So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
She is very important to many in the movement based on her work on the Skeptichick web site. I don't know that she's actually qualified to be on a panel, but one doesn't need a science degree to speak intelligently on skepticism.

But again, what does this have to do with what I, or you, said? You were talking about what she has to offer a man, specifically EG.

Yes, a man who claimed to be interested in what she had to say. I was suggesting that maybe she doesn't actually have very much of interest to say on private one to one basis and therefore concluded EG primarily wanted to have sex with her.
 
Yes, a man who claimed to be interested in what she had to say. I was suggesting that maybe she doesn't actually have very much of interest to say on private one to one basis and therefore concluded EG primarily wanted to have sex with her.

She had just been on a panel saying things, and in a bar saying a lot more things. I find it extremely unlikely that Rebecca didn't think she had anything to say, and therefore the man was after sex.
 
How the hell would I know? They all do their own thing based on where they are in their life. You know, like people.

So the "hot girls hitting on nerds" is marketing nonsense exploiting the insecurities and base desires of men who often have trouble getting dates, and if fact, "skepchicks", if hitting on the men at sceptical conferences at all, were doing so for reasons other than their degree of nerdiness?
 
So the "hot girls hitting on nerds" is marketing nonsense exploiting the insecurities and base desires of men who often have trouble getting dates, and if fact, "skepchicks", if hitting on the men at sceptical conferences at all, were doing so for reasons other than their degree of nerdiness?

Wha?

Skepchick means a lot of different things. it can be someone who writes for the bog, a personal friend of those, or a stranger who identifies with some of the things they write about. All of those people have different reasons for hitting on anyone. There is no single mold from which they are cast. They get to have their own opinions.

You belong to the JREF forum - does that mean that all JREForumites follow your dating patterns? or even share your gender?
 
The bolding on that one is all her btw. You agree with "well he didn't rape her."

How can you NOT agree ? Did he rape her ?

That Watson's flirting & sexual past has been raised, numerous times, as an excuse to discount what she is saying is obvious.

I don't think it's obvious at all. Some have said that it's a bit odd that she's complaining about being objectified when she's contributed to this view herself, and I agree, but it does nothing to diminish her discomfort during the event in question. That you think we are claiming that it does shows how you're incapable of keeping things in perspective.

So yeah, people in this thread are saying nothing like "Elevators aren't that scary, she's a slut anyway, he didn't rape her, etc" <--sarcasm.

Why did you add that "<--sarcasm" bit ? Because you know that your previous statement, quite obviously non-sarcastic, is untenable ?

You focused in on the throwaway sentence (again!) and breezed right past the more important "What if she says yes." paragraph (again!)

Booky, don't try to sell me the idea that it was a throwaway sentence. I think you believed what you said, otherwise you wouldn't have typed it. And I strongly disagree with what you typed. If you wish to retract it, fine, but don't claim it was an unremarkable bit of text because it was a very strong claim.
 
How can you NOT agree ? Did he rape her ?



I don't think it's obvious at all. Some have said that it's a bit odd that she's complaining about being objectified when she's contributed to this view herself, and I agree, but it does nothing to diminish her discomfort during the event in question. That you think we are claiming that it does shows how you're incapable of keeping things in perspective.



Why did you add that "<--sarcasm" bit ? Because you know that your previous statement, quite obviously non-sarcastic, is untenable ?



Booky, don't try to sell me the idea that it was a throwaway sentence. I think you believed what you said, otherwise you wouldn't have typed it. And I strongly disagree with what you typed. If you wish to retract it, fine, but don't claim it was an unremarkable bit of text because it was a very strong claim.

And I stand by it. Period. Obviously you still think that "Elevators aren't that scary" was never raised. You still don't think that people are calling Watson a slut and think that "at least he didn't rape her" is some sort of valid argument. So be it.

I'd still love to hear your ideas on that last part.
 
So the "hot girls hitting on nerds" is marketing nonsense exploiting the insecurities and base desires of men who often have trouble getting dates, and if fact, "skepchicks", if hitting on the men at sceptical conferences at all, were doing so for reasons other than their degree of nerdiness?

Maybe someone else has better links but the only reference I can find on the skepchick site of hitting on drunk nerds is the post about James Underdown from 2008. Even that is extremely oblique.

It seems that the "hot girls hitting on nerds" reputation has been manufactured outside of the actual website.
 
And I stand by it. Period.

So it wasn't a throwaway line, as you claimed. It's also irrelevant to the issue you're trying to muddle.

Obviously you still think that "Elevators aren't that scary" was never raised.

I agree that it was discussed but I disagree that it was used in a way that indicates that RW shouldn't be free to be uncomfortable wherever she damn well pleases.

You still don't think that people are calling Watson a slut

I don't need to think it or not. All you need to do is provide a link to people saying that. Otherwise you're just making stuff up. And I don't mean some random poster on a blog comment.

and think that "at least he didn't rape her" is some sort of valid argument.

What are you talking about, anyway ? Where did you get the idea that I or anybody thinks this ? Do you read your own posts ? You've been doing nothing but this wordplay, strawman, emotional appeal in this thread. Do you think this will foster intelligent discussion when you so blatantly misrepresent what other people say ?
 
So it wasn't a throwaway line, as you claimed. It's also irrelevant to the issue you're trying to muddle.



I agree that it was discussed but I disagree that it was used in a way that indicates that RW shouldn't be free to be uncomfortable wherever she damn well pleases.



I don't need to think it or not. All you need to do is provide a link to people saying that. Otherwise you're just making stuff up. And I don't mean some random poster on a blog comment.



What are you talking about, anyway ? Where did you get the idea that I or anybody thinks this ? Do you read your own posts ? You've been doing nothing but this wordplay, strawman, emotional appeal in this thread. Do you think this will foster intelligent discussion when you so blatantly misrepresent what other people say ?

Evasion noted.
 
Maybe someone else has better links but the only reference I can find on the skepchick site of hitting on drunk nerds is the post about James Underdown from 2008. Even that is extremely oblique.

It seems that the "hot girls hitting on nerds" reputation has been manufactured outside of the actual website.


It's their youtube promo, linked to last week in this thread. Upon review, the slogan is actually "hot chicks get drunk and hit on nerds", which I had been transliterating in earlier posts as "hot girls hit on drunk nerds" (apologies for that), not that there's a spectacular lot of difference in the two messages. I would still maintain that if you want to avoid uncomfortable encounters, it's not a good idea to focus on drunkenness, your own or your audience's (one tends to imply the other), in your self-promotion. (As an aside, whatever that song is used on the soundtrack, all copies of it should by UN humanitarian fiat be located and erased and the original tagged, bagged, stuffed in a lead-lined capsule and shot into the sun.) :covereyes

 
Last edited:
McGraw argument can be boiled down to her final line


The reason that this comes across as excusing sexism is because, well it is. Watson was not demonizing EG for being a sexual being. She didn't even demonize him at all. She said that she didn't like it. The reason she didn't like it was because EG ignored several key-points of context.

Talking about context:

http://skepchick.org/2011/06/about-mythbusters-robot-eyes-feminism-and-jokes/

In her video, RW literally said that EG didn't grasp what she was saying on the panel earlier that day. Maybe not. But what was she saying on the panel that relates this to the elevator incident? Let's see: she started talking about the conservative right war on women (abortion, contraception, etc.) and then, for the most part of her talk, she talked about the hate mail she receives and the misogyny that exists also within the atheist and skeptic community and how it prevents women from attending more to these type of meetings. See here:



So what does this all have to do with EG's approach later in the elevator?

Sure, she didn't explicitly demonize him as in "he's a demon!". She used him as an example of what she was talking about and that EG didn't grasp. What exactly? The conservative right? The overtly sexist and violent hate mail she gets? The misogyny within the skeptic community? Take your choice. To me, it's obvious: she put EG's attitude in the "sexist" category. If there was any doubt about it, RW's reaction makes it easier:

http://skepchick.org/2011/06/on-naming-names-at-the-cfi-student-leadership-conference/

Here, RW labels Stef McGraw as someone who parrots misogynistic thoughts and speaks ancient anti-woman rhetoric. How about another possibility? Let's say she disagreed that this had anything to do with misogyny. No, that's not a possibility. The only possibility is that she was parroting misogynistic thoughts and speaking ancient anti-woman rhetoric. That's the dogmatism I was talking about.

With all this context at hand Stef McGraw's conclusion makes sense. You can disagree, maybe her argument could've been better, maybe she ignored some important nuances, maybe she was wrong, but she wasn't excusing sexism unless we determine that the elevator incident was one of sexism. And we haven't done that.


Excusing all behavior because "men are sexual beings" implies that no matter what a woman might want, it is her duty to accept an advance that may come at anytime.
That's a strawman. Who is excusing all behavior?

And who is saying that it's women's duty to accept an advance? Women don't have any duty to be welcoming, but advances happen from time to time and not always will be in the most appropriate context. Nerd guys don't always know how to do it, and some are really ugly. What's the big deal? Is that sexist now too?

She is graciously allowed to decline said invitation, (if she is dealing with a more civilized person) but there are no circumstances in which she can expect that it won't happen. Even if she's the speaker at a professional conference who has been talking about objectification, has stated that she wants to go to bed (because it's 4 AM ffs) and is alone in an elevator. Even then, she must be ready to use her option to refuse but there is no option to be left alone.
Do you think this only happens to women? In fact, is the option to be left alone only about sex? Sometimes I have no option to be left alone for whatever reason when I'm out or after having played in a gig. Drunk people who won't leave me alone, weird people who come high on cocaine and can't stop talking to me, gay men who hit on me, women who hit on me (here I might not want to be left alone, but that depends). Do you think all this people listen carefully to my demands? Big sexist deal.

That has been even more fully realized in this thread. Elevators aren't that scary, she's a slut anyway, he didn't rape her, etc. And of course, "but what if she had said yes." Which further reinforces the idea that women should always be ready to be propositioned. Because "what if she has said yes?" completely ignores "What if she says no?" The potential benefit to men is more valuable than any potential discomfort to women. Even though the possibility of "no" with all attending discomforts is the much, much greater possibility.
Wow, she's a slut anyway? Yes, that has been said too. By a strawman. ;) Can you be a bit more serious with the arguments you put forth? Just try not to argue with an imaginary person who says stupid things like that. If you quote me, please, use my arguments.

What if she says no? Again, is it only about women? What if a woman or a gay man approaches me and I say no? Drums rolling... tension... suspense... well, it happens that I say no. End of story? In my experience, yes, although more than once I struggled to be convincing with my first response. Creepy? It can be, yes. For me, to be approached by a gay man is always uncomfortable and some women have made me feel uncomfortable for various different reasons. Big sexist deal.

The potential discomforts are explained away as trivial, how the woman feels about it simply doesn't matter. She is there for one purpose only.
And this purpose is? Let me guess: another strawman?

How I feel about many things in my daily life doesn't matter to most other people, no matter whether I'm a man or a woman. When my interests are in conflict with those of other people I interact with, there's an evitable clash. Sometimes you get angry with people, sometimes you say "sorry", whatever. Sometimes I don't get what I want because I don't live alone in this world. People interact, and good interaction is a lot about balance and mutual respect, but at the same time people will still pursue their interests, even the most trivial ones, and there will still be inevitable clashes, and some more awkward than others. Some people are weird. "I find you interesting.? Do you want to go back to my room and have a coffee? No, thanks." Just an example of something that happens on a daily basis in our society. The potential discomforts of an experience like this are, in fact, trivial to make it a problem of sexism, which is not.
 
Last edited:
Skeptic Ginger has many, many posts about the safety of elevators. Watsons previous history (calender, very old article, etc) have been presented as evidence that she is sexually active, and "talk is not rape!" has come up a gazzilion times.

I honestly don't know how you missed all that. I can only assume that you are saying that those exact, specific words were never used but that's so intellectually dishonest that I can't imagine anyone doing it.
I'm going to repeat my goal here in addressing the 'women are at risk in elevators' theme because you've distorted it.

We are, as skeptics, about challenging myths.
I am, as a feminist the way I see the role, interested in contributing to women's liberation.
And lots of people have been perpetuating the myth that hotel elevators in nice hotels at 4am in Dublin are places women should fear being alone with a man they haven't met who asks them to his room.
In addition, it is being portrayed that perpetuating this elevator/foreign country myth is in the best interests of women whereas I think it is the opposite.

When I began reading people's comments repeating the elevator myth it immediately struck me as reinforcing the sexist belief women were more vulnerable than they really are, and women should be afraid more than they really need be. I've been all over the world, and quite a bit of the time, I traveled alone. It's safe, for the most part. It's as least as safe as staying home, which is also safe for the most part.

In addition, it goes against the goal of women's lib to promote a solution that requires men take action when the woman experiencing an unwanted sexual interest like this one could so easily handle it herself. The expectation a man needs to act to correct this problem is the exact opposite of women's liberation.

Is the elevator risk a myth? The evidence supports that conclusion.
In the end, it’s just not a very reasonable risk and women should not panic if they are asked to coffee on an elevator. It might be a dumb place to ask a woman for coffee, because it would somewhat put her on the spot (but how many of us haven’t asked something dumb at least once). Still, being flirted with on a hotel elevator should not cause a feeling of terror.

It’s a little sad that a self-described skeptic would have such irrational fears and such a victim complex.


What are some examples of the kinds of behaviors men and women should be asked not to do as it relates to this discussion and constitutes sexism?
  • using sexist ad homs in debates or elsewhere
  • making rude and/or lewd comments in that elevator or elsewhere
  • groping women or men
  • double standards for example when you made derogatory remarks about women who admit they might like casual sex as much as some men
  • reinforcing the sexist belief women are weak and vulnerable more than they really are
A polite come on when the woman is alone someplace is not on that list. An individual woman can certainly ask that men refrain from things which that individual woman does not want. That is a different matter.


As for the calendar, the bordello themed Skepchick party at TAM8 (BTW, is 2010 really a very long time ago?), and how the Skepchick brand is marketed, nowhere have I said that indicated someone was sexually active, nor have I said promotion of oneself as a sexual being excuses anything beyond men flirting with you. That you keep making straw men arguments suggests you truly cannot counter what people are really saying here.

As for the "talk is not rape", it isn't. People exaggerating what EG did or said is more straw.
 
Last edited:
It's their youtube promo, linked to last week in this thread. Upon review, the slogan is actually "hot chicks get drunk and hit on nerds", which I had been transliterating in earlier posts as "hot girls hit on drunk nerds" (apologies for that), not that there's a spectacular lot of difference in the two messages. I would still maintain that if you want to avoid uncomfortable encounters, it's not a good idea to focus on drunkenness, your own or your audience's (one tends to imply the other), in your self-promotion. (As an aside, whatever that song is used on the soundtrack, all copies of it should by UN humanitarian fiat be located and erased and the original tagged, bagged, stuffed in a lead-lined capsule and shot into the sun.) :covereyes


Oh, the one that says "Uploaded by Rystefn on Apr 3, 2008" right under it?

It would seem that in the intervening years, the skepchicks have decided that being hot girls who like nerds was not rewarding. Wonder why?

Or maybe all this is payback for that song? I'd be willing to switch sides for proof of that.
 
I'm going to repeat my goal here in addressing the 'women are at risk in elevators' theme because you've distorted it.

We are, as skeptics, about challenging myths.
I am, as a feminist the way I see the role, interested in contributing to women's liberation.
And lots of people have been perpetuating the myth that hotel elevators in nice hotels at 4am in Dublin are places women should fear being alone with a man they haven't met who asks them to his room.
In addition, it is being portrayed that perpetuating this elevator/foreign country myth is in the best interests of women whereas I think it is the opposite.

When I began reading people's comments repeating the elevator myth it immediately struck me as reinforcing the sexist belief women were more vulnerable than they really are, and women should be afraid more than they really need be. I've been all over the world, and quite a bit of the time, I traveled alone. It's safe, for the most part. It's as least as safe as staying home, which is also safe for the most part.

In addition, it goes against the goal of women's lib to promote a solution that requires men take action when the woman experiencing an unwanted sexual interest like this one could so easily handle it herself. That expectation is the exact opposite of liberation.

Is the elevator risk a myth? The evidence supports that conclusion.


What are some examples of the kinds of behaviors men should be asked not to do as it relates to this discussion?
  • using sexist ad homs in debates or elsewhere
  • making rude and/or lewd comments in that elevator or elsewhere
  • groping women
  • double standards for example when you made derogatory remarks about women who admit they might like casual sex as much as some men
  • reinforcing the sexist belief women are weak and vulnerable more than they really are
A polite come on when the woman is alone someplace is not on that list. An individual woman can certainly ask that men refrain from things which that individual woman does not want. That is a different matter.


As for the calendar, the bordello themed Skepchick party at TAM8 (BTW, is 2010 really a very long time ago?), and how the Skepchick brand is marketed, nowhere have I said that indicated someone was sexually active, nor have I said promotion of oneself as a sexual being excuses anything beyond men flirting with you. That you keep making straw men arguments suggests you truly cannot counter what people are really saying here.

As for the "talk is not rape", it isn't. People exaggerating what EG did or said is more straw.

Elevators are an unlikely place to get raped, therefor women can drop their guard when on an elevator. it is safe simply because it is not always dangerous. Therefore, Watson had no reason to be creeped out.

How is the relative safety of elevators a myth? Either women have reason to watch out for themselves everywhere or they don't. Elevators have nothing to do with it.

You do know that blog is written by a guy whose behavior has been so bad in the past that people have called for him to banned from TAM? And who has creepily offered to, and I quote, "pork" Watson. I find that infinitely amusing.
 
Last edited:
Elevators are an unlikely place to get raped, therefor women can drop their guard when on an elevator. it is safe simply because it is not always dangerous. Therefore, Watson had no reason to be creeped out.

Um, no, that's not what is being said. Elevators are an unlikely place to get raped, therefor it's wrong to state that the elevator made it more likely that EG was a rapist.
 
Elevators are an unlikely place to get raped, therefor women can drop their guard when on an elevator. it is safe simply because it is not always dangerous. Therefore, Watson had no reason to be creeped out.
I'm sorry you don't understand the point., but this is not it.

How is the relative safety of elevators a myth? Either women have reason to watch out for themselves everywhere or they don't. Elevators have nothing to do with it.
Yes, elevators have nothing to do with it, and "watch out for themselves everywhere" depends on what that entails.

You do know that blog is written by a guy whose behavior has been so bad in the past that people have called for him to banned from TAM? And who has creepily offered to, and I quote, "pork" Watson. I find that infinitely amusing.
He's sexist (or whatever) therefore his blog content should not speak for itself?

I welcome any rebuttal analysis, but the analysis by Depleted Cranium is pretty thorough.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom