So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
So saying, "don't do that," is whining and bitching and not dealing with it?

Not at all. A person is free to reject any proposition they wish. The issue to which I was referring is her apparent dissatisfaction with her public image and the effects of such.
 
Last edited:
....
The comments on RW's blog seem to indicate that it is a factor. I am not sure how decisive it is, or whether it is more prevalent among skeptics than in general male dominated groups. I would add though that if we reject the argument that her complaints can be safely ignored because there are bigger fish to fry, like the position of muslim women, we should also reject the notion that the problem is not relevant for the skeptics community, if it turns out to be only as bad as in general patriarchal society.
This is not what RD said. He clarified that wasn't what he said. It is a straw man.
 
Apparently RW needed 100% certainty to be sure he was a threat/hitting on her, in order to be justified in being uncomfortable.

Well no. Her feelings are her feelings and very few people are questioning her right to a biological reaction to a situation. The question seems to be more whether she should have made an issue of her discomfort and her expectation that other people should behave in a way that doesn't trigger this biological reaction in her regardless of whether her reaction is. Then there is the whole idea of people who don't behave in the way she wants being sexist, mysogynist, etc.

To be honest i think both sides of this discussion tend to be talking past each other as we are arguing about different things and different perceptions of situations.

In fact, it is perfectly appropriate for men to "put in requests" as you say for how they want women to REFRAIN from hitting on them in certain situations in certain ways. Just as I've said about the men learning, women might learn from such expression as well.

I don't see where you perceive a double standard here.

Why does 'refraining from hitting on me' get some special status here as a perfectly appropriate request? How do we determine what requests to modify behaviour are OK and what aren't? If a male conference speaker had asked skeptic females not to wear low cut clothing to the conference because he finds it makes him uncomfortable would we be defending his right to make requests on how others behave?

I disagree. An individual has no business speaking for an entire group without the group's prior authorization. RW telling "men" what is acceptable behaviour on behalf of women who have not given her the authority is rather presumptuous of her.

And because one man was ignorant of, or just ignored, her demands doesn't make him sexist. RW is not the decider on what is, or is not, sexist behaviour and there is nothing in the incident that demonstrates sexist behaviour.

Me thinks RW has a pet project that requires her to create strawmen she can then publicly rant about. Reading her bio on Skeptchick is evidence of that.

I would agree with pretty much all of that.

( Since this was dredged up from some 400 posts ago, it also prompts me to comment .. )


If women are really concerned about being followed ( Was she followed ? ) into an elevator by someone they don't know, they should consider taking the stairs or finding an escort ..

Of course in an ideal world women shouldn't have to consider such things but we don't live in an ideal world. If the idea of being approached in an elevator at 4am really is uncomfortable for her then she should maybe have taken some steps to avoid it. Especially if she was so conscious of being alone, foreign, at 4am, suffering rape threats etc.

Of course, if something had happened, there would have been no excuse for it. But nothing did.

If it had happened to you, how you react would be based on things individual to you.

It doesn't matter to this incident if you wouldn't react the same way.
Your estimation of your reaction has nothing to do with RW's reaction.

You are two different women. That you would react in a certain way to it doesn't invalidate her reaction.

I can't even tell you exactly how I would react to it, until it happens to me in exactly the same way it happened to her, and the chances of that are nil.

I can tell you that in general, and given only what I've read about it, when I project myself into that scenario, I think I'd be worried more than irritated. Because in my personal experience, when a man is alone with me in a private setting, away from all other people, and we've just left a public setting, and he says something contrived to get me alone ("come back to my room" for any reason), I'm going to feel he wants intimacy.

Rape? No, I didn't say rape. But we just left an open pub that serves coffee. Now he's asking me to go to his private room, where there's a door that locks, and where there's no one else around, so I'm going to assume he wants more than just to talk to me over a cup of coffee that we could have gotten in the open, public pub we both just left!

I'm going to feel that way because of my personal history.
My history isn't yours, and can't inform your choices or feelings.

That you can't understand my feeling that way about it doesn't make either of us wrong about it. It makes us individuals.

Individuals will react to circumstances in different ways. I think the question is to what extent we can expect others to know how we will react and change their behaviour to avoid making us uncomfortable.

Even with good intentions I could probably make you uncomfortable. Had I been at the event and RW had said 'I'm going to bed now' I might have offered to escort her back to her room as it was 4am and she was alone and she had been being threatened, etc. Now she could take that as a genuine offer and be relieved to have the escort or she could feel uncomfortable that some creepy perv wants to take her back to her room.

The aftermath of the incident is interesting to me though. Surely in a situation like that as soon as it diffuses you would think 'well, nothing came of that. Relax and get some sleep' I think it takes a special kind of personality to react with 'OMG! What a sexist pig! How dare he sexualise me! I'm going to make a video about this and tell the world not to do that!' Maybe I'm misreading it though or maybe I'm just unusual.



Watson (original video): EG made me uncomfortable because this, this, & this. Please don't do that.
Reply:
Some people: yeah, I'm sick of creepy stuff like that, too
Other people: Hell no! Hittin' on chicks in semi-professional settings is A-ok.

Watson: That A-ok (and other repeated versions of it) is making some women uncomfortable at freethought events.
Some people: yes, it is. here is my example.
Other people: Why are you making one event all about sexism within skepticism? We have every right to proposition people anywhere we like!

(internet explosion!)

It's the attitude that is making this an issue. Saying that it's specifically EG is misleading.

Seems like people's interpretation of the incident is based on what interpretation and bias they are bringing to the table.

Could just as easily interpret it as:

Watson: Why can't people just act the way I want them to act all the time? Why should I have to deal with people who don't do what I want?

Some people: Yeah. People should act like I want them to all the time.

Some other people: No. We'll act how we like just like you do.

Some weird people: YOU'RE ALL RAPISTS!!!!1111

Some weird other people: I LIEK SEXXIE WIMMENS!!!1


So saying, "don't do that," is whining and bitching and not dealing with it?

Well....yeah. For certain values of 'that'.

I guess this is why it's difficult, or at least part of why it's difficult, to pin this all down.


I can understand a young woman who's involved with a group of "intelligentsia" wanting to put out the message that, "Yeah, we're intelligent, and kind of geeky, and kind of scientific in our thinking. But that doesn't mean we're sexually neutral. Geeky girls like sex too, you know."

And then on the other hand wanting to put out the message that, "Yeah, we're sexual beings, but we don't like being treated as that and only that: as airheads with more between our legs than between our ears. Don't do that, either."

It really is a balancing act, and one isn't always going to come out exactly even and equal on it, no matter what the circumstances. But I think it often comes down to that one point: "We've got brains, and we've got boobs. Try to respect us regarding both."

Well it certainly is difficult but you cannot control and dictate how other people regard you regardless of gender. It would be great if we could all segment our lives and only be treated how we want when we want but it doesn't work that way.

The tricky thing for me is that in some cases women are playing on their difference to get attention and a platform, use their platform to tell us how unique their view is as women and how different they are from men and then complain when the result is that they aren't treated the same as 'one of the boys'

Part of me wonders whether if RW was a man she'd even have been on the speakers list for the event. She certainly wouldn't have been speaking about sexism and a women's view of the skeptic community.
 
You are close. According to RW ( here ) the topic was 'the Religious Right’s War on Women'.

Definitely related to religion, although not as unrelated to feminism as one would assume from your phrasing.

Thanks. Should have looked that up.

But still, Stef is part of the Religious Right's War on Women? No. Stef was a skeptic who disagreed with RW on a topic that is so ambiguous that we have a 50 plus page thread with posters disagreeing. She didn't say 2 + 2 = 5 or 0.9999. . . < 1. She simply disagreed with RW's take on an ambiguous situation.

Bringing your online drama into a talk like that is unprofessional.
 
Could just as easily interpret it as:

Watson: Why can't people just act the way I want them to act all the time? Why should I have to deal with people who don't do what I want?

Some people: Yeah. People should act like I want them to all the time.

Some other people: No. We'll act how we like just like you do.

Some weird people: YOU'RE ALL RAPISTS!!!!1111

Some weird other peopleDr. Keith: I LIEK SEXXIE WIMMENS!!!1

FTFY.

Proper attribution is important.
 
...
I can understand a young woman who's involved with a group of "intelligentsia" wanting to put out the message that, "Yeah, we're intelligent, and kind of geeky, and kind of scientific in our thinking. But that doesn't mean we're sexually neutral. Geeky girls like sex too, you know."

And then on the other hand wanting to put out the message that, "Yeah, we're sexual beings, but we don't like being treated as that and only that: as airheads with more between our legs than between our ears. Don't do that, either."

It really is a balancing act, and one isn't always going to come out exactly even and equal on it, no matter what the circumstances. But I think it often comes down to that one point: "We've got brains, and we've got boobs. Try to respect us regarding both."
I think the framing of intelligent and beautiful is a worthwhile brand for skepchicks to promote. Why not include, and capable?
 
On another note, let me pose another issue. The self identified feminists in this case are taking the initiative to promote certain behaviors in men as the said feminists believe it is one of their goals to facilitate men changing their behavior.

Given that concept, wanting to make the world a better place for women, suppose I choose an alternate approach. Suppose I'd like to see women not allow themselves to be bothered by situations like that of EG? I find it much more liberating than seeing myself as the victim who needs to get men to stop doing [X] to me. I hate to see women afraid to move about freely in a nice hotel just because it is 4 in the morning. Why should they allow themselves to be made uncomfortable by some guy making a pass in a hotel elevator at 4am when (given there aren't more menacing cues) the fear is more imagined than real?

Suppose I have evidence the perceived risk is way out of proportion to the real risk? Is my cause of wanting to liberate women any less deserving than the feminist cause of wanting to change men's behaviors?

Well, that's one way to evaluate the elevator story and related issues. Here's another: sexual mores are controversial in our society and apparently many people, regardless of where their own values lie within the sexual mores spectrum, would prefer that their sexual mores be society's norms.

This is not necc. a men vs. women's, or a religious right vs. everyone else issue.

In other words, some non-religious people, including men, believe in conservative sexual mores. And some women believe there should be no social stigma to one-night stand with strangers.
 
Last edited:
This is not what RD said. He clarified that wasn't what he said. It is a straw man.

It may not have been what RD meant to say. It certainly was what was understood and rejected first by most commenters (including PZ Myers) on Pharyngula.

Edit: For those interested in two earlier takes on Watson vs. Dawkins that are less muddled by fangirling and indignation, here is one from Pz Myers, and here one from Jen McCreight. Read for yourself.

Thanks. Should have looked that up.

You are welcome.

But still, Stef is part of the Religious Right's War on Women? No. Stef was a skeptic who disagreed with RW on a topic that is so ambiguous that we have a 50 plus page thread with posters disagreeing. She didn't say 2 + 2 = 5 or 0.9999. . . < 1. She simply disagreed with RW's take on an ambiguous situation.

Bringing your online drama into a talk like that is unprofessional.

Yes, and no. The topic of feminist consciousness as exemplified by contemporary students would have been appropriate for a basically feminist lecture. Bringing a specific student into it was imho unnecessary and naming the student when there is an obvious social power difference, and she is emotionally involved to that degree was (again in my opinion) rude, and yes a bit unprofessional.
 
Last edited:
Well, that's one way to evaluate the elevator story and related issues. Here's another: sexual mores are controversial in our society and apparently many people, regardless of where their own values lie within the sexual mores spectrum, would prefer that their sexual mores be society's norms.

This is not necc. a men vs. women's, or a religious right vs. everyone else issue.

In other words, some non-religious people, including men, believe in conservative sexual mores. And some women believe there should be no social stigma to one-night stand with strangers.
And? ....

Not sure where you meant to go with this.
 
And? ....

Not sure where you meant to go with this.

I don't think the elevator guy story is a feminist* issue. I think the story and the reactions to it are a reflection of the fact that many facets of Western Society don't agree on what Society's norm for sexual mores are or should be.


*FWIW, I prefer simpler definitions over complicated ones and to me feminism simply just means a belief in equal rights, opportunities and obligations for men and women.
 
Last edited:
Yes, and no. The topic of feminist consciousness as exemplified by contemporary students would have been appropriate for a basically feminist lecture. Bringing a specific student into it was imho unnecessary and naming the student when there is an obvious social power difference, and she is emotionally involved to that degree was (again in my opinion) rude, and yes a bit unprofessional.

So, we disagree slightly on why it may have been unprofessional, but agree that it was rude and maybe a bit unprofessional.

I can live with that.
 
I don't think the elevator guy story is a feminist* issue. I think the story and the reactions to it is a reflection of the fact that many facets of Western Society don't agree on what Society's norm for sexual mores are or should be.

Agreed.

And your sig line seems relevant.

When everyone think alike, no one thinks very much. -- Walter Lippman''
 
Yes, and no. The topic of feminist consciousness as exemplified by contemporary students would have been appropriate for a basically feminist lecture. Bringing a specific student into it was imho unnecessary and naming the student when there is an obvious social power difference, and she is emotionally involved to that degree was (again in my opinion) rude, and yes a bit unprofessional.

So, we disagree slightly on why it may have been unprofessional, but agree that it was rude and maybe a bit unprofessional.

I can live with that.


FWIW, I think this is the first issue I disagree with blauregen on but perhaps its because I'm not familiar with the organizations, arena and the people involved.

I don't agree that the social power difference was an issue, but I think it would have been more appropriate for Rebecca Watson to let Steph McGraw know that she was going to respond to her blog comment. However, if IIRC, I think RW said she was made aware of SM's blog very close to the speaking event. Still even a few minutes advance notice is better than none.

But AFAICT it was off topic for RW to bring the drama up in her presentation -- so IMHO it would have been even more appropriate for her not to bring it up at all.



FWIW, RW probably did SM a favor. A lot more people know who SM is now.
 
Last edited:
Can you quantify how low of a denominator a man should use considering we women have widely different comfort levels?

I think you've hit on a key question here... well put.

From my point of view, there is no single correct answer. It is contemplating the possible outcomes, and being aware of the different comfort levels, before acting, that is important.

I think I commented before that the kind I would consider insensitive or sexist is one that will completely disregard the possibility of spooking the person--or base their decision only on how likely they are to get what they want out of it.
 
I think you've hit on a key question here... well put.

From my point of view, there is no single correct answer. It is contemplating the possible outcomes, and being aware of the different comfort levels, before acting, that is important. I think I commented before that the kind I would consider insensitive or sexist is one that will completely disregard the possibility of spooking the person--or base their decision only on how likely they are to get what they want out of it.

I'm like that. The vast majority of women do not want to have any kind of intimate relationship with men like that.

People like the appearance of power, assertiveness and confidence.

People dislike the appearance of meekness, shyness and uncertainty.
 
I'm still wading through the 10 page thread about the Skepchick bordello themed party at TAM8 but so far I'm blown away by the direction of the discussion there compared to the direction of this one, especially the comments made by some of the same people in both threads.


Here's a hint:
Uh-oh, someone put her toe off the party line.
Very insightful that Marquis is.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom