So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Please provide examples, either general or specific, of requests that men make to women about when, where or how they don't want to be hit on.

Not wanting to be hit on by someone who physically intimidates them (it happens)

Not wanting to be hit on in situations they would find embarassing.

Not wanting to be hit on by someone they turned down five minutes ago.

I'm not sure I"m following your logic. The claim I'm making is that any such requests are as valid as they would be for women. Whether it's common doesn't seem to be relevant.
 
...
What I do find curious about her having the nerve to challenge some of the responses and naming names; that's what I see a lot of them do. I've seen Dawkins do it, I've seen Sam Harris do it, PZ Meyers posts emails with names on his blog. RW has given those she named, exactly what they wanted. Do you honestly think that they post their videos and comments to be ignored?

Please do not take me the wrong way. I have said that calling women who disagree with her as "part of the problem" (in short) or calling any man who disagrees with her "sexist" or "a misogynist, is wrong and I've never gotten behind that or attempted to support it. It's how she addressed those opinions that I disagree with, not addressing them. None of those people she "called out" would have been known if they didn't put their own names on it.
Naming names of the initiators of the reply video and the comments RW incorporated into her talk at the Student Conference isn't my issue here. It depends how it was done and there are a lot of additional issues it brings up. The comments/video were public and they addressed RW by name. But it could have been rude/awkward depending on how the discussion went. I wasn't there. There were people who thought it was tacky, and PZ supported RW's naming names. So opinions are split and I'm neutral. If I said or implied it was wrong for RW to name names, I would take it back having thought more about it. I don't think I said more than it was in the chronological record of events.
 
That's still up in the air. He wasn't on the discussion panel but she seems sure that he was there at the conference and there at the bar. ....
Which would be even more reason, if I were in RW's shoes, not to be automatically uncomfortable when this guy approached me in the hotel elevator.
 
I can assure you that being followed into an elevator at 4:00 AM by a man she has not previously interacted with and being propositioned may not make every single woman on the planet at best uncomfortable ..............

-Pieter

( Since this was dredged up from some 400 posts ago, it also prompts me to comment .. )


If women are really concerned about being followed ( Was she followed ? ) into an elevator by someone they don't know, they should consider taking the stairs or finding an escort ..
 
Please provide examples, either general or specific, of requests that men make to women about when, where or how they don't want to be hit on.

Generally, they can't. The response to such a request would be amusement and/or ridicule, as it would be contrary to masculine toughness and seen as "whining".
There is pretty much no example in media where a man wanting a woman to leave him alone is treated as anything other than comedy.
 
Not wanting to be hit on by someone who physically intimidates them (it happens)

Not wanting to be hit on in situations they would find embarassing.

Not wanting to be hit on by someone they turned down five minutes ago.

I'm not sure I"m following your logic. The claim I'm making is that any such requests are as valid as they would be for women. Whether it's common doesn't seem to be relevant.

I was interested in requests, either specific or general, made to all women, not a woman in a particular situation.

For example, "women, don't hit on men when they're watching football", or "women, don't hit on married men in bars in case we think you're a honey trap hired by our wives".
 
Generally, they can't. The response to such a request would be amusement and/or ridicule, as it would be contrary to masculine toughness and seen as "whining".
There is pretty much no example in media where a man wanting a woman to leave him alone is treated as anything other than comedy.

And if he expresses displeasure at being hit on by a gay guy in any situation, he's an evil homophobe. No, I personally don't tend to get offended when gay guys hit on me (if it weren't for them I wouldn't get hit on at all), but I can imagine situations in which I wouldn't like it.
 
I was interested in requests, either specific or general, made to all women, not a woman in a particular situation.

For example, "women, don't hit on men when they're watching football", or "women, don't hit on married men in bars in case we think you're a honey trap hired by our wives".

Why does it matter? If a woman making blanket statements about when to hit on women is wrong, why would a man making blanket statements matter? Rebecca, at first, didn't say all women either.

In her opinion, don't hit on women alone in elevators. That's not the part of the entire thing that's objectionable.
 
Wait, I got confused. Are we discussing likely scenarios or evaluating a hypothetical standard of fairness?

If it's the former, I can totally agree that sexism hits men in just the way tyr described. If it's the latter, it's not relevant.

Please don't ascribe opinions to me I haven't expressed. The one at hand is: It is just as fair for a man to propose a standard of restraint in sexual propositions as it is for a woman.
 
Last edited:
I honestly didn't know that women went through life this scared and this timid.

I don't think "scared and timid" is the right description exactly. Just watchful, and uncomfortably aware when something could turn into a scary situation.

I don't know much about all the personalities involved or the history here, so I can't comment on the rest of the drama at all.
 
Which would be even more reason, if I were in RW's shoes, not to be automatically uncomfortable when this guy approached me in the hotel elevator.

If it had happened to you, how you react would be based on things individual to you.

It doesn't matter to this incident if you wouldn't react the same way.
Your estimation of your reaction has nothing to do with RW's reaction.

You are two different women. That you would react in a certain way to it doesn't invalidate her reaction.

I can't even tell you exactly how I would react to it, until it happens to me in exactly the same way it happened to her, and the chances of that are nil.

I can tell you that in general, and given only what I've read about it, when I project myself into that scenario, I think I'd be worried more than irritated. Because in my personal experience, when a man is alone with me in a private setting, away from all other people, and we've just left a public setting, and he says something contrived to get me alone ("come back to my room" for any reason), I'm going to feel he wants intimacy.

Rape? No, I didn't say rape. But we just left an open pub that serves coffee. Now he's asking me to go to his private room, where there's a door that locks, and where there's no one else around, so I'm going to assume he wants more than just to talk to me over a cup of coffee that we could have gotten in the open, public pub we both just left!

I'm going to feel that way because of my personal history.
My history isn't yours, and can't inform your choices or feelings.

That you can't understand my feeling that way about it doesn't make either of us wrong about it. It makes us individuals.
 
You're right. English is not my first language, and I guess it's obvious by the mistakes I make.

I took a WAG based on your location in Spain. :) Your English is very good, I wish I knew another language as well.


Feel free to correct me, I'll honestly appreciate it.
Oh, I'm not the best person to do that. Despite my best attempts, I've been told my grammar still has issues. Perhaps a left over effect from not having good hearing aids until I was an adult. So if anyone wants to PM me when they see a grammar mistake in my posts, I'd appreciate it also.

I don't agree that she didn't describe it as sexism. RW didn't mention the exact word, but by the context I inferred what she was talking about.

I'm smiling because a lot of the posts have been about whether to take EG literally or to take into account context, innuendos and social cliches.


I know you have a right to disagree, and I guess we would engage in a discussion about what "I don't like being sexualized" means, and whether "being sexualized" is one of those things RW considers part of a bigger problem that we could call sexism or misogyny.

Well, honestly at this point I'm more than ready to stop discussing these issues in the context of the elevatorgate blogwar.

It's too hard to discuss when the posters in this thread can't come to an agreement as to what it is we are actually discussing. Just the first video blog? The entire blogwar? Can we discuss what the bloggers said even though they aren't the best spokespersons because they engage in sarcasm and/or strawman arguements (RD) and mixed messages or hypocrisy depending upon your POV (RW) ... or are we getting bogged down in ad hom fallacies? And just what exactly is under contention here?

(While I posted some replies back to Skeptic Ginger in the wee hours of the morning saying that OK, RW was engaging in extreme sarcasm but not strawman arguments, I've since reconsidered that. RD's "Muslima" post was probably both sarcastic and a strawman argument. I think the deciding factor would have to be what the average reasonable bystander thinks would be understood by the average reader, not RW. )

I'm meandering, but I think I'm going to switch my attentions to the other link where hopefully it will be more clear as to what it is we are actually debating about.

Thanks for the link. Maybe that new discussion is more interesting.

Well, I hope it will be more fruitful! :)
 
Last edited:
I honestly didn't know that women went through life this scared and this timid.

"Women" in general, probably not.

Me, yes. I've been assaulted. I once sent a man to jail for sexual assault. He accosted me while I was in my car, in a shopping mall parking lot.

I was also, as I've said several times in other threads here, serially sexually molested from the ages of 6 to 14, by several adult men over that time period.

I have reasons to be much more cautious than one might think "normal."
Scared and timid? Sometimes, yes. Not always. But definitely sometimes.

Not all women have these reasons. But then, these reasons don't come up all that often in casual conversation, so how would you know?
 
I don't think "scared and timid" is the right description exactly. Just watchful, and uncomfortably aware when something could turn into a scary situation.<snip>

Yeah, I have similar feelings practically everytime I drive my car. There are some risks I can't avoid and still drive a car.

Similarly, whether or not some guy propositions a woman in an elevator at 4am in the morning does not alter her risk of being raped because he's either going to try rape her or he is not. There is nothing she could do which would change his reason for being in the elevator with her. Whether he keeps his mouth shut, makes smalltalk or propositions her, it reveals practically nothing about his likelihood of being a rapist.
 
"Women" in general, probably not.

Me, yes. I've been assaulted. I once sent a man to jail for sexual assault. He accosted me while I was in my car, in a shopping mall parking lot.

I was also, as I've said several times in other threads here, serially sexually molested from the ages of 6 to 14, by several adult men over that time period.

I have reasons to be much more cautious than one might think "normal."
Scared and timid? Sometimes, yes. Not always. But definitely sometimes.

Not all women have these reasons. But then, these reasons don't come up all that often in casual conversation, so how would you know?

FWIW, if this is supposed to matter, I was sexually molested from the ages of 6 to 9 (since 3 point 14 previously responded to one of my posts on the issue of perceiving women as weak and vulnerable).

Linda
 
FWIW, if this is supposed to matter, I was sexually molested from the ages of 6 to 9 (since 3 point 14 previously responded to one of my posts on the issue of perceiving women as weak and vulnerable).

Linda

I'm sorry that happened to you. Sincerely.

However, you didn't specify why you mention it. Would I be wrong in taking your words to mean that your sexual molestation doesn't seem to have affected you in the same way mine affected me?

That would probably be true. Mostly because of the other life variables we've each been through, and the individuality of each of our persons.

I'm only explaining how I, as the individual I am, might possibly react to certain situations. But I'm also acknowledging that others won't react the same way as I, because they are not me, and I am not them.

Is this, as it seems, difficult to grasp?
 
I'm sorry that happened to you. Sincerely.

However, you didn't specify why you mention it.

Because you gave it as a reason in response to 3point14's question. In the interests of full disclosure (since he previously stated that his experience with women was that they were more like what I described for myself) it wouldn't be fair to leave him with the impression that I hadn't had the experience of sexual molestation.

Linda
 
ImaginalDisc said:
She specifically called Dawkins out as not knowing what the heck he's talking about because he's too rich, white, and male to have an opinion.

More than once now, which indicates a bit of an obsession with those particular facts, since they aren't relevant enough to have even been mentioned the first time. And he was just as rich, just as white, just as male, and approximately as old before, when she acted like she was fine with him and the things he says and writes.

From now on, instead of using the phrase "the pot calling the kettle black," I'll say "Rebecca Watson calling Richard Dawkins white." She's so white she's practically transparent.
 
Because you gave it as a reason in response to 3point14's question. In the interests of full disclosure (since he previously stated that his experience with women was that they were more like what I described for myself) it wouldn't be fair to leave him with the impression that I hadn't had the experience of sexual molestation.

Linda

Ah, I see, that makes a great deal of sense, then. Thank you for explaining. :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom