So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Neither do I, but the workplace guidelines (under the assumption, which isn't really true, that there is one set of workplace guidelines) are not the TAM guidelines. The TAM guidelines (at least the one I quoted) are wishy-washy and vague. What do they mean "without invitation?"

Are you claiming not to understand as a rhetorical device, or do you honestly not understand? Because it seemed evident to me the moment I read it that "uninvited" means "where a person has not previously indicated that they would be receptive to such comments".

The message, in my opinion - "there's a chance they might say yes" is not sufficient; save it for when you have reason to believe it's likely they will say yes".


I don't disagree except for the highlighted word. The rules don't rule out "unwelcome" sexual advances. They rule out "uninvited" sexual advances. There is a significant difference.

Wouldn't an unwelcome advance necessarily be uninvited? Describe a case where an advance would be invited, but unwelcome.


What if I decide to break the rules and I make an uninvited sexual advance to a hot skepchick and she accepts? And what if you witness this or Grothe witnesses this? Are there repercussions?

I would say not, because a third party has no way of knowing whether one or the other of you had indicated at some earlier point that you were willing.
 
:boggled:

It was a joke.

I re-read the initial post and the reply. If Humes fork is joking, it went right over my head. I am used to jokes that are funny, though, so maybe my life experience is such that I won't get that one.

The initial post was moderated, so pardon my gullability. Was it some reference to another thread? Given the newness of Hume, I assumed he was referencing this discussion.
 
Last edited:
My point is to contradict Rebecca Watson's ad hominem, "Thanks, wealthy old heterosexual white man!" Nothing about those privileges makes his opinion irrelevant and if Dawkins can put a legitimate example of sex abuse into some perspective, maybe Watson should, too.


Ah, I see, thanks for explaining. I do think the conversation has broken down on both sides. /obvious statement

RW's ad hominem's response was to RD's straw response. By this point, neither of them are displaying shining examples of rational discourse.

That being said we are talking about common social scenarios where, depending upon our assigned role, we only get to see up close one side of it.

There was probably a better way to get that point across so it didn't look like strictly an ad hominen attack.

Some cuts and pastes from posts up thread:





Is it bad that I think that her initial complaints are valid?

<snip>

See, back when I was a student I jobbed in a bar for a time, and I got to experience some of it. Nothing traumatizing. It comes - depending on the bar - with the job, and if a patron grabs your ass (as one of the worse offenses), you give him a sweet smile and tell him to stop this, and if he doesn't, you kindly ask the manager to have a word with the guy. It works. But over all, it was annoying enough for me, that I dropped the job after a few months and looked for something different. Call me a sissy for being overly sensitive if you want.

The point is of course, that as a man, I have to actually go to places to experience this degree of objectification, and no in my experience the vast majority of women are far less direct in this regard and better at picking up disinterest.

Women though mostly don't have this privilege. The vast majority of guys are interested in them, and express their desire wherever they just happen to meet them. And frankly, if I came to conferences as a lecturer to state my results or merely my opinions, and I would constantly get the impression that people are more interested in my pecs and my ass, than in my thoughts, I guess I would pretty soon stop feeling flattered and become subliminally pissed. I might even overreact, if I get the feeling that my core concern is ignored over a bad example.

So yes, I think there was some overreaction, I don't know whether it was dramatic or emotional or maybe both, but I wouldn't deny it. And yes, the elevator incident has been blown completely out of proportion

But I think we shouldn't ignore her basic concerns over it. I think she has enough supporting votes to show that she isn't alone with it.



<snip>
I had briefly mentioned the mess to my wife earlier (mostly ended up being "Richard Dawkins was a dick AGAIN?") but we spent a lot more time talking about it yesterday. Our eventual conclusion was that being hit on was a lot like being called by a telemarketer: the answer is probably no, and many people find it more and more irritating as frequency increases. So... don't be elevator guy, please, especially with public figures.


A random pile of thoughts. At this point, after reading so many things, I can't remember who all claimed what. I worried about this for a while, and then decided I didn't care what RW or RD said. The discussion seems more interesting on the periphery where they're not directly involved.

- It's reasonable to be irritated after being hit on AGAIN. It may not seem fair that you're getting an unexpectedly harsh response, but it doesn't seem fair that you're person-to-reject #517 either...

- It's reasonable to just be uncomfortable/awkward being hit on at all

- There's a great video by Steven Pinker about language that's partially about sex vs "coffee" that was linked from a page linked from one of the pages Tyr linked to. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3-son3EJTrU.

- It's perfectly legitimate to feel uncomfortable/threatened in the elevator situation, even though you could argue about how rational the discomfort is.

- EG sexualised RW: assuming it was "coffee", yes. Is this bad?

- EG's proposition was almost certainly doomed to failure, whether it truly was an invitation for coffee or not. Following a complete stranger from some public place to a hotel room isn't super bright, regardless of gender. Changing the invitation to be to an all-night coffee house would have been a better bet, even it was still almost certainly going to be turned down.

- EG objectified RW: no.

- EG was a misogynist: bloody ridiculous.

- Other people making critical comments about RW are misogynists: not any of the authors of things I read. It seems reasonable to call someone like Dave Sim a misogynist. Even disliking and critically commenting on some behaviour stereotypically associated with women is not, on its own, misogyny. I'm not sure anything even came this close...

- Saying RD couldn't understand the threat of sexual assault because he was a privileged white male was a giant face-palming pile of fail. "You just can't understand!" is a weak argument at the best of times, and this example is part of the reason why: you might just be totally wrong.

- RW is perfectly free to be tired of being hit on, and publicly let people know that she's not interested in an attempt to minimise it. It will be interesting, however, to see whether she up-sells her ideas with sex in the future... There is a clear distinction between talking about sex and "listen to me about this unrelated thing because I'm sexy."


From reading their posts I know that blauregen and Folly are males. I think blauregen got some special insights because he worked in a gay bar and Folly because he spent time discussing this topic with his wife.

When the point under dissension is one that falls under sociological mores and assigned roles -- it probably is relevant what the arguer's assigned role and life experiences had been. But that alone is not enough to win the debate.

So yes, RW made an ad hom attack -- but it is a valid point that one's demographic and assigned sociological roles will have an impact on one's life experiences and perceptions of this debate.

Not my best written post, but I hope I managed to make my point. Running behind schedule and need to go back to my errands. Ciao for now.
 
Last edited:
<snip>

That depends on the situation, all other things being equal, there's no real reason he can't chat. He should realize the setting and, not for example, proposition the woman with his first words.

I know, I know, this is an impossible standard. When I run into women in elevators, I might look over and see that they have a college name on their sweatshirt. I will then think to myself, yes, ask her about this college, but invariably, I just blurt out, "DO YOU SHAVE YOUR BIKINI LINE?!?"

It's so hard to find a topic other than something overtly sexual when isolated in an elevator with a woman. Truly the burden is more than anyone should be expected to bear.

Yet rapists generally do chat with women first before suggesting something more intimate or making a date to meet up again later. Women say this puts them at ease. Why? The stats indicate that this behaviour is more typical of rapists than jumping them in elevators in plush hotels.

That's a big leap from "uninterested" to "they must think I'm a rapist."

<snip>

Maybe so, but given that it was remarkably easy for some to come to believe I'm a misogynist, it doesn't seem such a leap from there for others to go a step further and think I think so little of women that I'm a likely potential rapist.
 
Last edited:
Busy taking care of an awesome dog (whooza good boy, you are! Walkies in 30 seconds, ok?) so can't really chat.

Quick question for all - Do you feel there is any problem with sexism within the free-thought communities?

(walkies!)

There are problems with sexism with humans. Free-thought communities are made up of humans. Therefore, I'd say it's a given.

The groups that I've seen an especially large problem with sexism personally are sporting events, and college feminism events. I've never been to a free-thought or skeptical event, so I couldn't provide an anecdote about one of those.
 
The transcripts I've seen of her initial response all seem to show a request from her not to do that to her. If she said "this is why women aren't going to TAMs" or anything like that, it wasn't in the quotes anyone has posted on this thread.
Sigh....

[To the tune of Spoonful by Cream] Spoon feed spoon feed spooooon feeed. [/Spoonful]

Let me try again.

[Links are in this post.]
RW's video.
Stclairose's response video.
[Oh yeah, I forgot there was also McGraw's response which was the person RW talked about in her talk at the CFI conference. My bad, it was McGraw named. I don't know if Stclairose was also named in RW's talk.]
CFI Student Leadership Conference.
RW's Skepchick blog explaining her response to EG and what she meant in the video.
PZ's blog empathizing with RW.
RD's reply in PZ's blog.
Cue the blogosphere eruption.


I [RW] was pretty frustrated, seeing a young woman who I’m sure is intelligent be so incredibly dismissive of my experience and that of other women in this community, and so uneducated about the fundamentals of feminist thought....

in my video I specifically said that most of the conference attendees – men and women – were awesome. What I should have added is this: for the men (and women) who are behaving in sexist and destructive ways, I hope that pointing it out to them has the effect of making them consider their actions and stop being sexist and damaging.

I was blown away to be told that there were other student leaders who had expressed similar dismissive attitudes recently on Facebook and on other blogs. An hour or so prior to my talk, someone sent me this link to a post by Stef McGraw on the UNI Freethinkers site. I added a paragraph of that response to a slide for the intro to my talk, in which I hoped to call out the anti-woman rhetoric my audience was engaging in.
(emphasis mine)

McGraw's words RW didn't appreciate:
My concern is that she takes issue with a man showing interest in her. What’s wrong with that? How on earth does that justify him as creepy? Are we not sexual beings? Let’s review, it’s not as if he touched her or made an unsolicited sexual comment; he merely asked if she’d like to come back to his room. She easily could have said (and I’m assuming did say), “No thanks, I’m tired and would like to go to my room to sleep.”

The key point RW intended to say in her initial video according to RW:
I had already expressed my desire to go to sleep. I also pointed out that approaching a single woman in an elevator to invite her back to your hotel room is the definition of “unsolicited sexual comment.” But those are unimportant details in comparison to the first quoted sentence, which demonstrates an ignorance of Feminism 101 –
(again, emphasis mine)



As Linda pointed out on the first page of this thread,
I still don't think I quite grasp what the complaint is.

Don't hit on people at conventions? (Sexism because men are more likely to do it than women?)

Don't hit on me when I'm tired? (Sexism because men are more likely to do the hitting and therefore more likely to do it when it's not appreciated?)

Don't hit on me in an elevator? (Sexism because a man would not feel as vulnerable in an enclosed space?) Would the story not be told had he asked her outside the bar?

And I don't quite grok the difference between sexual attraction (okay) and sexual objectification (not okay) in this case, as it sounded like he was indicating an attraction to her (if anything). PZ Meyers said something about men thinking it's okay to make proposals which women are obliged to turn down, which would make sense if women never hit on men. But when is it hitting on someone and when is it indicating attraction?

I have to get this straight because I have a son in college and I'm likely to screw it up, otherwise. Just today I made the mistake of suggesting that if he wants to meet people that share his interests he should consider joining a club. I now realize that if he happens to meet a woman there who he was attracted to who shared his interests, he might do something horribly sexist like ask her on a date.

Linda
It's amazing to me that point was made and 51 pages later it still isn't clear to a lot of people here and elsewhere why some of us see RW's reaction the way we do.
 
Last edited:
I re-read the initial post and the reply. If Humes fork is joking, it went right over my head.

The initial post was moderated, so pardon my gullability. Was it some reference to another thread? Given the newness of Hume, I assumed he was referencing this discussion.
I am the last one to ask about sarcasm. I get it wrong all the time. And since a mod also thought it was serious, I'm going to bow out. I thought it was funny.

BTW, if you were mistaken and reported it, that would explain the mod edit.
 
Last edited:
You are continuing to try and pull me into the debate which took place later over feminism. I'm satisfied to defend the notion that it's okay for a person to politely ask other people not to do something that makes them uncomfortable, particularly when compliance actually results in less net energy expenditure than noncompliance.

How much of a bully Rebecca is about feminism is yours to debate with anyone else; I'm not interested in the subject frankly and certainly don't know enough about it to argue for or against. As I indicated once, I don't read "skepchicks", or any skeptic blogs except Phil's to be honest (which is how I was alerted to this situation to begin with); I've never spoken with Watson or Dawkins, and have no idea about their histories re: feminism or misogyny. But as long as you contend that because you consider it unreasonable to feel uncomfortable about a certain situation, that's a good enough reason to deny a request from someone not to put them in that situation, I'm going to take exception.

Because I can't think that way. If someone tells me "such and such makes me uncomfortable", and it's something as mindlessly simple to acknowledge as "please don't hit on me in the elevator", I cannot bring myself to reply with "What? That's so stupid - I would never feel uncomfortable being hit on in an elevator; so screw your 'discomfort', request denied." I just can't.
 
Last edited:
....RD's straw response. ....
This depends on which of the 2 ways one takes RD's comments.

My take was RD used an extreme example using the contrast to illustrate how petty RW's complaint was. That is not a straw man.

If you read his comments as sarcasm because RW was claiming the incident was as bad as severe forms of discrimination, that would be a straw man.

I just don't see how the latter interpretation of RD's comments fits better than the former. And in fact, RD said as much in his subsequent comment:
Posted by: Richard Dawkins | July 2, 2011 11:35 AM
"Did you just make the argument that, since worse things are happening somewhere else, we have no right to try to fix things closer to home?"

No I wasn't making that argument. Here's the argument I was making. The man in the elevator didn't physically touch her, didn't attempt to bar her way out of the elevator, didn't even use foul language at her. He spoke some words to her. Just words. She no doubt replied with words. That was that. Words. Only words, and apparently quite polite words at that.
If she felt his behaviour was creepy, that was her privilege,...

...Muslim women suffer physically from misogyny, their lives are substantially damaged by religiously inspired misogyny. Not just words, real deeds, painful, physical deeds, physical privations, legally sanctioned demeanings. The equivalent would be if PZ had nailed not a cracker but a Catholic. Then they'd have had good reason to complain.
 
Then EG is guilty of objectifying. After a woman announced that she was exhausted and was going to her room to sleep, he followed her into the elevator and (politely!) requested that she come and entertain him instead.

See, Checkmite, this is why I hate participating in discussions like this, even on a skeptics forum. "Entertain him". Why would you phrase this exactly this way, without any evidence that this was his attitude, unless you had already made up your mind before this thread even started ?

And now, he isn't guilty of objectifying. The fact that he was both polite, and respectful of her response to him certainly indicates so.
 
...
Quick question for all - Do you feel there is any problem with sexism within the free-thought communities?
In my experience here in Seattle with the local skeptic and atheist groups that I see often, on the forum, and at one TAM, no. There are occasional sexist ad homs posted, but they are pretty insignificant on the whole.

Shermer seems like a bit of a womanizer when I've seen him on 3 different occasions, but I don't think that means anything other than he like pretty young women.
 
You are continuing to try and pull me into the debate which took place later over feminism. I'm satisfied to defend the notion that it's okay for a person to politely ask other people not to do something that makes them uncomfortable, particularly when compliance actually results in less net energy expenditure than noncompliance.

How much of a bully Rebecca is about feminism is yours to debate with anyone else; I'm not interested in the subject frankly and certainly don't know enough about it to argue for or against. As I indicated once, I don't read "skepchicks", or any skeptic blogs except Phil's to be honest (which is how I was alerted to this situation to begin with); I've never spoken with Watson or Dawkins, and have no idea about their histories re: feminism or misogyny. But as long as you contend that because you consider it unreasonable to feel uncomfortable about a certain situation, that's a good enough reason to deny a request from someone not to put them in that situation, I'm going to take exception.

Because I can't think that way. If someone tells me "such and such makes me uncomfortable", and it's something as mindlessly simple to acknowledge as "please don't hit on me in the elevator", I cannot bring myself to reply with "What? That's so stupid - I would never feel uncomfortable being hit on in an elevator; so screw your 'discomfort', request denied." I just can't.
Confirmation bias could explain your refusal to look at RW's own clarification of what she herself meant by her comments in the first video. I cannot ignore that clarification, especially since it confirms my impression of what she meant by "guys, don't do that".
 
The transcripts I've seen of her initial response all seem to show a request from her not to do that to her. If she said "this is why women aren't going to TAMs" or anything like that, it wasn't in the quotes anyone has posted on this thread.

Well it might be pedantry on my part or it might be that I read an incorrect transcript but my understanding was that she said 'I don't like that, so don't do it' [with an implied 'to anyone']

She then made some stab at telling people it was sexualisation. The follow up suggests that she sees a bigger issue than just whether something was or wasn't pleasant for her. Maybe I've misinterpreted.

Of course at any point she could have clarified what she meant without escalating things.

If her only claim was that she doesn't like it when people do X, and she'd prefer it if people didn't do X to her specifically then there wouldn't be much to argue about (except maybe why she thought we would care?)
 
How do you feel about playing the lottery?

Plenty of people play the lottery because there's much to gain even if the odds aren't good. So even if the odds were really low, I'd still expect some men to try their chances as he did, assuming sex is what he wanted.

But as we're confronted with posters who apparently don't care about the substante of other people's posts, let me help you a bit:

No. Objectifying is not caring about a person's feelings. Casual sex could be, in fact, taking them into account.

Which has NOTHING to do with what you eventually replied.

Asking people for sex isn't necessarily objectifying. I wouldn't even agree that it's objectifying most of the time. So why is EG described as objectifying Rebecca ?
 
Confirmation bias could explain your refusal to look at RW's own clarification of what she herself meant by her comments in the first video. I cannot ignore that clarification, especially since it confirms my impression of what she meant by "guys, don't do that".
\

No I read it; I considered it immaterial because she said it was something she should've added to the video (and therefore, wasn't in it), not a rephrasing of what was in the video.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom