So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
More wow, just wow. Sorry, yes I am rubbing it in, it is clearly very relevant.
It's been a long time coming. I've been giving Skepchick the benefit of the doubt for a long time.
This is the first time I feel they've crossed a line.
They do not seem to care about raising the profile of women in skepticism if they are willing to reduce them to sex objects in the name of "fun."
The fact that they are alienating people by making their party one big in-joke is further evidence that they have lost the plot.

And anyone who calls me a prude can refer to my picture on the back of the 2009 Skepchick calendar.

I think you've [Scrut] missed the point. Each group is made of people who are familiar enough with one another by association that they get in-jokes and feel comfortable with how to interpret each other's ironies. If your aim is to invite others into your group, they won't be 'in' on your subtle nuances of jokes and euphemisms. Hence slutting it up while representing a group who supposedly value the idea that women shouldn't feel objectified can't rely on the traditional, in-group, ironic sub-clause of 'it's all just a bit of fun - get over it'.

Athon
 
Last edited:
Point taken. Although I still disagree with the notion a few other posters seem to imply that being sex-positive and using "sexualization" as a marketing technique somehow removes your right to criticize it, if it happens to you in an inappropriate context. To cite the american convention on human rights ( for you predominantly US-people ) "Everyone has the right to have his honor respected and his dignity recognized.", which - at least to me - means too, that trying to disregard your complaints on the aforementioned ground wouldn't be okay.

There is two things being conflated here. One is Watson's rights as an individual. The other is what she says as a minor celebrity as a representative of the Skepchick community. This is not simply her speaking as an individual, but her speaking on behalf of an entire community, perhaps even an entire sex. Even at minimum, her website, which is still a greater thing than the reactions of a single individual.

When I turn to NPR on Friday, it's a reasonable expectation that I hear Ira Flatow talk about science, not to hear him talk about politics. It has nothing to do with denying him his right to free speech or dignity; it's that this is what he is supposed to be doing at this time. Watson's original comments were a minor derail, but it's the kind of thing that happens on panels, which are pretty informal and impromptu events, so I was willing to give her the benefit of the doubt. Calling out Stef McGraw in a more formal talk was more unprofessional.

The question has arisen about whether she should be treated as a professional. Well, this is what she seems to be demanding. I do not think it unreasonable to expect people who want to be treated as professionals to behave like professionals, at least in professional settings and with respect to sequelae from what happens there.

Watson seems to want to have it both ways, and she is being supported by many. She gets to wave her hands about how EG and rape are linked somehow, but then when she is criticized within that context, the context gets dramatically shifted it is all about her rights to dignity. (Watson has confirmed that she wants this by saying that any criticism is sexism.) I find this more than a little disingenuous and certainly the polar opposite to what skepticism has to be about.

The comments on RW's blog seem to indicate that it is a factor. I am not sure how decisive it is, or whether it is more prevalent among skeptics than in general male dominated groups. I would add though that if we reject the argument that her complaints can be safely ignored because there are bigger fish to fry, like the position of muslim women, we should also reject the notion that the problem is not relevant for the skeptics community, if it turns out to be only as bad as in general patriarchal society.

A couple of things.

First, while I think that Dawkins was crude and unprofessional in his reply, there is a point there. It's about privilege. I think it is valid to bring up, especially as Watson herself was talking about privilege and even named her blog entry about it. http://skepchick.org/2011/07/the-privilege-delusion/ This is the blog entry that made me think a lot less of Watson. The idea is that the difference in privilege between white men and white women who can afford to travel for a really big conference is so huge that this is what we should talk about most of the time. Dawkins' point, beneath the rude way he chose to express it, is that it just ain't so.

Second, I'm not sure that any of this is really true. The skeptic group I go to more than any other, at Lake Hypatia, is run by two women and has more than 50% female attendees. It's warm and friendly and nice, and people bring their dogs and children and play in the lake, and I am certain that nothing like the Elevator Incident could happen there.

Third, we are not being asked to get more women in, only women like Rebecca Watson. I'm pretty sure that Watson would be just as happy if Stef McGraw stayed the hell away. So, as the actors say, what is my motivation for wanting to see more women like Watson at the expense of women like Stef McGraw?
 
Another worthwhile comment:
How can one support women who encourage men to engage in the objectification of women as sex objects on the one hand, yet complain about a group of women throwing a party which presents women as sex objects on the other?

Either you think it's okay for women to be thought of as sex objects or you don't. You can't have it both ways, no matter how liberal or trendy you consider yourself.

My opinion is that as a sexual species all of us treat other people as sex objects, but many of us also look for and value additional characteristics in people as well.
 
As was said before, how was EG supposed to know if he was making a pass at someone like RW or someone like me?

That seems clear. He was supposed to think he was making a pass at someone like you, so that when he did it, he could be turned into an image of sexism and misogyny.

As I think I've said before, it's a bait-and-switch. It doesn't work on men in their 40s and later, but it works great on men in her appropriate age cohort. It's an extended version of a game that Eric Berne called "RAPO." Poor weenies. Well, when they figure it out, they'll be having babies with much younger women, and women in their age cohort will object to that, too.
 
Ottle explains the theme of the Bordello party:
Hi all!

I am super crazy busy at work and in general but here's my two cents. I am a Skepchick but am not speaking for everyone because, honestly, I have no idea what their opinions are on this; we haven't talked about it.

When we booked the house in Vegas, the first thing we thought was wow, that's a weird looking house that looks like an old West bordello. And there the theme was born. I swear no more thought was put into it. (I suspect most of us had the same impression of the word bordello as TragicMonkey)

I'm sorry if we offended people or if people thing it's not appropriate or that we've crossed some line. The thing about crossing lines is that everyone has a place where that line is and it's different for each person.

We work really hard to build a happy, friendly, fun community on Skepchick that agrees and disagrees in all sorts of ways. We're usually civil and polite although that sometimes gets away from us but we do try to keep the discussions in line.

I would never dream to say that I speak for skepticism, for women in skepticism or for any other large group (brown-haired girls, UNITE!). I speak for me and I am part of a group of women who talk about skepticism and often discuss women's issues in a skeptical light. I'm proud of that.

The point of the party is to get together with our friends, readers and other TAM-goers who want to hang out with us and to get to know each other in person. It's a very rare opportunity that we have so many of us in one place and we want to take advantage of it.

Noblecaboose's OP said we were
hosting a party where all women in attendance are essentially reduced to sex objects, prostitutes, no less.

I have no intention of reducing myself or anyone else to anything. If that's what you take away from the theme of the party, I think it's a bit of a stretch but that's fine. If it had been purely a Wild West party, would that mean that I assumed everyone was reckless and cowboy-like? If it had been a space themed party, would it mean that we reduced all the attendees to alien creatures?

I think you'll find that we try to treat everyone with respect and have a little fun in the process. You don't have to dress up, you don't have to even really like us and you certainly don't have to attend. But you *are* welcome to attend and we hope you'll have fun.

Also, I worry that the folks who say that we're giving TAM a bad name are putting a whole lot on our shoulders. Let's be honest. Drunken and bawdy nights would happen at TAM regardless of whether we threw a party or not. TAM is TAM, for better or worse. The JREF have done a great job of bringing in a broad spectrum of people of all different ages into the group and that makes for a slightly wilder convention 'off-hours'.

In fact, our party is probably more 'tame' because we ask you to clean up after yourself and not drink and drive :) Also, we encourage geekiness. I expect lots of Firefly costumes, please! :)

Ok, I've gone on way too long. It's been said already but if you want to chat about this, that's fine. If you think there is something we can do to change it, feel free to post on the party page at Skepchick. We don't bite, I promise. Unless you're Scrut. That guy can eff off :)

kisses,
Maria

So it's time to comment here. I think NobleCaboose had a reasonable point that this party theme could matter to potential new TAM attendees. OTOH, being comfortable with the theme also indicates one is past seeing women negatively for being sexual beings. Women shouldn't avoid having such a party because of what people, including other women, will think ... except, when there is another reason, like encouraging more women to participate in TAM. Then such a theme might be inappropriate.

I do think the real issues of real prostitutes should not be trivialized by women who are not dealing with tragic reality at the moment, if ever, but that's a separate issue.

Bottom line is, why was it of so little concern to RW at the time, that this party theme might keep women from attending TAM? Noblecaboose certainly seemed to think it would drive women away from this skeptic event. Note, this was only last year, not something from the distant past.
 
"Women" in general, probably not.

Me, yes. I've been assaulted. I once sent a man to jail for sexual assault. He accosted me while I was in my car, in a shopping mall parking lot.

I was also, as I've said several times in other threads here, serially sexually molested from the ages of 6 to 14, by several adult men over that time period.

I have reasons to be much more cautious than one might think "normal."
Scared and timid? Sometimes, yes. Not always. But definitely sometimes.

Then I understand why you might have that outlook. It's just not one I've really encountered.

My quandary is that I don't know if I should adjust the way I treat or approach women I don't know on the off-chance that their experience has been as unpleasant as yours.

I am honestly struggling with the answer. If I don't I risk inadvertently intimidating someone or making them nervous or uncomfortable, if I do I feel like a patronising arse. Actually, the latter option feels more like discrimination in that it actually makes me a little uncomfortable.

Not all women have these reasons. But then, these reasons don't come up all that often in casual conversation, so how would you know?

I might not know of specific experiences (although I honestly think I would in most, if not all of the cases, of course I can't be sure), but I was discussing the attitude I observe in them. I don't think my lack knowledge of their history makes my assessment of their attitude invalid.


Because you gave it as a reason in response to 3point14's question. In the interests of full disclosure (since he previously stated that his experience with women was that they were more like what I described for myself) it wouldn't be fair to leave him with the impression that I hadn't had the experience of sexual molestation.

Linda

I thank you for your support. I shall wear it always. :)
 
Still reading through the bordello party thread. I couldn't pass this comment up:
.....
It's quite interesting to me, to be honest. And I think it says a lot about how women are percieved even in our modern times. :) So many assumptions and so much baggage still ensconced in the bits between our legs and how we manage them...
 
Is that a genuine question or a rhetorical one?
Well RW can't answer here but it was a serious comment. She said her concern was that the men's behavior was one of the reasons for low attendance by women at skeptic/atheist/freethinker events. How does the effect of the party differ if it too has the same effect?
 
Then I understand why you might have that outlook. It's just not one I've really encountered.

I was not only sexually assaulted but sexually battered. So I guess I win now! Everybody has to listen to me!

No, of course, that would be stupid. It wouldn't just be stupid for me; it would be stupid for everybody.
 
Well RW can't answer here but it was a serious comment. She said her concern was that the men's behavior was one of the reasons for low attendance by women at skeptic/atheist/freethinker events. How does the effect of the party differ if it too has the same effect?

Well the possible options are:

1. She genuinely thinks that the vast majority of women share her feelings that things like the party are fine, while men's behaviour isn't.

2. She doesn't really care about getting more women to the events but rather more women like her to the events, and she can then rightly use the argument from 1.

or

3. It's not about whether women want to attend these events or not but about claiming power and control over other people's behaviour.

Without knowing her its hard to tell what the proportion of these 3 in the mix are. However, in my limited brushes with radical feminism I'd say 3 has been known to play a significant role
 
RW was to be talking about something about religion, I honestly don't remember what, but instead started her talk with a derail about Stef not getting it. At this point should Stef respect the hosts and the audience who came to her about something else, or should she drag the derail into the Q&A? I think she acted more professionally by not feeding the troll, but others disagree.

The point is that RW was there to talk about something but had to drag her internet drama into the forum. That is unprofessional. It is rude to the audience and the hosts.



No, if the topic of the talk was sexism in the skeptic movement I think her comments would have been very on-point and Stef would have been expected to deal with them in the Q&A. But that wasn't why she was there.

Think about being the host for an event like this. Say you land James Randi to speak at your local event about his latest antics in busting psuedo-science and there is an audience just brimming with excitement. Now, Mr. Randi comes to the stage and starts a slide show about how wonderful it is to be out of the closet after so many years despite the naysayers. For the first 15 minutes he just goes on bashing people who have attacked him for being gay and even those who are just not supportive. He even singles out one of the attendees for an internet post that questioned whether his coming out was good for the movement, comparing that person to a Nazi.

So, maybe Randi is right, but would that be professional? No. Would you be happy as a host? No. Would you be happy as an audience member? I wouldn't.

The thing is, Randi wouldn't do that because he is a professional who has built up a professional reputation. Rebecca hasn't. And this won't help.



You're welcome.

Her talk was about the Religious Right's war on women.

She started the talk with some of the 'fan mail' she has received from religious men in the past wishing her ill (rape/murder/hellfire/etc).

She then compared this with similar mail she has received from within the skeptical community; and then finally raised the issue that even at CFI there were people who had opinions that trouble her and why they were troubling. She named Stef McGraw and used an excerpt from Stef's blog post. Total time spent on Stef would have been maybe two minutes by all accounts.

So...not exactly off topic, and not exactly a fifteen minute rant.
 
So...not exactly off topic, and not exactly a fifteen minute rant.

Off-topic for two reasons.

1) Stef is hardly a member of the religious right.

2) Disagreeing with something that Watson said is hardly part of a war on women.
 
Well RW can't answer here but it was a serious comment. She said her concern was that the men's behavior was one of the reasons for low attendance by women at skeptic/atheist/freethinker events. How does the effect of the party differ if it too has the same effect?

Warning: Opinion ahead!

It seems to me that what we're seeing is actually a change in outlook over the past year -- Rebecca has said as much about the change herself, not as much about any specific timeline. She has been quite forward with the fact that her opinions now are quite different from when she started, and that she's said things in the past that she no longer agrees with or even regrets.

To the best of my knowledge she hasn't made any comment on last year's party since this brouhaha erupted; and now is probably not the best time to ask. However, given that there's no Skepchick party this year (at least that is my understanding) and her comments on how she's changed, it may be that she no longer sees the bordello party in the same light.

Again, this is speculation; I put it out there only because I think (a) it's reasonable speculation given the facts at hand and (b) it's not an option I've seen get a lot of play amongst the cries of 'hypocrisy' or 'gratuitous attention seeking behaviour'.
 
I was not only sexually assaulted but sexually battered. So I guess I win now! Everybody has to listen to me!

No, of course, that would be stupid. It wouldn't just be stupid for me; it would be stupid for everybody.

Do your arguments always have to take this mocking, belittling tone?
 
Off-topic for two reasons.

1) Stef is hardly a member of the religious right.

2) Disagreeing with something that Watson said is hardly part of a war on women.

Oy, I really don't want to get dragged into all this, so I'll try and keep this brief: Sure, if you want to have an extremely narrow interpretation of what a speaker is allowed to talk about, then yes, Rebecca bringing up anything other that the "Religious Right's war on women" is off-topic. By that metric, nearly every speaker ever has gone off topic.

However, we normally don't hold that against them -- not unless they stray massively far from what they've said they'll talk about (a la the fictional account of James Randi and the Nazi Homophobes). In this case, there's a clear and direct message that Rebecca was communicating: Yes, the religious right are bad; but before we get into that, let's also be aware that we still have work to do in our own community -- yes, even this one here. And rather than being passive aggressive about it, she cited an example and why she felt that was an example; she didn't call Stef evil, or a gender traitor, or a misogynist (even by the accounts of people who were there), despite the blowup that occurred over the issue (and what you might read on the Internet).

So, sure, she was off topic if we measure the topic to the letter of her title; but it was still perfectly within the spirit of the topic -- and as that's how we normally make these considerations, I see no reason why this situation should be treated differently.
 
Last edited:
A few more worthwhile points from the bordello thread:

... Bordello was the compromise. IT's rather no matter what chosen someone would be offended. ...

... Tolerance is a two way street. Let's show the skeptics know that better than most religious groups.
feminism has many schools of thought. Don't act like the diversity doesn't exist just so you can challenge NC's cred....

If it really was so appropriate I don't know why more men aren't volunteering to be sex objects for the ladies/gay dudes abound at TAM.
 
Warning: Opinion ahead!

It seems to me that what we're seeing is actually a change in outlook over the past year -- Rebecca has said as much about the change herself, not as much about any specific timeline. She has been quite forward with the fact that her opinions now are quite different from when she started, and that she's said things in the past that she no longer agrees with or even regrets.

To the best of my knowledge she hasn't made any comment on last year's party since this brouhaha erupted; and now is probably not the best time to ask. However, given that there's no Skepchick party this year (at least that is my understanding) and her comments on how she's changed, it may be that she no longer sees the bordello party in the same light.

Again, this is speculation; I put it out there only because I think (a) it's reasonable speculation given the facts at hand and (b) it's not an option I've seen get a lot of play amongst the cries of 'hypocrisy' or 'gratuitous attention seeking behaviour'.
It's worth adding to Fraggle's hypothesis list of 1-3 possibilities above.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom