So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Um, no, that's not what is being said. Elevators are an unlikely place to get raped, therefor it's wrong to state that the elevator made it more likely that EG was a rapist.
And to add a very astute observation Linda made in another thread:
And yet, her risk of rape for "on an elevator with a man" was much higher than it would be for "on and elevator with a man and he makes a proposition". It's a classic example of an error made in the name of an availability bias. This perfectly illustrates that the thinking on this issue has been irrational.

Linda
 
Oh, the one that says "Uploaded by Rystefn on Apr 3, 2008" right under it?

It would seem that in the intervening years, the skepchicks have decided that being hot girls who like nerds was not rewarding. Wonder why?

Yes, there does seem to have been some sort of feminist epiphany, somewhere on the road from Bordello-fete to Elevator-gate, I'd guess. If that's no longer a message they wish to be identified with, taking it down probably a good idea (it and a calendar retrospective are the two youtube vidz that usually pop up when you google "Skepchick").

Or maybe all this is payback for that song? I'd be willing to switch sides for proof of that.

:D Gawd, that song. What a vicious, vicious earworm that is. I may have to schedule surgery to have the part of my brain that is now remembering it and playing it over and over and over and over in my head cut out (maybe have them erase my entire memory and personality [blobru, personality?] just to be safe).
 
Last edited:
It's their youtube promo, linked to last week in this thread. Upon review, the slogan is actually "hot chicks get drunk and hit on nerds", which I had been transliterating in earlier posts as "hot girls hit on drunk nerds" (apologies for that), not that there's a spectacular lot of difference in the two messages. I would still maintain that if you want to avoid uncomfortable encounters, it's not a good idea to focus on drunkenness, your own or your audience's (one tends to imply the other), in your self-promotion. (As an aside, whatever that song is used on the soundtrack, all copies of it should by UN humanitarian fiat be located and erased and the original tagged, bagged, stuffed in a lead-lined capsule and shot into the sun.) :covereyes

Yep, marketing a brand. The brand is fine, BTW, as far as it goes. One would like brains not to be any more associated with unattractive than one wants attractive to be a requirement for recognition.


That is of course not the problem.
 
Last edited:
Um, no, that's not what is being said. Elevators are an unlikely place to get raped, therefor it's wrong to state that the elevator made it more likely that EG was a rapist.

Yes, that is a more correct reading of the premise.

But it doesn't make it any less stupid. Watson wasn't worried about being raped specifically. She was made uncomfortable by the situation because everything she had been saying went ignored, because the space was confined, because she was in a foreign country where things were unfamiliar and because it was late.

Also, because women are taught from a very early age that they should make an effort to not get raped, they can be more readily creeped out in less than ideal circumstances.

Also, where were all these stats about the possibility of elevator rape when Watson was in the elevator. Do you expect her to just know that it's safe? Like any of you had any idea before this? "But she's been on thousands of elevators and never got raped, therefore it's safe! She should know that!" Yeah, most women who get raped were doing something they do all the time when it happened. Rape is opportunistic.
 
FLS: And yet, her risk of rape for "on an elevator with a man" was much higher than it would be for "on and elevator with a man and he makes a proposition".
Interesting stat. I'd be interested in the data. I think we need to be careful of intuitive assumptions. Sounds reasonable but is it right? More importantly, assuming it is right, how much "higher"?

We need to do much better on educating people on what is and is not rational to fear. Make informed decisions not one's based on perceptions and fear. To be sure, I DON'T know what those figures are.

http://www.amazon.com/Culture-Fear-Americans-Afraid-Things/dp/0465014909
 
Hey, more straw! Did you get that stuff at a discount ?

If we can agree that the fact an elevator is an unlikely place to get raped is not sufficient reason for women to drop their guard, then people need to stop throwing it out there as if it's relevant.
 
If we can agree that the fact an elevator is an unlikely place to get raped is not sufficient reason for women to drop their guard, then people need to stop throwing it out there as if it's relevant.

I think the sixty odd pages of this thread indicate that agreement of any sort is in short supply.
 
She was made uncomfortable by the situation because everything she had been saying went ignored, because the space was confined, because she was in a foreign country where things were unfamiliar and because it was late.

It doesn't sound to me like "everything she said was ignored." Sounds like it could have been taken to heart. First, he told her not to take in the wrong way, which is a euphemism for "I'm not trying to get in your pants." Of course, some here seem convinced it actually means, "I *do* want to get into your pants."

Second, he didn't compliment her physical appearance. He complimented her intellect/personality ("I find you interesting").

Third, he asked her to talk. Some seem to think that means an offer of sex, but that's reading a lot into it.

Fourth, he suggested coffee. Had he suggested alcohol, that would add a different dimension to the encounter unless there's a song called "Why Don't We Drink Espresso and Screw?" that I've never heard of before.

As for why the hotel room, where else could they go away from the crowds?

Once again I put forth the question, what should EG have said to RW to request some harmless conversation?
 
It doesn't sound to me like "everything she said was ignored." Sounds like it could have been taken to heart. First, he told her not to take in the wrong way, which is a euphemism for "I'm not trying to get in your pants." Of course, some here seem convinced it actually means, "I *do* want to get into your pants."

Second, he didn't compliment her physical appearance. He complimented her intellect/personality ("I find you interesting").

Third, he asked her to talk. Some seem to think that means an offer of sex, but that's reading a lot into it.

Fourth, he suggested coffee. Had he suggested alcohol, that would add a different dimension to the encounter unless there's a song called "Why Don't We Drink Espresso and Screw?" that I've never heard of before.

As for why the hotel room, where else could they go away from the crowds?

Once again I put forth the question, what should EG have said to RW to request some harmless conversation?

Already asked and answered upthread. One answer was to give her his phone number and ask if they could meet the next day in a public area, like a coffee shop or bar.

Rebecca could have said:
  • no
  • yes
  • sure, but why not meet now?


Did you watch this video?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=3-son3EJTrU

It has also been linked to at least twice in this thread. It's a hypothesis by Pinker as to why people sometimes choose to speak indirectly or in innuendo.

Do you have any comments on that video?
 
Interesting stat. I'd be interested in the data. I think we need to be careful of intuitive assumptions. Sounds reasonable but is it right? More importantly, assuming it is right, how much "higher"?

We need to do much better on educating people on what is and is not rational to fear. Make informed decisions not one's based on perceptions and fear. To be sure, I DON'T know what those figures are.

http://www.amazon.com/Culture-Fear-Americans-Afraid-Things/dp/0465014909

Intuition has nothing to do with it. That you suggest it does means that you are demonstrating something called an availability bias. The more details that are given for a scenario, the easier it is to picture that scenario. And the easier it is to picture, the higher the probability you will give for its occurrence. By adding the detail "he makes a proposition", it becomes easier to see it as the kind of creepy scenario under which a rape would occur. Without that detail, "on an elevator with a man" doesn't seem particularly creepy, and you are inclined to give it a lower probability. And of course, you'd have to be wrong (don't feel bad, most everybody gets this wrong). The number of men who are on an elevator with a women and who proposition her has to be the combination of "on an elevator with a man" and "makes a proposition". There is no way for the intersection of two groups to be larger than than either one of the groups. The number of women who were raped after finding themselves alone on an elevator with a man has to include both the men who propositioned them and the men who did not. Which means that the number of women who were raped following "on an elevator with a man", has to be larger than either of the subgroups "and was/was not propositioned". Intuition has nothing to do with it.

Linda
 
Yes, that is a more correct reading of the premise.

But it doesn't make it any less stupid. Watson wasn't worried about being raped specifically. She was made uncomfortable by the situation because everything she had been saying went ignored, because the space was confined, because she was in a foreign country where things were unfamiliar and because it was late.

Also, because women are taught from a very early age that they should make an effort to not get raped, they can be more readily creeped out in less than ideal circumstances.

Also, where were all these stats about the possibility of elevator rape when Watson was in the elevator. Do you expect her to just know that it's safe? Like any of you had any idea before this? "But she's been on thousands of elevators and never got raped, therefore it's safe! She should know that!" Yeah, most women who get raped were doing something they do all the time when it happened. Rape is opportunistic.


So she didn't complain about the possibility of it being rape...but it could have been rape? This is the 'have your cake and eat it too' thinking that is getting way out of hand. It wasn't about rape, fine, then why go on about rape? It's using a real problem to lend credence to an argument that doesn't deserve the status.

And again, not everything she said was being ignored. The options of 'not heard at all', 'considered but outweighed by other factors,' and 'misunderstood' are perfectly viable ones that keep getting dismissed. Hell, he could have even been a fan of Watson and thought, 'Hey, I wouldn't do this to some other woman, but she'll be fine with this.' Or he really did want to sleep with her because of that interesting conversation, which isn't sexism either. Nor is it sexism to say, 'why not get hit on in elevators'?

Do you expect EG to just know that it's not seen as safe? Why but all the burden on him? Watson's "I'm tired and going to bed to sleep," is to be taken literally as true, none of his words are? If elevators aren't actually more dangerous why should HE think, 'I better not ask, elevators are more dangerous.'

Again, she was perfectly fine to say it was creepy and don't do it to her, but taking it as sexism, sexualization, misogyny, and whatnot is wrong. It's also probably fallacious. I don't know what specific fallacy it is, but assuming that the information provided by Watson, and foremost in her thoughts, would be equally accessible by EG is silly.
 
Intuition has nothing to do with it. That you suggest it does means that you are demonstrating something called an availability bias.
No. I make no claims. I only ask for those who do to provide data and methodology.

I'm sorry Linda but you are not going to be able to turn my skepticism into bias. I'm assuming the null hypothesis here and only asking you to support your claim. That's how science works. Accusing me of bias for that is woo.
 
And of course, you'd have to be wrong (don't feel bad, most everybody gets this wrong).
Please, spare me the rhetoric. I so tire of that. I don't use invective or brow beating. I only want evidence. That's it. Like Randi I don't want long winded explanations of why everyone is wrong nor do I want emotional appeals or any other fallacy. Please, stick to logic, reason and valid argument. Please. I'm not here to win an argument. Again, I MAKE NO claims. Support yours or move on.

By adding the detail "he makes a proposition", it becomes easier to see it as the kind of creepy scenario under which a rape would occur.
"Creepy"? Your probability theory includes the word "creepy"? Appeal to disgust?
 
Last edited:
Oh, the one that says "Uploaded by Rystefn on Apr 3, 2008" right under it?

Nice moving the goalposts. A link has been provided. You have been corrected, politely.

It would seem that in the intervening years, the skepchicks have decided that being hot girls who like nerds was not rewarding. Wonder why?

More speculation. Might be true. After all, Watson just turned 30, an age at which many people massively change their sexual expectations. Might not be. We won't know until Watson posts something declaring a sea change. I doubt that will happen. It is also possible that Watson doesn't see this as a sea change and that they will keep that message. This is a tactic that has worked for many groups in the past, mostly because fans will provide apologia. It might work for them, but then again, it might not.

Way, way back in this or the other thread, some people suggested that everything, including the blithe tween lubriciousness and the current fairly hard-line feminism, serve the purpose of aggrandizing Watson. A stronger assertion would be that she engineered this (some of her tweets seem to support this).

In any event, several things are evident:

1) Watson and her site, Skepchick, have used sexualization extravagantly for many years.

2) It has worked, and it has garnered many supporters. (Watson has claimed 10,000).

3) Watson's initial complaint in the video was about being sexualized "in that way" and did not contain any feminist rhetoric directly connected to EG.

People can accept these ideas and see how they influence thought about the matter. They can argue them rationally. My observation is that there are many people who prefer to run interference. The means of doing that which I have mostly seen are as follows:

1) Talk about how Watson has the right to reject unwanted attention, no matter how much she sexualizes herself. This is, of course, strictly accurate, but completely idiotic. There is not a significant number of individuals who would deny her this right. In the EG incident, she declined, he stopped, and that was that. There was no significant denial or criticism of her rights at any point. However, it makes a nice loud noise, especially if one uses the term "rape" a lot.

2) Move the goalposts. I guess that you already know about this one.

3) Conflate, conflate, conflate! "Sexualization" and "objectification" mean different things on Monday, Wednesday, and Friday, and they mean the same thing on Tuesday, Thursday, and Saturday. (Today is Sunday.)

4) The general fog of blather and invective. Accusations of being a traitor to your gender, of being a misogynist (if male) or a parrot of misogyny (if female), of being ignorant of Feminism 101, or You're Just a Bad Person.

Many people live their entire lives doing these things. They have nothing to do with skepticism, at all.
 
If we can agree that the fact an elevator is an unlikely place to get raped is not sufficient reason for women to drop their guard, then people need to stop throwing it out there as if it's relevant.

I don't think anyone said that they should drop their guard anywhere. I know I wouldn't.
 
If we can agree that the fact an elevator is an unlikely place to get raped is not sufficient reason for women to drop their guard, then people need to stop throwing it out there as if it's relevant.
I honestly don't know how likely it is to be raped in an elevator. However, what it is relevant to is whether or not the fear is rational. Of course it's prudent to not let down your guard but that is irrelevant to the discussion as no one is suggesting anyone let down their guard.

And let me repeat. I don't at all fault Rebecca for voicing her concern. Not in the least. My only problem is that she gave the appearance that she presumed to speak for all women and, IIRC, didn't give credit to the young man for accepting "no" as an answer. I got her point and think it great as a source for a discussion. I'm just not very happy with both sides as it relates to a lot of the rhetoric.
 
Already asked and answered upthread.
Must have missed it in the deluge. I didn't ask you, so I might have skipped over your post (not that you couldn't answer - just wasn't looking for it).

One answer was to give her his phone number and ask if they could meet the next day in a public area, like a coffee shop or bar.
At an educational conference? Not really an option in my experience. The next day is either more meetings or everybody leaves (depending on the day). Time is usually scarce.


Rebecca could have said:
  • no
  • yes
  • sure, but why not meet now?
There's that insidious sexism again. If Rebecca suggests that they meet now, that's alright but the guy is not allowed? He's gotta set some future date?

I wonder if "why not meet now?" means "I want to have sex" in the same way that "let's have coffee and talk" does.

Did you watch this video?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=3-son3EJTrU

It has also been linked to at least twice in this thread. It's a hypothesis by Pinker as to why people sometimes choose to speak indirectly or in innuendo.
No, and I have no intention of watching it. I *know* that people sometimes speak in innuendo. It's quite common. I don't think anyone has claimed that it's not possible that EG had an ulterior motive, but his statements as given would not have been innuendo.

Innuendo doesn't start with "don't take this the wrong way" but quite often it ends with "if you know what I mean."

Innuendo would be asking her to have a drink or a nightcap, not coffee.

Innuendo would be complimenting her appearance rather than her intellect.

Innuendo would be asking if she wanted to "hang out" or "get away from crowd" not "talk."

Of course, EG might really suck at innuendo.
 
And let me repeat. I don't at all fault Rebecca for voicing her concern. Not in the least. My only problem is that she gave the appearance that she presumed to speak for all women and, IIRC, didn't give credit to the young man for accepting "no" as an answer. I got her point and think it great as a source for a discussion. I'm just not very happy with both sides as it relates to a lot of the rhetoric.

It is an epic thread of fail. After 2400 posts, nobody has managed to convince anybody else of anything.

ETA: On the other hand, the sharp divide between people on this issue is fair evidence that the topic deserves more time. As I understand it, everyone can agree that there are much fewer women than men becoming "involved" in skepticism, and it has been floated by some that less-than-desirable treatment of women is one of the possible reasons. This may not be true at all; but it doesn't seem to be an insta-de-bunk possibility either.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom