So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Thanks for your response.

But, as it is defined, there are examples of sexual objectification that I have no problem with. For example, teenagers having posters of hot boys or girls on the walls of their rooms, go-go dancers, porn, foot fetishim, etc. You can focus on bodies as objects and still respect the person who is in that body, or not interact with that person at all. The problem I see is that sexual objectification and respect for the person who is in the objectified body aren't mutually exclusive.

And this concerns me because I think many feminists are wrong about this approach and too often make unreasonable demands. Why use this parameter to make judgments if the moral worth of the different possible situations differs greatly?

What exactly is useful about the concept of "sexual objectification"? I'm struggling to find sexual objectification as a relevant part of these problems. And where exactly is the line between sexual attraction and sexual objectification? What about two mutually consenting people who are just physically attracted to each other and have sex (at 4.00 a.m., after a coffee, to be more exact):)? Not my thing, but what's wrong with that?

I think it's more about respect, and in this particular case, respect towards women. I agree with you that there are issues with women even in the most advanced societies. I'm not trying to distract from actual discrimination. Quite the opposite. I'm trying to focus on what's relevant.

Your examples seem to focus on what I think is what we have to focus: respect and non-discrimination among human beings.

My conclusion is that it's not about removing sexual objectification. It's about adding respect.
It's all about respect and I totally agree with your post here. But respect comes in different forms, some don't involve sexual issues. What people are confusing IMO, is sex vs sexism. They are two different things. And I don't like seeing women's or men's interest in sex as being vilified by feminists.
 
Last edited:
I usually cross to the other side of the street. But a good number of women I've talked with about it have chided me for this sexist behavior: I shouldn't cross to*the other side of the street. To assume that women are fragile dolls that need to be coddled and protected just*perpetuates sexist attitudes.

No foolin'. I've been told this - a lot. As well as the opposite, of course.*I begin to wonder if I should stay home and avoid streets altogether.

In the absence of a general consensus from women on this question, I'm going to continue my practice of crossing to the other side. But this is mostly to protect me from shouted*rape accusations, as I noted in a previous post. If it makes my sidewalk companion easier in her mind, so much the better.*
 
In order to fight rape and especially to keep the female flight/fight reflex at its prime at all times men should please just use different sides of the street or different streets altogether. Some men are out for rape so all men should be aware of that are under the suspicion and therefore please keep the behaviour that might be construed as vaguely threatening to a minimum.


:rolleyes:

Why don't they just know that you're safe and that behavior that appears threatening really isn't. Being seen as threatening can make you feel bad.

:rolleyes:
 
I hope people can understand what I'm talking about here and don't think it is just about the fact I liked one of these friends and not the other. I did, but it was because of who they were.
I'm not sure but I think I have a better grasp on your position. Thanks.
 
Why don't they just know that you're safe and that behavior that appears threatening really isn't. Being seen as threatening can make you feel bad.

:rolleyes:

Especially when you have no way to ascertain which behaviour is seen as threatening by individual women at that time, date and point in her life unless you ask or she reacts.
 
You know I have a hard time following these long threads, so maybe I missed it, but I still can't figure it out: Which guy was Rebecca?

:)
What? :boggled:

The main problem with marketing the Skepchick brand as sex plus brains came from the hypocrisy of RW, not the 'objectification of women' that the brand included. I don't have an issue admiring a nice male body, nor do I have an issue with men's attraction to women's bodies. (There are associated issues beyond the basics of sex appeal that I do take issue with. For example, promoting the unrealistic Barbie ideal to children, and the image of the sexy nurse has damaged our profession. But I digress....)

Not sure if this is the direction you are going here but: RW admitted a guy's sexual interest in her was OK. She pigeonholed EG in a way that maybe made sense to her, but was not supported by the evidence presented or the way she rationalized her conclusions about EG.

Linda articulated the problem quite well on page 1 of this thread:
I still don't think I quite grasp what the complaint is.

Don't hit on people at conventions? (Sexism because men are more likely to do it than women?)

Don't hit on me when I'm tired? (Sexism because men are more likely to do the hitting and therefore more likely to do it when it's not appreciated?)

Don't hit on me in an elevator? (Sexism because a man would not feel as vulnerable in an enclosed space?) Would the story not be told had he asked her outside the bar?

And I don't quite grok the difference between sexual attraction (okay) and sexual objectification (not okay) in this case, as it sounded like he was indicating an attraction to her (if anything). PZ Meyers said something about men thinking it's okay to make proposals which women are obliged to turn down, which would make sense if women never hit on men. But when is it hitting on someone and when is it indicating attraction?

I have to get this straight because I have a son in college and I'm likely to screw it up, otherwise. Just today I made the mistake of suggesting that if he wants to meet people that share his interests he should consider joining a club. I now realize that if he happens to meet a woman there who he was attracted to who shared his interests, he might do something horribly sexist like ask her on a date.

Linda
 
Last edited:
Yes, we should do all we can to make interacting in public, especially at night, as normal as possible to encourage more people to do it, the more people who are about the safer we all are.

I am all for desensitization as a therapy in cases of irrational emotional responses. It is known to be reasonably effective. However, in most cases you don't treat people without their explicit and informed consent, and forced desensitization looks like a rather grave violation of a persons integrity, which is why I wouldn't support it.

Do you have alternate proposals?
 
For the record, since I have trouble staying on topic, I thought I would state how I see this whole tempest:

I agree with RW's original unremarkable post. No big deal.

I also found Stef's response unremarkable. A different view, but not earth shattering. Opinions differ, discussion is good. This could have been one of those cases at this point.

RW's response to critics, Stef in particular, was remarkable. And, as time goes by it just looks worse. She doesn't want a discussion, she wants to preach and anyone who differs just needs to sit down and shut up. And that should fly in a skeptical community?

PZ jumps to her defense, Dawkins is a jerk, I really stopped trying to keep up around this point.
 
It's all about respect and I totally agree with your post here. But respect comes in different forms, some don't involve sexual issues. What people are confusing IMO, is sex vs sexism. They are two different things. And I don't like seeing women's or men's interest in sex as being vilified by feminists.

Sexual objectification comes in different forms too, and some don't involve not acknowledging a person's individuality. Respect is a broad term, yes, but at least it's morally relevant. I don't see the moral relevance of sexual objectification.

Yes, some confuse sex with sexism. The problem is how you define sexism, and that's why I found it interesting to take a look at that site, to which RW referred talking about its "fundamentals".

So I'm getting introduced to the fundamentals of Feminism 101, of which I was ignorant. At least with this point, these fundamentals aren't consistent with critical thinking. I did a brief look at the site, and it's not looking any better. Honestly, I'm not surprised.
 
For the record, since I have trouble staying on topic, I thought I would state how I see this whole tempest:

I agree with RW's original unremarkable post. No big deal.

I also found Stef's response unremarkable. A different view, but not earth shattering. Opinions differ, discussion is good. This could have been one of those cases at this point.

RW's response to critics, Stef in particular, was remarkable. And, as time goes by it just looks worse. She doesn't want a discussion, she wants to preach and anyone who differs just needs to sit down and shut up. And that should fly in a skeptical community?

PZ jumps to her defense, Dawkins is a jerk, I really stopped trying to keep up around this point.

Well, that sums up the whole story and my view is similar, but I can see some connotations of RW's dogmatism with her first video and the context. No big deal though at that point.
 
....
Greg Laden ( he uses the same strategy I do ) thinks that:

To him this seems to be simply a consequence of the not negligible possibility that he might scare her.[snip]

Feel free to have different priorities.
It's not different priorities, it's a different perception of reality. I fail to see why RW just saying no to EG wasn't the end of the story.

And while you've elaborated on your perception of the incident concluding every guy should know [X], it doesn't wash. First, everyone doesn't agree what [X] should be. And second, it is unrealistic. RW saying no seems to be the response she had control over. Trying to make this about controlling's all men's behavior wasn't a battle I would want to waste energy on.


Perhaps the parents in this discussion understand the issue of choosing your battles with your kids and not fighting every battle. You give in to letting the kids do some things you'd rather they not do, but aren't that important to you. The kids have a chance to exercise their own control which has some benefits of its own. But you put your foot down on the important things.

Empowering women is an important thing. Some people would rather not have a guy hit on a woman in a 5 star hotel elevator at 4am in a foreign country. Is that really a battle that matters? In the bigger picture of things, I think not.
 
Last edited:
For the record, since I have trouble staying on topic, I thought I would state how I see this whole tempest:

I agree with RW's original unremarkable post. No big deal.

I also found Stef's response unremarkable. A different view, but not earth shattering. Opinions differ, discussion is good. This could have been one of those cases at this point.

RW's response to critics, Stef in particular, was remarkable. And, as time goes by it just looks worse. She doesn't want a discussion, she wants to preach and anyone who differs just needs to sit down and shut up. And that should fly in a skeptical community?

PZ jumps to her defense, Dawkins is a jerk, I really stopped trying to keep up around this point.
Yeah, I think your impressions are very close to mine. I wish RW had been a bit less presumptuous in her fist post but it really wasn't a big deal. I've already made several similar presumptions in this thread. Otherwise, yeah, I agree.
 
The problem is how you define sexism, and that's why I found it interesting to take a look at that site, to which RW referred talking about its "fundamentals".

So I'm getting introduced to the fundamentals of Feminism 101, of which I was ignorant. At least with this point, these fundamentals aren't consistent with critical thinking. I did a brief look at the site, and it's not looking any better. Honestly, I'm not surprised.

Could you give the link? Thanks.
 
Another big bomb thrown out was the "White Privileged Male" meme. As if we could know that Dawkins' was motivated by his privileged class. Further it was an ad hominem. Then again Dawkins' engaged in his own ad hom (false consolation). A big mess that is potentially good for discussion but heavy in noise.

The Privilege Delusion

Thanks, wealthy old heterosexual white man!
Alex, I'll take ad hominem for a $1,000 please.

Decidedly not critical thought.
 
Yeah, I think your impressions are very close to mine. I wish RW had been a bit less presumptuous in her fist post but it really wasn't a big deal. I've already made several similar presumptions in this thread. Otherwise, yeah, I agree.

The point is that it wasn't remarkable. Agree or disagree, there was not much to it. The post did not cause this *********, her reaction to criticism did. And that is the point the SGU failed to address completely.


ETA: That censored word would be a storm made of fecal matter, if that helps.
 
Last edited:
The point is that it wasn't remarkable. Agree or disagree, there was not much to it. The post did not cause this *********, her reaction to criticism did. And that is the point the SGU failed to address completely.
No, I agree. It's just the undercurrent of the presumption. Some percentage of women don't share her opinions. It would be helpful if in an instance like this she wouldn't presume to lecture men on behalf of all women. "This is just my opinion" would likely have nipped it in the bud and no reaction to the criticism would have been necessary. She was dispensing advice. This is mine. Of that which you don't know, don't speak. That's all.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom