So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
In case anybody is vaguely interested, Dawkins is speaking at TAM 9 as I write this. I hear RW and others are at the bar instead, but as far as I can tell a very large percentage of the 1600+ attendees are still in the room.

I once went to a restaurant, paid for my meal, then snuck out without eating.
 
As a liberated female and a skeptic, it concerns me to see the dangerous foreign country elevator myth perpetuated. I would like women to know they can travel the world alone with some basic caution and they'll be fine.

RW has made it difficult to get this message out. She attacked those people trying to tell her her assessment of EG could have been wrong. Can you tell someone they are overreacting without invalidating their feelings? And don't you think some of us tried to do that but to no avail?

I don't know if you can or can't tell them that. I'm sorry I keep saying this, but it's true. It really is situational. For me, you could tell me, in a certain way (gently, and non-blaming, and trying to understand my POV, even if you feel it's wrong), and then give me time to consider it without insisting I see it the way you think I should see it, right now. I often come round if I really have been overreacting. But to insist often makes me dig in my heels.

We tend to do that if we're feeling attacked over having felt attacked (and I don't mean EG, but Dawkins et al).
 
We can say that in her initial remarks, Watson didn't say anything about objectifying and sexism. She only talked about being "sexualized" and uncomfortable. She also didn't say anything about fear or rape.

So we can take her at her word, or not. If we take her at her word, then it is possible to find fault with her claim that "sexualization" is what the problem was.

Accusations of "sexism" and "misogyny" only come into it later, as in the Number 11 item in her Frequently Answered (sic) Questions. The charge of sexism there is applied to whoever criticizes her.
We have a different perception of the events here.

I wrote a short review in post 2259 which is where the links are.

RW's initial remarks:
it creeps me out and makes me uncomfortable when men sexualize me in that manner...

EG's words according to RW:
'Don't take this the wrong way, but I find you very interesting, and I would like to talk more. Would you like to come to my hotel room for coffee?'

No overt sexualizing there.

So what was RW basing her assessment of EG on?:
approaching a single woman in an elevator to invite her back to your hotel room is the definition of “unsolicited sexual comment.”

difference between sexual attraction and sexual objectification ... the latter involves dismissing a person’s feelings, desires, and identity, with a complete disinterest in how one’s actions will affect the “object” in question.

Sexual objectification seems to be the main complaint RW has for EG. What do you think her complaint is?
 
I don't know if you can or can't tell them that. I'm sorry I keep saying this, but it's true. It really is situational. For me, you could tell me, in a certain way (gently, and non-blaming, and trying to understand my POV, even if you feel it's wrong), and then give me time to consider it without insisting I see it the way you think I should see it, right now. I often come round if I really have been overreacting. But to insist often makes me dig in my heels.

We tend to do that if we're feeling attacked over having felt attacked (and I don't mean EG, but Dawkins et al).
But can't I understand your point of view and still believe it is baseless as you describe what it is based on?
 
As a liberated female and a skeptic, it concerns me to see the dangerous foreign country elevator myth perpetuated

Just don't get a Mickey Mouse cockamamie, because it might be laced with a drug that will put you under until the chihuahua that is really a rat can take out your kidney and sell it on the open market.
 

Linked to twice already, but it is a very useful resource. He cites sources. Those sources are what I used to form a more concrete opinion of this whole kerfuffle.

It shows that there actually is a rational discussion to be had, with sane supporters on all sides offering good points. Including on Rebecca's side, I add because some people might get the wrong impression of my actual stance here as I've been criticizing her a lot more than some of the other players here.
 
We have a different perception of the events here.

I don't see much of a difference. Her complaint was that he was sexualizing her. Whether that was true or not is not relevant. The point is what Watson claimed.

Sexual objectification seems to be the main complaint RW has for EG. What do you think her complaint is?

If I take her word for it, she said "sexualize" and did not say "objectify," at least not in the original complaint.

If I don't take her word for it, I could presume anything.
 
But can't I understand your point of view and still believe it is baseless as you describe what it is based on?

I said you could, but that how you do it will matter. I thought I made it clear that when trying to tell me you think I overreacted, I'll then come to feel like you're attacking me too, if you don't allow me time to digest what you've said.

If I feel adamant about my reaction at the time, I'm simply not going to immediately swing over to your POV, just because you insist that I do. Even if you are right. I need time to get over my mad a little bit, so I can think.

And I'd hope you can realize that you won't always be right. You might think I'm overreacting, but you might be wrong. Maybe my reaction is right just for me, and not right at all for you. That has to be taken into account, as well. Because I'm not you, and won't react as you do.
 
I said you could, but that how you do it will matter. I thought I made it clear that when trying to tell me you think I overreacted, I'll then come to feel like you're attacking me too, if you don't allow me time to digest what you've said.

If I feel adamant about my reaction at the time, I'm simply not going to immediately swing over to your POV, just because you insist that I do. Even if you are right. I need time to get over my mad a little bit, so I can think.

And I'd hope you can realize that you won't always be right. You might think I'm overreacting, but you might be wrong. Maybe my reaction is right just for me, and not right at all for you. That has to be taken into account, as well. Because I'm not you, and won't react as you do.
Looking at Stef McGraf's comments, how should she have made her point and what did she say that disrespected RW's 'feelings'?
 
I don't see much of a difference. Her complaint was that he was sexualizing her. Whether that was true or not is not relevant. The point is what Watson claimed.



If I take her word for it, she said "sexualize" and did not say "objectify," at least not in the original complaint.

If I don't take her word for it, I could presume anything.
I'm sorry, Rebecca did indeed say EG sexualized and objectified her. I posted the direct quotes from RW.

You are ignoring the facts.
 
We have a different perception of the events here.

I agree with this on one point:

EG's words according to RW:

'Don't take this the wrong way, but I find you very interesting, and I would like to talk more. Would you like to come to my hotel room for coffee?'

No overt sexualizing there.

Not to you.

To me, it's obvious the man is trying to hook up with me, that he's asking for sex. Because we both just left an open, public area that serves coffee. So to me, the only reason to ask me to go back to his private hotel room is to get me in bed.

I can't help it that your mileage varies, but then--without trying to condescend to you--I'm 52 years old, and I've been having sex of one kind or another since I was six years old. And I have had a lot of sex. I'm very, very good at recognizing an attempt. I really have seen them all, frankly. I've even done it myself.

When I met my husband, I blatantly picked him up with the line, "I hear you have a waterbed." My intent was perfectly clear to both of us, and discussing furnishings wasn't it. ;)
 
Another great piece of work. ;)


Just curious, did you see my TAM hug link or discover it on your own? :D

Here's the actual sign (no kidding) for the whooping cough hug thing:

CoughSign.jpg
 
Last edited:
Looking at Stef McGraf's comments, how should she have made her point and what did she say that disrespected RW's 'feelings'?

This may sound bad, but aside from viewing Rebecca's initial vlog about it, and reading the first 100 or so comments at PZ's blog, I haven't read much more. It blew up too fast, and I found it too confusing to follow, so I didn't. I've not even seen Stef's comments. I hadn't read RD's other two posts regarding his first Muslima letter until I was pointed to them.

May I ask for links, so I can see what comments you mean?

And please don't put feelings in challenge quotes. I find it dismissive, being a highly emotional person myself. Feelings mean a great deal to me, where they don't to many other people. It's how I'm wired.
 
Not to you.

To me, it's obvious the man is trying to hook up with me, that he's asking for sex. Because we both just left an open, public area that serves coffee. So to me, the only reason to ask me to go back to his private hotel room is to get me in bed.

I can't help it that your mileage varies, but then--without trying to condescend to you--I'm 52 years old, and I've been having sex of one kind or another since I was six years old. And I have had a lot of sex. I'm very, very good at recognizing an attempt. I really have seen them all, frankly. I've even done it myself.

When I met my husband, I blatantly picked him up with the line, "I hear you have a waterbed." My intent was perfectly clear to both of us, and discussing furnishings wasn't it. ;)
Sling, I hate to say it, but interpreting a statement that says nothing about sex as being sexual is something that you are doing. It's you, in my opinion, sexualizing yourself. You chose to interpret the phrase the way you did, and you did it on faulty logic. :(

You're not the only one who's had a lot of sex and are very good at recognizing an attempt. I've had the phrase "so, do you like this band?" be a pick up line (and it actually worked, too). That doesn't mean, however, that every time someone asks if I like the band that they're asking me for sex. That phrase was only a pick up line because of the context of what was going on at the time, the body language, the tone of voice, and the facial expression of the person asking.

Insisting that the statement EG made HAD to be a pick up line or a proposition for sex because "you're very very good at recognizing an attempt", when you weren't there, is not a fair judgement to make. Since you're adept at spotting pick up lines, you should know that whether or not a normally innocuous phrase is taken as a pick up line generally includes body language, tone of voice, and facial expression.

Do you know what EG's body language, tone of voice, or facial expression were? No, you don't. Not unless you're RW, and the Sling we know is some sort of fictional persona (and I know it's not :) ).

You simply cannot judge, based on the information at hand, whether or not EG was trying to get RW into bed. You cannot. Period. Any attempt to do so is a Fallacy of Composition.

A: I've had someone attempt to get me into bed by saying "would you like to come back to my room for coffee".
B: All instances of anyone asking anyone to "come back to their room for coffee" must be attempts to get them into bed.

These sorts of fallacies have run rampant throughout this discussion. I know this is an emotionally charged subject for some people (myself included, especially when we start talking about sexual assault and/or molestation), but there's simply no point in bringing our own biases into the matter. It won't get anyone anywhere productive or positive if we do.
 
Okay, then we disagree. Sorry my logic is faulty.

Edit: that was too abrupt. i don't mean to be. I'm trying to be calm, and doing a lot better at it than I normally do. :)

But I feel how I feel about it. And it really is only my opinion on something for which we all have faulty data, but are discussing anyway. I'm not the only one doing it. But since we can't agree, I'm all right with leaving it alone.

In other words, no harm, no foul. We just don't agree, and that's okay. No need to apologize or anything, I don't has a mad about it. :)
 
Last edited:
Sorry. This got way too long somehow and I'm either too drunk or nerdy or both and lazier than a toothless hound anyway to edit at the moment...

It's just so weird to me that people will hear "other women have been creeped out at the conferences" and reply "Yeah, so what. Watson deserves it."

I agree, it's weird. I think the emotional logic behind it may go something like: "other women have been creeped out at the conferences": why? by being hit on awkwardly or too much. Who for years has been putting out the message that there are women at the conferences who like to be hit on, by drunk nerds no less, which pretty much guarantees the awkward and too much quotas will be met? Watson. Is there an apology from Watson for having contributed to the problem women are now complaining about? Not that I know of. Instead, is she now complaining about someone, Elevator Guy, a drunk nerd(?), having, arguably, hit on her awkwardly, after she mentioned in a speech earlier she doesn't like "being sexualized" or something to that effect (raising all sorts of questions: does "being sexualized" extend to being hit on by drunk nerds, her earlier message? should EG have known this? did EG even hear the speech? might RW come off better if she took responsibility for having for years invited drunk nerds to hit on her and then, arguably, taking it back by saying she doesn't like "being sexualized"; for having, arguably, created the confusion which led to her, arguably, being hit on by EG? Imo, yes. Does this imply: "Yeah, so what. Watson deserves it"? Well, that's a difficult question. When you target "drunk nerds" with the message "I want to hit on you", you're setting yourself up for all sorts of unpleasant situations where the other party, the drunk nerd, has plausible deniability. Even if you claim to have retracted the message in a speech he may or may not have heard by saying you don't like "being sexualized", the drunk nerd may not have understood the phrase, which is somewhat nebulous, to mean you don't want to be hit on, or may not have heard it at all, or may be too drunk to remember, or too drunk to care, or too nerdy not to make an awkward pass or an awkward early morning invite for coffee in an elevator that might be mistaken for a pass, or may wonder if after a few drinks you'll revert to "hot girl hits on drunk nerds" form as advertised, etc. All sorts of plausible deniability. So to the question "does Watson deserve it"? Well... in cases where her target demographic, the drunk nerd, should have known better, no. Hopefully in the future drunk nerds, fully cognizant of her revised "don't hit on me" stance, will take the message to heart and act more responsibly: although "drunk nerds act responsibly" as a phrase is a bit of an oxymoron, almost guaranteed to lead to disappointment, I'm afraid.

The glaring flaw in RW's marketing strategy which now seems to have backfired on her, the ticking blotto dork jizzbomb which has blown up in her face (pictures of which to feature heavily in her new promos -- kidding [I hope... sort of]): when you put how well you are treated in the hands of drunk nerds, having targeted them with the message "[I'm a] hot girl [who] hits on drunk nerds", you're setting yourself up to be treated very badly, because, as I would have thought someone her age with her hefty drinking resume was well aware, drunks in general, even and especially drunk nerds, don't always behave very well, don't always treat you the way you want to or think you should be or in fact should be treated. When you chose by your marketing to surround yourself with a fanbase of drunk nerds, you will be treated badly, guaranteed. That's just a sad fact of life. Drunks and nerds and drunk nerds often behave badly. So, was EG a bad experience she set herself up for by having branded herself a "hot girl [who] hits on drunk nerds"? Imo, yes. There are all sorts of plausible circumstances, some outlined above, where she got exactly what she asked for. Putting all the blame on Elevator Guy seems disingenuous to me. Part of the blame, whether she has the critical capacity and humility to ever realize and admit it, is hers. She left how well she would be treated at the discretion of drunk nerds, not a very reliable group when it comes to decent treatment! So far, I've seen no recognition of that, part of the reason Dawkins was so dismissive of her experience in the first place (he referred to the "Chicks" marketing), and many others are now. Which is unfortunate, I think, because the dismissal of her for failing to acknowledge her own role in her discomfort shouldn't apply to the general case. It's important to keep them separate. Not all women market themselves as "hot girls who hit on drunk nerds". Unfortunately, when some do, all suffer, it seems.

The skepchick crowd is a very limited sample of any gender within the skeptical community. Treating a larger group based on the actions of one person within a sub-group doesn't seem rational. The "Don't be that guy." proponents can be found within every sub-group and every part of the whole. Watson has given them an opening for the message, killing the messenger doesn't negate it.

Yup, as I've lamented: good message (something that needs to be discussed); bad messenger (someone whose fame, limited as it is, far exceeds her brains, if her "hot girls hit on drunk nerds" marketing and much of her conduct during this whole brouhaha is anything to go by).

You know, I'd be ok with saying "EG was an aberration," if someone would just offer a little evidence that the free-thought community has the same percentage of socially awkward people as the rest of the population. But even "There is no such thing as *that* guy" group keep arguing the opposite. You have a movement with a much advertised flaw (social ineptitude) who is trying to say that the obvious results of that flaw do not exist.

I can't put it on all EG's dorkiness, though. Some admission of guilt from the "hot girls hit on drunk nerds" Skepchicks; a condemnation of that wilfully stupid message; a follow-up contrary marketing campaign, just as high profile, to get the reverse message out there, "respect women you meet at cons", if they think it's important, would be nice, if I'm to take their feminist transformation seriously. Of course, there are other factors as well: anywhere one gender is outnumbered by the other can be a bit uncomfortable for the minority, especially under the wrong conditions (such as a high profile group of the minority gender branding itself with the message "hot girls hit on drunk nerds"). (Jesus, with this [over]analysis I feel a bit like the Skeptical Inquisitor: "Confess! Confess your guilt in your current complaint, Skepchicks! Hot girls who hit on drunk nerds, confess!" blobru needs a hobby.)

Look at all the "Well what if I do this, why would that be bad?" posts in which someone is arguing that slightly rude behavior isn't "logically" wrong and therefore should be just peachy. For fun, apply it to real life.

I get the feeling disputants are trying to establish when does behavior become so rude that it needs to be complained about. That's an interesting exercise in community etiquette, and is bound to be contentious, as what is deeply offensive to one maybe inconsequential to another. My conclusion is: by all means, complain if you feel you have been offended. Talk about it as rationally as possible, why you think the act was offensive. Just don't expect everyone to share your sense of offense. Some will care a lot; some not so much; some not at all. That's often part of how one picks one's friends, finds one's niche, in any social circle. Skepticism -- no different. RW was and many others would have been offended by EG's coffee invite in the elevator. Others, meh, sort of. Others (Dawkins), pffttt! Cool by me. Be offended if you want to be. Try to not offend in that way if you want to be okay with the group that has taken and expressed offense at EG (or whatever). Different strokes and all that. I'm optimistic. I think there's a basic level of respect that everyone can assume always applies. As long as, as a community, skeptics keep it free of clutter from thoughtless messages that invite a lack of respect, such as, you guessed it, "HGHODN", they should get along just fine, in spite of their not always showing as much finesse as one might hope. (Uncle Ben's IQ curse, I calls it: with great brainpower comes date impossibility!)

In an elevator and out of the blue, person A (a stranger) says "Hey you wanna go to my room?" and person B says no with obvious distaste. So then person A comes back with one of the comments bouncing around le blogsphere:
Well, if you thought I was attractive you would.
Lots of people have sex without much discussion.
Just exercising my freedom to say what I want and insult you.
Why can't you just politely say no? You choose your own comfort level.
Getting hit on wouldn't bother me. What's your problem?
You need to respect that I was willing to be embarrassed.
Men have to make the first move, I had no choice.
I'm not sexualizing you because I didn't rape you.
You should be flattered, you're not all that pretty anyway.

Kind of what I'm trying to say at wearying length (sorry). In the end, you let it be known what you're comfortable with, people who agree gravitate to that, those that don't don't. It's an interesting discussion for finding out where everyone stands, and for influencing opinions a bit this way and that with good arguments. But in the end... some will be offended, some won't. Groups within the group will form around centers of agreement, then disperse and form around other nexuses, and so on. Just your garden variety social dynamics.

And so forth. It's romcom, pathetic best friend stuff.

At times. But then, we're only human (and who in his/her heart of hearts doesn't prefer tabloid news to science experiments, really; besides us bright-eyed best-hope-for-humanity-and-a-sane-tomorrow skeptics, that is). ;)
 
I agree with this on one point:

Not to you.

To me, it's obvious the man is trying to hook up with me, that he's asking for sex. Because we both just left an open, public area that serves coffee. So to me, the only reason to ask me to go back to his private hotel room is to get me in bed.
So you are convinced you can read his mind?

I can't help it that your mileage varies, but then--without trying to condescend to you--I'm 52 years old, and I've been having sex of one kind or another since I was six years old. And I have had a lot of sex. I'm very, very good at recognizing an attempt. I really have seen them all, frankly. I've even done it myself.

When I met my husband, I blatantly picked him up with the line, "I hear you have a waterbed." My intent was perfectly clear to both of us, and discussing furnishings wasn't it. ;)
I hate to disclose that I'm older, but I might as well. I am.

I am not saying he didn't just want sex. I'm saying he could have, but he also could have been interested in a relationship. RW says she has no objection to someone expressing an interest in a person except if the interest is just in screwing and nothing else. How can you possibly say what EG had in mind? I can't. I couldn't even give it a 60:40 or a 50:50. It could be either one.
 
This may sound bad, but aside from viewing Rebecca's initial vlog about it, and reading the first 100 or so comments at PZ's blog, I haven't read much more. It blew up too fast, and I found it too confusing to follow, so I didn't. I've not even seen Stef's comments. I hadn't read RD's other two posts regarding his first Muslima letter until I was pointed to them.

May I ask for links, so I can see what comments you mean?

And please don't put feelings in challenge quotes. I find it dismissive, being a highly emotional person myself. Feelings mean a great deal to me, where they don't to many other people. It's how I'm wired.
The links are all in my post 2259.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom