So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why is EG being applauded for "taking no for an answer." Shouldn't that be the norm, instead of some proof of character? You don't get brownie points for stuff like that. Didn't Chris Rock already cover this better than I could?
 
....

In the meantime, can anyone convince me that sexual objectification is a problem in itself?
It's quite rude when it does occur. I don't agree, of course, that convincing evidence it is a significant problem within the skeptic/atheist/freethinker communities has so far been presented.

The best description I have of sexual objectification is when a guy thinks very little of women except for having sex with. Women are excluded from the pool of people one would choose friends from, only 'the boys' are in the potential pool. Women are not respected as qualified to be much of anything except for having sex with and fulfilling a few female roles like housewife and nurse. And 'nurse' in this case would be a low ranking role, not the science based profession it actually is. I am also refraining from saying sex partners, because 'partner' is the wrong word choice here.

In my world, I've run across it occasionally but not often. In some cultures it may not be perceived as a problem because it is ingrained in the culture. And I would also think there are many differences when it is a normal part of the culture which make it less offensive than when it is an aberration in the culture, or when women were culturally moving past that history.

I suspect others have their own version of the meaning of the word.
 
Why is EG being applauded for "taking no for an answer." Shouldn't that be the norm, instead of some proof of character?

EG is being accused of being a creep, a stalker, a misogynist, etc. His conduct is not being held up for "applause" but for evidence of positive normal behavior -- which, you admit, it is.

Nobody is nominating EG for man of the year; people are just pointing out that turning him into a stalker-rapist is inappropriate considering that, by Watson's own account, he asked politely and accepted a "no" answer.
 
So one can promote publicly their sexuality then complain about a guy hitting on you in a fairly benign way?

In my opinion and regarding the context yes. If she had complained about guys hitting on her at the bar or at any other place where she could have felt safe, be it because other people are around, be it because she had an easy way to escape should the 'hitting on her' become less benign, I would have agreed that she had no reason to complain about this particular incident.

Some of us think it might be sexist to assume "my room", "coffee", and "don't take this the wrong way" means sex was all the guy could have possibly wanted.

As I said, it is possible that he was completely benign and it is even possible that he only wanted to talk. Rebecca couldn't know this though, and I support her right to err on the side of caution. Even if elevators in nice hotels are actually low risk places, she ( and a lot of commenters ) don't seem to perceive them as such, and short-term she can only react according to her perceptions, not according to an extensive study of the actual dangers of hotel-elevators.

Personally, coming just from the bar which certainly had coffee, and given that only talking doesn't require as much alone-time, I would have interpreted an invitation to someones room at 4am in an elevator as not only concerned with talking, not even if the guy had only complimented me for being interesting, but that's me. :)

How was EG supposed to know it wasn't OK?

Some people claim every guy should have known based on how they perceived vulnerable women in 5 star hotel elevators at 4 am in a "foreign" country. Not all of us agree with the depiction of the setting.

Greg Laden ( he uses the same strategy I do ) thinks that:

All men. ALL men who have given sufficient consideration to women's position in our society do this walking trick. If you are a man and you do not know about this trick then there is a problem with you.

To him this seems to be simply a consequence of the not negligible possibility that he might scare her.

I don't know about all men, but I know that I can scare a lot of women without even trying in such situations. It might not bother you, or any number of other assertive women, but neither can the woman know whether I am dangerous, nor can I know whether I would scare her, and so I simply choose to err on the side of caution.

Whether I or the guy in the elevator incident was benign, wanted only to talk, was a boddhisattva or whatever, is, as far as I can see, irrelevant for this.

Whether RW interpreted his intention correctly or whether the situation was indeed as dangerous as she felt it to be, is of no relevance for this either.

The relevant factors are: From the perspective of women and men, I might be a dangerous aggressor in a situation where they can't be reasonably sure that they have an escape route or could successfully defend themselves, and from my perspective: I can minimize the chance to possibly scare someone for no good reason with minimal effort and no detriment to myself or anybody else, which is enough for me to implement this behavior.

Feel free to have different priorities.
 
Last edited:
In the meantime, can anyone convince me that sexual objectification is a problem in itself?
I'm not convinced of it myself. I think the problem arises when predominant views and popular culture craft women only as sexual objects. When we look to the past cultural references we tend to see them as passé. I think we do so because the characters were often one dimensional and their sexuality was often their main attribute. Further, these kinds of characters were often the rule and not the exception. I think such a character crafted today is seen less as a threat because pop culture has many characters (protagonists and antagonists) are women who are not simply sexual objects and for many sexuality is minor part or, in many cases, not even an integral part of the character.
 
Why is EG being applauded for "taking no for an answer." Shouldn't that be the norm, instead of some proof of character? You don't get brownie points for stuff like that. Didn't Chris Rock already cover this better than I could?
That's a fair question. At the least he shouldn't be criticized for it, right? I think it should be applauded because of the light of the times. We have not yet eradicated sexual assault and rape (or largely eradicated it). Positive reinforcement. Our evolutionary programing did not precisely give us the best morals and or ethics. We have to fashion those ourselves and then instill them into society. When women are not fearful of men then I think it should simply be treated as simply the social norm it should be.
 
That's a fair question. At the least he shouldn't be criticized for it, right? I think it should be applauded because of the light of the times. We have not yet eradicated sexual assault and rape (or largely eradicated it). Positive reinforcement. Our evolutionary programing did not precisely give us the best morals and or ethics. We have to fashion those ourselves and then instill them into society. When women are not fearful of men then I think it should simply be treated as simply the social norm it should be.

Could you clarify this bit, please.
 
ALL men who have given sufficient consideration to women's position in our society do this walking trick.

you see, this is where I have a problem, because the fact is that the position of women in my society in that situation is that they are safer than an equivalent man. This isn't about risk assessment it's about feeding and nurturing rape fear which is is one of the sources of inequality between the sexes.

Rape is a serious issue, tackling rape is is something we must do. That does not mean that everything we do in the name of combating rape is helpful or good.

Perpetuating rape myths is not helpful. De-normalising men and women sharing the same side of the street does nothing to prevent rape, what it does do is make those instances where a man has to, for one reason or another, walk behind a strange woman even more frightening.
 
Last edited:
Could you clarify this bit, please.
I live in a glass house. Sorry.

In context with the claims of RW. Whatever her point was about women feeling intimidated, uncomfortable, or fearful of rape. And, to the extent that there are significant numbers of women who feel so. If RW's claims and the claims of others are unfounded (regarding rape, assault, harassment) and, in fact, there largely is no problem, or assuming that the perceptions are not significant assuming the previous premise, then I would agree with your point. There should not be any special attention paid to a man doing what is simply the morally responsible thing to do. I hope I clarified.
 
It's quite rude when it does occur.
I'm curious, when two people's eyes meet in a night club and sparks fly, is that what you mean by rude? I mean, that hardly takes into account traits beyond the individuals as sexual objects, right? Or am I missing something? Is the skepchicks calendar rude? Do the calendars focus on or accentuate attributes other than sex?

This photo of Carrie (sp?). Most of us know of her mental and technical capabilities but does this image accentuate those?

Kari_Byron_fire-extinguisher_budweiser_bud-light.jpg


Perhaps its just our take on what objectification means. Like the definition provided, it's not simply sexual attraction. But how do you distinguish the two on a case by case basis when all we have to work with is sexual imagery?
 
Last edited:
you see, this is where I have a problem, because the fact is that the position of women in my society in that situation is that they are safer than an equivalent man. This isn't about risk assessment it's about feeding and nurturing rape fear which is is one of the sources of inequality between the sexes.

Rape is a serious issue, tackling rape is is something we must do. That does not mean that everything we do in the name of combating rape is helpful or good.

Perpetuating rape myths is not helpful. De-normalising men and women sharing the same side of the street does nothing to prevent rape, what it does do is make those instances where a man has to, for one reason or another, walk behind a strange woman even more frightening.

So in order to "tackle rape" we should get women used to men walking up behind them on the sidewalk. That woman should also please keep any fight/flight response to a minimum until she is actually attacked.

And now here comes ginger to tell us all about how many men have walked behind her, she wasn't bothered, no other women should be bothered (weaklings!) and therefore she's the uber feminist.
 
It's quite rude when it does occur. I don't agree, of course, that convincing evidence it is a significant problem within the skeptic/atheist/freethinker communities has so far been presented.

The best description I have of sexual objectification is when a guy thinks very little of women except for having sex with. Women are excluded from the pool of people one would choose friends from, only 'the boys' are in the potential pool. Women are not respected as qualified to be much of anything except for having sex with and fulfilling a few female roles like housewife and nurse. And 'nurse' in this case would be a low ranking role, not the science based profession it actually is. I am also refraining from saying sex partners, because 'partner' is the wrong word choice here.

In my world, I've run across it occasionally but not often. In some cultures it may not be perceived as a problem because it is ingrained in the culture. And I would also think there are many differences when it is a normal part of the culture which make it less offensive than when it is an aberration in the culture, or when women were culturally moving past that history.

I suspect others have their own version of the meaning of the word.

Thanks for your response.

But, as it is defined, there are examples of sexual objectification that I have no problem with. For example, teenagers having posters of hot boys or girls on the walls of their rooms, go-go dancers, porn, foot fetishim, etc. You can focus on bodies as objects and still respect the person who is in that body, or not interact with that person at all. The problem I see is that sexual objectification and respect for the person who is in the objectified body aren't mutually exclusive.

And this concerns me because I think many feminists are wrong about this approach and too often make unreasonable demands. Why use this parameter to make judgments if the moral worth of the different possible situations differs greatly?

What exactly is useful about the concept of "sexual objectification"? I'm struggling to find sexual objectification as a relevant part of these problems. And where exactly is the line between sexual attraction and sexual objectification? What about two mutually consenting people who are just physically attracted to each other and have sex (at 4.00 a.m., after a coffee, to be more exact):)? Not my thing, but what's wrong with that?

I think it's more about respect, and in this particular case, respect towards women. I agree with you that there are issues with women even in the most advanced societies. I'm not trying to distract from actual discrimination. Quite the opposite. I'm trying to focus on what's relevant.

Your examples seem to focus on what I think is what we have to focus: respect and non-discrimination among human beings.

My conclusion is that it's not about removing sexual objectification. It's about adding respect.
 
Last edited:
So in order to "tackle rape" we should get women used to men walking up behind them on the sidewalk.
Yes, we should do all we can to make interacting in public, especially at night, as normal as possible to encourage more people to do it, the more people who are about the safer we all are.

or should women be made to fear going out alone, leading to largely deserted streets and no-one to help if there is a rapist/ attacker out there?

That woman should also please keep any fight/flight response to a minimum until she is actually attacked.

How should a man react when someone walks up behind him? How should anyone react? Do we really want to live in a society that is so damn fearful of each other largely on the basis of myths?
 
EG is being accused of being a creep, a stalker, a misogynist, etc. His conduct is not being held up for "applause" but for evidence of positive normal behavior -- which, you admit, it is.

Nobody is nominating EG for man of the year; people are just pointing out that turning him into a stalker-rapist is inappropriate considering that, by Watson's own account, he asked politely and accepted a "no" answer.

EG is (as I said 40 or so odd pages back) neither a stalker-rapist or a deaf, shy, asperger sufferer. Just a normal guy, doing a normal thing, at completely the wrong time.

But if EG is a normal guy, then other normal people may have also done normal things at the wrong time and intimidated or discomforted someone. Saying that it is bad to make someone uncomfortable because you're too lazy to read the clues, means that more people will be guilty of EG's "crime." (Doing a normal thing at the wrong time.)

If it actually is bad, it needs to be addressed. Addressing it could lead to change. If there is one thing that skeptics pride themselves on, it's never, ever changing. Watson, for example, is not allowed to change her mind about being seen as a sexual object.

Anything she said a year ago is still held up as how she thinks now. Because that is normal behavior for people who self-identify as skeptics. "Despite this being outside my area of expertise, I have formed an opinion. I have also used google to find statistics which support this opinion. I will quote them at you now."
 
So in order to "tackle rape" we should get women used to men walking up behind them on the sidewalk. That woman should also please keep any fight/flight response to a minimum until she is actually attacked.

And now here comes ginger to tell us all about how many men have walked behind her, she wasn't bothered, no other women should be bothered (weaklings!) and therefore she's the uber feminist.


In order to fight rape and especially to keep the female flight/fight reflex at its prime at all times men should please just use different sides of the street or different streets altogether. Some men are out for rape so all men should be aware of that are under the suspicion and therefore please keep the behaviour that might be construed as vaguely threatening to a minimum.


:rolleyes:
 
I'm curious, when two people's eyes meet in a night club and sparks fly, is that what you mean by rude?
Absolutely not. You may have missed some of my earlier posts where I defended women's interest in casual sex. That was the norm in my crowd when I was a teenager and in my 20s. And I'm glad I had that freedom and that the HIV pandemic didn't effect heterosexual teens until later. (I did have a homosexual friend I knew all my life who did not escape that fate. In his sexual group HIV hit a decade sooner. It claimed his life.)

Let me give you an example I have experienced. It happened when I was younger and was in a long term relationship (we lived together) with my partner at the time. We went backpacking on a regular basis. We traveled around Fiji, New Zealand, and Australia for 6 months together living much of the time in a tent. We had moved to 3 different cities together over the years. In other words, we were friends as well as partners.

Jim had one obnoxious friend who was disgustingly sexist. He constantly wanted to do things with Jim that excluded me. I'm not talking about a guy's night out here or there, but every time he wanted to spend time with Jim, it was a guy thing as far as he was concerned. That's just how he saw the world.

Jim had another friend that was the opposite. He was an architect. He met a woman and they were living together. Once when this friend was staying with us, and his girlfriend was still at home in another state, we had an interesting conversation I still remember. He told us he was trying to decide if he wanted to stay in the relationship. He really loved her, she was pretty, and she did all the nice housewife caretaker things some guys like (and I don't begrudge that particular attraction), but he worried he didn't have the kind of more equally educated, intellectual relationship with her that Jim and I had. And he wasn't sure if that mattered to him.

I don't see that as sexist in any way. This friend was merely looking at the pros and cons of his particular relationship with this woman. There were things he liked a lot and they happened to be classic female role things. He wondered if he would like a more equal intellectual relationship, she just didn't have those qualities and he was willing to contemplate, of all the qualities a woman might have, was this the relationship he wanted?

I haven't seen him in years so I don't know whether he stayed with her or not.


I hope people can understand what I'm talking about here and don't think it is just about the fact I liked one of these friends and not the other. I did, but it was because of who they were.
 
Last edited:
I've been convinced. I started off being strongly on the side of Watson. I thought that her request was mild and earnest and totally understandable, if a bit futile. I thought that her calling out of McGraw seemed uncool, but then again, I wasn't there, and I was willing to give her the benefit of the doubt. I thought that this entire bruhaha had been started and maintained by third parties, and that she was just caught up in it, that a mountain had been made out of a molehill, but that she was herself relatively innocent.

Now I'm strongly against. Mostly, her apologists pushed me in that direction, with their drivel, apologia, lies, and facile and stupid accusations, but that was only emotional. I tracked down links of things that Watson had said, and that convinced me.

Pretty much the same here. Once I read what each party actually said when, I switched 'sides', although I still think Dawkins was a dick. But water is also wet.

It's nice of y'all to do all the typing so I can just sit back and say: Yep, my take, too.

Thanks.

Also, finally heard the SGU version and was sorely disappointed in the setup and execution. They missed the whole point of her bullying being the main catalyst to create this tempest. I hope they have time to reconsider before the TAM show or next podcast. If not, they have missed a real opportunity to apply skeptical thinking to themselves. At that point, what's the point?
 
Absolutely not. You may have missed some of my earlier posts where I defended women's interest in casual sex. That was the norm in my crowd when I was a teenager and in my 20s.

Let me give you an example I have experienced. It happened when I was younger and was in a long term relationship (we lived together) with my partner at the time. We went backpacking on a regular basis. We traveled around Fiji, New Zealand, and Australia for 6 months together living much of the time in a tent. We had moved to 3 different cities together over the years. In other words, we were friends as well as partners.

Jim had one obnoxious friend who was disgustingly sexist. He constantly wanted to do things with Jim that excluded me. I'm not talking about a guy's night out here or there, but every time he wanted to spend time with Jim, it was a guy thing as far as he was concerned. That's just how he saw the world.

Jim had another friend that was the opposite. He was an architect. He met a woman and they were living together. Once when this friend was staying with us, and his girlfriend was still at home in another state, we had an interesting conversation I still remember. He told us he was trying to decide if he wanted to stay in the relationship. He really loved her, she was pretty, and she did all the nice housewife caretaker things some guys like (and I don't begrudge that particular attraction), but he worried he didn't have the kind of more equally educated, intellectual relationship with her that Jim and I had. And he wasn't sure if that mattered to him.

I don't see that as sexist in any way. This friend was merely looking at the pros and cons of his particular relationship with this woman. There were things he liked a lot and they happened to be classic female role things. He wondered if he would like a more equal intellectual relationship, she just didn't have those qualities and he was willing to contemplate of all the qualities a woman might have, was this the relationship he wanted?

I haven't seen him in years so I don't know whether he stayed with her or not.


I hope people can understand what I'm talking about here and don't think it is just about the fact I liked one of these friends and not the other. I did, but it was because of who they were.

You know I have a hard time following these long threads, so maybe I missed it, but I still can't figure it out: Which guy was Rebecca?

:)
 
Yes, we should do all we can to make interacting in public, especially at night, as normal as possible to encourage more people to do it, the more people who are about the safer we all are.

or should women be made to fear going out alone, leading to largely deserted streets and no-one to help if there is a rapist/ attacker out there?



How should a man react when someone walks up behind him? How should anyone react? Do we really want to live in a society that is so damn fearful of each other largely on the basis of myths?

Which myth specifically? That of stranger rape?

One (and only one of many) reasons that stranger rape is less common that acquaintance rape is because people are more on guard in a situation in which it could occur. It is fairly difficult to sneak up on someone who is being hyper-vigilante, or to jump out of the bushes that people will consciously avoid.

There is a small dark hallway on my subway stop (It's by the elevator!) I have had men try to herd me towards it by standing too close or even shouldering me. If I was not being vigilante, my natural instinct would be to move away from them and into this hallway. Which is dark, and fairly isolated. Because I am hyper-aware of what strangers are doing when I'm alone, I stop, step backwards and get on the other side of them and head for the stairs.

Being aware has also kept me from getting groped. Groping isn't rape but it's far more common. I've never been raped by a guy who walked up behind me, but I have had my ass grabbed, kissy sounds made right in my ear, and other "harmless" threats of a sexual nature.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom