So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
I must have missed this gem. Care to give me a source?
I feel that was an extraordinarily unfair characterization of what she said. She said disagreeing about her statement is sexism. While I don't agree, it's entirely different. If I made the statement "you know, maybe we shouldn't lynch blacks" and somebody disagreed with that statement, I could comfortably, without losing any sleep over an ensuing 50 page brouhaha, state that that person was racist. They aren't racist because they disagree *with me* (let's pretend I'm black for this mental exercise), but because they disagree with *the statement*.

None of that is meant to address her broader points about sexism, just to point out that she wasn't saying disagreement with RW=sexism. It was disagreement with a specific position vis a vis women = sexism. Which may or may not be true depending on the statement.
 
To hear Rebecca's side of things, I've uploaded an audio recording (safe, fast, working) of the whole Elevatorgate section in the latest SGU podcast:

http://soundcloud.com/ufo-keke/elevatorgate-sgu

Just click the link and you're good to go, the section lasts about 23 minutes.

And just in case, here's a link to a recap of how & where it all started:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7355603&postcount=1286

Well, that was awful. I suppose it shouldn't surprise me that "Rebecca's side of the story" means that Rebecca excludes every element of the story which led to the criticism. I guess the other hosts were under an obligation not to call her on it. I'm mixed as to whether Dawkins should take them up on the offer to come on the podcast at TAM. It's pretty clear he can't expect a fair hearing.

Linda
 
Last edited:
How is politely asking if a woman would like to come back to your room for a coffee and a chat about what she had been talking about sexualizing or objectifying her?

Why is it more a case of sexualization and/or objectification than approaching a woman in a bar who you know little about other than her approximate height, weight and bra size and offering to buy her a drink in the hope she'll talk to you?
 
Oh, well I did disagree with you, but now that you've made such an insightful and airtight argument, I've been completely swayed. After all, it's not like she's ever discussed these topics before, so when she brought it up at CFI completely out of the blue that should have been a red flag. Thanks, O paragon of reason!

Seriously: this is why I didn't want to get dragged into this. No matter what you say, there's always someone who's willing to counter with "Nuh-uh, she's just a jerk!"

Well of course, you know best. My apologies for attempting to put a damper on the hype: I see now that Rebecca is a screaming harpy who feeds on the flesh of the innocent and that I was wrong to suggest that she might have had anything but pitch black motives. Mea frickin' culpa.

I didn't say she's a jerk or anything of the sort. I think it's pretty obvious that she used her platform to comment on a very specific focus of discussion which is quite controversial within the community when the topic was "Religious Rights war on women" to portray Stef as guilty of jeopardizing gender equality.

That was a cheap shot.
 
How is politely asking if a woman would like to come back to your room for a coffee and a chat about what she had been talking about sexualizing or objectifying her?

Why is it more a case of sexualization and/or objectification than approaching a woman in a bar who you know little about other than her approximate height, weight and bra size and offering to buy her a drink in the hope she'll talk to you?

Ok, I'll give it a try. From the beginning, phrased like this it isn't, but let's apply a little systemic thinking to your two situations and observe how a few changing conditions influence the system.

a) is always bar-condition
b) is always elevator condition

1) Timeframe:
a) around 9-12pm ( rather typical bar-time for making social contacts )
b) 4am ( rather untypical time to meet new people )

2) Basic mood:
a) chipper ( reasonable assumption for sitting at the bar and sipping drinks).
b) tired and wanting to sleep. ( reported by RW )

3) Expectation:
a) The woman in question sits at a bar. Chances are good that she expects to be talked to, or even being chatted up. The bar is, after all commonly agreed upon as a typical place for making social contacts.
b) The woman is tired and wants to go to bed for the purpose of sleeping. Because the elevator isn't a typical place for making social contacts ( most people who are strangers to each other actually avoid eye contact there ), she does not expect to be chatted up, especially since there was ample opportunity to do it the last few hours at the bar.

4) Security
a) There is at least one additional person, the bartender. The area has in most cases an easily available exit ( fire security ) and the risk for the woman to be cornered, should the guy chatting her up be of the sinister type, is rather low.
b) There are intermittently available exits, which can be time-delayed accessed via a control panel, which could be easily blocked by a malign person of at least her strength. The cabin itself is too small for effective evasion. No other persons are in the cabin. Due to it being 4am the chance of other persons being on random corridors is negligible.

Now those differences, only indicate why the woman in question may feel a lot less comfortable with a come on in the elevator than in the bar. Rape is after all a very real possibility, and most girls are extensively cautioned against it. It doesn't make it sexist to chat her up in the elevator.

But all those informations are readily available to you, in both cases. ( Relaxed and smiling often means chipper and hanging shoulders and eyes slowly closing oftens means tired, if it isn't said explicitly ).

And choosing the elevator-approach over the bar-approach, is therefore at least very inconsiderate. And being that inconsiderate of the women's likely feelings, which seem easily enough predicted, because you consider your desire to bed her much more important, is in individual cases egocentric and as a general approach to women sexist.

Did that help?
 
Last edited:
Nice post, blauregen.

I only disagree about labelling the episode as sexist. I think it's a case of social ineptitude.
 
I guess the other hosts were under an obligation not to call her on it. I'm mixed as to whether Dawkins should take them up on the offer to come on the podcast at TAM. It's pretty clear he can't expect a fair hearing.

Linda


They were being way too soft in my opinion, Steve was trying to bring the "other side" to the discussion, though. I'm pretty confident Steve is capable of hosting a balanced talk @ TAM SGU even if he clearly has more personal ties to Rebecca than to Richard. Dawkins can easily hold his own and be a gentleman, the only question mark to me is Rebecca...but that's why it's going to be interesting :)
 
Last edited:
Nice post, blauregen.

I only disagree about labelling the episode as sexist. I think it's a case of social ineptitude.

Thank you. But if you are able to recognize those differences, and you still generally chose the elevator approach towards women, because you don't care how it is likely to make her feel, it shows from my perspective a high degree of disregard for her feelings and a lack of respect for her as a person.

To me this hints that you see her more as a sex-object than as a person. Which I would call sexist ( unless you treat men the same way of course).

For the actually socially inept, not much more than a 'Guys, don't do this.' came from it anyway. Initially at least.
 
They were being way too soft in my opinion, Steve was trying to bring the "other side" to the discussion, though. I'm pretty confident Steve is capable of hosting a balanced talk @ TAM SGU even if he clearly has more personal ties to Rebecca than to Richard. Dawkins can easily hold his own and be a gentleman, the only question mark to me is Rebecca...but that's why it's going to be interesting :)

That's a good point. On the show, he only has to please Rebecca, so there isn't any particular pressure to address the falsity of her account. At TAM, there will be pressure for him to be less dishonest (or to make some minimal effort at due diligence) in front of his colleagues.

I've no doubt that Dawkins can hold his own, but he may want to think twice about lending credibility to her claim to fame.

Linda
 
And choosing the elevator-approach over the bar-approach, is therefore at least very inconsiderate. And being that inconsiderate of the women's likely feelings, which seem easily enough predicted, because you consider your desire to bed her much more important, is in individual cases egocentric and as a general approach to women sexist.

Did that help?

Being inconsiderate of someone's feelings doesn't necessarily mean you are objectifying them nor does it mean you are being sexist if the person happens to be of the opposite gender.

Had RW said 'I'm going to bed' and a guy had said 'no...stay and have another drink we're just getting started' it would have been inconsiderate of her stated feelings but wouldn't have made anyone bat an eyelid and certainly wouldn't have been labelled sexist.
 
Thank you. But if you are able to recognize those differences, and you still generally chose the elevator approach towards women, because you don't care how it is likely to make her feel, it shows from my perspective a high degree of disregard for her feelings and a lack of respect for her as a person.

Agreed, but I don't think that's the case. The guy was obviously turned down and the story ended there. The events as we know them are more consistent with a socially inept person than with the type of person you describe in this hypothesis. If it were this type of person, I would expect some type of response after being turned down.

For the actually socially inept, not much more than a 'Guys, don't do this.' came from it anyway. Initially at least.
And she added that she doesn't like being sexualized in the manner. And, again, my point is that the problem here is not "sexualization". The problem is that the guy was socially inept.
 
Last edited:
Being inconsiderate of someone's feelings doesn't necessarily mean you are objectifying them nor does it mean you are being sexist if the person happens to be of the opposite gender.

Had RW said 'I'm going to bed' and a guy had said 'no...stay and have another drink we're just getting started' it would have been inconsiderate of her stated feelings but wouldn't have made anyone bat an eyelid and certainly wouldn't have been labelled sexist.

You mean at the reasonably safe bar, where are all the socializing happens? With possibly other night owls and the bartender around?

Well, first you just acknowledged her feelings of being tired and her intention to go to bed by referencing them ( 'No ....stay' ). Her likely feelings of anxiety in the elevator don't apply at the bar, so you don't have to consider them there.

So, no you weren't inconsiderate of the feelings relevant to this situation in your example. You merely made a counterproposal, which she can safely decline, even if you should be secretly the big bad wolf, because the bartender would shoot you if you try to devour hotel guests.

And she added that she doesn't like being sexualized in the manner. And, again, my point is that the problem here is not "sexualization". The problem is that the guy was socially inept.

If I read the elevator incident as the sole problem, I would agree. My impression was that she meant it as an illustration of a general attitude towards women.
 
Last edited:
If I read the elevator incident as the sole problem, I would agree. My impression was that she meant it as an illustration of a general attitude towards women.

Well, then the elevator incident is a bad example to illustrate her point. If the example is bad, her point about the general attitude towards women is wrong in at least one aspect.
 
As for the first bit: I'm confused as to what the furore is over.

Sorry, Mobyseven. It seems we don't have to listen to you. After all, you're not actually saying anything original or unique; we don't actually have to evaluate the content of your message.

See, you're parroting misandrist thought.

It's great, see, because I haven't actually accused you of being a misandrist; there's nothing for you to get directly upset over.

Instead, all I've done is accused your ideas, the things you're actually saying, as being examples of misandry.

And at the same time, I've also dismissed you as a thinking being, because I'm not even attributing the misandry to you. I'm saying its unwitting misandry; that you don't even realize the actual content of your own arguments. You're just "parroting". There's no reason to engage you directly about it; I can just hold you up as an example to everyone else of what not to do.

So, since you're "parroting misandrist thought", we can ignore you as uninformed and your arguments as hateful, without actually having to show either to be true.
 
1) Timeframe:
a) around 9-12pm ( rather typical bar-time for making social contacts )
b) 4am ( rather untypical time to meet new people )
They had already met.

Time to Approach a Woman
a) When she's in a crowd having a conversation
b) In a one-on-setting


2) Basic mood:
a) chipper ( reasonable assumption for sitting at the bar and sipping drinks).
b) tired and wanting to sleep. ( reported by RW )
The better mood for a one-on-one conversation is not when she's chatting it up in a crowd

3) Expectation:
a) The woman in question sits at a bar. Chances are good that she expects to be talked to, or even being chatted up. The bar is, after all commonly agreed upon as a typical place for making social contacts.
b) The woman is tired and wants to go to bed for the purpose of sleeping. Because the elevator isn't a typical place for making social contacts ( most people who are strangers to each other actually avoid eye contact there ), she does not expect to be chatted up, especially since there was ample opportunity to do it the last few hours at the bar.

While neither of us was there, I've been in similar situations many times before. There was most likely a group conversation going on. Quite possibly since she was a presenter and a female, she was probably the center of attention. I've typically been the center of conversation when I've been the presenter. Sometimes we don't want to be "on" anymore, but that doesn't mean we're definitely not interested in some one-on-one, quiet conversation.

4) Security
a) There is at least one additional person, the bartender. The area has in most cases an easily available exit ( fire security ) and the risk for the woman to be cornered, should the guy chatting her up be of the sinister type, is rather low.
b) There are intermittently available exits, which can be time-delayed accessed via a control panel, which could be easily blocked by a malign person of at least her strength. The cabin itself is too small for effective evasion. No other persons are in the cabin. Due to it being 4am the chance of other persons being on random corridors is negligible.
I don't know for sure, but most likely EG was an attendee at the conference wearing a badge at least at some point. It's a very nice hotel. The chances of someone being "sinister" (and foolish) enough to attack a person on an elevator is extremely slim.

And choosing the elevator-approach over the bar-approach, is therefore at least very inconsiderate.
What's even more inconsiderate is to make a one-on-one move on a woman who is engaged in group conversation.

And being that inconsiderate of the women's likely feelings, which seem easily enough predicted, because you consider your desire to bed her much more important, is in individual cases egocentric and as a general approach to women sexist.
Unless, of course, there's a shared mutual interest, in which case it's a welcome approach.

Then again, you're jumping to conclusions about him wanting to get her into bed. See these forensic animations.




 
Well, then the elevator incident is a bad example to illustrate her point. If the example is bad, her point about the general attitude towards women is wrong in at least one aspect.

If the supposed ineptitude were the result of a simple unwillingness to consider the woman's feelings, and it would be symptomatic for how RW perceives the treatment of women among skeptics, it would be a completely appropriate example. As I understood it, she gave it as an example of behavior that creeps her out, and could detract women from participating in the skeptics movement.

It is mainly bad,because for some reason people here choose to deconstruct it, as if it were the problem, not only a possible sign of it. As far as I am concerned this approach makes as much sense as trying to get rid of problematic waste by arguing that the symbol on the container can be interpreted as something completely harmless.

@Trasher

I only tried to explain the difference between the two settings to Ivor, on the off-chance that he really does not understand what the problem might be, despite it having been explained in various posts here and in several related blogs that were linked from here, but it is of course your prerogative to construct off-chance interpretations of the incident, if it cheers you up.

They had already met.

Although RW stated that they didn't speak with each other, so it would be more correct to say, they might have seen each other.

Time to Approach a Woman
a) When she's in a crowd having a conversation
b) In a one-on-setting

The better mood for a one-on-one conversation is not when she's chatting it up in a crowd

While neither of us was there, I've been in similar situations many times before. There was most likely a group conversation going on. Quite possibly since she was a presenter and a female, she was probably the center of attention. I've typically been the center of conversation when I've been the presenter. Sometimes we don't want to be "on" anymore, but that doesn't mean we're definitely not interested in some one-on-one, quiet conversation.

If you can't catch her attention in a group setting, then there simply was no good opportunity to make a closer acquaintance. It may have been better to simply forfeit than to predictably creep her out.

I don't know for sure, but most likely EG was an attendee at the conference wearing a badge at least at some point. It's a very nice hotel. The chances of someone being "sinister" (and foolish) enough to attack a person on an elevator is extremely slim.

And yet Greg Laden or Melissa McEwan seem to regard it as possible, so your assumption isn't exactlly undisputed.

What's even more inconsiderate is to make a one-on-one move on a woman who is engaged in group conversation.

In which case less determined men would consider not to approach the woman at all.

Unless, of course, there's a shared mutual interest, in which case it's a welcome approach.

Of course. We live in an universe of infinite possibilities. It may even be that the woman in question actually finds elevator-come ons incredibly erotic and that approaching her there would increase your chances significantly. It is unlikely in the case of RW. because she was apparently creeped out and had stated that she has no further interest except for sleeping, but as a general possibility it can't be ignored.

Then again, you're jumping to conclusions about him wanting to get her into bed. See these forensic animations.

It was how RW interpreted it. Usually the content of a message is regarded as what was understood, which isn't necessarily the same as what was intended.

But yes, there are of course several possibilities more, among them the one outlined in your videos, as well as the possibility that he actually wanted to secretly recruit her for a highly secret and well funded government project, or that he was an extraterrestrian, who went for an inconspicuous route of abduction. Admittedly none of this is probable, but the possibility cannot denied.

Have fun.
 
Although RW stated that they didn't speak with each other, so it would be more correct to say, they might have seen each other.
I would say they most definitely saw each other. And if RW's experience is similar to mine, she won't recall everyone she spoke to.

If you can't catch her attention in a group setting, then there simply was no good opportunity to make a closer acquaintance. It may have been better to simply forfeit than to predictably creep her out.
So instead of Elevatorgate, we'd have RW complaining that there she was sitting with a group of people and some guy was trying to get some alone time with her. How creepy and inconsiderate!

Approaching someone is how we meet people. We do it politely ("don't take this the wrong way"), show them that we have a personal rather than prurient interest ("I find you interesting") and suggest something neutral ("coffee"). Sometimes all that's at hand is an elevator and a hotel room. If you get rejected, then that's the end of it.

No harm. No foul.

And yet Greg Laden or Melissa McEwan seem to regard it as possible, so your assumption isn't exactlly undisputed.
I said extremely slim, not impossible. Strangers following someone off the street are a far cry from conference attendees at a nice hotel.

In which case less determined men would consider not to approach the woman at all.
Some men wouldn't. Some would. One did. Big deal.


Of course. We live in an universe of infinite possibilities. It may even be that the woman in question actually finds elevator-come ons incredibly erotic and that approaching her there would increase your chances significantly. It is unlikely in the case of RW. because she was apparently creeped out and had stated that she has no further interest except for sleeping, but as a general possibility it can't be ignored.
Can you present your evidence that it was a sexual come-on? Better yet, explain to me how someone who just wanted to talk with someone interesting who he may never see again would make a request for conversation.

It was how RW interpreted it. Usually the content of a message is regarded as what was understood, which isn't necessarily the same as what was intended.
Why did you just call me an elephant and ask me to pull down my pants?

But yes, there are of course several possibilities more, among them the one outlined in your videos, as well as the possibility that he actually wanted to secretly recruit her for a highly secret and well funded government project, or that he was an extraterrestrian, who went for an inconspicuous route of abduction. Admittedly none of this is probable, but the possibility cannot denied.

Except he didn't say anything about government projects. He suggested conversation and coffee in pretty much the only location possible since she obviously wanted to leave the bar. But, hey, you called me an elephant, so who knows?

Even if it was a come-on for a roll in the hay, this falls squarely in the no harm, no foul category. If feminism has come down demanding that men not be "inconsiderate," then the battle is won.
 
I'm glad people are speaking up about feeling uncomfortable at events and why. That's a good discussion to have. Unfortunately, the messenger for the event, by her past and present conduct, is overshadowing the discussion. The war of egos between Rebecca Watson and Richard Dawkins is distracting the community from a necessary discussion, it seem to me, which is too bad. It's helpful, I think, to separate the two. Bad behavior at skep cons: great discussion! Rebecca "hot girls hit on drunk nerds" Watson versus Richard "rich, white privileged male who doesn't get it let's boycott his books!" Dawkins: not so much.



Yes, there's definitely more to this than EG meets Skepchick and offers coffee. :D

It's just so weird to me that people will hear "other women have been creeped out at the conferences" and reply "Yeah, so what. Watson deserves it." The skepchick crowd is a very limited sample of any gender within the skeptical community. Treating a larger group based on the actions of one person within a sub-group doesn't seem rational. The "Don't be that guy." proponents can be found within every sub-group and every part of the whole. Watson has given them an opening for the message, killing the messenger doesn't negate it.

You know, I'd be ok with saying "EG was an aberration," if someone would just offer a little evidence that the free-thought community has the same percentage of socially awkward people as the rest of the population. But even "There is no such thing as *that* guy" group keep arguing the opposite. You have a movement with a much advertised flaw (social ineptitude) who is trying to say that the obvious results of that flaw do not exist.

Look at all the "Well what if I do this, why would that be bad?" posts in which someone is arguing that slightly rude behavior isn't "logically" wrong and therefore should be just peachy. For fun, apply it to real life.

In an elevator and out of the blue, person A (a stranger) says "Hey you wanna go to my room?" and person B says no with obvious distaste. So then person A comes back with one of the comments bouncing around le blogsphere:
Well, if you thought I was attractive you would.
Lots of people have sex without much discussion.
Just exercising my freedom to say what I want and insult you.
Why can't you just politely say no? You choose your own comfort level.
Getting hit on wouldn't bother me. What's your problem?
You need to respect that I was willing to be embarrassed.
Men have to make the first move, I had no choice.
I'm not sexualizing you because I didn't rape you.
You should be flattered, you're not all that pretty anyway.

And so forth. It's romcom, pathetic best friend stuff.
 
Sorry, Mobyseven. It seems we don't have to listen to you. After all, you're not actually saying anything original or unique; we don't actually have to evaluate the content of your message.

See, you're parroting misandrist thought.

It's great, see, because I haven't actually accused you of being a misandrist; there's nothing for you to get directly upset over.

Instead, all I've done is accused your ideas, the things you're actually saying, as being examples of misandry.

And at the same time, I've also dismissed you as a thinking being, because I'm not even attributing the misandry to you. I'm saying its unwitting misandry; that you don't even realize the actual content of your own arguments. You're just "parroting". There's no reason to engage you directly about it; I can just hold you up as an example to everyone else of what not to do.

So, since you're "parroting misandrist thought", we can ignore you as uninformed and your arguments as hateful, without actually having to show either to be true.

Whatever floats your boat, I guess.
 
Except he didn't say anything about government projects.

Of course not. It would be a secret project after all. There could be listeners.

But, hey, you called me an elephant, so who knows?

Exactly. :)

Even if it was a come-on for a roll in the hay, this falls squarely in the no harm, no foul category.

Except for a woman apparently being creeped out and feeling extremely uncomfortable in this case. But hey, since when are people's feelings important, when we ask how we can interest them in participating in the skeptics community, or when a roll in the hay is at stake? :D

Oh yes, and there are at least two women on this board alone who wouldn't have been creeped out. Isn't this proof enough that those feminist complaints are without any rational base? :D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom