So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Men do it constantly, especially when we're with other people. This is blitheringly obvious. Every nanosecond of being out, I'm plotting routes, think of lighting, other people, sources of help, even what the potholes are like. Every single of time when I'm out with a woman or even alone, I'm constantly aware of the social milieu, the body language of other people, the opportunities of escape from a bad situation, who is going in what direction, the level of voices raised, who has a pool cue, who has muscle tension, the topology and geometry of the buildings and street, even the cracks in the sidewalk. We all know, if we're good, exactly what to wear (even if it does not correspond to women's fashion sense), how to walk, where to walk, and how to respond to approaches. We are aware of when other men look at us, the subtle movements of eye muscles and muscle tension that might indicate that someone is looking for a fight.

Really? Then I am sorry to hear this, and happy for my sheltered existence. Because my basic environmental awareness is more concerned with orientation, than with plotting escape routes. My social awareness more with understanding what people are saying, than with identifying threats. I am mostly only worried about getting into a fight when there is already enough mutual brag and bluster about something. I also was hardly ever concerned whether anything I wear or do could provoke an attack (ok, I wouldn't ever have worn a fishnet-shirt and tight leather in certain areas, because some things can be dangerous to advertise ), but overall my level of anxiety is rather low in this regard.

We just don't make a big fat hairy histrionic deal about it, because nobody cares, and nobody is going to give us any sympathy. We learned this the first time we got knocked down in a sports game, and nothing since then has changed our minds. Maybe we learned it at age 1, when we expressed fear and vulnerability and it was interpreted as anger. In any event, we learned that we weren't going to get any help, and most of us adapted.

This could of course be the reason, that not only have I a vastly different experience, but that didn't find much clues to this in most men I know. Or it is a geographical thing.
 
This could of course be the reason, that not only have I a vastly different experience, but that didn't find much clues to this in most men I know. Or it is a geographical thing.

I don't know. It could be. I grew up in New York City, and I became aware of this at an extremely young age. Maybe people who grew up elsewhere had a different experience.

In any event, it's difficult to find out, because you are just not going to be able to get men to open up about it without extreme effort. I mean, I'll talk about it, because I'm particularly obnoxious, and I've adopted the attitude that I just do no care what other people think about me.

ETA: So I rather suspect that there are far more men who have had this experience than men who talk about it and put it on display in any way.
 
Last edited:
We're not talking about a hard physical science like physics or chemistry.
That doesn't change anything.

All we have available are the types of studies done by Pinker and other researchers in language and cognition and our own observations and experiences.
Pinker or anyone who deals in sociobiology be it linguistics or cognitive behavior will tell you that they don't speak to individual behavior. They can only talk about groups. Statistical probability measured over statistically significant sample sizes for some confidence in the data and then repeated studies, meta analysis and optimum sample sizes for consensus. Again, about groups, not individual behavior.

I am very sorry to hear about your niece and I hope she is doing OK now.
Thanks I appreciate that.
 
The validity of the 2008 promotional video has been called into question. I'm trying to track it down.

In the mean time, you can enjoy this official and genuine video, which is even more lubricious:



ETA: Warning! Bare nipples!
 
Last edited:
I hope I've convinced some people, regardless of how they feel about this specific incident, that there is another side to promoting feminist causes. Sometimes it is about empowering women, not simply un-empowering men.

Yes, and that's more Paula Kirby's approach, which was sadly misrepresented by RW at the "Communicating Atheism" before going into details with her own hate mail.

I'm honestly shocked with this whole thing. Who is this girl? Why has she become so popular within the skeptic community? It must've been more about marketing than skills. And that's kind of worrying.
 
I don't know. It could be. I grew up in New York City, and I became aware of this at an extremely young age. Maybe people who grew up elsewhere had a different experience.

In any event, it's difficult to find out, because you are just not going to be able to get men to open up about it without extreme effort. I mean, I'll talk about it, because I'm particularly obnoxious, and I've adopted the attitude that I just do no care what other people think about me.

ETA: So I rather suspect that there are far more men who have had this experience than men who talk about it and put it on display in any way.

I grew up in Barcelona and I'm usually very aware of where I am at every moment, especially when I'm alone. What part of the city I am, how many people are there around, etc. I've had my share of negative experiences in the past. It becomes routine.
 
I don't know. It could be. I grew up in New York City, and I became aware of this at an extremely young age. Maybe people who grew up elsewhere had a different experience.

In any event, it's difficult to find out, because you are just not going to be able to get men to open up about it without extreme effort. I mean, I'll talk about it, because I'm particularly obnoxious, and I've adopted the attitude that I just do no care what other people think about me.

ETA: So I rather suspect that there are far more men who have had this experience than men who talk about it and put it on display in any way.

As a single man I find myself a magnet for the attention of groups of young men who wish to pick on someone and prove how tough they are to the women with them. Fortunately I’m usually out on a run when this happens so I get past them quickly.

The idea that when in public single women have a higher level of anxiety than single men is laughable. There are many more violent thugs than rapists.
 
The idea that when in public single women have a higher level of anxiety than single men is laughable. There are many more violent thugs than rapists.

Interresting. As I wrote, it doesn't match, my experience, regarding caution when alone with strangers in confined or deserted space, but I'll see whether I can find some studies to confirm or reject your assertion.

If men on average really report a similar level of anxiety in situations like for example walking alone through a dark alley, hitchhiking, going alone into bars or travelling alone, then i would have to revise my assumptions there.
 
Interresting. As I wrote, it doesn't match, my experience, regarding caution when alone with strangers in confined or deserted space, but I'll see whether I can find some studies to confirm or reject your assertion.

If men on average really report a similar level of anxiety in situations like for example walking alone through a dark alley, hitchhiking, going alone into bars or travelling alone, then i would have to revise my assumptions there.

http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/20110218135832/rds.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/pdfs04/r214.pdf

Key points

  • Research consistently shows the peak time for violent offending is weekend nights and thepeak location is in and around pubs and clubs (Allen et al., 2003).
  • Violence in the night-time economy typically involves young males who do not know each other well. Resulting injuries are often facial, some of which are ‘glassings’ (Allen et al., 2003; Hutchison et al., 1998).
  • Most incidents involve drinking by the offender, victim or both (Murdoch et al., 1990).
  • Alcohol contributes to violence in many direct and indirect ways (Graham et al., 1998).
  • Factors associated with violence in high-risk pubs and clubs include inconvenient accessroutes, poor ventilation, overcrowding, and permissive social environments, communicated through pub/club policies and staff behaviour (Homel et al., 2001).
  • Violence outside venues may be associated with large numbers of intoxicated people congregating and competing for limited food and transport facilities (Marsh and Fox-Kibby, 1992).

ETA:

Characteristics and consequences of violence in the night-time economy

Participants

Violence in the night-time economy predominantly involves young males as both offenders and victims. In Maguire and Nettleton’s (2003) Cardiff study of police and A&E data, 72% of those arrested for violence and disorder were aged under 30 and 88% were male. The proportions for victims were similar.

A national A&E study found people aged 15 to 25 were at highest risk of assault-related injuries in bars. About ten times more males than females had been assaulted in licensed premises (Hutchison et al., 1998).
 
Last edited:
Interresting. As I wrote, it doesn't match, my experience, regarding caution when alone with strangers in confined or deserted space, but I'll see whether I can find some studies to confirm or reject your assertion.

If men on average really report a similar level of anxiety in situations like for example walking alone through a dark alley, hitchhiking, going alone into bars or travelling alone, then i would have to revise my assumptions there.
It probably depends on the guy and the situation. I'm pretty sure my son and his friend were quite nervous walking from the bus station to the youth hostel in WA DC because there were a number of surly looking guys they had to walk past. And I've rarely felt nervous when I've traveled alone. The only reason I don't like going someplace like a bar alone is because it isn't that much fun, not because it would make me nervous.

Oh, yeah and I walk my two dogs at night around my neighborhood and alone on the park trails all the time and the dogs aren't really big enough to protect me from much. I never feel nervous doing it.

I'm not trying to say it is equal, but I suspect it is less unequal that you might think.
 
Last edited:

You're talking past each other. You are addressing actual risk and blauregen is talking about perception of risk.
Epepke has raised the interesting issue of the social acceptability of expressing concern over risk (real or perceived).
What is with all these fearful women you guys are familiar with? And macho guys? I haven't have that same experience. Many of my girlfriends are pretty much like me. And I can relate to what Ivor is saying. Clearly guys can be nervous under many circumstances. If we are going to talk about stereotypes, I have one in mind of guys with some bizarre social behavior of frequently intimidating each other.
 
I'm still getting the facts on this, and just finished reading Greta Christina's blog on this. When we say "Propositioned," are we saying, "Would you be interested in having breakfast with me?" or "I'd like nothing more than to have sweaty monkey sex with you right here and now." If it was more in line with the first, Dawkins might have a point, but if it's the latter, Watson definitely does. I don't know. I'm not attractive enough for anyone to proposition me, (and the one time anyone did, it was on I-5, and I'm not stopping by the side of the road for a little quickie while driving a day cab.)

There's too much I don't know about this yet, and too much I don't know in broader contexts. I spend a lot of time around women, at truck stops, in offices, and the like, and having been married for over 26 years, I'm not exactly in a rush to hit on women I don't know, simply because there's too much to lose once my wife finds out.

Having said that:

None of the above. Frankly, I'm not sure what's more unnerving: That Dawkins would make light of Watson's very real and valid concerns, or her demand that we reconsider where to spend our money. Dawkins is right that Muslim women suffer horribly, but others are correct that Dawkins is missing -- or ignoring -- her point.

Sad to say that women are still treated as objects by this society, that they run the risk of being sexually assaulted simply for drawing breath, or, heaven forbid, dressing "sexually." I'm sure Jesse Helms and his ilk are nodding with the latter, lamenting that women just don't "know their place anymore," but the reality remains that Watson felt threatened.

True story: Similar situation for me, though it was here in the States, and I was in a particular town for driver's orientation. All I said was "Hello." I was simply being polite.

The woman I shared that elevator with immediately tensed up. I don't know why, except that I was a (fairly large) man alone with her in an elevator, it was very early in the morning, and the hotel in Dallas was kind of ratty. We hit the ground floor, I went to breakfast, and the woman made a quick exit. That told me right there any further conversation would not have been received well. (Including any suggestion that getting some was on my mind.)

Not hard to figure out.

So, Dawkins is a clod. No surprise; as has been pointed out, Atheism has no perfected masters. Trust me, I've been a clod on more than one occasion myself. So, I'm also not going to tell Rebecca Watson she needs to "get over it," because I don't know the whole story, nor her past, nor anything else about this situation.

When do I think rape is more likely? I honestly don't know. Frankly, I'd be more concerned with someone who said nothing at all on an elevator. At that point, you have no clue what they might do.

And that would only be a best guess.
 
As far as bringing up statistics...

It has been suggested that men should be aware of which circumstances make women anxious. Men may suspect that anxiety depends upon perceived risk which depends upon actual risk. If people aren't rational about perceived risk vs. actual risk, it makes it difficult for a man to guess at what the perceived risk may be.

Linda
 
As far as bringing up statistics...

It has been suggested that men should be aware of which circumstances make women anxious. Men may suspect that anxiety depends upon perceived risk which depends upon actual risk. If people aren't rational about perceived risk vs. actual risk, it makes it difficult for a man to guess at what the perceived risk may be.

Linda

It is also important for how we tackle the issue.
If the perception of risk is accurate then what we need to address is behaviour, if the perception is not accurate then the most sensible thing to do is to try and tackle the perception.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom