epepke
Philosopher
- Joined
- Oct 22, 2003
- Messages
- 9,264
That is, as far as I can tell, Rebecca does not distinguish between sexualization, objectification and sexism (sexism is the process of sexualizing/objectifying a person on the basis of gender (afaict)).
I'll talk to you. I hope you understand that any signs of irritation on my part are not directed at you.
She clearly does make a distinction, and this distinction has been the basic idea of Skepchick. She has used the term "sexualize" in a positive sense, many, many times. Skepchick is about sexualizing various people, including "geek girls." It is not about objectifying women (well, some might disagree) but it is specifically about sexualizing women. Sexualization is primarily what Skepchick is for.
In any event, even if she didn't make a distinction, it would make no difference whatsoever. Didn't somebody say that words matter? One way words matter is their effect on listeners, and this usually has to do with what they mean to other people, that is, in this case, people who do not live inside Watson's skull. The most relevant dictionary definition is "to give or acquire sexual associations," which describes most of Skepchick to a T.
Most people find the word "objectification" stronger and having more connotations (especially negative) than "sexualization." Those not-Watson people are the ones who are hearing and reading Watson's words and reacting to them.
Certainly, most people would say that Skepchick, which Watson founded, sexualized female skeptics but does not objectify them. I think I've seen statements like that in this thread, and nobody challenged them.
So I'm curious as to why this point is being argued when there doesn't seem to be a distinction. The distinction which Rebecca does make which I really cannot understand is that of "sexual attraction" and "sexual objectification" as applied to this incident. If someone in the know could argue with me about that, it would be much appreciated.![]()
Here goes.
Watson's video appeared first on June 20. http://skepchick.org/2011/06/about-mythbusters-robot-eyes-feminism-and-jokes/
On June 22, Stef McGraw issued her first reaction.
Watson didn't start using the term "objectification" until the weekend of June 26 at the earliest. That was where the whole "naming names" thing happened. On June 28, she issued a blog post that did use the term "objectification." http://skepchick.org/2011/06/on-naming-names-at-the-cfi-student-leadership-conference/
Now, the June 20 statement was the only one that McGraw had to responded to. So she responded to those words. Please remember that McGraw's response was the sine qua non of this whole bruhaha, so it is rather important in understanding what happened.
If Watson had said "objectification" (a stronger word) as opposed to "sexualization" (a word Watson has pretty consistently used in a positive sense up until now), then I think it highly likely that she would gotten a different impression and would have responded in a different way.
I know that I would have gotten a very different impression, so I think it's possible that another person would, too. If Watson had said, "objectify," I would probably have just nodded, because it's about the billionth time I've heard such statements. "Sexualize," a word that is so often used as positive in the context of Skepchick, jarred me a bit. It stood out like a sore thumb, and in the words of Frank Zappa, I had a real "what de **** be gwine on here?" moment. It made me pay attention.
Or maybe McGraw wouldn't. Or maybe she would have reacted more strongly. Or not at all. I don't know, but it would be a valid thing to discuss. Everybody has analyzed EG's words and the effect they had on Watson up the wahoonie, and these words were from a single source with no change. Discussing Watson's words and the effect they had on McGraw seems to me just as valid and a lot more interesting, because we get new words.
To rule out the possibility for a discussion by means of conflating two terms does not seem to me to be an honest argument. In fact, it doesn't seem to me an argument at all.
I see it a bit like defining conservatism as fiscal responsibility to prevent talking about conservative irresponsibility or defining God as love to prevent talking about some of the nastier things in the Old Testament.
Last edited: