So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
That is, as far as I can tell, Rebecca does not distinguish between sexualization, objectification and sexism (sexism is the process of sexualizing/objectifying a person on the basis of gender (afaict)).

I'll talk to you. I hope you understand that any signs of irritation on my part are not directed at you.

She clearly does make a distinction, and this distinction has been the basic idea of Skepchick. She has used the term "sexualize" in a positive sense, many, many times. Skepchick is about sexualizing various people, including "geek girls." It is not about objectifying women (well, some might disagree) but it is specifically about sexualizing women. Sexualization is primarily what Skepchick is for.

In any event, even if she didn't make a distinction, it would make no difference whatsoever. Didn't somebody say that words matter? One way words matter is their effect on listeners, and this usually has to do with what they mean to other people, that is, in this case, people who do not live inside Watson's skull. The most relevant dictionary definition is "to give or acquire sexual associations," which describes most of Skepchick to a T.

Most people find the word "objectification" stronger and having more connotations (especially negative) than "sexualization." Those not-Watson people are the ones who are hearing and reading Watson's words and reacting to them.

Certainly, most people would say that Skepchick, which Watson founded, sexualized female skeptics but does not objectify them. I think I've seen statements like that in this thread, and nobody challenged them.

So I'm curious as to why this point is being argued when there doesn't seem to be a distinction. The distinction which Rebecca does make which I really cannot understand is that of "sexual attraction" and "sexual objectification" as applied to this incident. If someone in the know could argue with me about that, it would be much appreciated. :)

Here goes.

Watson's video appeared first on June 20. http://skepchick.org/2011/06/about-mythbusters-robot-eyes-feminism-and-jokes/

On June 22, Stef McGraw issued her first reaction.

Watson didn't start using the term "objectification" until the weekend of June 26 at the earliest. That was where the whole "naming names" thing happened. On June 28, she issued a blog post that did use the term "objectification." http://skepchick.org/2011/06/on-naming-names-at-the-cfi-student-leadership-conference/

Now, the June 20 statement was the only one that McGraw had to responded to. So she responded to those words. Please remember that McGraw's response was the sine qua non of this whole bruhaha, so it is rather important in understanding what happened.

If Watson had said "objectification" (a stronger word) as opposed to "sexualization" (a word Watson has pretty consistently used in a positive sense up until now), then I think it highly likely that she would gotten a different impression and would have responded in a different way.

I know that I would have gotten a very different impression, so I think it's possible that another person would, too. If Watson had said, "objectify," I would probably have just nodded, because it's about the billionth time I've heard such statements. "Sexualize," a word that is so often used as positive in the context of Skepchick, jarred me a bit. It stood out like a sore thumb, and in the words of Frank Zappa, I had a real "what de **** be gwine on here?" moment. It made me pay attention.

Or maybe McGraw wouldn't. Or maybe she would have reacted more strongly. Or not at all. I don't know, but it would be a valid thing to discuss. Everybody has analyzed EG's words and the effect they had on Watson up the wahoonie, and these words were from a single source with no change. Discussing Watson's words and the effect they had on McGraw seems to me just as valid and a lot more interesting, because we get new words.

To rule out the possibility for a discussion by means of conflating two terms does not seem to me to be an honest argument. In fact, it doesn't seem to me an argument at all.

I see it a bit like defining conservatism as fiscal responsibility to prevent talking about conservative irresponsibility or defining God as love to prevent talking about some of the nastier things in the Old Testament.
 
Last edited:
Here's my first cut at a timeline of events:


World Atheist Convention
June 3-5 2011

Watson used her portion of a panel with Dawkins on a forum about education about atheism to talk about sexism and feminism in the atheist community. Talks about rape threats. Flagrantly misrepresents Paula Kirby

Elevator incident is placed at this time and location.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W014KhaRtik

-----

ABOUT MYTHBUSTERS, ROBOT EYES, FEMINISM, AND JOKES
Posted June 20, 2011

Rebecca Watson's initial video describing the elevator incident. Watson says she is extremely uncomfortable about being sexualized that way.

http://skepchick.org/2011/06/about-mythbusters-robot-eyes-feminism-and-jokes/

-----

My response and take on sexism in the atheist community
Uploaded June 21, 2011

Rose St. Clair criticizes Watson's speech.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TfA5AZutpCs

-----

Fursdays wif Stef #32
Posted June 22, 2011

First reaction by Stef McGraw to Watson's initial video, criticizing Watson.

http://www.unifreethought.com/2011/06/fursdays-wif-stef-32.html

-----

CFI Student Leadership Conference
Weekend of June 26, 2011

Watson calls out McGraw during a talk on the Religious Right's war on women, reportedly saying that McGraw was ignorant of feminism.

-----

ON NAMING NAMES AT THE CFI STUDENT LEADERSHIP CONFERENCE
Posted June 28, 2011

Watson continues to criticize McGraw, indirectly associating EG with the term "objectification" for the first time on the web. She refers to a tweet @rebeccawatson "[@stef_witha_f]'s post was a pretty standard parity [parody?] of misogynistic thought," clarifying in the blog that she meant "parroting."

http://skepchick.org/2011/06/on-naming-names-at-the-cfi-student-leadership-conference/

-----

Fursdays wif Stef #33
Posted June 30, 2011

McGraw responds to Watson.

Watson replies, citing 10,000 visitors to Skepchick, claims "Dawkins or Christina have never to my knowledge dismissed misogynist thinking."

http://www.unifreethought.com/2011/06/fursdays-wif-stef-33.html

-----

Bad form, Rebecca Watson
July 1, 2011

ERV criticizes Rebecca Watson for calling Stef out. .

http://scienceblogs.com/erv/2011/07/bad_form_rebecca_watson.php

-----

Always name names!
Posted July 2, 2011

P.Z. Myers supports Watson. Later that day, Dawkins makes his "Dear Muslima" response in the comment section at 11:11 AM Eastern. Later, he made another explanatory comment.

http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/2011/07/always_name_names.php

-----

Richard Dawkins and male privilege (Discover blogs)
Posted July 2, 2011

Bad Astronomer and Skepchick fan Phil Plait criticizes Dawkins. Dawkins responds at 11:35 AM Eastern

http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/badastronomy/2011/07/05/richard-dawkins-and-male-privilege/

-----

The Decent Human Being's Guide to Getting Laid at Atheist Conferences
Posted July 3, 2011

P.Z. Myers says something.

http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/2011/07/the_decent_human_beings_guide.php

-----

THE PRIVILEGE DELUSION
July 5, 2011

Watson criticizes Dawkins, refers to him as a "wealthy old heterosexual white man" and "stinking rich." Talks more about rape threats. Says she's not going to buy or recommend his books.

http://skepchick.org/2011/07/the-privilege-delusion/

-----

DEAR RICHARD DAWKINS
July 6, 2011

A bunch of letters selected within Skepchick criticizing Dawkins.

http://skepchick.org/2011/07/dear-richard-dawkins/

-----

Take Back the Elevator
July 6, 2011

Alison Smith criticises Watson.

http://skeptoid.com/blog/2011/07/06/take-back-the-elevator/

-----

Elevator Guy Hits the Wires (updated)
July 6, 2011

A very interesting suggestion that Dawkins lost patience with Watson during the panel in Dublin.

http://kazez.blogspot.com/2011/07/elevator-guy-hits-wires.html

-----

Rebecca Watson on Richard Dawkins’ sexist comments and the atheist community
July 7, 2011

Citizen Radio has a story about this.

http://wearecitizenradio.com/2011/0...ns-sexist-comments-and-the-atheist-community/

-----

Who is the Elevator Man? For me, he's someone I know
July 7, 2011

Emily has an interesting slant and obviously knows what it's like to be at a conference.

http://biologyfiles.fieldofscience.com/2011/07/who-is-elevator-man-for-me-hes-someone.html

-----

Dublin panel: Women atheist activists (comment)
July 8, 2011

Paula Kirby, whom Watson misrepresented, explains it to everyone who didn't get it the first time.

http://whyevolutionistrue.wordpress...panel-women-atheist-activists/#comment-116920

-----

Why does everyone keep leaving out Stef McGraw as if she doesn't exist?
July 12, 2011

Rose Schwartz asks, well, the title says it all.

http://jewmanist.com/2011/07/12/why...aving-out-stef-mcgraw-as-if-she-doesnt-exist/

-----

Mr. Deity and the Opposition
July 13, 2011

Some funny comments

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zKAO_ieeqTo

-----

Notes:

1) For events on July 2, 2011, either the time stamps are funky or people were typing extremely fast.
2) This is obviously not complete, and any additions and revisions are welcome. I'm not trying to include everybody, mostly the major players and events. I have thrown in a few things that seemed to me atypical and interesting. If this gets orphaned, I can be reached as epepke via PM on www.rationalskepticism.com
3) There's some evidence that Watson also criticized St. Clair, but I cannot find a link to anything substantial.
4) If anybody can figure out what in the blue blazes P.Z. Myers is on about in his July 3 entry, please clue me in.
 
Just for your information, blauregen, Richard Dawkins was sexually molested as a child.

That doesn't mean that his comment wasn't overtly dismissive.

But that means that bringing his social status and upbringing was not that good an idea, if it ever were. It's quite ironic, in fact, that they're using this argument against Richard Dawkins (yes, it's ad hominem, but it's even worse!).

And, well, I guess I'm not saying anything new, but here it goes: males are also potential victims of all sorts of violence.

As for Sharon Moss' comment:

Sure, a few guys flirting with us is sexy. BUT!!! (we all screamed in our heads, even though the panel never let us say it out loud) 20 guys our father’s age blatantly staring at and talking to our cleavage is a totally different situation! It’s not sexy, it’s gross and creepy.
I read that some time ago and did my research. It seems there was a big fuss about a woman dismissed when she complained about the use of the word "female". Well, apparently, other women don't have the same opinion (the latter of which was the only - can I say this word? - female panelist that day, by the way).

So Sharon Moss' anecdotal evidence that there's sexual discrimination is balanced by other anecdotal evidence from other women that it's mostly a problem of being oversensitive on her part. And "20 guys our father’s age blatantly staring at and talking to our cleavage is a totally different situation" doesn't sound like the most reasonable depiction of what's really going on.
 
Last edited:
I appreciate that you wrote this all out, but Rebecca did not complain of any of that. The closest her complaint comes to that list is that one guy flirted with her. And "a few guys flirting with us" was actually given as an example of something which was acceptable and even desirable. I totally get that there are ways women can and have been objectified (after all, I am a woman who happens to work in a traditionally male profession). But she specifically states that the only negative thing which happened to her is a single incident which didn't involve someone talking to her cleavage or indicating that he saw her as a pair of tits and a pussy, or violating her respect or dignity (he was polite and he accepted her denial).

I thought the issue was not the flirting itself, but the perceived stalking to and into the elevator at 4am, when she had announced to be tired and wanting to go to bed.

Well, again, Rebecca did not complain about inducing fear. The worst emotion she claimed for herself was "uncomfortable". Yes, it is reasonable to argue over the extent to which it is acceptable to induce fear. However, this incident was not an example.

English isn't my first language, so I may misunderstand the term, but she said it creeps her out, and http://thesaurus.com/browse/creepy gives as definition for 'creepy' 'nasty' and 'scary'. I always took the second to mean fear-inducing.

Dawkins was not called to task for the idea that inducing unease, anger and other negative feelings should not necessarily stop us from following a goal (I hadn't thought of it quite like that, but that is a good point). That actually would have been a rational and interesting discussion, and probably one Dawkins would be pleased to participate in. He was called to task for a strawman which did not go away after he provided two specific refutations of that strawman.

I could have phrased that better, yes. Dawkins was called to task by several prominent fellow-skeptics for dismissing the concerns RW voiced, not for this opinion. Specifically he was told that he was speaking outside his field of expertise, flippantly phrased as 'You don't get it.'
 
Fursdays wif Stef #33
Posted June 30, 2011

McGraw responds to Watson.

Watson replies, citing 10,000 visitors to Skepchick, claims "Dawkins or Christina have never to my knowledge dismissed misogynist thinking."

http://www.unifreethought.com/2011/06/fursdays-wif-stef-33.html

She mistyped that though.

She meant the opposite: "dismissed feminist thinking," or "propagated misogynist thinking". She clarifies it in this post:

http://www.unifreethought.com/2011/...howComment=1309495122792#c4074759046544261090
 
English isn't my first language, so I may misunderstand the term, but she said it creeps her out, and http://thesaurus.com/browse/creepy gives as definition for 'creepy' 'nasty' and 'scary'. I always took the second to mean fear-inducing.

I hope you don't mind if I practice my TEFL. The following are generalizations, but I think they apply to most people:

Outgoing guys are not creepy. Socially awkward guys are creepy.

AK-47s are not creepy. AK-47s with Hello Kitty painted on them are creepy (but I want).

Ladybugs are not creepy. Cockroaches are creepy.

Criminals are usually not creepy. Criminals dressed as clowns are creepy.

Clear skin is not creepy. Psoriasis is creepy.

Peter Falk was not creepy. Peter Falk tapping his glass eye with a spoon was creepy.

A bald head is not creepy. A bald head with steel spikes coming out of it is creepy.

A tattoo that says "Mom" is not creepy. A tattoo that says "Pork!" is creepy.
 
Thanks. You're the first to have given me a correction. You deserve a T-shirt, but I don't have one, so you will just have to accept my warmest thanks.

That's alright. I'll accept a coffee instead. But please, don't make the offer just now, wait for a more suitable moment so I don't freak out. ;)
 
other women[/URL] don't have the same opinion (the latter of which was the only - can I say this word? - female panelist that day, by the way).

Yeah, that happened in a place where I used to live. Very similar kind of thing.

But anyway, there isn't much point in going too far into logic over this one, because it isn't about dismissing women. We know that. We know that it is not only OK to dismiss a Stef McGraw or a Rose St. Clair, but that it's considered a positive good, perhaps essential. Scaring them away is just fine, and the most insulting and denigrating terms are great! They are Traitors to the Gender.

And who gets do decide whether a woman is a Traitor to the Gender? You got it.
 
I'll talk to you. I hope you understand that any signs of irritation on my part are not directed at you.

She clearly does make a distinction, and this distinction has been the basic idea of Skepchick. She has used the term "sexualize" in a positive sense, many, many times. Skepchick is about sexualizing various people, including "geek girls." It is not about objectifying women (well, some might disagree) but it is specifically about sexualizing women. Sexualization is primarily what Skepchick is for.

In any event, even if she didn't make a distinction, it would make no difference whatsoever. Didn't somebody say that words matter? One way words matter is their effect on listeners, and this usually has to do with what they mean to other people, that is, in this case, people who do not live inside Watson's skull. The most relevant dictionary definition is "to give or acquire sexual associations," which describes most of Skepchick to a T.

Most people find the word "objectification" stronger and having more connotations (especially negative) than "sexualization." Those not-Watson people are the ones who are hearing and reading Watson's words and reacting to them.

Certainly, most people would say that Skepchick, which Watson founded, sexualized female skeptics but does not objectify them. I think I've seen statements like that in this thread, and nobody challenged them.

I agree with all this. I misunderstood what the argument was about.

Watson clearly means "sexualize" to be negative in her video. Later she refers to the same action as "sexual objectification". I agree that the words have different connotations. What I meant is that she used the words to describe the same action. That is, she did not distinguish between them on the basis of what action they were being applied to.

Here goes.

Watson's video appeared first on June 20. http://skepchick.org/2011/06/about-mythbusters-robot-eyes-feminism-and-jokes/

On June 22, Stef McGraw issued her first reaction.

Watson didn't start using the term "objectification" until the weekend of June 26 at the earliest. That was where the whole "naming names" thing happened. On June 28, she issued a blog post that did use the term "objectification." http://skepchick.org/2011/06/on-naming-names-at-the-cfi-student-leadership-conference/

Now, the June 20 statement was the only one that McGraw had to responded to. So she responded to those words. Please remember that McGraw's response was the sine qua non of this whole bruhaha, so it is rather important in understanding what happened.

If Watson had said "objectification" (a stronger word) as opposed to "sexualization" (a word Watson has pretty consistently used in a positive sense up until now), then I think it highly likely that she would gotten a different impression and would have responded in a different way.

I know that I would have gotten a very different impression, so I think it's possible that another person would, too. If Watson had said, "objectify," I would probably have just nodded, because it's about the billionth time I've heard such statements. "Sexualize," a word that is so often used as positive in the context of Skepchick, jarred me a bit. It stood out like a sore thumb, and in the words of Frank Zappa, I had a real "what de **** be gwine on here?" moment. It made me pay attention.

Or maybe McGraw wouldn't. Or maybe she would have reacted more strongly. Or not at all. I don't know, but it would be a valid thing to discuss. Everybody has analyzed EG's words and the effect they had on Watson up the wahoonie, and these words were from a single source with no change. Discussing Watson's words and the effect they had on McGraw seems to me just as valid and a lot more interesting, because we get new words.

To rule out the possibility for a discussion by means of conflating two terms does not seem to me to be an honest argument. In fact, it doesn't seem to me an argument at all.

I see it a bit like defining conservatism as fiscal responsibility to prevent talking about conservative irresponsibility or defining God as love to prevent talking about some of the nastier things in the Old Testament.

Okay, that makes sense. I was thinking that someone was arguing the other way round - that when Rebecca brought up objectification and sexism, that she was talking about something different, something more obviously objectifying and sexist as opposed to this highly questionable example.

Linda
 
Epepke, I like your timeline. There were a few I hadn't seen (Paula Kirby's comment was very valuable). It helped that you provide a brief synopsis of what each comment was about. I also noticed Richard Dawkins' body language in the original video. :)

I would suggest adding the SGU podcast to the list, where Rebecca gives "her side of the story" - if someone has gone through the rest of the timeline by the time they listen to it, it really highlights the dishonesty of her 'story'.

Linda
 
Last edited:
The sincerest form of compliment, disagreeing with most of my opinions and still respecting me. :D

I would like to see a different female figurehead, but I think Linda is a better role model. She's much more intelligent than I am.

I'm coming to the conclusion the biggest turn-off for intelligent women joining the sceptical "community" is the likes of Ms. Watson, who as far as I can tell has *nothing* else to talk about but herself and her opinions.

Perhaps she knew EG was hitting on her because she knows that's all she's got to offer a man?

As for hot girls hitting on nerdy guys: it's bollocks.

In general women don't hit on men. The reason being that they don't have to: men are both expected and are driven to make the first move. That, and it's far more enjoyable to know you're desired by someone you don't fancy than be rejected by someone that you've made clear to that you do.

As for those women who claim "I hit on a guy! I asked him xyz!", where xyz is not "I find you interesting and attractive. Would you like to come out on a date with me" or similar, are fooling themselves. All you did was make it more likely for the guy to hit on you without having to feel as bad if you'd been direct and honest about your intentions with him. It's the dating equivalent of standing by the goal and claiming to have scored when the ball bounces off you and into the net.

Even if some women do hit on men, I've seen little evidence to suggest any women are using 'nerdiness' as a major criterion for the men they're hitting on. Instead it seems women are primarily attracted to handsome, assertive and/or rich men, who may or may not have a nerdy job or pastime.

Interestingly, men who talk total crap most of the time, or who treat women badly do not appear to be at a significant disadvantage so long as they possess at least some of the three magic ingredients that women find irresistible.

In summary, moderately ugly blokes who stutter and are not particularly wealthy do not gain anything in their attractiveness to women by having nerdy interests.
 
I thought the issue was not the flirting itself, but the perceived stalking to and into the elevator at 4am, when she had announced to be tired and wanting to go to bed.

If you listen to the original video and to Rebecca on the SGU podcast, she states that it was about being hit on. She didn't originally even describe it as perceived stalking.

English isn't my first language, so I may misunderstand the term, but she said it creeps her out, and http://thesaurus.com/browse/creepy gives as definition for 'creepy' 'nasty' and 'scary'. I always took the second to mean fear-inducing.

Okay. It is a subtle thing. The list epepke provided may help.

I could have phrased that better, yes. Dawkins was called to task by several prominent fellow-skeptics for dismissing the concerns RW voiced, not for this opinion. Specifically he was told that he was speaking outside his field of expertise, flippantly phrased as 'You don't get it.'

I don't think "making people uncomfortable" would be considered outside Dawkins' field of expertise. :)

Linda
 
This is probably going to end up sounding rude and I don't mean it to be but in general, people need to get over themselves sometimes. Yes, we know that we are all special little snowflakes and that our feelings are really important and the whole world should take special care to make sure we never have to feel bad about anything but unfortunately there just aren't enough hours in the day to sit down with everyone and carefully examine their feelings over what, to us, are minor events.

What you say, because you prefaced your intentions, doesn't really come across as rude. I appreciate that preface, because it helped me understand your words better, to read them and not just react, but think about them. It was as if you set up a curtain over your ideas, and then said, "this may be painful; please know I don't mean it to be, before you look, okay?" Thank you. :)

And I know, as almost my every sentence illustrates amply, that I do a lot of "I" speaking, and it can be annoying. But there's a reason for it: mine is the only brain and the only thought process I really understand or intimately know. I can guess at yours, but I'm probably going to be wrong at some point. So I do try to speak only for myself when I can. I think it's the most reasonable approach. And it results in a lot of "I" statements.

Having a moan about something over the breakfast table with your friends is one thing, and will likely get a more sympathetic reaction than blogging/making videos/calling people out from a podium during a speech about something else.

I don't disagree with this, in a general sense.

While being told your feelings aren't the most important thing in the world might not be very nice or very fair, sometimes its going to happen and we really need to learn to deal with it.

Again with the "I" speaking, but yes, I do understand that. What I've learned, however, is that "emotional wiring," just like "intellectual wiring," varies from person to person. My intellectual wiring, for instance, is something on the high side. I'm not super brill, but I am reasonably intelligent. My emotional wiring, however, is definitely on the high side. I really do go to 11, and this isn't something a huge part of the population does. Not in my experience. I think I'm harder to understand, because of it, but I also know it's a core part of my identity, and I'm tired of pretending my feelings don't matter. I want people to accept it, to accept me, to deal with it, as you say. I try really hard to work my empathy, and try to understand other people and how they're each wired.

Each human belongs to myriad little subsets. Being an individual means there are ways in which you are like most other people, and ways in which you aren't. The little subsets can be repeatedly divided. This is the essence of being an individual. When you belong to a rather exclusive and tiny subset, you do tend to want people to know that, to understand it in their dealings with you, because you know they probably don't, and thus probably don't understand you.

It's no different to when we tell people who moan about not being able to pray in school, or wear their crosses in the workplace or go round badgering people about Jesus that their religion isn't the most important thing in the world. Even if that makes them feel bad and hurts their feelings.

I guess all I can say about that is how important it is to each of us to be accepted for who we are, for all our little subsets. It's not that you have to see life the way I see it. It's that I want you to understand how I see it, and how my sight colors everything I do or say or think, just as yours does for you. That something is important to me but not to you doesn't mean you should tell me it's not important at all. When you tell me that X isn't the most important thing in the world to you, and yet it is very important to me, I feel disrespected and disregarded.

"Be Yourself!" is probably Number One on my list of harmful, bull dung things we tell ourselves and each other. We don't really want people to be themselves; we want them to be us, for maximum empathy.

I apologize for coming across as a "fragile little snowflake." It wasn't my intention, at all.
But...snowflakes are hugely individual. It's not true that no two are exactly alike. Sometimes, they are. But not very often. In a way, while we may not be fragile, we really are snowflakes.
 
I don't think "making people uncomfortable" would be considered outside Dawkins' field of expertise. :)

Linda

I think the "field of expertise" or speculating from a priviledged position is about understanding the experience of the minority, not about being uncomfortable.
 
Yeah, that happened in a place where I used to live. Very similar kind of thing.

But anyway, there isn't much point in going too far into logic over this one, because it isn't about dismissing women. We know that. We know that it is not only OK to dismiss a Stef McGraw or a Rose St. Clair, but that it's considered a positive good, perhaps essential. Scaring them away is just fine, and the most insulting and denigrating terms are great! They are Traitors to the Gender.

And who gets do decide whether a woman is a Traitor to the Gender? You got it.

Hmm... I have a slight idea. This goes along the same line as Alison Smith's article, who reaches a similar conclusion through a different argument: this is not a feminist issue, it's a human issue. If you look at it from a human persepective in general, it's easy to see the double standards. And yes, of course there is male sexism still going on in Western societies, let alone others, but I think it's better not to waste ammunition with trivial stuff for which there is not evidence that it's caused by a problem of sexism. And there's a very powerful reason for that: it lowers one's credibility.

Judging from Rebecca Watsons' reaction to the rather mild response by Stef Mcgraw, that's clear enough. If, according to RW, Stef Mcgraw was parroting anti-woman rhetoric and validating misogyny, a rational debate is impossible. This is a clear example of a dogmatic attitude. What also grabbed my attention is the emphasis RW puts on the ignorance Stef Mcgraw apparently demonstrated of Feminism 101. Even if she ignored what Feminism 101 is about, what is it, the Bible? Fine. I have never read the Bible entirely. So? It all goes to show how dogmatic her stance is.
 
Last edited:
I'm coming to the conclusion the biggest turn-off for intelligent women joining the sceptical "community" is the likes of Ms. Watson, who as far as I can tell has *nothing* else to talk about but herself and her opinions.

Perhaps she knew EG was hitting on her because she knows that's all she's got to offer a man?

Now that's uncalled for and silly. I don't know Rebecca, but I doubt she has any such hang ups, her looks and opinions obviously aren't all she has to offer, and even if she thought they were, she seems to value her opinions very highly. This is not a reasonable criticism in my book, and I'm being charitable in my wording.
 
Can I just tangent for a moment from the original EG/Dawkins comment and offer up an observation I've had regarding Rebecca for quite a while - She has built up quite the personality cult around her and this whole bruhaha as reminded me of a chapter in Shermer's "Why People Believe Weird Things" entitled The Unlikeliest Cult. It's disturbing to see "skeptics" using buzz words and presuming things without any evidence what-so-ever. Whatever happened in that elevator in Dublin, what has happened in the skeptic community since then has been even more ugly and I'm sorry, but that blame doesn't rest on Rebecca and her attention whoring, but on the cultish behavior of readers of a marginal blog and the endless blather that constitutes podcasts and Youtube videos.
 
Can I just tangent for a moment from the original EG/Dawkins comment and offer up an observation I've had regarding Rebecca for quite a while - She has built up quite the personality cult around her and this whole bruhaha as reminded me of a chapter in Shermer's "Why People Believe Weird Things" entitled The Unlikeliest Cult. It's disturbing to see "skeptics" using buzz words and presuming things without any evidence what-so-ever. Whatever happened in that elevator in Dublin, what has happened in the skeptic community since then has been even more ugly and I'm sorry, but that blame doesn't rest on Rebecca and her attention whoring, but on the cultish behavior of readers of a marginal blog and the endless blather that constitutes podcasts and Youtube videos.

You will note that the drama section of the video store is always much larger than the education or documentary section.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom