So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oy, I really don't want to get dragged into all this, so I'll try and keep this brief: Sure, if you want to have an extremely narrow interpretation of what a speaker is allowed to talk about, then yes, Rebecca bringing up anything other that the "Religious Right's war on women" is off-topic. By that metric, nearly every speaker ever has gone off topic.

However, we normally don't hold that against them -- not unless they stray massively far from what they've said they'll talk about (a la the fictional account of James Randi and the Nazi Homophobes). In this case, there's a clear and direct message that Rebecca was communicating: Yes, the religious right are bad; but before we get into that, let's also be aware that we still have work to do in our own community -- yes, even this one here. And rather than being passive aggressive about it, she cited an example and why she felt that was an example; she didn't call Stef evil, or a gender traitor, or a misogynist (even by the accounts of people who were there), despite the blowup that occurred over the issue (and what you might read on the Internet).

So, sure, she was off topic if we measure the topic to the letter of her title; but it was still perfectly within the spirit of the topic -- and as that's how we normally make these considerations, I see no reason why this situation should be treated differently.

It was clearly off topic and a cheap shot. Of course, a speaker can make that cheap shot fit in within the spirit of the topic.
 
What are you going on about? Nobody suggested her request be denied. If that's all you're worried about, you could have left 51 pages ago perfectly satisfied.

Linda

From reading blog is seems she agrees with Ms. Watson, with the exception of not boycotting Dawkins books.

It seems she wants men to hit on her, but only when she deems it appropriate.

Obviously men aren't allowed to put in requests for how they want women to behave toward them. That would be sexist.

It must be terrible to have lots of people find you attractive. I can't imagine how bad it must be to have to turn down all those dates and offers of sex.

To me it's the equivalent of a fat person complaining to a starving African about how terrible it is that so many food products are loaded with HFCS.

Perhaps the women complaining about being hit on when they don't want to be would like to switch positions with men who are constantly ignored and/or rejected and see which they find more unpleasant?

So there's that then.
 
So there's that then.

Which doesn't actually say that her request should be denied, but that the request indicates a 'have your cake and eat it too' type of hypocrisy and that the request is 'petty' compared to not being hit on at all.

Now I don't necessarily agree with that view. In fact I don't. There is every reason to want to be sexualized sometimes, by some people, but not at other times by other people. However, that view isn't the same as saying if someone specifically says not to hit on them in an elevator (or other enclosed space) we shouldn't comply.

If I've gotten what Ivor meant wrong, I apologize.
 
It was clearly off topic and a cheap shot. Of course, a speaker can make that cheap shot fit in within the spirit of the topic.

Oh, well I did disagree with you, but now that you've made such an insightful and airtight argument, I've been completely swayed. After all, it's not like she's ever discussed these topics before, so when she brought it up at CFI completely out of the blue that should have been a red flag. Thanks, O paragon of reason!

Seriously: this is why I didn't want to get dragged into this. No matter what you say, there's always someone who's willing to counter with "Nuh-uh, she's just a jerk!"

Well of course, you know best. My apologies for attempting to put a damper on the hype: I see now that Rebecca is a screaming harpy who feeds on the flesh of the innocent and that I was wrong to suggest that she might have had anything but pitch black motives. Mea frickin' culpa.
 
Seriously: this is why I didn't want to get dragged into this. No matter what you say, there's always someone who's willing to counter with "Nuh-uh, she's just a jerk!"

*sigh* So you didn't want to get into this, because someone might challenge your point of view? If you go back and read, there is some discussion about why the comments might have been off topic or not, and not just some people saying, 'yes it was/no it wasn't'.

For what it's worth, I don't think that the comments there were completely off topic, but the sure were both a cheap shot and insanely stupid. Putting rational disagreement over what constitutes objectification and sexualization from another feminist within the skeptical movement next to emailed rape threats from religious extremists in anything other than the context of 'this is the right way to have a discussion about feminist goals and this is the wrong way' is such a bludgeoning, manifest form of bullying guilt by association that it comes off as making Rebecca look foolish. It was truly shocking, and Rebecca had had my full support until I read what was said. That part is the part I object to most fully.

But I admit that I tend to have the 'white knight' knee jerk reaction that led me to support Rebecca in the first place.
 
....

But I admit that I tend to have the 'white knight' knee jerk reaction that led me to support Rebecca in the first place.
Oh my FSM, I can't resist. Please remember this is exaggerated for effect:

So if a damsel in distress asks for help with being made uncomfortable by elevator guy, your white knight reflex is triggered.

Would your white knight reflex be similarly triggered if that had been a small mild mannered guy intimidated by a body builder female on the same elevator at 4 am?

(Don't lie. :) )
 
*sigh* So you didn't want to get into this, because someone might challenge your point of view? If you go back and read, there is some discussion about why the comments might have been off topic or not, and not just some people saying, 'yes it was/no it wasn't'.

Not what I said: it's not that somebody might challenge my point, it that I was wary that someone would ignore what I said in favor of a knee-jerk "No you're wrong and I don't need to justify that argument or respond to what you wrote." -- which was indeed the first reply I got, hence the snippiness.

I actually appreciate your response, by the way. It's the first time I've seen someone actually attempt to lay out why they find Rebecca's behaviour unacceptable in this thread (I've been lurking since the start, but may have missed something earlier). That said...

For what it's worth, I don't think that the comments there were completely off topic, but the sure were both a cheap shot and insanely stupid. Putting rational disagreement over what constitutes objectification and sexualization from another feminist within the skeptical movement next to emailed rape threats from religious extremists in anything other than the context of 'this is the right way to have a discussion about feminist goals and this is the wrong way' is such a bludgeoning, manifest form of bullying guilt by association that it comes off as making Rebecca look foolish. It was truly shocking, and Rebecca had had my full support until I read what was said. That part is the part I object to most fully.

But I admit that I tend to have the 'white knight' knee jerk reaction that led me to support Rebecca in the first place.

...okay, I have two points here: one of disagreement, and one of clarification.


First: I disagree that putting Stef's words after rape threats from extremists is clear cut bullying behaviour. To be clear (from my understanding of what happened), Stef's words were not put alongside the threats, they followed them. The message was, again from accounts I've read, not "This person is as bad as people who threaten rape," but was instead, "Those are extreme examples, and those guys are bad; we are not that bad, but we still have some worrisome opinions in our community -- here's one and here's why it's worrisome to me."

To the best of my knowledge, Watson has never said anything about Stef McGraw to draw an equivalence between her and extremists. The way that criticism was presented seems textbook to me as well: present praise first (I.e. "we are not these guys") before the criticism ("but that doesn't mean we're flawless").

That brings me to my second point, the clarification: you say that Rebecca had your full support until you read what was said. What have you heard that she said? It could be that I'm missing some details here.
 
{snip} The worst revelation about "skeptical community" in this situation is that she can reveal herself to be like that and still have an audience.

:th:

This is all utterly fascinating. Truly. It just keeps going. I'm biting my tongue.

Do we have a champion female statement as of yet? Has it been decreed that it's up to each woman to choose her own comfort level and action level? Or must the schism between skeptic men and women grow deeper?

Hey Moe. Nice of you to stop by. :)
 
Do your arguments always have to take this mocking, belittling tone?

Not always, and if you think they always do, then I don't think that you've read all of them. I get mocking and belittling in discussions where the mocking and belittling knob has already been set to 11, and where I've tried calmer arguments and been mocked and belittled for them.

It's kind of like how everybody stands up at rock concerts. Once enough people are standing up, those sitting down are at a distinct advantage.
 
That brings me to my second point, the clarification: you say that Rebecca had your full support until you read what was said. What have you heard that she said? It could be that I'm missing some details here.

That she referred to McGraw as "parroting misogynist thought", and "ignorant of the fundamentals of feminism".
 
Oh, well I did disagree with you, but now that you've made such an insightful and airtight argument, I've been completely swayed. After all, it's not like she's ever discussed these topics before, so when she brought it up at CFI completely out of the blue that should have been a red flag. Thanks, O paragon of reason!

Seriously: this is why I didn't want to get dragged into this. No matter what you say, there's always someone who's willing to counter with "Nuh-uh, she's just a jerk!"

Well of course, you know best. My apologies for attempting to put a damper on the hype: I see now that Rebecca is a screaming harpy who feeds on the flesh of the innocent and that I was wrong to suggest that she might have had anything but pitch black motives. Mea frickin' culpa.

(Nota bene, @slingblade. Stuff like this.)
 
That she referred to McGraw as "parroting misogynist thought", and "ignorant of the fundamentals of feminism".

Right, and this seems consistent with Watson's other comments that anyone who criticizes what Watson says is a sexist or a misogynist, while she also denies that another woman (McGraw) can think for herself. This is pretty consistent with Watson's refurbished image as a nouveau feminist and which is against treating women with respect.
 
FWIW, I think this is the first issue I disagree with blauregen on but perhaps its because I'm not familiar with the organizations, arena and the people involved.

That's ok. RW and PZ Myers disagree with me in this regard too. :)

I don't agree that the social power difference was an issue, but I think it would have been more appropriate for Rebecca Watson to let Steph McGraw know that she was going to respond to her blog comment. However, if IIRC, I think RW said she was made aware of SM's blog very close to the speaking event. Still even a few minutes advance notice is better than none.

I saw a problem because RW was a celebrated guest lecturer in this case. Common courtesy puts every part of the host at a disadvantage there, if she doesn't want to grab the Q&A to contest a minor rebuttal. And unnecessary rudeness towards your host isn't professional behavior in my opinion.

But this is my opinion. RW apparently considers it a sign of respect to confront an opponent openly ( which she could have done in her capacity as a blogger later too ) and PZ Myers seems to see it as a skeptic's duty to be confrontational.
 
That she referred to McGraw as "parroting misogynist thought", and "ignorant of the fundamentals of feminism".

Right -- the first bit I knew, but not the second; I absolutely agree that the second bit was poorly considered and too much of a dig, though as McGraw had accused Rebecca of misunderstanding feminism I can see where it came from. That's not a decent excuse though, and I agree it shouldn't have been included. Too much of a condescending snipe.

As for the first bit: I'm confused as to what the furore is over. Some of the things in McGraw's post did parrot misogynistic thought -- that's not saying that McGraw is a misogynist, it's simply pointing out that some of the arguments that were picked up have been made by people with an agenda to push (e.g. promoting false balance by failing to recognize that there is still an unequal dynamic in many male/female interactions, a la "it wouldn't be wrong if a woman did it to a man, so it's not wrong if a man does it to a woman; charges of 'demonizing' men).

Perhaps she could have been gentler in her phrasing -- hindsight is 20-20 after all -- but it's hardly the fire and brimstone it's been made out to be.
 
Right, and this seems consistent with Watson's other comments that anyone who criticizes what Watson says is a sexist or a misogynist, while she also denies that another woman (McGraw) can think for herself. This is pretty consistent with Watson's refurbished image as a nouveau feminist and which is against treating women with respect.

Sorry, I must have missed where Watson said that. Linky?
 
Last edited:
There is two things being conflated here. One is Watson's rights as an individual. The other is what she says as a minor celebrity as a representative of the Skepchick community. This is not simply her speaking as an individual, but her speaking on behalf of an entire community, perhaps even an entire sex. Even at minimum, her website, which is still a greater thing than the reactions of a single individual.

No, I think this hypothesis isn't supported. Last I looked at skepchick.org, it was a blog, not a nation, army or company, and I can't remember RW making any broad statements starting with 'We at Skepchick.org ...' or 'I in my capacity as spokeswoman of ( whatever )...'. As far as I am concerned, she speaks for herself.

She has admittedly a reputation for occasionally interresting and thoughtful texts on topics that interest me, which is why I sometimes read it. Apparently I am not the only one.

When I turn to NPR on Friday, it's a reasonable expectation that I hear Ira Flatow talk about science, not to hear him talk about politics. It has nothing to do with denying him his right to free speech or dignity; it's that this is what he is supposed to be doing at this time. Watson's original comments were a minor derail, but it's the kind of thing that happens on panels, which are pretty informal and impromptu events, so I was willing to give her the benefit of the doubt. Calling out Stef McGraw in a more formal talk was more unprofessional.

I don't deny it. But it is hardly the first instance of unprofessional behavior I saw, and I am not unforgiving enough to discard someones thoughts, because they sometimes don't meet MY ideals of behavior. If I were I would have to start ignoring my own thoughts sometimes.

Watson seems to want to have it both ways, and she is being supported by many. She gets to wave her hands about how EG and rape are linked somehow, but then when she is criticized within that context, the context gets dramatically shifted it is all about her rights to dignity.

*Sigh*. The elevator incident, or more precisely the class of situations it represents, and the perceived threat of rape are linked somehow. RW though didn't equate them. On the contrary, she was quite clear that she doesn't consider chatting her up a rape attempt.

The hyperboles on this topic, look to me as if they are mainly from the detractor's side. Really, none of the feminists said 'All men who are interested in women are rapists'. And even the frequently attacked text about 'Schrödinger's Rapist' mainly points out that the rape statistics hint at rape being a very real possibility for women, that it is wiser for them to err on the side of caution when assessing male strangers, and that it would be nice if the guys could understand this.

I don't want to take position there on either side, because as far as I am concerned I never had any sexual contact I didn't at least implicitly agree to (Implicitly because of two instances were I either thought that being wined and dined establishes an obligation or where it was emotionally easier to sleep with the guy, than to become really rude in my decline. Juvenile foolishness in both cases and nothing that gave me any unsurmountable trouble). I could only relate to this second hand. But hey, I am a man, and for a few reasons we can discuss in another post, I think it is different for girls.

No, stop. I think it is different for many girls ( and possibly some dudes ). Skeptic Ginger for example apparently has no problems in this regard either, which is great. More power to her. I still don't think she represents a majority.

(Watson has confirmed that she wants this by saying that any criticism is sexism.) I find this more than a little disingenuous and certainly the polar opposite to what skepticism has to be about.

I must have missed this gem. Care to give me a source?

A couple of things.

First, while I think that Dawkins was crude and unprofessional in his reply, there is a point there. It's about privilege. I think it is valid to bring up, especially as Watson herself was talking about privilege and even named her blog entry about it. http://skepchick.org/2011/07/the-privilege-delusion/ This is the blog entry that made me think a lot less of Watson. The idea is that the difference in privilege between white men and white women who can afford to travel for a really big conference is so huge that this is what we should talk about most of the time. Dawkins' point, beneath the rude way he chose to express it, is that it just ain't so.

RW wasn't particularly serene in either her response to Stef nor to RD. She is obviously invested in the topic, and reacts emotional. But to paraphrase PZ Myers: Science isn't always calm and serene debate. They scream a lot there. I guess the same goes for discussion of social problems.

As for the privilege: Let me give you my reading: Her complaint towards Dawkins is:

Richard Dawkins believes I should be a good girl and just shut up about being sexually objectified because it doesn’t bother him. Thanks, wealthy old heterosexual white man!

The complaint is in my opinion not without merit and her calling him a 'wealthy old heterosexual white man' is flippant but not purely an insult. It serves, as I read it, to point out in what regards RD is privileged towards various other people.

Let me dissect it: 'White' is true for both, and in the context of RW's problem insignificant. It would be significant in the context of Dawkin's reply, because he referenced a practice mainly seen in third-world-countries as worse, and whether he wanted it or not, it was understood as belittling RW's complaint. As a first-worlder he would indeed be privileged compared to most muslim women.

'Wealthy' is insignificant to regarding RW's problem, because she is obviously well enough off, that lack of money doesn't play much into whatever discrimination she faces.

'Old' is moderately significant. His age signifies the circumstances of his upbringing which was largely before the main waves of feminism, which might make it difficult for him to understand the problem. On the other hand, RD may be occasionally a dick ( although a brilliant one ), but one can hardly accuse him of intellectual inflexibility or inability to learn.

'Heterosexual' is mainstream, and indeed it is an indicator that at least sexually RD likely had no pressing need to question societal norms regarding genderroles and similar topics.

'Man' constitutes a privilege in my eyes. We still live in a largely patriarchal society. Not as bad as last century around this time, but nevertheless true. And there are enough conservative (religious) groups who would love nothing more than turning the wheel back.

As a whole though the expression signifies RD's place on the social food chain ( very high ), and with his wealth, his membership in various ingroups and his fanbase, he commands respect in several ways. He is a prime example of an alpha male. I don't begrudge him. He certainly earned a lot of this place, and because he isn't in the habit of slaughtering youngs who might threaten his position, I see no harm in it.

BUT, the tribulations and problems of the alpha-male ( the animal that eats first and has to deal with the politics of his pack ) are a lot different than those of us sub-alpha males or of the females. And it seems reasonable to me, that he has problems to recognize the significance of problems those lower on the ladder face.

AND, he is a vastly more influential speaker than RW, and from this I can understand that his perceived casual dismissal hit her pretty hard. Richard Dawkins dismissing your problems as petty, is the social equivalent to the big mallet, and I am actually glad that the skeptics community is a disrespectful enough pack to call their alpha to task in such a case. The Privilege Delusion has a series of nice links in the first line, that are quite interesting, and they make a good case for RW having a point. As for 'talking about it 'most of the time': I didn't find anything demanding first priority for feminism in skeptical debate. I did find a lot demanding that it isn't ignored, which is a position I agree with.

Second, I'm not sure that any of this is really true. The skeptic group I go to more than any other, at Lake Hypatia, is run by two women and has more than 50% female attendees. It's warm and friendly and nice, and people bring their dogs and children and play in the lake, and I am certain that nothing like the Elevator Incident could happen there.

The elevator incident itself was actually a rather minor fluke, and in itself pretty harmless. I find it regrettable that it was blown that much out of proportion, but I can't honestly blame RW for it. I read it more as a illustration, not as the sole problem or even the core of the problem. Why people are so hellbent on making a drama out of it and contesting it, is beyond me. I could speculate that people perceive it as an attack on their extended home and fight it, because it is an easy target, when taken as the sole problem, instead of an illustration of a wider topic, but that's neither here nor there.

I am glad that you have such a nice group. :) I don't know whether it is representative either though.

Third, we are not being asked to get more women in, only women like Rebecca Watson. I'm pretty sure that Watson would be just as happy if Stef McGraw stayed the hell away. So, as the actors say, what is my motivation for wanting to see more women like Watson at the expense of women like Stef McGraw?

That's a bit much mindreading for my tastes. And I am not entirely sure that addressing feminist problems as RW sees them would drive women like Stef McGraw away. It could as well just add another perspective.
 
Last edited:
Just heard Rebecca ruin my favorite podcast. I expected some reason in response from Steve, Bob and Jay, but no joy
 
Well RW can't answer here but it was a serious comment. She said her concern was that the men's behavior was one of the reasons for low attendance by women at skeptic/atheist/freethinker events. How does the effect of the party differ if it too has the same effect?

And how can people say RW didn't speak for all women, after that comment ?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom