So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
( Since this was dredged up from some 400 posts ago, it also prompts me to comment .. )


If women are really concerned about being followed ( Was she followed ? ) into an elevator by someone they don't know, they should consider taking the stairs or finding an escort ..

I would do just that. Given the circumstances as described, I'd have gotten off the elevator as soon as this stranger got on, and probably would have sought an escort from someone I knew, still in the pub.

I realize "hinky feelings" aren't exactly scientific, but when I get them, I listen to them.
 
Watson (original video): EG made me uncomfortable because this, this, & this. Please don't do that.
Reply:
Some people: yeah, I'm sick of creepy stuff like that, too
Other people: Hell no! Hittin' on chicks in semi-professional settings is A-ok.

Watson: That A-ok (and other repeated versions of it) is making some women uncomfortable at freethought events.
Some people: yes, it is. here is my example.
Other people: Why are you making one event all about sexism within skepticism? We have every right to proposition people anywhere we like!

(internet explosion!)

It's the attitude that is making this an issue. Saying that it's specifically EG is misleading.
 
Watson (original video): EG made me uncomfortable because this, this, & this. Please don't do that.
Reply:
Some people: yeah, I'm sick of creepy stuff like that, too
Other people: Hell no! Hittin' on chicks in semi-professional settings is A-ok.

Watson: That A-ok (and other repeated versions of it) is making some women uncomfortable at freethought events.
Some people: yes, it is. here is my example.
Other people: Why are you making one event all about sexism within skepticism? We have every right to proposition people anywhere we like!

(internet explosion!)

It's the attitude that is making this an issue. Saying that it's specifically EG is misleading.

That summary does not include the events that actually led to most of the internet explosion. Her treatment of Stef was unprofessional. But then, is she a professional? Should we expect her to act like a professional? Looking back through her history, probably not. It seems some of the people who pushed to have her speak at this particular event are having the same thoughts.

So I will agree with Delvo: The fact that she still has an audience in this movement says more about the movement than her.

PS: I wonder if she will pull a "death-by-mod" move at TAM to show her frustration with the movement as she did on this forum.
 
Should men behave like me, be passive and wait for an explicit offer or request from a women to have sex?

I can't speak for women, but male assertiveness is mostly a rather attractive trait for me. Although, depending on the guy, it can devolve into jerk-hood, which isn't, so YMMV.

Griping you didn't like the guy in the elevator is fine as far as that went. Making it a feminist cause claiming said elevator behavior was the kind of thing keeping women away from atheist and skeptical events .... not so fine.

I saw it more as an illustration of a wider concern, and she didn't gripe that she doesn't like the guy. Nor did she make a feminist cause solely of this incident, which was in itself admittedly harmless enough. I don't know whether it is a very constructive approach to constantly pretend that this single incident is the whole issue.

Jen McCreight gives a few points that might clarify the perceived problems here

What I'm saying is that, originally, she didn't say "objectification." She said "sexualization." Since she's made quite a reputation for Skepchick by doing that, it seems pretty obvious that she makes a distinction, whether you do or not.

Point taken. Although I still disagree with the notion a few other posters seem to imply that being sex-positive and using "sexualization" as a marketing technique somehow removes your right to criticize it, if it happens to you in an inappropriate context. To cite the american convention on human rights ( for you predominantly US-people ) "Everyone has the right to have his honor respected and his dignity recognized.", which - at least to me - means too, that trying to disregard your complaints on the aforementioned ground wouldn't be okay.

Mostly, I agree with you, but I do not think that Watson is totally innocent. ]

The debate is admittedly emotionally charged, yes. :)

Yeah, I don't see it readily.
(...)
One is if it is viewed as emblematic of some huge problem, which is where the conflation of sexualization, objectification, threat, and rape come in. If one buys into that, I can see how they would consider it really important.

I see it as emblematic of a real problem. The mentioned conflation is rather detrimental though. People on both sides tend to resort to exaggeration and strawmen on this ( not that I am completely innocent there. I went on a tangent on this topic too yesterday.)

The second if it is based on the idea that this sort of thing keeps women away from skeptic conventions.

The comments on RW's blog seem to indicate that it is a factor. I am not sure how decisive it is, or whether it is more prevalent among skeptics than in general male dominated groups. I would add though that if we reject the argument that her complaints can be safely ignored because there are bigger fish to fry, like the position of muslim women, we should also reject the notion that the problem is not relevant for the skeptics community, if it turns out to be only as bad as in general patriarchal society.

Perhaps the women complaining about being hit on when they don't want to be would like to switch positions with men who are constantly ignored and/or rejected and see which they find more unpleasant?

:D This somehow reminds me of an old book from somewhere in the seventies I once read. I think it was titled 'Egalia's Daughters'

Let me play with the proposed position switch for a moment please:

So you want to be a sex-object:

At first glance it doesn't look that bad. As a young and pretty manwom ( just to make wom the reference point ) you could gain considerable power over some wim, especially if you use your assets right. I guess making doe-eyes on a wom can get you some favors. Sure, it can feel a little odd, to be told that the wom would of course do this or that for a pretty boy like you, and there might be a hint that sexual favors are expected, but there is no free lunch, no?

You might consider tight and a little revealing clothes though, so your assets aren't overlooked. Of course, as a modern manwom you won't get problems if you don't wear a penisholder, but you might consider doing it anyway, because the padding and wiring in some models can help to emphasize your goods. You might want to grow a beard too, if you don't have one and take care to groom it carefully, or even curl it , so it looks prettier. A beard is an important symbol of masculinity, and you want to look sexy and masculine for the wim, no?

It might be a little annoying, if you are a professional manwom and you are announced as a speaker on a conference with a remark about your cute ass (your actual qualifications will probably be mentioned too, but one has to recognize what wim primarily see in menwim). Or if you talk to people about a topic that is important to you, and their eyes repeatedly wander down to your groin, but don't be rude and tell them that your eyes are up there. Wim just have needs and menwim simply have to learn to put up with it. It is a biological imperative. You will be more attractive if you stay nice and agreeable. And besides, isn't it nice that wim find your assets attractive?

Oh, and be careful not to get into dark alleys or confined spaces with wim you don't know. While most wim respect you of course, you are still very attractive to them, and if you just don't want sex at the moment, despite your getup, they might not always understand that your 'No' isn't simply playing hard to get, which you sometimes do to tease them, because it is the biological role of wim to conquer menwim, and a little resistance just makes you more alluring.

...

Ok, I'll stop the silliness now. :p
 
Last edited:
That summary does not include the events that actually led to most of the internet explosion. Her treatment of Stef was unprofessional.

I'm a little unclear as to why that is so. Would Stef happen to be a student? Is that the reason .. the belief that an adult blogger shouldn't pick on a student blogger at a in-real-life meeting, or at least not without warning?

Thanks for helping me understand why you think this was unprofessional.
 
Last edited:
From now on, instead of using the phrase "the pot calling the kettle black," I'll say "Rebecca Watson calling Richard Dawkins white." She's so white she's practically transparent.

Often Dawkins has downplayed the impact of the sexual abuse he experienced by comparing it to the much more humiliating and harmful abuse he sees in others.

Dawkins has sat down in sober judgement and minimized the significance of the sexual abuse he experienced by reflecting on how much worse others have it, which he was suggesting Rebecca Watson do.

No matter if you disagree with him or not, you cannot accuse him of ignorance on the subject or unwillingness to apply his advice to himself.

A child being fondled by an adult in a position of responsibility over them is, unquestionably, worse than a grown woman being made slightly uncomfortable by either a clumsy pass or a misunderstanding in an elevator and though you can argue he was too glib, he was neither wrong nor barred from expressing an opinion because of his skin color, money, or sex.
 
Last edited:
blaugren, I think I'm going to use that link from Jen M. in future argument a lot. Thanks
 
Naming names of the initiators of the reply video and the comments RW incorporated into her talk at the Student Conference isn't my issue here. It depends how it was done and there are a lot of additional issues it brings up. The comments/video were public and they addressed RW by name. But it could have been rude/awkward depending on how the discussion went. I wasn't there. There were people who thought it was tacky, and PZ supported RW's naming names. So opinions are split and I'm neutral. If I said or implied it was wrong for RW to name names, I would take it back having thought more about it. I don't think I said more than it was in the chronological record of events.

I didn't mean to imply you did have an issue with it. That was me, rambling. Sorry.

Which would be even more reason, if I were in RW's shoes, not to be automatically uncomfortable when this guy approached me in the hotel elevator.

I don't know how I would react, were I in her shoes because I am in a much different place than she is. I'm no spring chicken, time/age/stress/poor nutrion/sun have made their visit and left their signatures all over my face, and I spend most days feeling invisible so I, personally, would probably fall to the elevator floor, crying, and thanking EG for noticing me.
 
Last edited:
And if he expresses displeasure at being hit on by a gay guy in any situation, he's an evil homophobe.

Not really. If he makes a big thing about how terrible being chatted up by a gay man at a social occasion is for him, then yes, I might call him a homophobe and tell him that desensitization is known to have reasonable success rates in cases of irrational fear from objectively harmless stimuli.

If he complains about being stalked and cornered by a gay man in a confined space, or being groped despite making it clear that he isn't interested, then he has my support.
 
If only it were that elementary, my deer Watson. ;)
Watson (original video): EG made me uncomfortable because this, this, & this. Please don't do that.
Reply:
Some people: yeah, I'm sick of creepy stuff like that, too

Me, too. Up to this point, I have a lot of empathy.

Other people: Hell no! Hittin' on chicks in semi-professional settings is A-ok.

Well, that varies from chick to chick, hitter to hitter, and event to event, I guess. If a chick markets herself, sexualizes herself, as "the hot girl [who] hits on drunk nerds", she might tend to get hit on more often, even if she should later speak about being uncomfortable being sexualized. (Should the drunk nerd, even if he did happen to hear her speak, assume she'll still feel that way after drinking until 4 AM? Ideally, he should; but we're relying an awful lot on the reasoning power of her target audience, drunk nerds; it's possible, due to drunkenness or nerdiness or both, he may clumsily act on "the hot girl [who] hits on drunk nerds" message that's still out there; that's why it's probably not real smart ever to market yourself on the internet as "the hot girl [who] hits on drunk nerds". People, especially drunk nerds, may just believe you; and be too drunk or nerdy or skeptical or unaware that you now claim to no longer be "the hot girl [who] hits on drunk nerds" -- or do you?).

I.e., if you make your bed with the incredibly airheaded slogan "hot girls hit on drunk nerds", don't be too shocked, or expect a huge outpouring of sympathy from all corners, if at some point a drunk nerd asks to sleep in it.

Watson: That A-ok (and other repeated versions of it) is making some women uncomfortable at freethought events.

And does she have any idea where that "A-ok" may have come from? What prominent female skeptics org may have put that message out there, may have contributed to or even created the problem in the first place? Does she plan a public apology like she's demanding from Richard Dawkins for failing to have enough empathy for the discomfiture that a woman who has branded herself as "the hot girl [who] hits on drunk nerds" experiences when she is (possibly) hit on by a drunk nerd?

This is the lack of self-awareness, self-criticism and moral culpability that's cost her my former respect at the moment, and dwindled my sympathy for her elevator encounter from "a lot" -- where it would be in the general case; no one likes to be creeped out; creeper nerd did a bad thing; many women feel vulnerable in that and similar situations; smarten up! -- to a lot less that "a lot".

Some people: yes, it is. here is my example.
Other people: Why are you making one event all about sexism within skepticism? We have every right to proposition people anywhere we like!

I'm glad people are speaking up about feeling uncomfortable at events and why. That's a good discussion to have. Unfortunately, the messenger for the event, by her past and present conduct, is overshadowing the discussion. The war of egos between Rebecca Watson and Richard Dawkins is distracting the community from a necessary discussion, it seem to me, which is too bad. It's helpful, I think, to separate the two. Bad behavior at skep cons: great discussion! Rebecca "hot girls hit on drunk nerds" Watson versus Richard "rich, white privileged male who doesn't get it let's boycott his books!" Dawkins: not so much.

(internet explosion!)

It's the attitude that is making this an issue. Saying that it's specifically EG is misleading.

Yes, there's definitely more to this than EG meets Skepchick and offers coffee. :D
 
Last edited:
Has the PR genius of the Rebeca chick been mentioned yet? Just google "elevator" and "sexism", she owns the first page.

By the way, JREF is #4 on the list and rising!

Keep posting and clicking on this most interesting topic; are drunk men, in fact, attracted to tits and ass.
 
I guess this is why it's difficult, or at least part of why it's difficult, to pin this all down.


I can understand a young woman who's involved with a group of "intelligentsia" wanting to put out the message that, "Yeah, we're intelligent, and kind of geeky, and kind of scientific in our thinking. But that doesn't mean we're sexually neutral. Geeky girls like sex too, you know."

And then on the other hand wanting to put out the message that, "Yeah, we're sexual beings, but we don't like being treated as that and only that: as airheads with more between our legs than between our ears. Don't do that, either."

It really is a balancing act, and one isn't always going to come out exactly even and equal on it, no matter what the circumstances. But I think it often comes down to that one point: "We've got brains, and we've got boobs. Try to respect us regarding both."
 
I'm a little unclear as to why that is so.

RW was to be talking about something about religion, I honestly don't remember what, but instead started her talk with a derail about Stef not getting it. At this point should Stef respect the hosts and the audience who came to her about something else, or should she drag the derail into the Q&A? I think she acted more professionally by not feeding the troll, but others disagree.

The point is that RW was there to talk about something but had to drag her internet drama into the forum. That is unprofessional. It is rude to the audience and the hosts.

Would Stef happen to be a student? Is that the reason .. the belief that an adult blogger shouldn't pick on a student blogger at a in-real-life meeting, or at least not without warning?

No, if the topic of the talk was sexism in the skeptic movement I think her comments would have been very on-point and Stef would have been expected to deal with them in the Q&A. But that wasn't why she was there.

Think about being the host for an event like this. Say you land James Randi to speak at your local event about his latest antics in busting psuedo-science and there is an audience just brimming with excitement. Now, Mr. Randi comes to the stage and starts a slide show about how wonderful it is to be out of the closet after so many years despite the naysayers. For the first 15 minutes he just goes on bashing people who have attacked him for being gay and even those who are just not supportive. He even singles out one of the attendees for an internet post that questioned whether his coming out was good for the movement, comparing that person to a Nazi.

So, maybe Randi is right, but would that be professional? No. Would you be happy as a host? No. Would you be happy as an audience member? I wouldn't.

The thing is, Randi wouldn't do that because he is a professional who has built up a professional reputation. Rebecca hasn't. And this won't help.

Thanks for helping me understand why you think this was unprofessional.

You're welcome.
 
This is all utterly fascinating. Truly. It just keeps going. I'm biting my tongue.

Do we have a champion female statement as of yet? Has it been decreed that it's up to each woman to choose her own comfort level and action level? Or must the schism between skeptic men and women grow deeper?
 
RW was to be talking about something about religion, I honestly don't remember what, but instead started her talk with a derail about Stef not getting it. At this point should Stef respect the hosts and the audience who came to her about something else, or should she drag the derail into the Q&A? I think she acted more professionally by not feeding the troll, but others disagree.

The point is that RW was there to talk about something but had to drag her internet drama into the forum. That is unprofessional. It is rude to the audience and the hosts.

Ah, I didn't realize that. I agree, that was unprofessional.

FWIW, in that scenario and IMHO, the only way it would have been appropriate for RW to talk about it with the audience would have been during the Q&A session IF:
1) Someone in the audience had decided to ask her about it
AND
2) There was no one left in the audience with any "on-topic" questions

Thanks again for explaining.
 
Ah, I didn't realize that.

Not your fault, there hasn't been much conversation about the actual facts in the last 50 pages.

I agree, that was unprofessional.

FWIW, in that scenario and IMHO, the only way it would have been appropriate for RW to talk about it with the audience would have been during the Q&A session IF:
1) Someone in the audience had decided to ask her about it
AND
2) There was no one left in the audience with any "on-topic" questions

Agreed.

Thanks again for explaining.

Again, you are welcome.
 
If it had happened to you, how you react would be based on things individual to you.

It doesn't matter to this incident if you wouldn't react the same way.
Your estimation of your reaction has nothing to do with RW's reaction.

You are two different women. That you would react in a certain way to it doesn't invalidate her reaction.

I can't even tell you exactly how I would react to it, until it happens to me in exactly the same way it happened to her, and the chances of that are nil.

I can tell you that in general, and given only what I've read about it, when I project myself into that scenario, I think I'd be worried more than irritated. Because in my personal experience, when a man is alone with me in a private setting, away from all other people, and we've just left a public setting, and he says something contrived to get me alone ("come back to my room" for any reason), I'm going to feel he wants intimacy.

Rape? No, I didn't say rape. But we just left an open pub that serves coffee. Now he's asking me to go to his private room, where there's a door that locks, and where there's no one else around, so I'm going to assume he wants more than just to talk to me over a cup of coffee that we could have gotten in the open, public pub we both just left!

I'm going to feel that way because of my personal history.
My history isn't yours, and can't inform your choices or feelings.

That you can't understand my feeling that way about it doesn't make either of us wrong about it. It makes us individuals.
As was said before, how was EG supposed to know if he was making a pass at someone like RW or someone like me? Is it fair to say all guys should subscribe to the lowest common denominator and never hit on any woman ever? After all there are likely some women who are uncomfortable around a guy they don't know in any situation.

It has even been suggested a man should wait for the next elevator car if a single woman is alone in the one he wants to get on, out of deference to her potential fear should he get on with her alone.

Can you quantify how low of a denominator a man should use considering we women have widely different comfort levels?
 
RW was to be talking about something about religion, I honestly don't remember what, .

You are close. According to RW ( here ) the topic was 'the Religious Right’s War on Women'.

Definitely related to religion, although not as unrelated to feminism as one would assume from your phrasing.
 
On another note, let me pose another issue. The self identified feminists in this case are taking the initiative to promote certain behaviors in men as the said feminists believe it is one of their goals to facilitate men changing their behavior.

Given that concept, wanting to make the world a better place for women, suppose I choose an alternate approach. Suppose I'd like to see women not allow themselves to be bothered by situations like that of EG? I find it much more liberating than seeing myself as the victim who needs to get men to stop doing [X] to me. I hate to see women afraid to move about freely in a nice hotel just because it is 4 in the morning. Why should they allow themselves to be made uncomfortable by some guy making a pass in a hotel elevator at 4am when (given there aren't more menacing cues) the fear is more imagined than real?

Suppose I have evidence the perceived risk is way out of proportion to the real risk? Is my cause of wanting to liberate women any less deserving than the feminist cause of wanting to change men's behaviors?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom