These have been my concerns and observations also. Rebecca would likely have gotten little if any response had she not presumed to speak for all women. Had she said, "this is my view and I suspect the view of many other women" there would have been little to complain about. It's that presumption and the presumption that EG was somehow "creepy" or "sexist" that I think lies at the heart of this conundrum. I don't think people have gotten to the core of why they are viscerally upset by this.
I agree that it's the presumption. I didn't agree with her the first time I saw the very first video, and when I gathered more context, I stood by my first conclusion. Needless to say, the worse events came later.
She didn't explicitly say that she was speaking for all women, but she explicitly demanded men in general to not behave that way, which affects all women too.
She didn't explicitly say that EG was sexist either, but since she referred to her earlier panel talk, which according to her EG didn't grab, I had to look for more context to see what EG "didn't grab". Her talk focused on sexism and misogyny within the society in general and the skeptic community in particular and how women are deprived from being more present in the community, with particular emphasis in her hate mail.
So, taking context into account, she used EG as an example to illustrate the sexism she was referring to in her talk, which is a major concern to her. My take on this is, if you use an example like this to illustrate this "problem of sexism", you'll have a hard time convincing people of the message you're trying to convey.
Also, I think that, concerning feminism, a proactive strategy nowadays can be more fruitful than a reactive one. But that depends on what you want. I'm not sure what RW wants. If I were a woman invited to a "communicating atheism" talk, I think I'd rather talk about someting related to communicating atheism and I'd try to impress my audience independently of my gender with my skills and tools in communicating atheism.
Last edited: