So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
You know, if you want to be taken seriously now, you might want to stop making extreme strawmen, exaggerating, and responding with emotion-based "arguments".

My description of objectification did sound like rape when applied to the person and not to the actual object like I had intended, so where is the straw man? What she said was accurate.
 
\

No I read it; I considered it immaterial because she said it was something she should've added to the video (and therefore, wasn't in it), not a rephrasing of what was in the video.
Riiight, not confirmation bias. Uh huh. Don't take RW's word for what she meant, stick with your own. :rolleyes:
 
Plenty of people play the lottery because there's much to gain even if the odds aren't good. So even if the odds were really low, I'd still expect some men to try their chances as he did, assuming sex is what he wanted.

But as we're confronted with posters who apparently don't care about the substante of other people's posts, let me help you a bit:



Which has NOTHING to do with what you eventually replied.

Asking people for sex isn't necessarily objectifying. I wouldn't even agree that it's objectifying most of the time. So why is EG described as objectifying Rebecca ?

Because in her opinion he showed a disregard for her feelings - which is what you yourself have defined as "objectification". She was under the impression that the man had heard her speech about not liking being sexualized; she also seemed to be under the impression that the man had heard her announce that she was exhausted and needed to sleep. Her impressions might've been incorrect. But they were what she was working with; and if those impressions were true, then yes, the man's request that she not continue to bed but instead accompany him to his room for whatever, showed a lack of consideration for what she had already said she wanted.
 
Riiight, not confirmation bias. Uh huh. Don't take RW's word for what she meant, stick with your own. :rolleyes:

She didn't say "this is what I meant", she said "I also should have said x".

And none of this still makes it okay to marginalize her discomfort in the elevator situation, even if I completely abdicate this single point to you.
 
I only meant to say, hear hear, not to suggest anyone should torture themselves reading 48 (now 50) pages of this thread. ;)
After taking a few hours to do some household chores and "paying work" (in theory), I come back to find another four pages to catch up on! Maybe I was imagining it, but I thought the thread actually slowed down a bit yesterday, or was that wishful thinking? :cool:
 
I am the last one to ask about sarcasm. I get it wrong all the time. And since a mod also thought it was serious, I'm going to bow out. I thought it was funny.

BTW, if you were mistaken and reported it, that would explain the mod edit.

I didn't. It would be odd to mention the moderated thread as a source of my confusion if I were the one that reported it...
 
Last edited:
She was under the impression that the man had heard her speech about not liking being sexualized; she also seemed to be under the impression that the man had heard her announce that she was exhausted and needed to sleep. Her impressions might've been incorrect. But they were what she was working with; and if those impressions were true, then yes, the man's request that she not continue to bed but instead accompany him to his room for whatever, showed a lack of consideration for what she had already said she wanted.

I wonder if the bloke was taking the p***...?
 
I wonder if the bloke was taking the p***...?

I don't know if I mentioned it earlier (I think I did), but my own theory is that he did hear her talk that day and intentionally did the elevator thing just to troll her. But people are straining their arteries to insist that something or other makes it more likely he was completely innocent, so I'm rollin' with it.
 
I have had many misunderstandings with women over the years. I once was invited by a woman stranger to come to her hotel room. It was so abrupt that I didn't find it appropriate. And I didn't feel like it. End of story. No sexism, no nothing. You reverse the story, and there you go. Sexism!
 
Last edited:
I don't know if I mentioned it earlier (I think I did), but my own theory is that he did hear her talk that day and intentionally did the elevator thing just to troll her. But people are straining their arteries to insist that something or other makes it more likely he was completely innocent, so I'm rollin' with it.

Well the truth is with the information given we really have no way of knowing. There are a million ways the scenario could have played out in which EG was a complete [insert insult of your choice here] and another million in which he was totally faultless.

There's also an outside chance that RW made the whole thing up to make a point or that she is mis-remembering or mis-informing as to what actually happened.

The evidence is pretty inconclusive.
 
I have had many misunderstandings with women over the years. I once was invited by a stranger woman to come to her hotel room. It was so abrupt that I didn't find it appropriate. And I didn't feel like it. End of story. No sexism, no nothing. You reverse the story, and there you go. Sexism!

You mean a stranger woman than you? And your a Zappa fan?
 
There's also an outside chance that RW made the whole thing up to make a point or that she is mis-remembering or mis-informing as to what actually happened.

That is downright insulting. Anyone who has ever spoken at a conference and then hung out at the bar talking with attendees until 4AM will tell you that their mind is a steel trap as they are heading up the lift. (It's still a lift in Dublin, right? That's not just a London thing, is it?) There is no way she is mis-anything about this encounter. /sarcasm

Not that it would change anything, but I would love to here that the guy was just trolling her. Obvious troll leading to such a tempest in a teapot is somehow very funny.
 
Busy taking care of an awesome dog (whooza good boy, you are! Walkies in 30 seconds, ok?) so can't really chat.

Quick question for all - Do you feel there is any problem with sexism within the free-thought communities?

Quick answer: yes.
 
Are you claiming not to understand as a rhetorical device, or do you honestly not understand? Because it seemed evident to me the moment I read it that "uninvited" means "where a person has not previously indicated that they would be receptive to such comments".
I mean it exactly as I explained it more than once. As written, it means just what you say (or close enough not to quibble). But as I further explained, this really means "No sex at TAM." I find it hard to believe they actually intend to impart that meaning, and I gave a description of what I think they actually mean.


Checkmite said:
The message, in my opinion - "there's a chance they might say yes" is not sufficient;
Just at TAM? Or always?


Checkmite said:
save it for when you have reason to believe it's likely they will say yes".
That's the point in regard to TAM and this guideline: Likelihood isn't sufficient; an actual invitation is required, and as has been pointed out, such invitation can't really be made without violating the guideline unless there is something akin to what I have jokingly suggested: a message on the nametag or the handkerchief code.


Checkmite said:
Wouldn't an unwelcome advance necessarily be uninvited? Describe a case where an advance would be invited, but unwelcome.
You are looking at the wrong part of the Venn Diagram.

I am talking about those advances that would be welcome but are not invited.



Checkmite said:
I would say not, because a third party has no way of knowing whether one or the other of you had indicated at some earlier point that you were willing.
Glad to hear it. How about my other question?

What if one TAM attendee makes an uninvited sexual advance and it is welcomed? If those two attendees go to their room and the JREF finds out about it will there be repercussions? They will have broken the guideline.
 
Sexual objectification in the sense that one is seen primarily as an object of sexual desire, instead of as a person?

What I'm saying is that, originally, she didn't say "objectification." She said "sexualization." Since she's made quite a reputation for Skepchick by doing that, it seems pretty obvious that she makes a distinction, whether you do or not.

The creeping up to rape was initially more a work of the community, I think.
Mostly, I agree with you, but I do not think that Watson is totally innocent. This essay about Privilege seems to me to conflate the ideas pretty readily.

http://skepchick.org/2011/07/the-privilege-delusion/

Why not? I mean this seriously. Why is there a special reason to care?
Aside from lofty ideals like equality and mutual respect? Empathy, I think. I wouldn't like it happening to me.

Yeah, I don't see it readily.

What we have, ultimately, is a statement from someone I do not know except by reputation about someone I don't know and will never know making her feel uncomfortable. I'm sure that this happens millions or tens of millions of times all over the world. (If family members are involved, it's probably more like billions.)

I can only think of three special reasons to care particularly about this.

One is if it is viewed as emblematic of some huge problem, which is where the conflation of sexualization, objectification, threat, and rape come in. If one buys into that, I can see how they would consider it really important.

The second if it is based on the idea that this sort of thing keeps women away from skeptic conventions (except that it is only a particular kind of women; there seems to be no desire by the people who seem to want more women like Rebecca Watson to make women like Skeptic Ginger feel more comfortable; in fact, they seem to do their best to put them down.) If that's the case, we could discuss that.

The third is for people who know Watson personally. There have been some in this and other threads who said they considered Watson a friend. So far, however, they have been saying that in their experience Watson has a tendency to overreact.
 
But as long as you contend that because you consider it unreasonable to feel uncomfortable about a certain situation, that's a good enough reason to deny a request from someone not to put them in that situation, I'm going to take exception.

Because I can't think that way. If someone tells me "such and such makes me uncomfortable", and it's something as mindlessly simple to acknowledge as "please don't hit on me in the elevator", I cannot bring myself to reply with "What? That's so stupid - I would never feel uncomfortable being hit on in an elevator; so screw your 'discomfort', request denied." I just can't.

What are you going on about? Nobody suggested her request be denied. If that's all you're worried about, you could have left 51 pages ago perfectly satisfied.

Linda
 
My description of objectification did sound like rape when applied to the person and not to the actual object like I had intended, so where is the straw man? What she said was accurate.

Well it must've gone over my head, because you were talking about actual objects, which cannot be raped.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom