sexism and objectification and all the reasons why, in accordance with a particular preconceived idea, there aren't enough women at feminist conferences.

PZ jumps to her defense, Dawkins is a jerk, I really stopped trying to keep up around this point.

I got very confused for a while, but then I found Gurdur's excellent summary at http://heathen-hub.com/blog.php?bt=5902 It pointed me to what well may have been the tipping point for me. In Watson's Dublin talk, she dramatically misrepresents the position of Paula Kirby.

Gurdur, rather charitably I think, describes any actual difference thus:

Gurdur said:
The basic point that seems to be being made by Watson (it morphs at times) is that women don't turn up at atheist conventions because of sexism, and that also explains the lack of women speakers. Kirby has pointed out that women are greatly encouraged in all sorts of practical assistance to become speakers, and that sexism has not greatly affected her or others at said conferences.

Except that Kirby is highly thoughtful and exploratory, has tried all sorts of things, thinks and discusses. Whereas Watson is dogmatic, presumptive, mendacious, and hypocritical. Anybody who disagrees with her is a sexist, misogynist, or "parrot" of misogyny. It comes across that she feels she has to act that way because of her version of feminism.

This is, itself, somewhat unremarkable. Neophyte feminists (and some long-termers) feel compelled to view reality through an extremely narrow lens and hurl invective at anyone who doesn't.

This is not unique to feminism. It's a phase in the conversion process. It happens with many new Christians, Marxists, vegetarians, non-smokers, skeptics, and atheists. The invective is most often hurled at people who think the way the hurler used to think, often people whom the hurler formerly canonized. Psychologically, the most plausible explanation is that they are repudiating their former selves by proxy.

Of course, a bit of invective now and then can be fun and cathartic, but it seems to me that Watson is doing little else. Understandable, perhaps, but also lamentable, wrong, anti-skeptical, and ironic, because of all the talk about sexism, Watson seems to be doing more to intimidate women out of skepticism than everybody else combined.

Maybe she'll settle down eventually. The smart people do. The stupid or malicious people escalate and eventually become embittered and old. Right now, I don't see how she merits her high status in the skeptical community, as evinced by how many times and at what level she is invited to speak. We'll see if there is a correction in this regard.
 
I'm going to publicly apologize to LInda. Not that I think she was necessarily right in our earlier discussion but because I'm confused and suspect that perhaps I didn't understand her fully. I've gone back and looked at her post and I'm still confused. Let's move on and I'll just retract what I said.

Sorry Linda.
Since I'm the one that cited this post from earlier, let me explain.

Linda is asking for the criteria to distinguish between simply hitting on someone you are interested in and objectifying them. Neither Linda nor I see how this elevator encounter stood out as beng the latter as opposed to the former.
 
Since I'm the one that cited this post from earlier, let me explain.

Linda is asking for the criteria to distinguish between simply hitting on someone you are interested in and objectifying them. Neither Linda nor I see how this elevator encounter stood out as beng the latter as opposed to the former.
Thanks. I agree with you both that it wasn't objectifying them and I very much agree with the post I quoted (the one where I apologized). Still, I don't understand our previous encounter (which I didn't quote). The reason I quoted the text in question and not the one that led to the disagreement was because the post I quoted stood in opposition to what I thought Linda's positions was. Obviously I've gone off the tracks somewhere. I just don't think it's worth trying to recover. I think we agree on the most important points.

I can move on. :)
 
Thanks. I agree with you both that it wasn't objectifying them and I very much agree with the post I quoted (the one where I apologized). Still, I don't understand our previous encounter (which I didn't quote). The reason I quoted the text in question and not the one that led to the disagreement was because the post I quoted stood in opposition to what I thought Linda's positions was. Obviously I've gone off the tracks somewhere. I just don't think it's worth trying to recover. I think we agree on the most important points.

I can move on. :)

I think I follow you.
 
This number of posts for a JREF thread makes me suspect Bigfoot was somehow involved in the incident and I just haven't read that bit yet.
 
It's disgusting how some perverts even went so far as to make a skepchic calendar of skeptic women, including poor Rebecca, in provocative and sexually suggestive poses. Sexual objectification of women, more of which can be seen here, really needs to stop. I don't think privileged white males should be commenting on this issue until they understand what women have to deal with.
 
Last edited:
Epepke, I like your timeline. There were a few I hadn't seen (Paula Kirby's comment was very valuable). It helped that you provide a brief synopsis of what each comment was about. I also noticed Richard Dawkins' body language in the original video. :)

I would suggest adding the SGU podcast to the list, where Rebecca gives "her side of the story" - if someone has gone through the rest of the timeline by the time they listen to it, it really highlights the dishonesty of her 'story'.

Linda

I'm going back and seeing if I've missed responses. I missed this one.

I'd like to put it in, but I haven't found a link. Do you have one?

ETA: Never mind. I found the link on page 56. Oh, and I'd say that you'd get the T-shirt, if I had one. But Gurdur got to it first.
 
Last edited:
I am all for desensitization as a therapy in cases of irrational emotional responses. It is known to be reasonably effective. However, in most cases you don't treat people without their explicit and informed consent, and forced desensitization looks like a rather grave violation of a persons integrity, which is why I wouldn't support it.

Do you have alternate proposals?

When my walking along a street requires approval from a medical ethics committee you may have a point. I'm talking about normal social interaction, not any form of treatment.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom