So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
What are you going on about? Nobody suggested her request be denied. If that's all you're worried about, you could have left 51 pages ago perfectly satisfied.

Linda

Right.

Telling people that an action makes me uncomfortable doesn't make that action unequivocally bad by general consensus. After I informed than an action makes me uncomfortable, we can agree that it's better not to do it if it's easily avoidable. But of course, this only means that "it is bad to do something to someone when you know in advance that it makes that person uncomfortable if that action is easily avoidable". This doesn't tell us whether that specific action is bad in itself (in this case, whether it is misogynist in itself). It's a whole different argument.
 
Because in her opinion he showed a disregard for her feelings - which is what you yourself have defined as "objectification".

I suppose we're going to have to agree to disagree because I simply don't see it that way.

If someone tells me "Ugh... I'm not really hungry this evening." and, a few minutes later, after my stomach growls, I say, "hey, wanna grab a bite, after all ?", am I showing disregard for the person's feelings ? Or am I just asking a fair question ?
 
Busy taking care of an awesome dog (whooza good boy, you are! Walkies in 30 seconds, ok?) so can't really chat.

Quick question for all - Do you feel there is any problem with sexism within the free-thought communities?

(walkies!)


Hi, bk. :)

Yes -- skimming what women are posting on other sites about this -- it seems there is a problem; one main symptom being that women at events are getting hit on either too much or too awkwardly or both. It seems a lot of men in the free-though community have yet to clue in that attending an event where women are typically outnumbered doesn't mean a woman wants salacious attention in proportion to which her gender is outnumbered. It doesn't mean she wants to hook up at all. Don't make that assumption. For women at events, maybe there should be a warning sign on a lobby marquee somewhere: Beware of oft-awkward sex-starved oft-drunken nerd-swarms. Not sure what the international symbol is for that but I'm sure if we free-thinkers put our pointy heads together we can come up with something.

One reason for the discomfiture women seem be experiencing at these events is almost surely that they are surrounded by men many of whom are not very comfortable around women, haven't had much experience approaching them for conversation let alone coffee at 4 AM, and it shows. That's a problem. Maybe some seminars, brochures, podcasts that go back to basics are in order: this is a man; this is a woman; when a man meets a woman... blablabla... coffee?... blablabla... adjoining cemetery plots. I don't know.

I also don't know, and am a little concerned, if Rebecca "hot girls hit on drunk nerds" Watson is the best choice to speak to whatever problems of sexism exist in the community, having seen how irresponsibly she promotes herself, self-promotion which very likely aggravated, possibly created, the "sexism", as it pertains to unwanted sexualization and objectification at events, that is now being complained about, most loudly by her. Given the clear video evidence of the unfathomably irresponsible way she has promoted herself in the past, imo, she can only be a polarizing figure in the present, shouting down attempts at rational discussion from opposing viewpoints, making things much worse before they can ever get better.

Sad but true, appears that some people have a genuine knack for getting themselves in the center of mediastorms and not much else in the way of reason; like Hollywood is stuck with Paris Hilton, we seem to be stuck with her; oh well, wait and see, see if the reasonable voices without the knack for self-promotion and publicity ever get heard over the self-righteous and self-absorbed catcalls, the shouting down of opposition, the abrogation of rational discussion...

Is my current take from afar (always subject to revision).
 
Last edited:
I suppose we're going to have to agree to disagree because I simply don't see it that way.

If someone tells me "Ugh... I'm not really hungry this evening." and, a few minutes later, after my stomach growls, I say, "hey, wanna grab a bite, after all ?", am I showing disregard for the person's feelings ? Or am I just asking a fair question ?

If I'm headed to bed at an event, but then sex is put on the table (literally or figuratively), I might reconsider my decision to go to sleep.
 
This depends on which of the 2 ways one takes RD's comments.

My take was RD used an extreme example using the contrast to illustrate how petty RW's complaint was. That is not a straw man.

I don't agree with your next sentence down below -- but I see your point that extreme sarcasm is not a straw man argument.

But I do think its usually an inferior way to argue and not likely to win over people to your POV. Instead I think it's far more likely to inflame and escalate an existing disagreement, much like what happened after RD posted his "Muslima" comments.

If you read his comments as sarcasm because RW was claiming the incident was as bad as severe forms of discrimination, that would be a straw man.

<snip>
 
I have had many misunderstandings with women over the years. I once was invited by a woman stranger to come to her hotel room. It was so abrupt that I didn't find it appropriate. And I didn't feel like it. End of story. No sexism, no nothing. You reverse the story, and there you go. Sexism!

RW in her first video blog didn't describe this a sexism. I don't think English is your first language so I'm not surprised about the confusion. Lots of people in this thread speak English fluently and I don't think we can come up with a consensus as to just exactly what it is that we're arguing about! :D
That's why this thread is over 50 pages and has come nowhere near a conclusion.


I'm not picking on you Dani, just using your post as a convenient springboard.

Seriously, maybe we should just select a few of the issues and discuss them in brand new threads without making any reference to RW, RD, Phil (?) or any of the other bloggers.


ETA:
Well, while I was away, I see that Skeptic Ginger started a thread a few hours ago on:

EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED


Guess I didn't have to post this!
 
Last edited:
I don't agree with your next sentence down below -- but I see your point that extreme sarcasm is not a straw man argument.

But I do think its usually an inferior way to argue and not likely to win over people to your POV. Instead I think it's far more likely to inflame and escalate an existing disagreement, much like what happened after RD posted his "Muslima" comments.
Maybe my second sentence wasn't clear. Let me try again then tell me what you disagree with.

I said "If you read his comments as sarcasm because RW was claiming the incident was as bad as severe forms of discrimination, that would be a straw man."

Here's the clarification: If you think RD was saying RW was claiming the elevator incident rose to the level of severe sexism, that would make RD's argument a straw man. I didn't read his comment to mean that.

But as for RD's style, lots of people are critical of it. I happen to favor the frank, in your face approach. I hate to admit but it is my natural state. I have to work at not being more frank than is socially acceptable. I am aware, however, of the "don't be a dick" position that many people prefer. I understand their position. Sometimes I wish that came more naturally for me, sometimes I'm glad I am naturally more frank.
 
Last edited:
I re-read the initial post and the reply. If Humes fork is joking, it went right over my head. I am used to jokes that are funny, though, so maybe my life experience is such that I won't get that one.

The initial post was moderated, so pardon my gullability. Was it some reference to another thread? Given the newness of Hume, I assumed he was referencing this discussion.

No, it was not a joke at all. I'm just surprised this subject creates such strong feelings.
 
Maybe my second sentence wasn't clear. Let me try again then tell me what you disagree with.

I said "If you read his comments as sarcasm because RW was claiming the incident was as bad as severe forms of discrimination, that would be a straw man."

Here's the clarification: If you think RD was saying RW was claiming the elevator incident rose to the level of severe sexism, that would make RD's argument a straw man. I didn't read his comment to mean that.

I don't disagree with your reworded statement.

Skeptic Ginger said:
But as for RD's style, lots of people are critical of it. I happen to favor the frank, in your face approach. I hate to admit but it is my natural state. I have to work at not being more frank than is socially acceptable. I am aware, however, of the "don't be a dick" position that many people prefer. I understand their position. Sometimes I wish that came more naturally for me, sometimes I'm glad I am naturally more frank.

IMHO, frankness != sarcasm.

Per dictionary.com

frankness is
plainness of speech; candor; openness.


sarcasm is
1. harsh or bitter derision or irony.
2. a sharply ironical taunt; sneering or cutting remark: a review full of sarcasms.

and dictionary.com also quotes the World English Dictionary:

1 mocking, contemptuous, or ironic language intended to convey scorn or insult
2. the use or tone of such language



Sarcasm is usually considered humorous by the members of the choir being preached to. But it usually fails to help people who are not on the same page to understand one's POV. Instead, it often just adds a lot of noise instead of signal to the subject being debated and will escalate an already inflamed disagreement. That's why I consider sarcasm to be an inferior form of argument.

IMHO, if you want to engage in a bonding exercise with people who already think the same thing that you do -- go for it. But if you want people to understand your POV, find another way to communicate.
 
Last edited:
I'm still unclear what this bloke did that made it seem he was more likely to be a rapist than a bloke who chats to a woman in a bar and then arranges a date with her, as the latter is just as (if not more) likely to be a rapist than the former.

If he was no more likely to be a rapist than a guy who chats to women in a bar, then it seems his only 'crime' was making Ms. Watson feel uncomfortable by a clumsy and possibly tactless come-on.

So is the real request that geeks and nerds should be better at interacting with people they find attractive, irrespective of whether or not they plan on raping them? Isn't social awkwardness one of the typical characteristics of geeks and nerds?

So Ms. Watson's request is that geeks and nerds should not behave like geeks and nerds?

ETA: Why would this be news to geeks and nerds? They've been being told and made to feel that they don't fit in most of their lives. I doubt one more person saying the same thing is going to make much difference.
 
Last edited:
Just to throw tuppence into the ring, there's an angle to Dawkin's original "Dear Muslima" comment that I think needs to be considered.

The comment has been criticised for many things, it's rude, sarcastic, "not getting it", badly written, doesn't understand how rape victims feel, but mostly the criticism was that Dawkins was telling RW: "STFU - How dare you complain about X when other people suffer Y - that's so much more important." People then flocked with examples of "trivial" atheistic issues saying that Dawkins was hypocritical in supporting them when obviously there was much worse things going on.

With some caveats, I don't think there was anything wrong with his post. It was a comment on someone else's blog, it was unlikely to be his best and most well thought out piece of writing, maybe the sarcasm was out of place, and possibly it was slightly rude and didn't take RW's feelings into account. Granted. But in the context that this was a comment on the blog of a man who nailed a communion wafer to a wall I'm not sure they're valid criticisms.

Anyway, on to the point by way of an analogy.

If a worldwide health organisation was spending much of its time and energy on say erectile dysfunction research, how would this look to someone outside the organisation? Would someone inside or outside the organisation be correct in saying that by prioritising something which affects primarily "rich western males" you look self-serving?

If a massive erectile dysfunction debate was engulfing the community (and say the organisation had a World Malaria Day in a few days time) could someone senior in the organisation be justified in penning a sarcastic "letter" in a comment section where this debate was raging, pretty much saying "this is what this looks like to the outside world - things that affect us (however trivial) are important - other stuff like malaria - not so much.

This would not be to say that erectile dysfunction is not a serious issue facing men, nor that anyone who attempted to do something about it should immediately be shouted down - "because there's malaria in the world" - it's a matter of priorities, fairness and appearance.

This was Dawkins point.
 
I must give props to you for the assist.
I have another one for you, Boobquake. "Jen McCreight is a liberal, geeky, nerdy, scientific, perverted feminist atheist who recently escaped Indiana for Seattle". Jen followed through with "And the Boobquake results are in!" It's priceless.

On my thread seeking evidence of the purported sexism within our community I came across a blog complaining that some guys were making boob comments about Jen when she spoke on another topic. I've not heard yet how Jen views the elevatorgate kerfuffle or the comment in the Nerd is my Gender Blog. It should be interesting to get her take on all this. I can't wait to see her again and ask her about it as she's joined our Seattle Skeptics group. She gave a nice rundown for us of her visit to the Creation Museum. Her talk was well received, no boob jokes were heard.
 
Last edited:
<snip>

I've not heard yet how Jen views the elevatorgate kerfuffle or the comment in the Nerd is my Gender Blog. It should be interesting to get her take on all this.

<snip>

From reading blog is seems she agrees with Ms. Watson, with the exception of not boycotting Dawkins books.

It seems she wants men to hit on her, but only when she deems it appropriate.

Obviously men aren't allowed to put in requests for how they want women to behave toward them. That would be sexist.

It must be terrible to have lots of people find you attractive. I can't imagine how bad it must be to have to turn down all those dates and offers of sex.

To me it's the equivalent of a fat person complaining to a starving African about how terrible it is that so many food products are loaded with HFCS.

Perhaps the women complaining about being hit on when they don't want to be would like to switch positions with men who are constantly ignored and/or rejected and see which they find more unpleasant?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom