So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
More speculation. Might be true. After all, Watson just turned 30, an age at which many people massively change their sexual expectations. Might not be. We won't know until Watson posts something declaring a sea change. I doubt that will happen.

I looked for the announcement among the "Quickies" (ahem) on their website, but I didn't see it. Someone said she announced it at the bordello party last year between body shots, but that's just a rumor.

So I then looked at the Skepchick store. I did find a button that reads, "Is it subverting our genetic imperative if I **** in your face?" I almost missed it among the "Selective Pressure (in my pants)" and "All Natural" tee shirts. Taken in context I would have to say that it's innuendo for "take us seriously, not sexually."

I did stumble across a document with a declaration about toning down the sexuality. The source was not known to me, so I tried to verify the signature. The only known signature I could find was the following, but it didn't match:

Possibly Not Safe for Work

RebeccaSignature.jpg

 
I posted this over at Rational Skepticism. I hope it's ok to repeat it here. I think it has bearing on the questions at hand. Forgive me if someone has already made the point.

me said:
Something just occurred to me. People defending RW are saying EG didn't just approach RW; context is important: he approached her in an elevator at 4 am, and that's what makes it creepy. Well, let's really look at the context: EG didn't just approach an ordinary woman; RW was a public figure at a conference where it's a lot more likely that people would want to have the opportunity to talk with her. That happens all the time.

So considered in a fuller context, EG's actions seem much more likely to be completely innocent. To use RW's phrasing: Just a word to the wise here, guys: if you're a panel speaker at a conference and someone says they find you interesting and politely asks for some time to talk with you one-on-one, don't publicly humiliate them for "sexualizing you" and "creeping you out". Uhhhh, don't do that.


http://www.rationalskepticism.org/nontheism/atheism-and-feminism-or-watson-v-dawkins-t23650-1540.html#p927550
 
Pretty much the same here. Once I read what each party actually said when, I switched 'sides', although I still think Dawkins was a dick. But water is also wet.

True enough. I've known that Dawkins was a dick for some years now. I don't think that his statement was cool in any way, and the best thing I can say is that there is a small point about privilege in there somewhere.

I never paid much attention to the Skepchick, suspecting that it was a bunch of half-smart tweens who realized that they could get fame and status despite their obvious lack of talent by using their feminine wiles. Now I know rather than suspect. That Watson could even get on a panel with Dawkins was somewhat surprising. It does indicate a kind of sexism amongst atheists, but the polar opposite of the kind of sexism that Watson now demands we consider. Pheeeuw!

The real clincher moment was comparing what Watson said about Paula Kirby with what Kirby actually said (there's a link to the latter in my timeline). Watson does not demonstrate honesty, integrity, or even a particular talent for talking about skepticism. The endless apologia for her are distressing, though far from surprising.

There are still no doubt many people (including many women) who seriously believe that the only reason to criticize her is that she is a woman, i.e. sexism. These people, however, are obviously as dumb as a bag of rocks and do not deserve to be listened to. Nor does Watson.
 
I think you make a good point. I'm not convinced that there is a "side". I think that is the flaw in that thinking to begin with. However I wouldn't see it in terms of advancing feminist causes vs no change in other view points.

There's every reason to believe that there can be advances for all positions. We weed out some fallacious reasoning from the various viewpoints who see this from various feminist perspectives and pro-equality, sex positive positions.
What I meant by another side is that in some cases, one should consider there may be another way to look at the same thing. When this began, accusations flew out of one camp that those disagreeing weren't sympathetic to the feminist cause. I saw the opposite. People were reinforcing the belief women were vulnerable and needing protection in a situation where that wasn't the case.

Regardless of how one sees this situation, I hope some people might at least think about the messages and sentiments being reinforced from a different perspective.
 
Last edited:
What I meant by another side is that in some cases, one should consider there may be another way to look at the same thing. When this began, accusations flew out of one camp that those disagreeing were hurting the feminist cause. I saw the opposite. People were reinforcing the belief women were vulnerable and needing protection in a situation where that wasn't the case.

Regardless of how one sees this situation, I hope some people might at least think about the messages and sentiments being reinforced from a different perspective.
Thanks. Agreed. I hope people will consider all valid points that were raised. In my mind this was never a black and white issue. Far from it. There were many valid points and perspectives buried in all of the emotional based rhetoric and fallacy. It was a great starting point for discussion. Sadly, ego and emotion too often ruled the day. And let's face it, Dawkins and Watson engaged in fallacy and emotion themselves.
 
My personal beef with the original EG story was that EG asked for casual sex immediately.

...there is absolutely no evidence of this. We have a second hand account of someone being asked for coffee. Are you a mind reader? Were you there, in the elevator? Can you please supply the evidence that EG was asking for casual sex.
 
I looked for the announcement among the "Quickies" (ahem) on their website, but I didn't see it. Someone said she announced it at the bordello party last year between body shots, but that's just a rumor.

So I then looked at the Skepchick store. I did find a button that reads, "Is it subverting our genetic imperative if I **** in your face?" I almost missed it among the "Selective Pressure (in my pants)" and "All Natural" tee shirts. Taken in context I would have to say that it's innuendo for "take us seriously, not sexually."

I did stumble across a document with a declaration about toning down the sexuality. The source was not known to me, so I tried to verify the signature. The only known signature I could find was the following, but it didn't match:

Possibly Not Safe for Work

[qimg]https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-dQxOTTNbRUg/TiOWSVXu66I/AAAAAAAAABw/H-HnSKu-deo/s800/RebeccaSignature.jpg[/qimg]

Nominated. And brilliant.
 
...there is absolutely no evidence of this. We have a second hand account of someone being asked for coffee. Are you a mind reader? Were you there, in the elevator? Can you please supply the evidence that EG was asking for casual sex.

Feel free to disagree with me but just because you snipped out the parts of my post that you disagree with doesn't mean that I didn't write it.
 
Feel free to disagree with me but just because you snipped out the parts of my post that you disagree with doesn't mean that I didn't write it.

...I'm not going to spend ten minutes watching an unrelated video to get your point. You weren't in the elevator, and you cannot read the mind of the Elevator Guy. You cannot make the claim that he was asking for casual sex based on the information we have. He asked for coffee: that is undeniable. Your assertion he asked for sex is based on your interpretation of statements based on a person who may well be an unreliable narrator. Unless you were there, or you can read the Elevator Guys mind, you cannot make the assertion he was asking for sex.
 
So considered in a fuller context, EG's actions seem much more likely to be completely innocent. To use RW's phrasing: Just a word to the wise here, guys: if you're a panel speaker at a conference and someone says they find you interesting and politely asks for some time to talk with you one-on-one, don't publicly humiliate them for "sexualizing you" and "creeping you out". Uhhhh, don't do that.

If, on the other hand, they request that you come alone to their hotel room in the middle of the night for that polite one-on-one talk...
 
...I'm not going to spend ten minutes watching an unrelated video to get your point. You weren't in the elevator, and you cannot read the mind of the Elevator Guy. You cannot make the claim that he was asking for casual sex based on the information we have. He asked for coffee: that is undeniable. Your assertion he asked for sex is based on your interpretation of statements based on a person who may well be an unreliable narrator. Unless you were there, or you can read the Elevator Guys mind, you cannot make the assertion he was asking for sex.

Finally, someone I can actually show my etchings to.
 
True enough. I've known that Dawkins was a dick for some years now. I don't think that his statement was cool in any way, and the best thing I can say is that there is a small point about privilege in there somewhere.

I never paid much attention to the Skepchick, suspecting that it was a bunch of half-smart tweens who realized that they could get fame and status despite their obvious lack of talent by using their feminine wiles. Now I know rather than suspect. That Watson could even get on a panel with Dawkins was somewhat surprising. It does indicate a kind of sexism amongst atheists, but the polar opposite of the kind of sexism that Watson now demands we consider. Pheeeuw!

The real clincher moment was comparing what Watson said about Paula Kirby with what Kirby actually said (there's a link to the latter in my timeline). Watson does not demonstrate honesty, integrity, or even a particular talent for talking about skepticism. The endless apologia for her are distressing, though far from surprising.

There are still no doubt many people (including many women) who seriously believe that the only reason to criticize her is that she is a woman, i.e. sexism. These people, however, are obviously as dumb as a bag of rocks and do not deserve to be listened to. Nor does Watson.


I don't think it's a completely 'dumb' confusion. There really is sexism, problems with rape, and feminist issues not being taken seriously. The problem is when the knee jerk reaction leads us to support someone just because they claim to be addressing those issues well, and being attacked for it. We need to be skeptical, especially of ourselves.

There are rational supports for Rebecca. They just don't happen to be that people are disagreeing with her mostly because of sexism and misogyny.
 
Finally, someone I can actually show my etchings to.

LOL! :D

@ Banquetbear: that ^ is my response to someone who can read over 2400 posts in this thread, but not watch a 11 minute video that IS relevant and does explain indirect communication that also takes into account context and timing.

I challenge you to go through a week of only speaking literally and taking everyone at their word literally. Post back to the thread if you manage to get through the experience alive.
 
Last edited:
I don't think it's a completely 'dumb' confusion. There really is sexism, problems with rape, and feminist issues not being taken seriously. The problem is when the knee jerk reaction leads us to support someone just because they claim to be addressing those issues well, and being attacked for it. We need to be skeptical, especially of ourselves.

When it becomes facile rhetoric, rife with accusations, it's dumb. Stating that a non-dumb person might say something else is special pleading.

There are rational supports for Rebecca. They just don't happen to be that people are disagreeing with her mostly because of sexism and misogyny.

There are rational reasons to keep incandescent light bulbs available, including good perception of art, color matching for woodworking, and allowing color-blind people to see well. That doesn't make Rush Limbaugh any less dumb.
 
LOL! :D

@ Banquetbear: that ^ is my response to someone who can read over 2400 posts in this thread, but not watch a 11 minute video that IS relevant and does explain indirect communication that also takes into account context and timing.

I challenge you to go through a week of only speaking literally and taking everyone at their word literally. Post back to the thread if you manage to get through the experience alive.

That's entirely irrelevant unless you have film or other witnesses to EGs question. It doesn't matter that we often say things that aren't meant to be taken literally, what you seem to believe matters is if that were the case here. Your video can't possibly show that. It's a red herring in that no one disagrees because no one cares, it isn't a point in contention. I don't think anyone is saying that EG must have been speaking literally, but that we can't know that he wasn't.
 
When it becomes facile rhetoric, rife with accusations, it's dumb. Stating that a non-dumb person might say something else is special pleading.

I just don't want to lump the non-misleading people in with the other people who are being less than rational.


There are rational reasons to keep incandescent light bulbs available, including good perception of art, color matching for woodworking, and allowing color-blind people to see well. That doesn't make Rush Limbaugh any less dumb.

True, but I think we are talking past each other.
 
True, but I think we are talking past each other.

Probably. Oh, and,

I just don't want to lump the non-misleading people in with the other people who are being less than rational.

Name some. They probably exist, but the nose from the "less than rational" people has made them as hard to hear as a SETI signal on a crystal set.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom