So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
These have been my concerns and observations also. Rebecca would likely have gotten little if any response had she not presumed to speak for all women. Had she said, "this is my view and I suspect the view of many other women" there would have been little to complain about. It's that presumption and the presumption that EG was somehow "creepy" or "sexist" that I think lies at the heart of this conundrum. I don't think people have gotten to the core of why they are viscerally upset by this.

I agree that it's the presumption. I didn't agree with her the first time I saw the very first video, and when I gathered more context, I stood by my first conclusion. Needless to say, the worse events came later.

She didn't explicitly say that she was speaking for all women, but she explicitly demanded men in general to not behave that way, which affects all women too.

She didn't explicitly say that EG was sexist either, but since she referred to her earlier panel talk, which according to her EG didn't grab, I had to look for more context to see what EG "didn't grab". Her talk focused on sexism and misogyny within the society in general and the skeptic community in particular and how women are deprived from being more present in the community, with particular emphasis in her hate mail.

So, taking context into account, she used EG as an example to illustrate the sexism she was referring to in her talk, which is a major concern to her. My take on this is, if you use an example like this to illustrate this "problem of sexism", you'll have a hard time convincing people of the message you're trying to convey.

Also, I think that, concerning feminism, a proactive strategy nowadays can be more fruitful than a reactive one. But that depends on what you want. I'm not sure what RW wants. If I were a woman invited to a "communicating atheism" talk, I think I'd rather talk about someting related to communicating atheism and I'd try to impress my audience independently of my gender with my skills and tools in communicating atheism.
 
Last edited:
I agree that it's the presumption. I didn't agree with her the first time I saw the very first video, and when I gathered more context, I stood by my first conclusion. Needless to say, the worse events came later.
Good post. Agreed. I was very disappointed when I listened to The Skeptics Guide To The Universe and she simply lumped all criticism into "they just don't get it" group. She didn't address any of the thoughtful criticisms or arguments and no one on the panel challenged her fallacy of "well of course Dawkins would say that he is from a privileged class". A meme bandied about a lot since this event.

I sent an email asking "how would one falsify the notion that Dawkins behavior is because of his white male privilege"? And, "isn't that an ad hominem"? No response.
 

It is also important for how we tackle the issue.
If the perception of risk is accurate then what we need to address is behaviour, if the perception is not accurate then the most sensible thing to do is to try and tackle the perception.
Sounds about right.
 
Good post. Agreed. I was very disappointed when I listened to The Skeptics Guide To The Universe and she simply lumped all criticism into "they just don't get it" group. ......
I was going to add, dismissing those who disagreed with ad homs about their anti-feminist attitudes to Ivor's list.
 
Slightly off-topic but RandFan has been disappeared for very long. I'm glad he is still alive and kicking and back posting.

Personally, about this thread, I spoke about the double standard in life. In this particular situation I believe not only would you need to have been there as a witness -- and even then it may have been a grey area. (Politely asking isn't wrong if you aren't the boss of someone, is it? )

What thinking people should focus on is what would have Ayn Rand would have done in this situation. She would have made his willy shrink by berating his lack of focus on the objectionist objective when asking for sex. (It's happened to me :rolleyes:)
 
She would have made his willy shrink by berating his lack of focus on the objectionist objective when asking for sex. (It's happened to me :rolleyes:)
I don't like to publicly discuss my willy. But when I do it's after drinking lots of Dos Equis. Stay thirsty my friend.
 
About men having to be aware: I've always done this. Always felt the need to have my antennae out for threats. Also, for a specific kind of potential threat from women: the possibility that she'll find me threatening, and will shout for help.

Thank you. I still didn't find reliable data on men's comparative anxiety-level, but I keep this in mind too.

I don't think people have gotten to the core of why they are viscerally upset by this.

I still don't get it completely.

I was under the impression that the only necessary qualification for being a productive member of the skeptics community is to further skeptical thinking, which I think her site did.

Regarding her sex-positive image, I am firmly convinced that no matter how much you slut yourself up, you still retain autonomy regarding your sexuality, so her complaints about being sexualized in a way she felt to be inappropriate are, in my mind, completely within in her rights.

I don't think that a slogan like 'Drunken girls hit on drunk nerds' can be construed as a serious offer either, so any disappointment about a perceived nonobservance to as whatever it was perceived is rather difficult to relate to.

As for the way she handled criticism, I already said what I think about it. She hardly is the only prominent skeptic who is guilty of occasional dickery though.
 
Fair criticism. I'm painting with broad brush strokes again and being unintentionally ironic. What I should have said is that it seems to me that many people haven't.

Oh, I definitely agree with that.

Goodness, it is unusual that we agree on so much. ;)
 
I was under the impression that the only necessary qualification for being a productive member of the skeptics community is to further skeptical thinking, which I think her site did.
I think the discussion very important and I thank her for that. Further, I think her opinion about the propriety of social navigation and negotiation to be a very appropriate topic and contribution to our community. However, her ad homs and refusal to acknowledge valid points and arguments, IMHO, do not advance skepticism and critical thinking.
 
