So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
For example, teenagers having posters of hot boys or girls on the walls of their rooms, go-go dancers, porn, foot fetishim, etc. You can focus on bodies as objects and still respect the person who is in that body, or not interact with that person at all.

Hear, hear.
 
One (and only one of many) reasons that stranger rape is less common that acquaintance rape is because people are more on guard in a situation in which it could occur. It is fairly difficult to sneak up on someone who is being hyper-vigilante, or to jump out of the bushes that people will consciously avoid.

You think _that's_ why rape is more common among people who know one another ?

Why don't they just know that you're safe and that behavior that appears threatening really isn't. Being seen as threatening can make you feel bad.

Hey, MORE straw. Could you at least TRY to address the ACTUAL words of people in this thread ?
 
It's not different priorities, it's a different perception of reality. I fail to see why RW just saying no to EG wasn't the end of the story.

Because, as I see it, RW just saying no to EG was not the point of the story. The point is first: that she was approached in a setting where she felt that she was not safe. The actual conversation isn't really that important for this, but if it helps I will readily agree that in the conversation EG behaved correct, responsible and laudable by accepting the rejection without any fuss.

The point is second: that her uneasiness could have been easily anticipated and I linked to the blog as a reference, that this is not only my opinion, but that for example Greg Laden and apparently all women he has spoken to about this, support it. Here is the quote:

Anyway, in life I was not as clueless as the above dialog suggests. Amanda hadn't really been thinking about the issue at all, and the moment she gave it any thought she immediately concluded that Elevator Guy did the wrong thing and that Rebecca Watson, in pointing this out to the clueless, was doing all women in the West, where there are elevators and a chance of some equality, a service. And every other woman that I've spoken to about this has said the same thing, more or less.


And while you've elaborated on your perception of the incident concluding every guy should know [X], it doesn't wash. First, everyone doesn't agree what [X] should be. And second, it is unrealistic.

On the contrary. I quoted Greg Laden's opinion that the need for consideration in this regard should be self-evident.

I wrote, that I don't know about all men. I can only speak from my experience, and I know that I can be scary for women purely by being a man, because women were fearful to take a ride with me and my then BF, until it was made clear to them, that i was in a steady relationship with another guy. I know it, because the body language of women I came too close to, in certain situations told me in all clarity that I scare them. I don't aspire to tell you or any other man or woman what to do. I am telling you what in this case is my priority.

My priority is to not scare them. It is what I think to be the right thing to do.

Brodski apparently considers desensitization in favor of a less fearful society more important.

You may choose your own priorities.

Perhaps the parents in this discussion understand the issue of choosing your battles with your kids and not fighting every battle. You give in to letting the kids do some things you'd rather they not do, but aren't that important to you. The kids have a chance to exercise their own control which has some benefits of its own. But you put your foot down on the important things.

Empowering women is an important thing. Some people would rather not have a guy hit on a woman in a 5 star hotel elevator at 4am in a foreign country. Is that really a battle that matters? In the bigger picture of things, I think not.

I am not sure what you are talking about. I don't assume that you compare adult men or women who are scared by strangers in the referenced situations to children, and I am not sure in what way you want to 'put your foot' down, in this regard. Do you want to forcefully empower them? And if yes, how do you plan to do this?
 
Last edited:
Another big bomb thrown out was the "White Privileged Male" meme. As if we could know that Dawkins' was motivated by his privileged class. Further it was an ad hominem. Then again Dawkins' engaged in his own ad hom (false consolation). A big mess that is potentially good for discussion but heavy in noise.

The Privilege Delusion

Alex, I'll take ad hominem for a $1,000 please.

Decidedly not critical thought.

The comments on her blog are just disgusting.
 
First, just want to say welcome back to the forum RandFan! :) It's been a long time and its good to see you again.


Now back to the regularly scheduled programming ...


That doesn't change anything.

My point is that AFAIK, its more difficult to do a controlled study in the "soft sciences" than in the hard sciences. If we were to treat people exactly like lab rats there would be legal problems, to say the least.

It makes it harder to control all the possible variables and I'm sure that a professional scientist could go into the problems in further detail.

Pinker or anyone who deals in sociobiology be it linguistics or cognitive behavior will tell you that they don't speak to individual behavior. They can only talk about groups. Statistical probability measured over statistically significant sample sizes for some confidence in the data and then repeated studies, meta analysis and optimum sample sizes for consensus. Again, about groups, not individual behavior.

That's is the basic function of statistics, but it was nicely put. If you take another look at my posts I think you'll see that we're on the same page on that. For example, I mentioned that we can't use the results from linguistic or cognitive behavior to know for sure what any one person is thinking, but we can use it as a guide.

As an analogy I can use the weather records from the past to decide not to pack winter boots for a trip to Boston, MA in May as it's unlikely to snow. Is it a guarantee? No. It snowed in Boson during May 1977 , I got snowed in as a matter of fact. ;)

That's an extreme example. For another less extreme one I can use my experience to know that when most people ask a friend or acquaintance, "How are you?", they aren't really expecting a detailed answer. Most people are looking to hear a "Fine" or "Doing good. You?". Does that mean that that definitive answers are never given? No. Our expectations as to what we will hear when we ask someone "How are you?" are only guidelines.
 
Because, as I see it, RW just saying no to EG was not the point of the story. The point is first: that she was approached in a setting where she felt that she was not safe. The actual conversation isn't really that important for this, but if it helps I will readily agree that in the conversation EG behaved correct, responsible and laudable by accepting the rejection without any fuss.

The point is second: that her uneasiness could have been easily anticipated and I linked to the blog as a reference, that this is not only my opinion, but that for example Greg Laden and apparently all women he has spoken to about this, support it. Here is the quote:






On the contrary. I quoted Greg Laden's opinion that the need for consideration in this regard should be self-evident.

I wrote, that I don't know about all men. I can only speak from my experience, and I know that I can be scary for women purely by being a man, because women were fearful to take a ride with me and my then BF, until it was made clear to them, that i was in a steady relationship with another guy. I know it, because the body language of women I came too close to, in certain situations told me in all clarity that I scare them. I don't aspire to tell you or any other man or woman what to do. I am telling you what in this case is my priority.

My priority is to not scare them. It is what I think to be the right thing to do.

Brodski apparently considers desensitization in favor of a less fearful society more important.

You may choose your own priorities.



I am not sure what you are talking about. I don't assume that you compare adult men or women who are scared by strangers in the referenced situations to children, and I am not sure in what way you want to 'put your foot' down, in this regard. Do you want to forcefully empower them? And if yes, how do you plan to do this?
Round and round the mulberry bush....

Forgive me, but this has all been addressed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom