So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
That's entirely irrelevant unless you have film or other witnesses to EGs question. It doesn't matter that we often say things that aren't meant to be taken literally, what you seem to believe matters is if that were the case here. Your video can't possibly show that. It's a red herring in that no one disagrees because no one cares, it isn't a point in contention. I don't think anyone is saying that EG must have been speaking literally, but that we can't know that he wasn't.

FWIW, I don't think it even matters. I mean, it matters if we want to get into the "sexism" business; but as I've said before, when someone stands up and says "I'm exhausted and have to go get some sleep", following her into the elevator and asking her to not go to bed, but instead come and keep you company because you still feel like talking manages to be rather inconsiderate.
 
FWIW, I don't think it even matters. I mean, it matters if we want to get into the "sexism" business; but as I've said before, when someone stands up and says "I'm exhausted and have to go get some sleep", following her into the elevator and asking her to not go to bed, but instead come and keep you company because you still feel like talking manages to be rather inconsiderate.

I think there is a video somewhere that can show you why he might not have taken her words literally. :p
 
LOL! :D

@ Banquetbear: that ^ is my response to someone who can read over 2400 posts in this thread, but not watch a 11 minute video that IS relevant and does explain indirect communication that also takes into account context and timing.

I challenge you to go through a week of only speaking literally and taking everyone at their word literally. Post back to the thread if you manage to get through the experience alive.
As Pinker well points out, the point of vagueness is deniable plausibility. If the line can only be interpreted one way then there is no point to using it. BTW: I've asked many people out for coffee, men and women and not once has asking someone to have coffee ever been a come on. Once at UCLA in the Revlon building, riding the elevator, a guy offered me coffee. We went to the lounge, drank coffee and continued our discussion on the Raelian clone press conference. No sex was offered or expected of. FWIW: When I met my wife I was a practicing Mormon and didn't drink coffee. I've been in a monogamous relationship since then. So, no, I don't buy that. Do I think there was a likelihood that casual sex was in the offing? Yeah. Otherwise I've gotta agree that you can't read the guys mind and it's not appropriate to declare that there was only one possible motive.
 
As Pinker well points out, the point of vagueness is deniable plausibility. If the line can only be interpreted one way then there is no point to using it.

How about to avoid sabotaging your efforts by having to say "Don't take this the wrong way..."
 
That Watson could even get on a panel with Dawkins was somewhat surprising.
:D I almost started a thread asking what made some "panelists" panelists after seeing the video from this gathering. Another one there was Aron-Ra, who also doesn't have Dawkinsish qualifications. The fourth was a guy I can't identify. So two or three of the four were people who seemed to have been chosen based on having an internet audience already, for whatever reason or lack of reason THAT had happened. But then the question is not only whether that's really a qualification at all, but also how people's prior levels of possibly unqualified internet fame are established...
 
How about to avoid sabotaging your efforts by having to say "Don't take this the wrong way..."
Sorry, you've lost me. Could you elaborate? And I promise I'm not being obtuse. I've gone back and read a couple of your posts to try and glean some context but I'll be damn if I know. Are you saying this is some kind of clincher that proves something? If so, what does it prove? I can see how it could be argued to go both ways. But more strongly toward just being coffee. :)
 
Last edited:
How about to avoid sabotaging your efforts by having to say "Don't take this the wrong way..."

Very interesting. So had he not said, "don't take this the wrong way" then it would *not* have been an invitation for casual sex but interpreted as a polite request for conversation over coffee? I didn't realize that RW had made that clear in her presentation. It just goes to show you how EG didn't pay any attention at all to what she had to say.
 
In the interest of full disclosure, I'm one of those people who don't think that casual sex should have the same regard that most people give to a handshake. That influences my reaction to the story also, obviously.

If it should have any effect, it should create more doubt in your mind since you've probably never accepted any such offer and, well, actually had coffee and conversation (definitely not sex, right?).

The people who know are the ones who've asked (they know their intentions) and those who accepted (they know what happened). I've been on both sides. It was always conversation. The times I declined, I'm sure there would have been sex involved. I just know it!!! The times it was rejected, I'm pretty sure she figured I was after sex, so no great loss. Conversation isn't much fun when people invent their own meanings for your words.
 
:D I almost started a thread asking what made some "panelists" panelists after seeing the video from this gathering. Another one there was Aron-Ra, who also doesn't have Dawkinsish qualifications.

I was also skeptical of AronRa. However, after I heard him talk, I went to look at his videos. They are truly excellent. In my view, he deserved to be up there on the basis of his work, especially since Dawkins likes to mentor people younger than he.

The other guy, well, I cannot even find the video of him, and on Youtube it says that it has been withdrawn on his request. So I can't say much about him. It's possible that he was as poorly competent as Watson, and did not deserve to be there. It's perfectly OK to criticize him, and you're not going to get told that your criticism must be on the basis of his sex.

The fourth was a guy I can't identify. So two or three of the four were people who seemed to have been chosen based on having an internet audience already, for whatever reason or lack of reason THAT had happened. But then the question is not only whether that's really a qualification at all, but also how people's prior levels of possibly unqualified internet fame are established...

It's a good question. I'd go for two, because I think that AronRa has simply done worthwhile work which would stand up with or without the internet, though obviously the internet makes it easier.

Still, I think it's fairly incontrovertible that Watson's fame was mostly due to Skepchick and the sexualization attendant thereto.
 
That's entirely irrelevant unless you have film or other witnesses to EGs question. It doesn't matter that we often say things that aren't meant to be taken literally, what you seem to believe matters is if that were the case here. Your video can't possibly show that. It's a red herring in that no one disagrees because no one cares, it isn't a point in contention. I don't think anyone is saying that EG must have been speaking literally, but that we can't know that he wasn't.

It's not entirely irrelevant because we are talking about a social situation and in social situations words are only a part of the communication process. Voice tone, body language, timing, time of day, context and more all add meaning to face to face communication.

We can't know, but we can make a good guess and we can all decide what we would do in that situation.

As Pinker well points out, the point of vagueness is deniable plausibility.

Agreed.

RandFan said:
If the line can only be interpreted one way then there is no point to using it. BTW: I've asked many people out for coffee, men and women and not once has asking someone to have coffee ever been a come on. Once at UCLA in the Revlon building, riding the elevator, a guy offered me coffee. We went to the lounge, drank coffee and continued our discussion on the Raelian clone press conference. No sex was offered or expected of.

:) Sounds like you had a nice time. And sometimes a cup of coffee means just a cup of coffee. However, in the EG & RW story, there were other factors factored in as many posters far more eloquent than me had discussed. As a result, if we were to take a poll, probably more people than not would assume that casual sex was being offered.


FWIW: When I met my wife I was a practicing Mormon and didn't drink coffee. I've been in a monogamous relationship since then. So, no, I don't buy that. Do I think there was a likelihood that casual sex was in the offing? Yeah. Otherwise I've gotta agree that you can't read the guys mind and it's not appropriate to declare that there was only one possible motive.

In social situations its not about mind reading -- its about making your best guess based on whats being communicated (both verbally and nonverbally), past experience and an understanding of society's norms and unwritten rules and guidelines.

I think part of the reason I find this interesting is because I find face to face communication along with its unwritten social rules and patterns interesting.

I guess we are all interested in this story for different reasons, but this is the main reason that its grabbed my attention.
 
Last edited:
:) Sounds like you had a nice time. And sometimes a cup of coffee means just a cup of coffee. However, in the EG & RW story, there were other factors factored in as many posters far more eloquent than me had discussed. As a result, if we were to take a poll, probably more people than not would assume that casual sex was being offered.
Well yeah, truth is based on popularity. ;)

In social situations its not about mind reading -- its about making your best guess based on whats being communicated (both verbally and nonverbally), past experience and an understanding of society's norms and unwritten rules and guidelines.
Agreed. And it was prefectly appropriate for RW to follow her intutions. Not so much for us as we are not in danger of anything. That RW was uncomfortable, IMO, is reasonable. What isn't reasonable is for anyone to state for all women how those women should feel.

I think part of the reason I find this interesting is because I find face to face communication along with its unwritten social rules and patterns interesting.

I guess we are all interested in this story for different reasons, but this is the main reason that its grabbed my attention.
I think that is a good reason to be interested.

My niece was raped and the detectives/police refused to forward the case to prosecutors. I don't know why. My Sister has her suspicions. In any event my sister and her family were devastated and my niece adversely affected for a long time. I take rape and women's rights very seriously. I think we should be judicious in these cases and careful to be fair to all involved. Since this was a case where the guy took "no" to mean "no" I think that was a significant and important point, as well as RW's feelings about it.
 

Yes, I know. I think, I actually dug out the original quote when it came up. Mainly because I thought the discussion is muddled enough without an additional competition about who was abused most.

And, well, I guess I'm not saying anything new, but here it goes: males are also potential victims of all sorts of violence.

Oh yes, but I hardly see men worrying much over what might happen to them at night in dark alleys or declining rides from other persons, because it could be too dangerous, so overall, we might talk about a difference in caused anxiety and resulting changes in behavior. A few purely opinionated and anecdotical examples are here.


I hope you don't mind if I practice my TEFL.

No, thank you. It is helpful.

If you listen to the original video and to Rebecca on the SGU podcast, she states that it was about being hit on. She didn't originally even describe it as perceived stalking.

But she is explicit about the context.

Uh, I don't really know how else to explain how this makes me incredibly uncomfortable, but I'll just sort of lay it out that I was a single woman, you know, in a foreign country, at 4am, in a hotel elevator with you, just you, and—don't invite me back to your hotel room, right after I've finished talking about how it creeps me out and makes me uncomfortable when men sexualize me in that manner.

Jen McCreight elaborates nicely about why the context matters in social interactions. The word stalking though is as far as i know never mentioned. It is just a fitting term for how it seemed to have been perceived by a lot of the comments I read on various blogs.

I think the "field of expertise" or speculating from a priviledged position is about understanding the experience of the minority, not about being uncomfortable.

That's what I meant and what became clear in the linked comment.

Why would the author think that most people would not see that men and women might be equally "uncomfortable" riding an elevator with someone they just rejected? It's quite the straw man to complain about a sexist attitude for which there is no evidence did or would occur.

Possibly because of the undeniable anabolic effect of high testosterone levels, which give on average a distinct advantage if the rejection isn't accepted, and possibly due to different socialization. Men get a lot less caution against the dangers of being alone with strange persons.

In addition, it goes against the goal of women's lib to promote a solution that requires men take action when the woman experiencing an unwanted sexual interest like this one could so easily handle it herself. The expectation a man needs to act to correct this problem is the exact opposite of women's liberation.

The funny thing is, I agree with you. It would be desirable, if women were on average more decisive and confident in their ability to handle unwanted sexual interest, and if rejection would be always understood. But from what I hear from friends and from what I read this isn't social reality. Unfortunately the degree of actual danger as portrayed by some, predominantly gender feminist sources, doesn't look like social reality either.

Therefore thank you for bringing up some statistics about elevators, though I still think reducing the problem to this specific situation is a disservice.

As for the "talk is not rape", it isn't. People exaggerating what EG did or said is more straw.

As is bringing up situations that portray him as completely benign to dismiss RW's concern. We don't know what he intended. He could have been completely harmless and well-meaning, he could have been shy, he could have speculated on the anxiety of a woman alone with him in a confined space to reject him. What we do know is what reactions this specific approach caused.
 
Has the PR genius of the Rebeca chick been mentioned yet? Just google "elevator" and "sexism", she owns the first page.

By the way, JREF is #4 on the list and rising!

Keep posting and clicking on this most interesting topic; are drunk men, in fact, attracted to tits and ass.
Yes, as are sober men. Details at eleven ... :cool:
Whatever floats your boat, I guess.
Moby, his post was a bit of sarcasm.
Because all men want to do with women is **** them.
I sometimes just like to have a cup of coffee with a lady, but not usually at 4 AM. Does that make me wrong?
A tattoo that says "Mom" is not creepy. A tattoo that says "Pork!" is creepy.
Respectfully disagree. Some people really love pork.
Can I just tangent for a moment from the original EG/Dawkins comment and offer up an observation I've had regarding Rebecca for quite a while - She has built up quite the personality cult around her and this whole bruhaha as reminded me of a chapter in Shermer's "Why People Believe Weird Things" entitled The Unlikeliest Cult. It's disturbing to see "skeptics" using buzz words and presuming things without any evidence what-so-ever. Whatever happened in that elevator in Dublin, what has happened in the skeptic community since then has been even more ugly and I'm sorry, but that blame doesn't rest on Rebecca and her attention whoring, but on the cultish behavior of readers of a marginal blog and the endless blather that constitutes podcasts and Youtube videos.
Correct.
You will note that the drama section of the video store is always much larger than the education or documentary section.
Touche'

After sixty pages, same things mostly, but a few nice bits of food for thought.

Glad I am out of the dating / scoring game. Appears to have more hazards than a Bosnian minefield.
 
The people who know are the ones who've asked (they know their intentions) and those who accepted (they know what happened). I've been on both sides. It was always conversation. The times I declined, I'm sure there would have been sex involved. I just know it!!! The times it was rejected, I'm pretty sure she figured I was after sex, so no great loss. Conversation isn't much fun when people invent their own meanings for your words.

I mentioned this, but more seriously, many, many pages ago, or perhaps in the older thread. Invitations in the middle of of the night amongst male conventioneers happen all the time. It's simple a fact that people are so busy during the day that people don't have time to talk one-on-one. It's happened to me many times, and I've done it many times. Just to name one example, how else did I find myself drinking gin with Stephen Wolfram at 5 AM?

Of course, I got put-down for saying this, told there were essential differences between men and women that I had to respect, and that I had a bizarre notion of equality, and so on and so forth.

So, basically, there's a demand from a woman, on behalf of all women, that I not treat women the same way that I treat men. OK, fine. I have no desire to tick women off. Enough aggravation, and I will accede to demands.

However, I've gotten many insights, job opportunities, invitations to panels and talks, and general professional opportunities from these impromptu, late night and early morning meetings. If there is a general demand from women that they be spared this, then, if they are convincing, they won't get it. When they don't get it, it's not my fault, nor is it the fault of "The Patriarchy" or men in general.
 
If it should have any effect, it should create more doubt in your mind since you've probably never accepted any such offer and, well, actually had coffee and conversation (definitely not sex, right?).

The people who know are the ones who've asked (they know their intentions) and those who accepted (they know what happened). I've been on both sides. It was always conversation. The times I declined, I'm sure there would have been sex involved. I just know it!!! The times it was rejected, I'm pretty sure she figured I was after sex, so no great loss. Conversation isn't much fun when people invent their own meanings for your words.

Getting a little tired and probably won't have time to post over the next few days, so I'll just jot down this post in more of an outline fashion than prose.

* In post #1882 I talked about one of those times when I decided to take someone's words literally.

* While I have my goals I'm not perfect so, in the past, I've been on both sides too.

* I've grown up partially deaf. I've socialized with people who also grew up partially deaf and were not taught ASL, people who acquired hearing loss later in life, and hearing people.

I have noticed that when hearing loss was acquired (assuming that there was no exposure to ASL) can have an impact on people's communication styles. Often people who acquire significant hearing loss before learning to talk are much more likely to speak directly and interpret conversation more literally than other folks. I don't believe that is due to intelligence issues, I think its because listening and lip reading can take so much work that a HoH person can be too busy jigsawing sounds into words to take much notice of some of the indirect aspects of face to face communication. This can often cause a lot of interpersonal problems.

From a combination of improved hearing aids, getting beat up (figuratively, not literally) by people who expected me to know better, and a lot of reflection -- I've gotten better at understanding the indirect aspects of face to face communication, luckily.

So, unless I'm in a really noisy room, I'm pretty confident of my ability to communicate face to face.
 
Last edited:
qqqq

I have skimmed most of the threads on EG, and find that there is just not enough information about the situation to even consider an opinion. The scenario has been made into an absurd dialog that has divided an entire community of so called "thinking people".

However, I just wonder why one of the lady's numerous male "friends" at the bar didn't offer to walk her to her room? I can't imagine letting a friend risk finding her way alone at 4 AM in a strange place, especially after drinking.

PS. I did not vote, because the poll is unpleasantly facetious.
 
Well yeah, truth is based on popularity. ;)

We're not talking about a hard physical science like physics or chemistry.
All we have available are the types of studies done by Pinker and other researchers in language and cognition and our own observations and experiences. I understand that we are at risk for bias, and probably even the language studies are more at risk for bias than the hard sciences studies -- but we got to work with what we got. That's all I'm trying to say.

Agreed. And it was prefectly appropriate for RW to follow her intutions. Not so much for us as we are not in danger of anything. That RW was uncomfortable, IMO, is reasonable. What isn't reasonable is for anyone to state for all women how those women should feel.

I think that is a good reason to be interested.

My niece was raped and the detectives/police refused to forward the case to prosecutors. I don't know why. My Sister has her suspicions. In any event my sister and her family were devastated and my niece adversely affected for a long time. I take rape and women's rights very seriously. I think we should be judicious in these cases and careful to be fair to all involved. Since this was a case where the guy took "no" to mean "no" I think that was a significant and important point, as well as RW's feelings about it.

I am very sorry to hear about your niece and I hope she is doing OK now.
 
Oh yes, but I hardly see men worrying much over what might happen to them at night in dark alleys or declining rides from other persons, because it could be too dangerous, so overall, we might talk about a difference in caused anxiety and resulting changes in behavior. A few purely opinionated and anecdotical examples are here.

Men do it constantly, especially when we're with other people. This is blitheringly obvious. Every nanosecond of being out, I'm plotting routes, think of lighting, other people, sources of help, even what the potholes are like. Every single of time when I'm out with a woman or even alone, I'm constantly aware of the social milieu, the body language of other people, the opportunities of escape from a bad situation, who is going in what direction, the level of voices raised, who has a pool cue, who has muscle tension, the topology and geometry of the buildings and street, even the cracks in the sidewalk. We all know, if we're good, exactly what to wear (even if it does not correspond to women's fashion sense), how to walk, where to walk, and how to respond to approaches. We are aware of when other men look at us, the subtle movements of eye muscles and muscle tension that might indicate that someone is looking for a fight.

We just don't make a big fat hairy histrionic deal about it, because nobody cares, and nobody is going to give us any sympathy. We learned this the first time we got knocked down in a sports game, and nothing since then has changed our minds. Maybe we learned it at age 1, when we expressed fear and vulnerability and it was interpreted as anger. In any event, we learned that we weren't going to get any help, and most of us adapted.

We try to know everything about dangerous spots, in hotels and elsewhere. We are constantly looking for danger. Everywhere we go, we make 3-D maps in our heads based on minimal cues. That's why we play first-person shooters more than women. That's why we have even evolved brain differences with respect to 3-D representation. The evolutionary pressure was so strong on men that those men who couldn't do it simply died off.

I know people don't see this. Why should they? We're supposed to make it appear effortless and invisible. People don't want to see the thousands of hours before the barre; they just want to see the pirouettes. Hell, I don't want to see women spend hours in front of the makeup table. If we talk about it, we're "whiners." If we don't get it right, we're "creeps."

Now, one of the really nice things about getting older (I'm 50) is that we eventually get to the point where this stuff is second-nature. I don't think I'll ever get a reaction like EG, because I know what to do, and that knowledge has gotten to the point where it is instinctual. I read body language well enough to navigate most situations. Of course, when I talked about it, I got strawmanned. So, we don't. It just isn't worth the argie-bargie.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom