So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Are you also unaware the initial video led to a video expressing a different opinion, a confrontation at another conference over the different opinion, and a full Skepchick blog commentary before the body waste hit the fan?

To be honest, the escalation thing puzzles me somewhat. To me these people are non-entities with the exception of RD who is the only one I would recognise in the street, but is it really an ego thing with them?

At any point anyone could have said 'this is getting silly now. I'm not necessarily apologising or changing my position but the reaction is way out of hand. Let's move on'

I think RD tried that a bit but unsuccessfully.

Maybe I'm just a bit of a luddite or not sufficiently into ubergeek/skeptic/online legend in your own lunchbox type blogs and videos but the original complaint seems about as useful a contribution to the 'skeptic debate' as tweeting that you 'just had a cup of tea and a biscuit...nom nom nom'

I think RD reacted to this in his typical slightly stuffy old man/headteachery way by more or less saying 'Oh FFS! Don't you anything more important than this to talk about?'

At that point, the conversation seems to have lost any link to the original event. Perhaps I'm wrong but that is how it looks to me anyway.

I appreciate this. But as much as it gives me the warm-fuzzies, unless Last of the Fraggles isn't a man, this just confirms that I am an Uncle Tom.

Linda

I'll take it back if you like;) I seriously hope it hasn't got to the point where anyone would start throwing terms like Uncle Tom in your direction over something as insignificant as this.
 
I'm in support of these guidelines being imposed at the workplace, and additionally I don't see anything wrong with any event organizer setting such guidelines in order to maintain a chosen atmosphere at their event if they wish.
Neither do I, but the workplace guidelines (under the assumption, which isn't really true, that there is one set of workplace guidelines) are not the TAM guidelines. The TAM guidelines (at least the one I quoted) are wishy-washy and vague. What do they mean "without invitation?" The real interpretation is in my first post in this thread: either no sex or advertise you are open to sex, but not vocally. So in effect, it's "no sex at TAM." Frankly, I can't believe they really mean that, which means they're just playing to the crowd.


Checkmite said:
If your motivation for attending TAM is to get some sex, I can see how this rule would make things inconvenient. The rule against "disparaging based on race, disability, sexual orientation" and the like, is similarly inconvenient for those who intended to go to TAM in order to exercise their Constitutional right to make fun of gay people. But TAM is a voluntary event; nobody is forced to attend to the exclusion of going somewhere else where making unwelcome sexual advances or making fun of gay people aren't against the "rules".
I don't disagree except for the highlighted word. The rules don't rule out "unwelcome" sexual advances. They rule out "uninvited" sexual advances. There is a significant difference.


Checkmite said:
If worse comes to worst and you go to TAM without sex on your mind at all, but by the second day suddenly you just got an itch that you're jonesing to scratch...dude, you're in Vegas. Walk outside; you'll find countless numbers of fellows offering any number of cards with numbers and addresses of strangers who are guaranteed to not be offended by your sexual advances.
What if I decide to break the rules and I make an uninvited sexual advance to a hot skepchick and she accepts? And what if you witness this or Grothe witnesses this? Are there repercussions?



Checkmite said:
It doesn't violate any rules that you agreed to follow by "attending" anything, no. You should however be prepared for the possibility that you might end up an example in someone's blog.
I accept that about everything I do and say. Likewise, the blogger should be prepared for the possibility that the blog comments or video might end up an example on some internet forum.
 
I appreciate this. But as much as it gives me the warm-fuzzies, unless Last of the Fraggles isn't a man, this just confirms that I am an Uncle Tom.

Linda
haint no shame in makin' sho da kids gits fed.

And with that, before the inevitable and unwarranted cries of racism and whatnot get leveled, I will depart the thread. It takes too much time.
 
That Ms. Watson was a victim of confirmation bias. She experienced a few things that she believed were consistent with a potential rape situation and was either ignorant of or ignored any that were not. ETA: Or those that were consistent with non-malevolent intent.

Confirmation bias? At what point did she accuse EG of being an assailant? She was worried beause of his behavior, that worry was justified because his behavior was objectively concerning given what we know about sexual assault, but nothing happened. She merely tried to explain why such actions caused here concern.

At no point did she infer from his behavior that he was a rapist. She simply said it was worrying.

The confirmation only came when he accepted her rejection. Before that point, the behavior was undefined.


The vast majority of time rapists who attack strangers subdue their victims with alcohol and/or drugs.

No, they take advantage of people who have been drinking. If they're the one administering the alcohol, they're not going to be strangers, at least in the way that term is defined for the purpose of these studies.

The statistics you cited involved alcohol used by the assailant or the victim or both. Again, this is an issue of opportunity.

I don't think 'acquaintance' means merely in the same room as the victim.

That is a non-response to my discussion on the subject.


Was Ms. Watson hammered or drugged? Had the guy in the lift bought her any drinks?

You need to read that article more carefully. The involvement of alcohol was not limited to an assailant consciously forcing alcohol into a victim.


Except that a lift in a 4 star hotel in Dublin with a woman capable of fighting back and/or screaming for help is not a particularly good opportunity to commit rape.

Again, by the time she's fighting back, an assault has already occurred.

But here we go again, fighting the same goddamn battles we had 40 pages ago. I linked a bevy of news articles about women who were assaulted and raped in elevators. There are literally hundreds if you just google the relevant terms. Many of these happened during the day in busy buildings. That moment of isolation is all an assailant needs, and once we're talking about fighting people off, we've gone too far.


The advice is that men need to take their sons and other men to task for thinking it's okay to sexually assault women, not that non-rapists need to tiptoe around women just in case they set off a woman's 'rapist alarm' with a clumsy proposition in a hotel elevator.

Yeah, you say "tip-toe" because you have, by your own admission, some ENORMOUS problems on this subject. Even so, you don't give yourself enough credit. As I said to a poster before, I doubt you will have to change your behavior in the least. Even thinking about this subject will likely put you in a place where you consider the well-being of the person you're talking to, and eliminate any chance that you're EG.

Again, unless you're sneaking up on women, ambushing them, or coldly propositioning them, this discussion doesn't involve you at all. You shouldn't be worried.
 
< snip >
Here's what bothers me. She [ed. RW] specifically called Dawkins out as not knowing what the heck he's talking about because he's too rich, white, and male to have an opinion.

Full stop.

Dawkins was sexually assaulted as a child. He did experience the kind of horrible sexual abuse that Rebecca Watson feared.


I<snip>It does put another interesting perspective on his reaction though. To someone who has actually been sexually assaulted, complaining about how being hit on in an elevator, plainly no less, being sexualization and objectification, is flat out insulting. Let's not go too overboard the way Dawkins did however; someone always has it worse so that's no reason to completely dismiss a complaint. I remember in college people sitting around talking about the abuse they went through, always starting the next sentence with, "That's nothing, listen to this..." as if it were a contest to see who hurt the worst.

In that light, it isn't surprising that it would push his button so, or that he would remain relatively silent after. This isn't to excuse his tone or dismissive manner, or the other flaws in reasoning.



This one?

Link: http://richarddawkins.net/articles/118

Happily I was spared the misfortune of a Roman Catholic upbringing (Anglicanism is a significantly less noxious strain of the virus). Being fondled by the Latin master in the Squash Court was a disagreeable sensation for a nine-year-old, a mixture of embarrassment and skin-crawling revulsion, but it was certainly not in the same league as being led to believe that I, or someone I knew, might go to everlasting fire. As soon as I could wriggle off his knee, I ran to tell my friends and we had a good laugh, our fellowship enhanced by the shared experience of the same sad pedophile. I do not believe that I, or they, suffered lasting, or even temporary damage from this disagreeable physical abuse of power. Given the Latin Master's eventual suicide, maybe the damage was all on his side.

FWIW, before I saw the quoted text from Dawkin's web site, I was expecting something far worse. I don't think Dawkin's experience should be dismissed but I don't think its the type of experience that gives him martyr trump rights over everyone else's experiences and opinions.

The main thing I note about his experience was that he and his friends did not hide it but shared it among themselves and were able to give each other the "hey we're OK, that guy is the weird one" validation. Also it occurred in the "squash court", isn't it likely that whatever occurred occurred out in the open than in secret?

Fondling can mean almost anything including pats on the fanny from adults whose hands have no business wandering there and especially if we are talking about a one or two time thing, than probably every child in the USA has been sexually assaulted.

Its still not right, but ... still in the absence of additional information, I think adding this to the discussion is almost a non sequitur. RD had written about childhood fondling that he experienced, therefore no one can blog about something that makes them uncomfortable? :confused: Which was the original issue.
 
Last edited:
You certainly have noticed, there's a number of different discussions going on in this thread at the moment. When I came into this thread, you folks had already turned the fact of RW's discomfort during the initial incident, and how "reasonable" or justified it was, into a legitimate point of debate; and that is part of the discussion I've chosen to engage in for my part. Whether Watson argued about feminism with others after the fact has no bearing on the topic of solicitations for sex, and accompanying discomfort. If Watson's later arguments about misogyny have been completely and fully unreasonable, that doesn't mean her initial discomfort becomes indefensible or dismissible.
(emphasis mine)

RW's initial response was that EG's come on was an example of objectifying women and a reason women shied away from skeptical events. That was unreasonable on a number of levels.

Your attempt to backpedal is a fail. You missed part of RW's initial response, it isn't that we were adding later stuff to the mix.
 
Are you also unaware the initial video led to a video expressing a different opinion, a confrontation at another conference over the different opinion, and a full Skepchick blog commentary before the body waste hit the fan?

What video expressing a different opinion, are you talking about?
 
Link: http://richarddawkins.net/articles/118



FWIW, before I saw the quoted text from Dawkin's web site, I was expecting something far worse. I don't think Dawkin's experience should be dismissed but I don't think its the type of experience that gives him martyr trump rights over everyone else's experiences and opinions.

The main thing I note about his experience was that he and his friends did not hide it but shared it among themselves and were able to give each other the "hey we're OK, that guy is the weird one" validation. Also it occurred in the "squash court", isn't it likely that whatever occurred occurred out in the open than in secret?

Fondling can mean almost anything including pats on the fanny from adults whose hands have no business wandering there and especially if we are talking about a one or two time thing, than probably every child in the USA has been sexually assaulted.

Its still not right, but ... still in the absence of additional information, I think adding this to the discussion is almost a non sequitur. RD had written about childhood fondling that he experienced, therefore no one can blog about something that makes them uncomfortable? :confused: Which was the original issue.

My point is to contradict Rebecca Watson's ad hominem, "Thanks, wealthy old heterosexual white man!" Nothing about those privileges makes his opinion irrelevant and if Dawkins can put a legitimate example of sex abuse into some perspective, maybe Watson should, too.
 
Of course not! I argue with Google. It actually answers back.

Regarding objectification though, seeing Rebecca as useful for her lady bits, reducing her use to them, would be objectification and sexualization. This assumes that EG really did want sex, which for the sake of argument I've been discussing as if it were a given, and that the reason he wanted sex with her was only because she had lady bits. The reason he brought up for 'coffee' was that he found the conversation interesting. So if EG was objectifying her, the object he was reducing her down to was her mind. I find this notion hilariously ironic if true.

I don't expect you to know my point and my point alone but what initiated that exchange was a quote in an argument where I did specifically state that I found the statement to be ambiguous. I was challenging multiple points in one post.
 
Its probably best for everyone, men and women, not to place themselves in a vulnerable situation with a stranger, at least not until a stranger turns into an acquaintance. ;)

Yep. Risk management.

Yet if one takes a look at the statistics, I'm pretty sure far more women are attacked and raped by acquaintances and partners than strangers. This is probably because rapists are intelligent opponents and adapt to the techniques women use to screen men.

It seems many (but not all) of the things women do to reduce risk are akin to a tennis player who always bounces the ball three times before serving on a big point.

Your response leaves me almost speechless. I'm glad Tranewreck has the patience to respond to you.

So I'll limit my response to I agree with his analogy of car accidents occurring more frequently near one's home. I gather that since you know that you wouldn't bother to drive in a maintained car with seat belts and operating lights, etc for any trip far away from home but drive in any wreck as you please. Fine, have a good time.
 
Confirmation bias? At what point did she accuse EG of being an assailant? She was worried beause of his behavior, that worry was justified because his behavior was objectively concerning given what we know about sexual assault, but nothing happened. She merely tried to explain why such actions caused here concern.

At no point did she infer from his behavior that he was a rapist. She simply said it was worrying.

The confirmation only came when he accepted her rejection. Before that point, the behavior was undefined.
<snip>

Right. At what point does a man in an elevator trigger thoughts "he may be a rapist" in a woman?

For example, should a 'strange' man even talk to a woman in an elevator?

Yeah, you say "tip-toe" because you have, by your own admission, some ENORMOUS problems on this subject. Even so, you don't give yourself enough credit. As I said to a poster before, I doubt you will have to change your behavior in the least. Even thinking about this subject will likely put you in a place where you consider the well-being of the person you're talking to, and eliminate any chance that you're EG.

Again, unless you're sneaking up on women, ambushing them, or coldly propositioning them, this discussion doesn't involve you at all. You shouldn't be worried.

Really? I'm trying to figure out what it is about me that women find unnerving or unattractive. I'm sure several women on the forum consider me a misogynist for my views on human behaviour. Many others probably find me dull and/or an idiot. Perhaps I'm giving off rapist vibes and I don't know it?
 
I don't expect you to know my point and my point alone but what initiated that exchange was a quote in an argument where I did specifically state that I found the statement to be ambiguous. I was challenging multiple points in one post.

Oh, I was only using your response as a jumping off point, and it wasn't a criticism of what you said. That's a bad habit of mine and I normally separate when I do that with a long line.

______________________________________________

It's so damn hot outside. At least it isn't raining.
 
Busy taking care of an awesome dog (whooza good boy, you are! Walkies in 30 seconds, ok?) so can't really chat.

Quick question for all - Do you feel there is any problem with sexism within the free-thought communities?

(walkies!)
 
(emphasis mine)

RW's initial response was that EG's come on was an example of objectifying women and a reason women shied away from skeptical events. That was unreasonable on a number of levels.

Your attempt to backpedal is a fail. You missed part of RW's initial response, it isn't that we were adding later stuff to the mix.

The transcripts I've seen of her initial response all seem to show a request from her not to do that to her. If she said "this is why women aren't going to TAMs" or anything like that, it wasn't in the quotes anyone has posted on this thread.
 
Right. At what point does a man in an elevator trigger thoughts "he may be a rapist" in a woman?

Well, since a whole lot of women have been trying to explain this for the past couple weeks (and longer than that Before Watson, BW), I would suggest reading what they're saying.

Notice that these boundries will not be uniform. We have a wide variety of opinions on this forum, alone.

For example, should a 'strange' man even talk to a woman in an elevator?

That depends on the situation, all other things being equal, there's no real reason he can't chat. He should realize the setting and, not for example, proposition the woman with his first words.

I know, I know, this is an impossible standard. When I run into women in elevators, I might look over and see that they have a college name on their sweatshirt. I will then think to myself, yes, ask her about this college, but invariably, I just blurt out, "DO YOU SHAVE YOUR BIKINI LINE?!?"

It's so hard to find a topic other than something overtly sexual when isolated in an elevator with a woman. Truly the burden is more than anyone should be expected to bear.


Really? I'm trying to figure out what it is about me that women find unnerving or unattractive. I'm sure several women on the forum consider me a misogynist for my views on human behaviour. Many others probably find me dull and/or an idiot. Perhaps I'm giving off rapist vibes and I don't know it?

That's a big leap from "uninterested" to "they must think I'm a rapist."

Look, I know for a fact that you realize aspects of EG's behavior was concerning. That's why everytime you create an analogy to your own behavior--"so you're saying if I walk up and..."--you eliminate aspects of EG's factual situation because you know how absurd it will sound.

I don't know what to tell you on a personal level. I know the best way to ensure you will never be interesting to women is to lash out at them in anger for ignoring you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom