I don't understand how Rebecca was discriminated against. Can you elaborate on that?
Yes, but it will become a little lengthy to put it into context.
RW complained first that being sexualized in an inappropriate context creeps her out and makes her uncomfortable. This in itself seems not a unique or RW-specific experience. Other female speakers on atheist conferences apparently experience this too. An example would be
here:
Sure, a few guys flirting with us is sexy. BUT!!! (we all screamed in our heads, even though the panel never let us say it out loud) 20 guys our father’s age blatantly staring at and talking to our cleavage is a totally different situation! It’s not sexy, it’s gross and creepy.
First on the topic of sexualization.
I know, some liberated and skeptic people would have simply told RW and other women in the skeptic community to grow some ovaries, and enjoy it. It is after all a compliment to be deemed attractive, but it is on the other hand, really annoying to have a rational talk with someone who primarily sees you as a pair of tits and a pussy, which is were I think the annoyance about inappropriate sexualization comes from.
If this is indeed a prevalent attitude in the skeptics community,as she asserts, and if men don't get the same treatment (dozens of sexually interested people, they may not likely by attracted to, talking primarily to their crotch when they are there in their capacity as skeptic or atheist persons ) it would file it under discriminatation against women. Their respect and dignity as skeptical persons is at least partly overshadowed there.
She used this incident as an example of things that could make women uncomfortable, and prevent them from participating in the skeptics community. As was to expected there was some healthy opposition to her position, which is where I think the perceived discrimination of RW as a woman comes in.
I had the impression that she felt that her concerns were summarily dismissed as irrelevant, because no real harm happened to her in the case she used as an illustration, and that women's specific concerns in this regard are generally ignored or downplayed, which again would qualify as discrimination against women, if it were factual.
I'll come to this soon.
Her responses to the criticism she received could certainly have been handled better. While the state of feminist consciousness in the skeptic/atheist movement certainly makes a good transition to the broader topic of feminist goals in society and the efforts of the religious right to reduce women's social status, it was in my opinion simply rude to challenge a part of the host. And instead of answering Dawkin's perceived dismissal of her concerns with a short dismissal of her own, as mentioned here.
My take was that rather than address RD's argument, RW dismissed it with an ad hom. "You aren't a women, you don't experience the prejudice women experience, you couldn't possibly understand"
She could have either explained to him, that his social status and upbringing may have deprived him of some experiences, which likely makes it difficult for him to appreciate the emotional gravity of the concerns, or could have elaborated on it like Jen McCreight did it
here.
Words matter. You don't get that because you've never been called a ****, a faggot, a ******, a kike. You don't have people constantly explaining that you're subhuman, or have the intellect of an animal. You don't have people saying you shouldn't have rights. You don't have people constantly sexually harassing you. You don't live in fear of rape, knowing that one wrong misinterpretation of a couple words could lead down that road.
Both would likely have been perceived more as a hint that he speaks out of his field of expertise, than as an ad hominem attack. But I don't know anybody who is always calm and rational, when it comes to topics they are emotionally invested in, be it feminism, atheism or perceived sleights against your peer group or people you happen to revere, and from this, I think I can understand the reactions.
Now whether I see the dismissal of RW's concerns as discriminating against RW as a woman, depends on the kind of arguments, the dismissal was justified with. I'll take the ones Dawkins as an influential and revered person in the community used here.
The first is that RW in her situation, was not injured, nor restrained nor did she lose any money or valuables, or as another poster here put it:
Similarly the women complaining about the guys constantly talking to their cleavage didn't experience any tangible harm. Just disregard of themselves as persons, and a looming feeling that a lot of men there rather wanted to get into their pants than to talk to them as intelligent persons.
Dawkins makes it very clear that from his point of view purely psychological harm, like induced fear and uneasiness in adult women does not qualify as harm done.
Richard Dawkins said:
Here's the argument I was making. The man in the elevator didn't physically touch her, didn't attempt to bar her way out of the elevator, didn't even use foul language at her. He spoke some words to her. Just words. She no doubt replied with words. That was that. Words.
The qualification 'in adult women' is necessary, because Dawkins's regards purely psychological harm like induced fear in children due to religious upbringing ( descriptions of hell ) as noteworthy. The argument in itself is faulty, because it doesn't consider the circumstances. I guess RW wouldn't have minded a few words earlier at the bar that much.
I disagree with him on the noteworthiness of fear and uneasiness too. Fear and uneasiness may be immaterial, and as Skeptic Ginger pointed out
There are two ways to consider a rational basis for a fear. It is rational if the risk is real. If the risk is perceived but not real, that explains the basis for the fear, it makes it understandable, but if one defines rational thinking as evidence based then perceived risk is not always real risk. In fact, very often perceived risk and real risk are miles apart (in both directions). Perceived risk is explicable, but not always rational.
not even rational, but they are still subjectively perceived as very real and lead to measurable reactions. As a general rule I consider scaring people, when I can easily avoid it, and have no pressing reason, as doing them harm. Wanting to hook up with someone does not qualify as a pressing need in my mind.
Dawkins follows up with
If she felt his behaviour was creepy, that was her privilege, just as it was the Catholics' privilege to feel offended and hurt when PZ nailed the cracker. PZ didn't physically strike any Catholics. All he did was nail a wafer, and he was absolutely right to do so because the heightened value of the wafer was a fantasy in the minds of the offended Catholics.
In his opinion, if a Skeptic is free to induce uneasiness, anger and other unwelcome feelings to follow a goal, he must also be free to induce uneasiness, fear and other unwelcome feelings in women to follow a goal. This sounds on the surface reasonable. The perceived threat, which lead to the uneasiness is after all, as pointed out by various posters here, only a fantasy in the minds of the respective women. So if indignation, anger and anxiety are acceptable means or even only acceptable side effects for one atheist in the pursuit of a goal, like demonstrating the silliness of some religious beliefs, there seems to be no reason why another atheist or a skeptic shouldn't tacitly approve of anxiety caused in his pursuit of a goal , like hooking up with a woman.
I would like to point out there, that it is comparatively easy to get rid of catholicism, if the treatment of catholics by inconsiderate atheists causes you too much distress. HRT and GRS sadly aren't that effective if you plan to stop being a woman and become a man, which makes this justification dubious too.
From this and from my perspective, I consider the dismissal of RW's concerns about women's fears and uneasiness in situations like the ones described above on the ground of Dawkins' arguments as discriminating against women.
You don't have to agree with my assessment of course. If you accept the above argumentation as valid, then the concerns brought up by RW and other women are just silly, and dismissing them as irrelevant is only consequent and not discriminating.
Dawkins was called to task for it though, which shows that 'the skeptic community as a whole' does not dismiss the mentioned concerns on the ground of those arguments, so it would be false to say the community as a whole discriminates against women or RW as a woman in this specific instance.
The perceived treatment of women primarily as sex-objects would still be discriminating, if it is factual. I can't tell first-hand.