Here’s my take on why people are pissed off:

Ms. Watson is a woman who has no particularly relevant skill or talent associated with scepticism. She has promoted herself and her organisation using blatant sexualisation and objectification of women in an attempt to appeal to the male-dominated sceptical community, a community which contains many men who are socially awkward, particularly around women. She is now complaining about a man from the sceptical community, who even by her account used polite phrasing, took no for an answer and may have been genuine in his invite for coffee and conversation in his room, of sexualising her and of sexism being a significant problem in the sceptical community.

1) She's an embarrassment.

2) She's a hypocrite.

3) Given what Skepchick stands for, it’s not part of the solution to sexist attitudes in the sceptical community and quite possibly an amplifying factor for such attitudes.

Yep....that's exactly how I see it...good post.
 
That's the story of my life, and many times I've been relegated to Busch beer. (and Ayn would understand -- you don;t drink on credit).
...or gamble on credit. Those things are why god invented stealing. I also found it dangerous to borrow money for hookers and strippers. Especially if the guy you borrow money from is Guido the killer pimp.
 
The good thing about all this brouhaha is that you always learn something.

What is sexual objectification?

Sexual objectification is the viewing of people solely as de-personalised objects of desire instead of as individuals with complex personalities and desires/plans of their own. This is done by speaking/thinking of women especially as only their bodies, either the whole body, or as fetishised body parts.
Sexual attraction is not the same as sexual objectification: objectification only occurs when the individuality of the desired person is not acknowledged. Pornography, prostitution, sexual harassment and the representation of women in mass media and art are all examples of common sexual objectification.
The concept of objectification owes much to the work of Simone de Beauvoir regarding the basic dualism of human consciousness between the Self and the Other: the general mental process where humans classify the world into ‘us’ and ‘them’. Women are universally viewed as the Other across all cultures, a role which is both externally imposed and internalised, and which means that women are generally not truly regarded as fully human. An important point of de Beauvoir’s was that this Othering effect is the same whether women are viewed as wholly inferior or if femininity is viewed as mysterious and morally superior: Otherness and full equality cannot coexist.

http://finallyfeminism101.wordpress.com/2007/03/23/faq-what-is-sexual-objectification/

I'm still digesting this. When I'll expel the wooish and superfluous parts I hope I'll have a clearer picture.

In the meantime, can anyone convince me that sexual objectification is a problem in itself?
 
I agree that it has nothing to do with whether or not RW felt uncomfortable. It is relevant to another claim - whether it is reasonable to expect men to realize when they may make someone uncomfortable.

Linda

With lonely women in dark places like alleys or parking areas or in confined spaces like elevators outside usual business-times, I assume that I would scare them as a default.

My strategy for not freaking them out is either to change street side at great distance, or to to make short eye-contact, give them my friendliest 'good evening', on the theory that a completely silent stranger is more scary, and immediately break contact. In elevators the iPhone is very helpful, because it allows me to appear completely absorbed in reading my mail.

After the assertions of Ivor and others that they are scared too, I will extend this to lonely men in such situations too.
 
.... Regarding her sex-positive image, I am firmly convinced that no matter how much you slut yourself up, you still retain autonomy regarding your sexuality, so her complaints about being sexualized in a way she felt to be inappropriate are, in my mind, completely within in her rights. ....
So one can promote publicly their sexuality then complain about a guy hitting on you in a fairly benign way? Some of us think it might be sexist to assume "my room", "coffee", and "don't take this the wrong way" means sex was all the guy could have possibly wanted.

How was EG supposed to know it wasn't OK?

Some people claim every guy should have known based on how they perceived vulnerable women in 5 star hotel elevators at 4 am in a "foreign" country. Not all of us agree with the depiction of the setting.

RW claimed EG should have known because of her panel discussion and comments she made in the bar that she was tired and going to bed. Not all of us are convinced EG heard and/or interpreted RW's comments the way RW is certain EG must have heard and understood.

One has to wonder if RW would have had the same reaction had she been attracted to EG. Not all of us are convinced RW's perception of the situation was based on the things she cites as opposed to simply being tired or bored with male admirers. And could discussing the incident on the video have been motivated by wanting to tout that she had admirers?
 
Regarding her sex-positive image, I am firmly convinced that no matter how much you slut yourself up, you still retain autonomy regarding your sexuality, so her complaints about being sexualized in a way she felt to be inappropriate are, in my mind, completely within in her rights.

Of course. It's just a bit ironic, considering that she sexualised and objectified herself, only to later find it unfortunate that other people sexualised and objectified her, assuming that we accept that this is what happened, which I don't.

As for the way she handled criticism, I already said what I think about it. She hardly is the only prominent skeptic who is guilty of occasional dickery though.

Which in no way nullifies the criticism, and is irrelevant.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom