So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
RW in her first video blog didn't describe this a sexism. I don't think English is your first language so I'm not surprised about the confusion. Lots of people in this thread speak English fluently and I don't think we can come up with a consensus as to just exactly what it is that we're arguing about! :D
That's why this thread is over 50 pages and has come nowhere near a conclusion.


I'm not picking on you Dani, just using your post as a convenient springboard.

Seriously, maybe we should just select a few of the issues and discuss them in brand new threads without making any reference to RW, RD, Phil (?) or any of the other bloggers.


ETA:
Well, while I was away, I see that Skeptic Ginger started a thread a few hours ago on:

EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED


Guess I didn't have to post this!

You're right. English is not my first language, and I guess it's obvious by the mistakes I make. Feel free to correct me, I'll honestly appreciate it.

I don't agree that she didn't describe it as sexism. RW didn't mention the exact word, but by the context I inferred what she was talking about. I know you have a right to disagree, and I guess we would engage in a discussion about what "I don't like being sexualized" means, and whether "being sexualized" is one of those things RW considers part of a bigger problem that we could call sexism or misogyny.

Thanks for the link. Maybe that new discussion is more interesting.
 
Last edited:
Hmmm...

I just got through reading the links offered up on Skeptic Ginger's thread asking for stories of sexism at skeptic/atheist events.

So, a group of women, led by Rebecca, sets up women to be sexualized to the point where those complaining that maybe it isn't such a good idea are called feminazis. But when it comes back to bite them on the ass, instead of abject apologies to the men they misled and the women they insulted for pointing out that it would bite them on the ass, they up the ante and call them misogynists?

This better be one giant gotcha.

Linda
 
I can assure you that being followed into an elevator at 4:00 AM by a man she has not previously interacted with and being propositioned may not make every single woman on the planet at best uncomfortable, I would bet very serious money that it will make almost every woman at best uncomfortable. That some people refuse to accept this fact both mystifies and saddens me.

-Pieter

I would tend to agree, but .... AFAIK, they were far from strangers. Hadn't they just been on a conference panel together?

Hans
 
A "wingwoman" on CNN has offered her dating tips for guys. For some reason this one made me think of this whole fiasco:

There is never a bad time to approach a woman.
Women want to be approached, as long as it's by the right person. If you see a girl you like, stop, breathe and think to yourself, "She's adorable. I want to talk to her and see if I like her." Notice the "I want" and the spirit of figuring out what you like. Until you get to know this girl, it's about you, not her.
 
Who cares ? Since when do you require 100% certainty in order to perform any action ?

Sheesh, aren't we supposed to be skeptics, here ?

Apparently RW needed 100% certainty to be sure he was a threat/hitting on her, in order to be justified in being uncomfortable.
 

Okay, I misunderstood you, then. I thought you were saying RW posted another video with a differing opinion. I saw that video on one of the side bars, on YT.

I don't know if your run down of specifics was intended to counter what I said but all the comments from; RW is whining to EG is proof of this male hierarchy, sexist world we live in, stemmed from her saying, "don't do that."

What I do find curious about her having the nerve to challenge some of the responses and naming names; that's what I see a lot of them do. I've seen Dawkins do it, I've seen Sam Harris do it, PZ Meyers posts emails with names on his blog. RW has given those she named, exactly what they wanted. Do you honestly think that they post their videos and comments to be ignored?

Please do not take me the wrong way. I have said that calling women who disagree with her as "part of the problem" (in short) or calling any man who disagrees with her "sexist" or "a misogynist, is wrong and I've never gotten behind that or attempted to support it. It's how she addressed those opinions that I disagree with, not addressing them. None of those people she "called out" would have been known if they didn't put their own names on it.
 
I would tend to agree, but .... AFAIK, they were far from strangers. Hadn't they just been on a conference panel together?

Hans

That's still up in the air. He wasn't on the discussion panel but she seems sure that he was there at the conference and there at the bar. There is no mention of whether or not they actually did interact but she does insinuate that he heard what she had to say about objectification. It would be nice to have some concrete answers on that one.
 
Obviously men aren't allowed to put in requests for how they want women to behave toward them. That would be sexist.

In fact, it is perfectly appropriate for men to "put in requests" as you say for how they want women to REFRAIN from hitting on them in certain situations in certain ways. Just as I've said about the men learning, women might learn from such expression as well.

I don't see where you perceive a double standard here.
 
In fact, it is perfectly appropriate for men to "put in requests" as you say for how they want women to REFRAIN from hitting on them in certain situations in certain ways. Just as I've said about the men learning, women might learn from such expression as well.

I disagree. An individual has no business speaking for an entire group without the group's prior authorization. RW telling "men" what is acceptable behaviour on behalf of women who have not given her the authority is rather presumptuous of her.

And because one man was ignorant of, or just ignored, her demands doesn't make him sexist. RW is not the decider on what is, or is not, sexist behaviour and there is nothing in the incident that demonstrates sexist behaviour.

Me thinks RW has a pet project that requires her to create strawmen she can then publicly rant about. Reading her bio on Skeptchick is evidence of that.
 
In fact, it is perfectly appropriate for men to "put in requests" as you say for how they want women to REFRAIN from hitting on them in certain situations in certain ways. Just as I've said about the men learning, women might learn from such expression as well.

I don't see where you perceive a double standard here.

Have you got any examples of such requests by men of women?
 
Qouting old posts here, but intermittent net access is causing me to read intermittent sections of the thread, and I haven't seen things like this in more recent posts...

Funny, yes. Discussing this IRL has lead to much laughter. I've been calling it "Please, somebody think of the dorks!" and my husband is seriously wondering if skeptical guys are really that pathetic.
I'm not convinced I've seen anything about it here that I wouldn't have seen in non-skeptical online communities. But that does remind me of something else I've wondered about Watson's complaints about the unwelcome attention she's gotten since becoming sort of famous in the skeptical community. She keeps presenting this as a characteristic of the skeptical community. She's never been famous in any other context, so she has no basis for comparison, and her complaints match what I'd expect for anyone who became equally famous in any other group. So what makes her so sure the problem of threatening email and such is a skeptical community problem, rather than just a problem of fame and humans in general?

In a way, suggestions such as Rebecca's original comment on the matter can HELP people avoid creeping out others. I wonder if there's a way for such suggestions to be taken as helpful more easily. Instead, intended or unintended--it has been taken by many to be a demand from feminism.
...or an insult by acting like we'd all be like him as a universal default.

However, as far as advice in general goes, it's like treatment for drug addiction: first, the person with the behavioral problem needs to admit it and be ready for help, in order to accept and use it. I recently had a co-worker who almost certainly has Asperger's Syndrome, and I mean the real thing, not just the pseudo-diagnostic bandwagon every slightly awkward and maybe intellectual person on the internet now hops on. His oddities have made him famous among the other riders of the bus he rides, and caused some of them not to ride that bus anymore. He seems aware that a problem exists, but when I've tried to talk to him about it to help him, he's shown me a close-up view of his middle finger and walked away with an infuriated look on his face.

She specifically called Dawkins out as not knowing what the heck he's talking about because he's too rich, white, and male to have an opinion.
More than once now, which indicates a bit of an obsession with those particular facts, since they aren't relevant enough to have even been mentioned the first time. And he was just as rich, just as white, just as male, and approximately as old before, when she acted like she was fine with him and the things he says and writes.

If she understands the fact that those demographic facts about him don't disqualify him from being taken seriously or invalidate what he says, then she's being dishonest to use them that way now, and pandering to an audience whom she expects to fall for that kind of thinking even though she knows it's false herself.

If she doesn't get it, then any positive thing she ever said about him or anybody else fitting at least one of those same demographic categories, and any seemingly positive interaction she's had before with him or anybody else fitting at least one of them, was all a pretense, faking getting along with people she hated, had no respect for, and was only setting up for the right time to reveal what she really thought/felt about later.

Either way, spouting off the "wealthy old white guy" attactic now, after not having mentioned that information about him before, means that either before or after, she is/was being dishonest for no possible purpose but to manipulate and troll. (Also with them at the same panel discussion was Aron Ra. She acts like everything's fine between them for the moment, but how is anybody to know? The instant they have the tiniest dispute, he could turn into just a "chubby hairy white guy".) The worst revelation about "skeptical community" in this situation is that she can reveal herself to be like that and still have an audience.
 
Hmmm...

I just got through reading the links offered up on Skeptic Ginger's thread asking for stories of sexism at skeptic/atheist events.

So, a group of women, led by Rebecca, sets up women to be sexualized to the point where those complaining that maybe it isn't such a good idea are called feminazis. But when it comes back to bite them on the ass, instead of abject apologies to the men they misled and the women they insulted for pointing out that it would bite them on the ass, they up the ante and call them misogynists?

This better be one giant gotcha.

Linda

Unless by "one giant gotcha" you mean standard operating procedure, I doubt it.

The worst revelation about "skeptical community" in this situation is that she can reveal herself to be like that and still have an audience.


This.

Linda

Yup. Skepticism's very own Paris Hilton. We've been blessed...
 

Attachments

  • con_043693226905_8070f54f99.jpg
    con_043693226905_8070f54f99.jpg
    97.1 KB · Views: 7
Last edited:
So are you saying it's a fair question or not ?

Depends on the person. If he knew she didn't like being hit on while at conferences, this assumes that he heard her comment in the first place and remembered that one bit of data among the many other more important bits from hours before after drinking and staying up until 4AM, then it wasn't a fair question at all.

My point was that Rebecca can say 'don't do that to me', but I'm saying for me, try it. (Note that I'm one of those people who like to make love to the person, and not just the body, so I'm unlikely to accept such a request from a stranger but I'd appreciate the request!)
 
I disagree. An individual has no business speaking for an entire group without the group's prior authorization. RW telling "men" what is acceptable behaviour on behalf of women who have not given her the authority is rather presumptuous of her.

Notice I used the word "request" not "demand". I think it's perfectly reasonable to have an opinion on what constitutes good manners, and to say it. That doesn't mean I'm claiming the right to speak for everyone else.

And because one man was ignorant of, or just ignored, her demands doesn't make him sexist. RW is not the decider on what is, or is not, sexist behaviour and there is nothing in the incident that demonstrates sexist behaviour.

Me thinks RW has a pet project that requires her to create strawmen she can then publicly rant about. Reading her bio on Skeptchick is evidence of that.
I realize it's a long thread, but you'll notice I have refrained from ever saying that EG (or anyone who makes a similar error such as I see it) is sexist. Where I see it perhaps venturing into sexism (or at least, a disrespect for others) is expressing disinterest in how one's behavior might be taken. Probably that just counts as rude, but if the rudeness is aimed mostly at women it could be seen as sexism.
 
Last edited:
Have you got any examples of such requests by men of women?

Do you mean requests made by specific people? I don't really feel like quote mining the whole internet right now.

If you want me to speculate on what men might not want women to do in that situation, I can.
 
Do you mean requests made by specific people? I don't really feel like quote mining the whole internet right now.

If you want me to speculate on what men might not want women to do in that situation, I can.

gnome said:
In fact, it is perfectly appropriate for men to "put in requests" as you say for how they want women to REFRAIN from hitting on them in certain situations in certain ways.

Please provide examples, either general or specific, of requests that men make to women about when, where or how they don't want to be hit on.
 
I can assure you that being followed into an elevator at 4:00 AM by a man she has not previously interacted with and being propositioned may not make every single woman on the planet at best uncomfortable, I would bet very serious money that it will make almost every woman at best uncomfortable. That some people refuse to accept this fact both mystifies and saddens me.

-Pieter
You're sad because I think most women can handle such an encounter with a simple, no thanks, and no more discomfort than that which comes from empathy for the guy who has just been rejected?

Pity.
 
I can assure you that being followed into an elevator at 4:00 AM by a man she has not previously interacted with and being propositioned may not make every single woman on the planet at best uncomfortable, I would bet very serious money that it will make almost every woman at best uncomfortable. That some people refuse to accept this fact both mystifies and saddens me.

-Pieter

I honestly didn't know that women went through life this scared and this timid.

I honestly don't recognise that in any of the women in my life. Maybe they just don't let me see it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom