So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
This is all I need explaining.

Man annoys man = not sexism.
Woman annoys woman = not sexism.
Woman annoys man = not sexism.
Man annoys woman = sexism.

Why?

Linda
 
This is all I need explaining.

Man annoys man = not sexism.
Woman annoys woman = not sexism.
Woman annoys man = not sexism.
Man annoys woman = sexism.

Why?

Linda

Because all men want to do with women is **** them.

We're not multitaskers you see, so screwing and talking are mutually exclusive.
 
Except for a woman apparently being creeped out and feeling extremely uncomfortable in this case.
The fact that you use the term woman instead of person says something about your attitudes. As my video points out, none of this is an issue if we flip the genders of any one or two of the parties.

Just for the record, when I ask questions of a person, and they snip them an ignore them, that really creeps me out.

Oh yes, and there are at least two women on this board alone who wouldn't have been creeped out. Isn't this proof enough that those feminist complaints are without any rational base? :D
Is the fact that I''m creeped out about anonymous Internet posters snipping out questions and inventing straw men make it a masculinist complaint?

It was a simple exchange with no harm and no foul. If anyone is so fragile that they can't handle feeling uncomfortable for a few seconds, they should stay at home. If you're going to go public with cases of what at worst is poor manners, then pick a situation where there are no other plausible explanations of the event, especially when one of the more plausible ones is that the guy actually meant what he said. I can only imagine what her blog would have been like had he been a black man and sit, "Hit the floor."

You are demonstrating the worst and most insidious sexism there is. I prefer to treat RW as a capable person, not a flower that needs protecting.
 
This is all I need explaining.

Man annoys man = not sexism.
Woman annoys woman = not sexism.
Woman annoys man = not sexism.
Man annoys woman = sexism.

Why?

Linda

It is sexism because despite how far our culture has come in equality, there are those men who think women still need protecting and those women who think equality means not having to deal with unpleasant situations. It's mutually reinforcing and quite insidious.
 
This is all I need explaining.

Man annoys man = not sexism.
Woman annoys woman = not sexism.
Woman annoys man = not sexism.
Man annoys woman = sexism.

Why?

Linda

Man dismisses man's stated preference in favor of his own, without considering other man's feelings - rudeness with possibility of objectification depending on context.

Woman dismisses woman's stated preference in favor of her own without considering other woman's feelings - rudeness with possibility of objectification depending on context.

Woman dismisses man's stated preference in favor of her own without considering man's feelings - rudeness with possibility of objectification and/or sexism depending on context.

Man dismisses woman's stated preference in favor of her own without considering woman's feelings - rudeness with possibility of objectification and/or sexism depending on context.

Context, can't judge a scene without it! Pick some up today!*


*Side effects may include empathy, thinking in grays, seeing the whole picture, and in some rare cases, nausea and vomiting. Void where peremptory.
 
It is sexism because despite how far our culture has come in equality, there are those men who think women still need protecting and those women who think equality means not having to deal with unpleasant situations. It's mutually reinforcing and quite insidious.

Exactly.
 
Except for a woman apparently being creeped out and feeling extremely uncomfortable in this case. But hey, since when are people's feelings important, when we ask how we can interest them in participating in the skeptics community, or when a roll in the hay is at stake? :D

Ummmmm . . . that gets a fail. RW already belongs to the community and wasn't in the process of being recruited.

Besides, "creeped out/extemely uncomfortable" =/= discrimination as the definition of sexism requires.

Oh yes, and there are at least two women on this board alone who wouldn't have been creeped out. Isn't this proof enough that those feminist complaints are without any rational base? :D

If a white man asks a black woman to have sex with him while they are in an elevator, is it racism?

The issue is that what has commonly been called "sexism" isn't. In the case under discussion, not only was there no sexism involved but the incident is being used to make a public statement about a group based on that mistaken claim.
 
And how can people say RW didn't speak for all women, after that comment ?
You lost me. I was pointing to the hypocrisy of RW's concern about sexism at skeptic/atheist/freethinking events while being part of that very sexism a year earlier. Noblecaboose was of the opinion the bordello themed party at TAM 8 sent the wrong message to some women skeptics and might affect their willingness to attend the skeptic event.

I said no more about speaking for all women. And this particular criticism of RW isn't about speaking for all women.

Perhaps you would elaborate?
 
If the supposed ineptitude were the result of a simple unwillingness to consider the woman's feelings, and it would be symptomatic for how RW perceives the treatment of women among skeptics, it would be a completely appropriate example. As I understood it, she gave it as an example of behavior that creeps her out, and could detract women from participating in the skeptics movement.

I thought we agreed on that. The supposed unwillingness to consider her feelings did stop after RW said "no, thanks". There were no further comments. There is no evidence that the episode was caused by a disdain towards the feelings of women in general. That takes a huge leap of faith, but I guess you already acknowledge that since you begin your post with "if".

The problem is that you don't illustrate a point with a questionable example. A questionable example only illustrates that your point questionable.
 
This is all I need explaining.

Man annoys man = not sexism.
Woman annoys woman = not sexism.
Woman annoys man = not sexism.
Man annoys woman = sexism.

Why?

Linda

Hard to answer in this form, because as it is stated these are just four cases of various annoyances.

But woman or man discriminates against man based on his sex, consciously or unconsciously, or woman or man discriminates against woman based on her sex again consciously or unconsciously, that would be sexism.

The point in the elevator incident, as I understood it, is that RW feels that it illustrates one occasion were she and (in similar cases) other women are not respected as persons by male members of the skeptic community because they are women.

The peculiarities of this disrespect can vary. It could be as assumed in the elevator incident, that her stated intent to go sleeping, and her need for safety are inconsiderately ignored by someone who proposes to her in the way described, which is creepy to her, and to various commenters on her blog.

It could express itself like in the context-matters list, where Jen McCreight among other things is annoyed when she is complimented for her looks after a presentation, instead of for her lecture. ( I really can understand this. )

Or it could present itself more as a systemic occurence like PZ Myers describes it in his blog-entry about a panel at an American Atheists meeting in Huntsville, Alabama.

Annoyance is, I think, in all cases I dug out a result, not a cause of the problem, a symptom, not the illness, if it is one.
 
Last edited:
Man dismisses man's stated preference in favor of his own, without considering other man's feelings - rudeness with possibility of objectification depending on context.

Woman dismisses woman's stated preference in favor of her own without considering other woman's feelings - rudeness with possibility of objectification depending on context.

Woman dismisses man's stated preference in favor of her own without considering man's feelings - rudeness with possibility of objectification and/or sexism depending on context.

Man dismisses woman's stated preference in favor of her own without considering woman's feelings - rudeness with possibility of objectification and/or sexism depending on context.

Context, can't judge a scene without it! Pick some up today!*


*Side effects may include empathy, thinking in grays, seeing the whole picture, and in some rare cases, nausea and vomiting. Void where peremptory.

Wow, I've been objectified and objectified/sexualized many times. Guys/girls/whatever: don't do it. I don't like being objectified and objectified/sexualized.
 
The fact that you use the term woman instead of person says something about your attitudes. As my video points out, none of this is an issue if we flip the genders of any one or two of the parties.

It happened to be a woman in this particular case.

Just for the record, when I ask questions of a person, and they snip them an ignore them, that really creeps me out.

Duly noted and tacitly approved.

Is the fact that I''m creeped out about anonymous Internet posters snipping out questions and inventing straw men make it a masculinist complaint?

No, I don't do this based on your sex. I simply don't take you serious, because your argumentation seems far fetched to me. I am simply rude in this case.

I prefer to treat RW as a capable person, not a flower that needs protecting.

That's nice to hear. :)
 
...
It was how RW interpreted it. Usually the content of a message is regarded as what was understood, which isn't necessarily the same as what was intended....
You appear to be doing what Checkmite has been doing, viewing the first video in isolation to the rest of the initial part of this debate. The thing that initiated this debate included the initial video, the response by McGraf and and Stclairose in the blogosphere and RW's further discussion of the elevator incident in the Student Conference.

Were it simply RW's video and the couple blogosphere replies who disagreed with her take on the incident, it would have in all likelihood faded away at that point.

It was RW, who upon hearing this different opinion to hers, went on to make the whole thing about feminism, objectifying women, sexualizing women, and being common enough among our community to be affecting the attendance of women at formal events.
 
I missed a lot of this discussion, so if I'm only reiterating something said several times in the last 50 pages, feel free to correct me.

I feel ambivalent towards this entire issue. On one hand, I don't think anyone should be offended by someone pointing out what they personally find disturbing and asking people not to do it. If people feel uncomfortable in situations that can be easily avoided with the cooperation of others, I see no reason for others not to cooperate, and I see no reason for others not to appreciate advice on how they can cooperate. No one should want a situation like that in the elevator to arise, and it takes little effort to avoid it now. Saying Watson should not have complained seems entirely counterproductive to me.

On the other hand, I still think there should be a discussion about how widespread and/or reasonable the beliefs and opinions leading to someone feeling seriously uncomfortable in this situation are. I don't think they are very reasonable. I just wish that discussion could be held with the premise that reasonable or not, there is no excuse for making people uncomfortable if you can easily avoid it.

Man dismisses man's stated preference in favor of his own, without considering other man's feelings - rudeness with possibility of objectification depending on context.

Woman dismisses woman's stated preference in favor of her own without considering other woman's feelings - rudeness with possibility of objectification depending on context.

Woman dismisses man's stated preference in favor of her own without considering man's feelings - rudeness with possibility of objectification and/or sexism depending on context.

Man dismisses woman's stated preference in favor of her own without considering woman's feelings - rudeness with possibility of objectification and/or sexism depending on context.

Context, can't judge a scene without it! Pick some up today!*


*Side effects may include empathy, thinking in grays, seeing the whole picture, and in some rare cases, nausea and vomiting. Void where peremptory.
Does providing an alternative to a stated preference constitute dismissing it outright?
 
You lost me. I was pointing to the hypocrisy of RW's concern about sexism at skeptic/atheist/freethinking events while being part of that very sexism a year earlier. Noblecaboose was of the opinion the bordello themed party at TAM 8 sent the wrong message to some women skeptics and might affect their willingness to attend the skeptic event.

I said no more about speaking for all women. And this particular criticism of RW isn't about speaking for all women.

I know you're like a kid with a new toy at Christmas with the bordello thread, but perhaps you could spare a moment from your gleeful victory dance to explain where the hypocrisy lies? It seems to me so far that your entire argument is:

1. Rebecca Watson has complained of sexism.
2. But one woman once accused Watson of sexism herself.
3. Therefore, Watson is a hypocrite.

By that logic, as long as I can find one person in this thread (or anyone else) who has accused you of sexism, you will never be able to complain of sexism again lest you be branded a hypocrite.
 
And choosing the elevator-approach over the bar-approach, is therefore at least very inconsiderate.

Only if you assume that this will make women uncomfortable, which is certainly true for RW, but in general ?

And saying it's inconsiderate is inconsiderate to EG's own feelings. There.
 
Except for a woman apparently being creeped out and feeling extremely uncomfortable in this case. But hey, since when are people's feelings important

And again with the emotional nonsense.

Feelings are only important once you have an idea that they're there. For example, if I don't know how a woman feels about me giving her a rose as a token of my love, how can I guess that she actually sees roses as declarations of war ?
 
You lost me. I was pointing to the hypocrisy of RW's concern about sexism at skeptic/atheist/freethinking events while being part of that very sexism a year earlier. Noblecaboose was of the opinion the bordello themed party at TAM 8 sent the wrong message to some women skeptics and might affect their willingness to attend the skeptic event.

I said no more about speaking for all women. And this particular criticism of RW isn't about speaking for all women.

Which is odd, because I didn't say "you", but "people". I would've thought it was clear I wasn't talking about you specifically.

Some people said "she isn't speaking for all women". The bit you mentioned (low attendance because of 'this kind of situation') certainly does speak for a lot of women.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom