So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Slightly exaggerated version :D
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IjrWOZby8s8

It doesn't take "anxiety" to be aware of your surroundings and checking for threats and reaction options. It doesn't even take thinking that the only possible threats are humans. It just takes wanting to be aware of circumstances.

The real point is that not just that people can and do have this situational awareness themselves, but also that we can and should base our behavior on knowing that other people do it too. (Maybe not as consciously or in as much detail as some describe, but everybody gets gut feelings of what situations are risky and what situations aren't.) That's how I know that if I'm walking along the street in the same direction as someone else who happens to have gotten there shortly before I did, I should wait until they're far ahead of me or cross the street and keep walking on the other side so I'm not "following" them. It's why lines at ATMs always start a few yards back from the person who's using the ATM instead of immediately behind him/her as lines elsewhere do. It's why when somebody looks at you with a certain look on his/her face and certain eye movement patterns, you subconsciously know to maintain a larger distance and a relaxed posture & vocal tone with no big gesticulations. It's why when you know someone else is nearby but they seem not to know you're there and might be startled to discover you, you find a way to inform them of your presence innocuously. It's why the last time I approached a woman who was a total stranger, I did it in a wide open well-lit place where other people would be within sight, and still put myself slightly off to the side of her path instead of right in it in front of her. For that matter, it's not even just humans; when I meet a new dog or cat, I have to keep in mind that my normal speaking voice will sound like a purr to a cat but like a growl to a dog, and that if I'm sitting or kneeling, I should turn away before standing up to leave instead of standing up while still facing the animal.
 
Sorry, you've lost me. Could you elaborate? And I promise I'm not being obtuse. I've gone back and read a couple of your posts to try and glean some context but I'll be damn if I know. Are you saying this is some kind of clincher that proves something? If so, what does it prove? I can see how it could be argued to go both ways. But more strongly toward just being coffee. :)

Very interesting. So had he not said, "don't take this the wrong way" then it would *not* have been an invitation for casual sex but interpreted as a polite request for conversation over coffee? I didn't realize that RW had made that clear in her presentation. It just goes to show you how EG didn't pay any attention at all to what she had to say.


No, that was just a joke. Sorry for the confusion.

But while we're on the subject; if it's fair for EG to have heard Watson say "I'm exhausted and want to get some sleep" and somehow interpret those words as not meaning she was exhausted and wanted to get some sleep, then it's fair for Watson to have heard his request to come up to his room alone for coffee as not meaning he wanted coffee.

...which, as I said, still doesn't matter because even if he honestly just wanted coffee, it was inconsiderate as Rebecca had announced that she needed sleep. It's not as if she said "Man, I'm really tired", and then proceeded to wander around and do other things for a while to the point where the guy following her may have forgotten that she said she wanted to go to bed.
 
Last edited:
Deleted. I obviously need to stay out of discussions like this. Call it cultural difference.

Hans
 
Last edited:
Watched Rebecca's video.

If she said "No," and that was it, why was the video even necessary?

The contention is that the sexual attention which female speakers/ delegates receive at these types of conferences is a factor which discourages women from attending. The rape argument appears to have been drawn out, or bolted on, after the initial complaint.
 

The contention is that the sexual attention which female speakers/ delegates receive at these types of conferences is a factor which discourages women from attending. The rape argument appears to have been drawn out, or bolted on, after the initial complaint.

The additional contention appears to be that refusing to completely condemn this man and anyone like him as guilty of the most heinous crimes against womankind, makes one a misogynist ignorant of basic feminist thought who should be publicly shamed at every opportunity.
 
Watched Rebecca's video.

If she said "No," and that was it, why was the video even necessary?

picture.php
 
See my response to Linda. The data are relevant in deciding how we address the issue.

I don't agree.

I'm perfectly fine with how RW felt uncomfortable and decided to say that she was, asking people not to do that to her. My only beef here is calling EG sexist or other labels for what he did. There's a lot of assumptions running around. Not to mention strawmen. The actual risk of EG being a rapist is not only irrelevant but also impossible to calculate.
 
About men having to be aware: I've always done this. Always felt the need to have my antennae out for threats. Also, for a specific kind of potential threat from women: the possibility that she'll find me threatening, and will shout for help. I've had two very frightening incidents when women perceived me as a threat and loudly threatened to scream "rape" if I didn't back off. There were security guards in the area during one of these incidents; it would have been her word against mine. I didn't feel like having my life ruined, so I backed very far off. Ever since, I've given solitary women a wide berth . And if at all possible, I make sure I'm seen by security cameras; I make sure I'm never alone with a strange woman but always within sight of other people. All this is not for their safety (I know I won't hurt them); but for mine.
 
<snip>

The actual risk of EG being a rapist is not only irrelevant but also impossible to calculate.

Hey, if archaeologists can make up a story deduce how that ice bloke died thousands of years ago, I'm sure us lot can come up with one poxy number for something that didn't happen in an elevator last month. At least give it a few more dozen pages and then let's see where we are, okay?
 
I don't agree.

I'm perfectly fine with how RW felt uncomfortable and decided to say that she was, asking people not to do that to her. My only beef here is calling EG sexist or other labels for what he did. There's a lot of assumptions running around. Not to mention strawmen. The actual risk of EG being a rapist is not only irrelevant but also impossible to calculate.

I agree that it has nothing to do with whether or not RW felt uncomfortable. It is relevant to another claim - whether it is reasonable to expect men to realize when they may make someone uncomfortable.

Linda
 
But while we're on the subject; if it's fair for EG to have heard Watson say "I'm exhausted and want to get some sleep" and somehow interpret those words as not meaning she was exhausted and wanted to get some sleep, then it's fair for Watson to have heard his request to come up to his room alone for coffee as not meaning he wanted coffee.

...which, as I said, still doesn't matter because even if he honestly just wanted coffee, it was inconsiderate as Rebecca had announced that she needed sleep. It's not as if she said "Man, I'm really tired", and then proceeded to wander around and do other things for a while to the point where the guy following her may have forgotten that she said she wanted to go to bed.
I can't read the guys mind so I don't know what he heard or knew. I think it likely he did hear and know that she wanted to go to bed. I would say that is inconsiderate. As for what Watson interpreted, I can't read her mind either. I think it very possible. But that is life. I'm annoyed by many things. And I'm intimidated from time to time. It's the cost of being human. Now, that's not to say that Rebecca doesn't have a right to speak out about it. Of course she does. I've said that countless times.
 
I don't agree.

I'm perfectly fine with how RW felt uncomfortable and decided to say that she was, asking people not to do that to her. My only beef here is calling EG sexist or other labels for what he did. There's a lot of assumptions running around. Not to mention strawmen. The actual risk of EG being a rapist is not only irrelevant but also impossible to calculate.
These have been my concerns and observations also. Rebecca would likely have gotten little if any response had she not presumed to speak for all women. Had she said, "this is my view and I suspect the view of many other women" there would have been little to complain about. It's that presumption and the presumption that EG was somehow "creepy" or "sexist" that I think lies at the heart of this conundrum. I don't think people have gotten to the core of why they are viscerally upset by this.
 
<snip>

I don't think people have gotten to the core of why they are viscerally upset by this.

Here’s my take on why people are pissed off:

Ms. Watson is a woman who has no particularly relevant skill or talent associated with scepticism. She has promoted herself and her organisation using blatant sexualisation and objectification of women in an attempt to appeal to the male-dominated sceptical community, a community which contains many men who are socially awkward, particularly around women. She is now complaining about a man from the sceptical community, who even by her account used polite phrasing, took no for an answer and may have been genuine in his invite for coffee and conversation in his room, of sexualising her and of sexism being a significant problem in the sceptical community.

1) She's an embarrassment.

2) She's a hypocrite.

3) Given what Skepchick stands for, it’s not part of the solution to sexist attitudes in the sceptical community and quite possibly an amplifying factor for such attitudes.
 

You're talking past each other. You are addressing actual risk and blauregen is talking about perception of risk.
Epepke has raised the interesting issue of the social acceptability of expressing concern over risk (real or perceived).

Eh yes. I took it to be self-evident that people react to their perception of risk, which may or may not reflect actual risk correctly. The provided study was nevertheless interesting to read, even if it didn't help with my question.
 
Last edited:
Here’s my take on why people are pissed off:

Ms. Watson is a woman who has no particularly relevant skill or talent associated with scepticism. She has promoted herself and her organisation using blatant sexualisation and objectification of women in an attempt to appeal to the male-dominated sceptical community, a community which contains many men who are socially awkward, particularly around women. She is now complaining about a man from the sceptical community, who even by her account used polite phrasing, took no for an answer and may have been genuine in his invite for coffee and conversation in his room, of sexualising her and of sexism being a significant problem in the sceptical community.

1) She's an embarrassment.

2) She's a hypocrite.

3) Given what Skepchick stands for, it’s not part of the solution to sexist attitudes in the sceptical community and quite possibly an amplifying factor for such attitudes.
Thanks Ivor. Fair enough.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom