So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm coming to the conclusion the biggest turn-off for intelligent women joining the sceptical "community" is the likes of Ms. Watson, who as far as I can tell has *nothing* else to talk about but herself and her opinions.

Perhaps she knew EG was hitting on her because she knows that's all she's got to offer a man?

As for hot girls hitting on nerdy guys: it's bollocks.

In general women don't hit on men. The reason being that they don't have to: men are both expected and are driven to make the first move. That, and it's far more enjoyable to know you're desired by someone you don't fancy than be rejected by someone that you've made clear to that you do.

As for those women who claim "I hit on a guy! I asked him xyz!", where xyz is not "I find you interesting and attractive. Would you like to come out on a date with me" or similar, are fooling themselves. All you did was make it more likely for the guy to hit on you without having to feel as bad if you'd been direct and honest about your intentions with him. It's the dating equivalent of standing by the goal and claiming to have scored when the ball bounces off you and into the net.

Even if some women do hit on men, I've seen little evidence to suggest any women are using 'nerdiness' as a major criterion for the men they're hitting on. Instead it seems women are primarily attracted to handsome, assertive and/or rich men, who may or may not have a nerdy job or pastime.

Interestingly, men who talk total crap most of the time, or who treat women badly do not appear to be at a significant disadvantage so long as they possess at least some of the three magic ingredients that women find irresistible.

In summary, moderately ugly blokes who stutter and are not particularly wealthy do not gain anything in their attractiveness to women by having nerdy interests.

Whoa slow down there! Women want this, women want that, women want bad boys, women want money, blah, blah blippity blu blah.

"Women" are simply human beings with their own agenda. Also, you're using the word "women" to mean sexually attractive young females and are ignoring a whole range of women who are married, gay, undesirable, older, handicapped, etc.

You are trying to speak from authority through your own bias. You have no evidence for any of this drivel because all you actually know about single, healthy, attractive, heterosexual females is that they don't like or hit on you. You can't speak for all "Moderately ugly blokes who stutter and are not particularly wealthy" because they are also simply human beings with their own agenda.

Worse, I know from other threads in which you've pushed this view, that aside from the stutter, none of it is true. You're an attractive man with a decent job who has several interesting hobbies. Trying to dump your own insecurities on the mythological hivemind of women may temporarily sooth your ego but if you are going to use them in this way, at least be honest about it.

Criminy Ivor, I'm truly sorry you can't get a date but do you really think that lumping all women together as passive, gold-digging nitwits who enjoy a bit of abuse is going to help matters?
 
Interesting article. I especially liked this:
Why would the author think that most people would not see that men and women might be equally "uncomfortable" riding an elevator with someone they just rejected? It's quite the straw man to complain about a sexist attitude for which there is no evidence did or would occur.

For the record, I actually said something in this thread somewhere to the effect that the discomfort one might feel in RW's shoes was for the rejection EG would likely feel.
 
Why would the author think that most people would not see that men and women might be equally "uncomfortable" riding an elevator with someone they just rejected? It's quite the straw man to complain about a sexist attitude for which there is no evidence did or would occur.

For the record, I actually said something in this thread somewhere to the effect that the discomfort one might feel in RW's shoes was for the rejection EG would likely feel.

Except that EG chose to make a move and Watson had no choice in the matter. Although I'm not surprised that you can dig up empathy for his feelings.
 
Hmm... I have a slight idea. This goes along the same line as Alison Smith's article, who reaches a similar conclusion through a different argument: this is not a feminist issue, it's a human issue. If you look at it from a human persepective in general, it's easy to see the double standards. And yes, of course there is male sexism still going on in Western societies, let alone others, but I think it's better not to waste ammunition with trivial stuff for which there is not evidence that it's caused by a problem of sexism. And there's a very powerful reason for that: it lowers one's credibility.

Judging from Rebecca Watsons' reaction to the rather mild response by Stef Mcgraw, that's clear enough. If, according to RW, Stef Mcgraw was parroting anti-woman rhetoric and validating misogyny, a rational debate is impossible. This is a clear example of a dogmatic attitude. What also grabbed my attention is the emphasis RW puts on the ignorance Stef Mcgraw apparently demonstrated of Feminism 101. Even if she ignored what Feminism 101 is about, what is it, the Bible? Fine. I have never read the Bible entirely. So? It all goes to show how dogmatic her stance is.

McGraw argument can be boiled down to her final line
If you really want social equality for women, which is what feminism is, why not apply the same standards to men and women, and stop demonizing men for being sexual beings?

The reason that this comes across as excusing sexism is because, well it is. Watson was not demonizing EG for being a sexual being. She didn't even demonize him at all. She said that she didn't like it. The reason she didn't like it was because EG ignored several key-points of context.

Excusing all behavior because "men are sexual beings" implies that no matter what a woman might want, it is her duty to accept an advance that may come at anytime. She is graciously allowed to decline said invitation, (if she is dealing with a more civilized person) but there are no circumstances in which she can expect that it won't happen. Even if she's the speaker at a professional conference who has been talking about objectification, has stated that she wants to go to bed (because it's 4 AM ffs) and is alone in an elevator. Even then, she must be ready to use her option to refuse but there is no option to be left alone.

That has been even more fully realized in this thread. Elevators aren't that scary, she's a slut anyway, he didn't rape her, etc. And of course, "but what if she had said yes." Which further reinforces the idea that women should always be ready to be propositioned. Because "what if she has said yes?" completely ignores "What if she says no?" The potential benefit to men is more valuable than any potential discomfort to women. Even though the possibility of "no" with all attending discomforts is the much, much greater possibility.

The potential discomforts are explained away as trivial, how the woman feels about it simply doesn't matter. She is there for one purpose only.
 
Whoa slow down there! Women want this, women want that, women want bad boys, women want money, blah, blah blippity blu blah.

"Women" are simply human beings with their own agenda. Also, you're using the word "women" to mean sexually attractive young females and are ignoring a whole range of women who are married, gay, undesirable, older, handicapped, etc.

I thought it was pretty obvious which group of women I was talking about. Why would a 34 year old heterosexual male in the market for a female partner he finds sexually attractive be referring to 75 year old lesbians?

You are trying to speak from authority through your own bias. You have no evidence for any of this drivel because all you actually know about single, healthy, attractive, heterosexual females is that they don't like or hit on you. You can't speak for all "Moderately ugly blokes who stutter and are not particularly wealthy" because they are also simply human beings with their own agenda.

So your claiming there are no common strategies in use, or qualities looked for, by 30-40 year-old heterosexual women in men?

Worse, I know from other threads in which you've pushed this view, that aside from the stutter, none of it is true. You're an attractive man with a decent job who has several interesting hobbies. Trying to dump your own insecurities on the mythological hivemind of women may temporarily sooth your ego but if you are going to use them in this way, at least be honest about it.

And yet, despite supposedly being attractive to them and having hobbies women are interested in, the only sex I've had is what I've paid for and the longest date (of two in total) has lasted 2 whole hours. I must be perceived as a real catch.

BTW, when you say to 'hivemind', are you referring to the phenomenon you mentioned in an earlier post, where if a man annoys one women, he can forget about getting a date with her or any women she knows in the future? Could it be that I've pissed off some female uber "connector" (as explained in the book "The Tipping Point" by Malcolm Gladwell) and inadvertently narrowed my possible dates to a few Inuit women in Northern Canada?:)

Criminy Ivor, I'm truly sorry you can't get a date but do you really think that lumping all women together as passive, gold-digging nitwits who enjoy a bit of abuse is going to help matters?

I have done no such thing.

It's strange that whenever I offer an explanation for why I (and men like me) are not having any luck with women where I point out my shortcomings, you feel obliged to make it sound like I'm blaming or ridiculing women for using a strategy which works reasonably well for them most of the time.

So, why would women want to hit on guys specifically because they have nerdy jobs or hobbies? For example, what is it about me building a CNC mill out of angle aluminium and MDF, or designing a negative output impedance motor speed controller that would make some woman be more inclined to want to talk to me / go on a date / have casual sex?
 
Except that EG chose to make a move and Watson had no choice in the matter.

Should she have that choice, in your opinion ?

Elevators aren't that scary, she's a slut anyway, he didn't rape her, etc.

I'm going to have to call you on this AGAIN: Where did ANYONE say these things ? To this observer, it looks like you are trying to make _any_ opposition to your viewpoint appear mysogynistic, which is PRECISELY how this whole matter started.
 
Now that's uncalled for and silly. I don't know Rebecca, but I doubt she has any such hang ups, her looks and opinions obviously aren't all she has to offer, and even if she thought they were, she seems to value her opinions very highly. This is not a reasonable criticism in my book, and I'm being charitable in my wording.

What is she qualified to talk about?
 
Should she have that choice, in your opinion ?



I'm going to have to call you on this AGAIN: Where did ANYONE say these things ? To this observer, it looks like you are trying to make _any_ opposition to your viewpoint appear mysogynistic, which is PRECISELY how this whole matter started.

Skeptic Ginger has many, many posts about the safety of elevators. Watsons previous history (calender, very old article, etc) have been presented as evidence that she is sexually active, and "talk is not rape!" has come up a gazzilion times.

I honestly don't know how you missed all that. I can only assume that you are saying that those exact, specific words were never used but that's so intellectually dishonest that I can't imagine anyone doing it.
 
I thought it was pretty obvious which group of women I was talking about. Why would a 34 year old heterosexual male in the market for a female partner he finds sexually attractive be referring to 75 year old lesbians?

Because they fall under the general category of "Women." Just because you have no sexual interest in them doesn't mean that they no longer count.

The rest of it is the same old "Let's talk about how women don't like Ivor" nonsense that has been addressed a billion times. I'm tired of it.
 
Skeptic Ginger has many, many posts about the safety of elevators. Watsons previous history (calender, very old article, etc) have been presented as evidence that she is sexually active, and "talk is not rape!" has come up a gazzilion times.

Nobody said she was a slut or anything even remotely CLOSE to that. Nobody claims that elevators aren't scary, simply because it's entirely subjective, and many have agreed that EG's approach was off. As for the "he didn't rape her", well he didn't, so I don't see what the problem is there.

I honestly don't know how you missed all that. I can only assume that you are saying that those exact, specific words were never used but that's so intellectually dishonest that I can't imagine anyone doing it.

See ? Here you do it again ! You're trying to make me appear to be dishonest or somehow evil rather than just address what I said.
 
Skeptic Ginger has many, many posts about the safety of elevators. Watsons previous history (calender, very old article, etc) have been presented as evidence that she is sexually active, and "talk is not rape!" has come up a gazzilion times.

I honestly don't know how you missed all that. I can only assume that you are saying that those exact, specific words were never used but that's so intellectually dishonest that I can't imagine anyone doing it.

Elevators aren't dangerous. Talk isn't rape. Watson has used her sexuality to sell her views. What does that have to do with anything? It doesn't minimize her discomfiture, and doesn't invalidate other rational criticizes of her opinions.
 
Elevators aren't that scary, she's a slut anyway, he didn't rape her, etc.
More of this lovely straw-manning to the point of abject absurdity.

Where did anyone actually say this? As Belz pointed out, you're doing this conversation (and, in my opinion, yourself) by reacting to the calm and well reasoned arguments in this thread with hysterics. You seem to be incapable of discussing this topic rationally, and are hell-bent on imagining that people are saying all sorts of wicked nasty things instead of addressing the arguments.

For the record, I'd never call RW a slut, and I'd object to anyone else calling her one as well because I actually have a high degree of respect for sluts. I don't have much respect for RW at this point because of how she's handled this whole situation. And I'd really hate for the reputation of other sluts to be dragged down by one bad seed.
 
I don't know. What does that have to do with what I posted?

I was wondering why she keeps on being asked to speak at events associated with scepticism other than merely her availability and/or popularity.

Has she written a book on a topic of interest to the sceptical community? Has she done a study of some kind and has some results to convey?
 
...it looks like you are trying to make _any_ opposition to your viewpoint appear mysogynistic, which is PRECISELY how this whole matter started.

Are you speaking of Dawkins, or Rebecca?

What I can't understand is why Rebecca has lowered herself to personal attacking others...as everyone knows, that is the last refuge of someone who has no evidence for their opinions.

As I posted earlier...the longer SHE draws this out, the more embarrassing it will become for the skeptical community.
 
I was wondering why she keeps on being asked to speak at events associated with scepticism other than merely her availability and/or popularity.

Has she written a book on a topic of interest to the sceptical community? Has she done a study of some kind and has some results to convey?

She is very important to many in the movement based on her work on the Skeptichick web site. I don't know that she's actually qualified to be on a panel, but one doesn't need a science degree to speak intelligently on skepticism.

But again, what does this have to do with what I, or you, said? You were talking about what she has to offer a man, specifically EG.
 
Nobody said she was a slut or anything even remotely CLOSE to that. Nobody claims that elevators aren't scary, simply because it's entirely subjective, and many have agreed that EG's approach was off. As for the "he didn't rape her", well he didn't, so I don't see what the problem is there.



See ? Here you do it again ! You're trying to make me appear to be dishonest or somehow evil rather than just address what I said.

I get it you disagree. That's fine. But I would like you to recognize that your perception that women should fear a guy in an elevator at 4 am given the relevant scenario says to me you think women are more vulnerable than I think they are. I'm telling the women reading this post, don't believe it. I've been in hundreds of hotel elevators in foreign countries and it is not something to fear. TraneWreck is wrong.

The bolding on that one is all her btw. You agree with "well he didn't rape her." That Watson's flirting & sexual past has been raised, numerous times, as an excuse to discount what she is saying is obvious.

So yeah, people in this thread are saying nothing like "Elevators aren't that scary, she's a slut anyway, he didn't rape her, etc" <--sarcasm.

You focused in on the throwaway sentence (again!) and breezed right past the more important "What if she says yes." paragraph (again!)
 
<snip>

The rest of it is the same old "Let's talk about how women don't like Ivor" nonsense that has been addressed a billion times. I'm tired of it.

Okay, leave me out of it.

Do "Skepchicks" hit on nerdy guys in particular, or is nerdiness irrelevant?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom