<snip>
I had briefly mentioned the mess to my wife earlier (mostly ended up being "Richard Dawkins was a dick AGAIN?") but we spent a lot more time talking about it yesterday. Our eventual conclusion was that being hit on was a lot like being called by a telemarketer: the answer is probably no, and many people find it more and more irritating as frequency increases. So... don't be elevator guy, please, especially with public figures.
A random pile of thoughts. At this point, after reading so many things, I can't remember who all claimed what. I worried about this for a while, and then decided I didn't care what RW or RD said. The discussion seems more interesting on the periphery where they're not directly involved.
- It's reasonable to be irritated after being hit on AGAIN. It may not seem fair that you're getting an unexpectedly harsh response, but it doesn't seem fair that you're person-to-reject #517 either...
- It's reasonable to just be uncomfortable/awkward being hit on at all
- There's a great video by Steven Pinker about language that's partially about sex vs "coffee" that was linked from a page linked from one of the pages Tyr linked to.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3-son3EJTrU.
- It's perfectly legitimate to feel uncomfortable/threatened in the elevator situation, even though you could argue about how rational the discomfort is.
- EG sexualised RW: assuming it was "coffee", yes. Is this bad?
- EG's proposition was almost certainly doomed to failure, whether it truly was an invitation for coffee or not. Following a complete stranger from some public place to a hotel room isn't super bright, regardless of gender. Changing the invitation to be to an all-night coffee house would have been a better bet, even it was still almost certainly going to be turned down.
- EG objectified RW: no.
- EG was a misogynist: bloody ridiculous.
- Other people making critical comments about RW are misogynists: not any of the authors of things I read. It seems reasonable to call someone like Dave Sim a misogynist. Even disliking and critically commenting on some behaviour stereotypically associated with women is not, on its own, misogyny. I'm not sure anything even came this close...
- Saying RD couldn't understand the threat of sexual assault because he was a privileged white male was a giant face-palming pile of fail. "You just can't understand!" is a weak argument at the best of times, and this example is part of the reason why: you might just be totally wrong.
- RW is perfectly free to be tired of being hit on, and publicly let people know that she's not interested in an attempt to minimise it. It will be interesting, however, to see whether she up-sells her ideas with sex in the future... There is a clear distinction between talking about sex and "listen to me about this unrelated thing because I'm sexy."