So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Which is fine, because that's exactly the same list of options she had at her disposal, and she picked one of them.

If EG was sincere in actually just wanting to talk to RW, his chances would have been better if he had suggested that they meet the next day. Of course RW could have suggested that, but its unlikely that she would if she wasn't interested in casual sex and she had reason to believe that is what EG was actually asking for.

Did you watch the short Pinker video on his theory why people often choose to use innuendo or indirect language? Any comments on it?

Any, FWIW, obviously this thread has not gone on for 60 pages over just questions and answers in general.


I think there's two main reasons why this topic has gotten so much attention in various forums:

1) Many people disagree on what "Society's" social norms should be when it comes to any area relating to sexual behavior -- flirting, dating, sex, etc.

AND many of them want their norm to be society's norm.

2) There's been a conflation of other issues and terms including sexualization, objectification, misogyny, feminism and more. This is just insane. AFAICT, this conflation has mostly been due to bloggers, and assuming that bloggers self-select themselves to blog because they think they are good at communicating -- this just blows my mind.

If one needs a category for the original issue as per RW's first video blog: a preference not to be picked up for casual sex by strangers -- etiquette or social norms are probably far more accurate. I really fail to see what this has to do with feminism.

This conflation of issues and terms makes it impossible to discuss this topic effectively. So here we are at 60 pages with no end in sight.
 
Last edited:
It is an epic thread of fail. After 2400 posts, nobody has managed to convince anybody else of anything.
I don't think success is measured by how many people are convinced. For Hagel, social and moral progress is the synthesis of the dialectic. For Harvard Justice professor, Michael Sandel, social and moral progress is an equilibrium found between in an adversarial system. We move forward by discussion and debate. Like a person changes imperceptibly from day to day so does the zeitgeist often change slowly. If you expect a significant number of people, if any, involved in a debate to throw up there hands and say, yeah, you are right, then you are, IMHO, missing the point. We have to have unequal views and we have to express those views to each other in order to have any progress.
 
I don't think success is measured by how many people are convinced. For Hagel, social and moral progress is the synthesis of the dialectic. For Harvard Justice professor, Michael Sandel, social and moral progress is an equilibrium found between in an adversarial system. We move forward by discussion and debate. Like a person changes imperceptibly from day to day so does the zeitgeist often change slowly. If you expect a significant number of people, if any, involved in a debate to throw up there hands and say, yeah, you are right, then you are, IMHO, missing the point. We have to have unequal views and we have to express those views to each other in order to have any progress.
You must be right, since I disagree.
 
Yes, but I've seen no evidence of any progress of any kind being made here. Progress suggests some type of change. This entire thread has been nothing but its participants reiterating their views continuously, with no change at all. Now everyone knows how everyone else feels; but this information has proven spectacularly useless.
 
Yes, but I've seen no evidence of any progress of any kind being made here. Progress suggests some type of change. This entire thread has been nothing but its participants reiterating their views continuously, with no change at all. Now everyone knows how everyone else feels; but this information has proven spectacularly useless.

Guess I'm the exception; I changed "sides" after the Skepchick youtube promo was introduced into evidence.
 
It is an epic thread of fail. After 2400 posts, nobody has managed to convince anybody else of anything.

I've been convinced. I started off being strongly on the side of Watson. I thought that her request was mild and earnest and totally understandable, if a bit futile. I thought that her calling out of McGraw seemed uncool, but then again, I wasn't there, and I was willing to give her the benefit of the doubt. I thought that this entire bruhaha had been started and maintained by third parties, and that she was just caught up in it, that a mountain had been made out of a molehill, but that she was herself relatively innocent.

Now I'm strongly against. Mostly, her apologists pushed me in that direction, with their drivel, apologia, lies, and facile and stupid accusations, but that was only emotional. I tracked down links of things that Watson had said, and that convinced me.
 
Intuition has nothing to do with it. That you suggest it does means that you are demonstrating something called an availability bias. The more details that are given for a scenario, the easier it is to picture that scenario. And the easier it is to picture, the higher the probability you will give for its occurrence. By adding the detail "he makes a proposition", it becomes easier to see it as the kind of creepy scenario under which a rape would occur. Without that detail, "on an elevator with a man" doesn't seem particularly creepy, and you are inclined to give it a lower probability. And of course, you'd have to be wrong (don't feel bad, most everybody gets this wrong). The number of men who are on an elevator with a women and who proposition her has to be the combination of "on an elevator with a man" and "makes a proposition". There is no way for the intersection of two groups to be larger than than either one of the groups. The number of women who were raped after finding themselves alone on an elevator with a man has to include both the men who propositioned them and the men who did not. Which means that the number of women who were raped following "on an elevator with a man", has to be larger than either of the subgroups "and was/was not propositioned". Intuition has nothing to do with it.

Linda
And Checkmite thinks no one is learning anything here. :)
 
Must have missed it in the deluge. I didn't ask you, so I might have skipped over your post (not that you couldn't answer - just wasn't looking for it).

What!? You missed something in 60+ pages? Seriously? :p :D

I didn't answer the question before. I don't recall all the people who did, but it was at least two or three posters who answered that question several times in several different ways. I just repeated one of the answers given and skipped on repeating the explanation as to why some people would find that to be a more comfortable approach from a stranger at 4AM in the morning.


At an educational conference? Not really an option in my experience. The next day is either more meetings or everybody leaves (depending on the day). Time is usually scarce.

There's that insidious sexism again. If Rebecca suggests that they meet now, that's alright but the guy is not allowed? He's gotta set some future date?

I wonder if "why not meet now?" means "I want to have sex" in the same way that "let's have coffee and talk" does.

My personal beef with the original EG story was that EG asked for casual sex immediately. (Yes. I am disagreeing with you. We have a different opinion about context, timing and indirect communication. I lack the ability and patience to explain it, the best I can do is to suggest watching Pinker's video.) If EG had suggested that they meet another time it would at least have been a less abrupt way of communicating to a stranger at 4AM in an confined space. ETA: It would have been a way to see if RW had any interest in meeting with him at all before asking for physical intimacy.

In the interest of full disclosure, I'm one of those people who don't think that casual sex should have the same regard that most people give to a handshake. That influences my reaction to the story also, obviously.

It has been pointed out by other posters that RW has used sex as a marketing tool for her web site and it appears that some people believe that as long as pictures, calendars and video using sex to promote her site are still up -- she is sending mixed messages and therefore doesn't have the right to tell people not to "cold call" her for sex. At least that is my interpretation of some people's posts in this thread. As of now, I don't have a response to that. I still have to think about it.

No, and I have no intention of watching it. I *know* that people sometimes speak in innuendo. It's quite common. I don't think anyone has claimed that it's not possible that EG had an ulterior motive, but his statements as given would not have been innuendo.

<snip>
I disagree. The video is just under 11 minutes long. The content and editing is quite good, it has a fast pace to it and doesn't drag. I really recommend watching it.
 
Last edited:
Yes, but I've seen no evidence of any progress of any kind being made here. Progress suggests some type of change. This entire thread has been nothing but its participants reiterating their views continuously, with no change at all. Now everyone knows how everyone else feels; but this information has proven spectacularly useless.
How would you know? First, I'm pretty sure there are always more readers than commenters. Second, not every commenter announces they've changed their opinion. Some just don't post more. And third, how are you defining progress of any kind?

Personally, contemplating what it was about this incident that initially bothered me has been very useful to me. Seeing a very unskeptical personality cult within our ranks has been enlightening. And as always, Linda's knowledge about research methods continues to impress.

Perhaps you have made less progress, but I wouldn't be so quick to assume your experience is universal.
 
Considering that most of this business has been maybe 10 people doing most of the arguing, I suppose I'd have to admit that 2 is a significant number of people changing their minds.

FWIW, I should be on the record as being both against the Bordello and the calendar things (please don't make me search); I just don't consider either to be "not allowed to feel uncomfortable from now on" kind of things. However, as it is beginning to seem as if the "greater universe" of feminism/anti-feminism-vis-a-vis-TAM has become the heavier part of the discussion (and I'm unwilling to slog through that mess) then it's my turn to just spectate for now.

If you see me in an elevator at some point in the future, do not ask me to come to your room; please presume I have one of my own and am otherwise engaged. Ignore this request at your peril; I have bees.
 
How would you know? First, I'm pretty sure there are always more readers than commenters. Second, not every commenter announces they've changed their opinion. Some just don't post more. And third, how are you defining progress of any kind?

I can't know about anyone who doesn't post; read the first line of that post you quoted carefully. As for defining progress, fair question - I would tend to take some movement toward settlement of the issue, or perhaps truce-like conditions at least as progress.

Personally, contemplating what it was about this incident that initially bothered me has been very useful to me. Seeing a very unskeptical personality cult within our ranks has been enlightening. And as always, Linda's knowledge about research methods continues to impress.

Perhaps you have made less progress, but I wouldn't be so quick to assume your experience is universal.

Irony; I confess myself fond of it.
 
I hope I've convinced some people, regardless of how they feel about this specific incident, that there is another side to promoting feminist causes. Sometimes it is about empowering women, not simply un-empowering men.
 
I've been convinced. I started off being strongly on the side of Watson. I thought that her request was mild and earnest and totally understandable, if a bit futile. I thought that her calling out of McGraw seemed uncool, but then again, I wasn't there, and I was willing to give her the benefit of the doubt. I thought that this entire bruhaha had been started and maintained by third parties, and that she was just caught up in it, that a mountain had been made out of a molehill, but that she was herself relatively innocent.

Now I'm strongly against. Mostly, her apologists pushed me in that direction, with their drivel, apologia, lies, and facile and stupid accusations, but that was only emotional. I tracked down links of things that Watson had said, and that convinced me.

Pretty much the same here. Once I read what each party actually said when, I switched 'sides', although I still think Dawkins was a dick. But water is also wet.
 
Yes, but I've seen no evidence of any progress of any kind being made here. Progress suggests some type of change. This entire thread has been nothing but its participants reiterating their views continuously, with no change at all. Now everyone knows how everyone else feels; but this information has proven spectacularly useless.
Evidence of "any" progress is entirely beside the point. People don't usually change their minds like that. It's long after the egos and emotion die down. Like I said, change is imperceptible. You don't look older in a month or two months, etc. Change can't be detected except by many months or even years.
 
I hope I've convinced some people, regardless of how they feel about this specific incident, that there is another side to promoting feminist causes. Sometimes it is about empowering women, not simply un-empowering men.
I think you make a good point. I'm not convinced that there is a "side". I think that is the flaw in that thinking to begin with. However I wouldn't see it in terms of advancing feminist causes vs no change in other view points.

There's every reason to believe that there can be advances for all positions. We weed out some fallacious reasoning from the various viewpoints who see this from various feminist perspectives and pro-equality, sex positive positions.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom