So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
<snip>

We could get into the actually studies on rapist behavior and deal with the approach in some detail, but subtlety is clearly not welcome in this setting, so what's the point? Recall that no one has accused EG of being a rapist, just that his behavior was concerning. It was concerning because it matched, quite closely, many of the common behavioral elements that rapists engage in (yes, that was contained in a link already).

There's a huge problem with that type of reasoning, which is that many of the common behavioural elements that rapists engage in are also engaged in by non-rapists. It's the same mistake people who go to the doctor convinced they have the symptoms of a terrible disease they read about on the internet make.

Let's try to work our way through some elementary reasoning on this.

What is the driving factor behid acquaintance rape outnumbering stranger rape? Is it the fact that once you get to know someone, the urge to rape grows? Is it because rapists don't want people to think they're sluts?

Or is it an issue of opportunity? If two people are acquainted, they are likely to find themselves alone. The victim (be it man or woman) will be more likely to voluntarily let their guard down and make themselves vulnerable.

NOtice the situation in the elevator: that opportunity is present.

Opportunity for physical assault is present anytime one person is alone with another. The vast majority of times both part company without having a violent altercation.

Acquanitance rape tends to be numerically superior for the exact same reason most auto accidents occur close to one's home--there is simply more opportunity for an incident to occur.

Thus, if that opportunity is supplied, the calculation becomes quite different. Perhaps someone has done a statistical analysis of stranger vs. acquaintance rape holding the variable of opportunity constant, but I haven't seen it. It would be interesting.

http://yesmeansyesblog.wordpress.com/2009/11/12/meet-the-predators/

Finally, in an entirely unsurprising finding, rapists who admitted assaulting strangers – ever – were less than a quarter of the rapist population. More than 90% targeted acquaintances some of the time, and about 75% said they only targeted acquaintances. Only 7% of all the self-reported rapists reported targeting only strangers. And, in fact, there was zero overlap between the men who said they targeted starangers, and those who used only force.
 
Last edited:
Is it bad that I think that her initial complaints are valid? ...
Griping you didn't like the guy in the elevator is fine as far as that went. Making it a feminist cause claiming said elevator behavior was the kind of thing keeping women away from atheist and skeptical events .... not so fine.
 
Yet if one takes a look at the statistics, I'm pretty sure far more women are attacked and raped by acquaintances and partners than strangers. This is probably because rapists are intelligent opponents and adapt to the techniques women use to screen men.

It seems many (but not all) of the things women do to reduce risk are akin to a tennis player who always bounces the ball three times before serving on a big point.
I was with you until you said things which help one avoid stranger rape were useless because they didn't address the more common partner assault and date rape. Surely you can see your logic fail there?
 
There's a huge problem with that type of reasoning, which is that many of the common behavioural elements that rapists engage in are also engaged in by non-rapists. It's the same mistake people who go to the doctor convinced they have the symptoms of a terrible disease they read about on the internet make.

That makes little sense. If I have symptoms of a terrible disease, I will go to the doctor. I don't just think, "well, it's possible that this is nothing, so I'll just ignore it." Acting reasonably and proportionally based upon the nature of the evidence is exactly what Watson did. She didn't scream, she didn't call the police, she didn't pre-emptively declare that she had "cancer," she calmly handled the situation then offered a short statement explaining why that situation was off-putting. Perfectly reasonable behavior (I won't defend her beyond that).

I can't imagine what you thought you were proving.


Opportunity for physical assault is present anytime one person is alone with another. The vast majority of times both part company without having a violent altercation.

The vast majority of the time one stranger doesn't proposition another. You just can't resist the urge to shave away relevant facts.


What's the definition of "acquaintance?"

as Bechhofer and Parrot point out it is not always possible to categorize all incidents of forced sex as acquaintance rape or stranger rape. For example, how do you categorize a woman who met an assailant ten minutes prior to the assault?
http://lmsurratt.tripod.com/section3.htm

Rebecca Watson "knew" EG. She was able to say he was at the bar, was at her talk, I don't know how this sort of situation would be dealt with in the statistics.

Certainly from EG's perspective, Watson wasn't a stranger. Because that article was composed of self-reporting surveys from college students and members of the Navy, it's impossible to determine if EG "knew" Watson for the purpose of those statistics.

It should also be pointed out that alcohol was a huge factor for almost all of the self-reporters:

61% of the reported attacks were intoxication-based, 23% were overt force alone, and 16% were both.

That article gives us very little insight into the actual statistical threat faced by Watson. It's also not quite on point with my argument. You have a raw number of people who target acquainances vs. strangers, but no explanation why. The survey merely asked whether they raped or assaulted a stranger or acquaintance, it said very little about why they made that choice. That survey is perfectly consistent with my claim concerning opportunity.

Given the nature of your position on this, I found the author's conclusion of the paper you cited interesting:

I’m directing this to men who inhabit het-identified social spaces, and I’m not really limiting it more than that. Women are already doing what they can to prevent rape; brokering a peace with the fear is part of their lives that we can never fully understand. We’re the ones who are not doing our jobs.

Uh oh, dude, he's telling you that men need to get their **** together. Scary stuff.
 
Last edited:
Don't take this the wrong way is an indicator that he knew it was potentially going to be taken the wrong way. It's just an answer to the question, "How was EG supposed to know?" The question is irrelevant because apparently he already knew. Now, any forewarning that something has the potential to be offensive, doesn't not automatically negate the offensiveness of the statement.
So many ways to interpret words....

EG could have known his offer could or even would be seen as a come on. That doesn't say anything about how he was supposed to know RW would be annoyed by a come on.
 
You're joining my argument in the middle, and thus without context. Richard Dawkins' comment that Watson was overreacting (or his support of others complaining that Watson was overreacting, whichever the case may be) was made after Watson's first video. Therefore, they can only have been referring to her first video as an overreaction. The "more she's written since then" didn't come until afterwards, and were responses not to the original incident but to those suggestions that asking strangers not to hit on her was "needless drama" or what have you.
Wrong. RD's comments followed RW's comments at another conference, another Skepchick post and PZ's blog. Catch up.
 
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_8LAOBexgxg&feature=related

7:35 in to the video, Ms Watson speaks about hate mail, and what brings it.

" is when we discuss feminist topics and we get a lot of hate mail from male skeptics who think that they, who think women don't need or deserve a voice of their own"

She goes on to talk in a lucid manner about the issues. You haters need to get a life. Or at least get laid.
 
That's funny, I was thinking the same thing about a three week debate sparked by a single woman who said, "Don't do that...it makes me uncomfortable." Sounds rather reasonable not much like a hissy fit. Ironic, though, isn't it?
Are you also unaware the initial video led to a video expressing a different opinion, a confrontation at another conference over the different opinion, and a full Skepchick blog commentary before the body waste hit the fan?
 
Are you also unaware the initial video led to a video expressing a different opinion, a confrontation at another conference over the different opinion, and a full Skepchick blog commentary before the body waste hit the fan?

Just curious SG, <SNIP>

Edited by Locknar: 
Edited, breach of rule 12; address the argument not attack the arguer.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
... fls and bookitty are getting a lot more flack than either deserves for example.....
Bookitty is mostly getting flack for setting up straw men. If you have an example of that demonstrates otherwise, feel free to link to it or even just give the post number.

If you think one of the straw men she posted was legit, I'll be happy to discuss it further.
 
You haters need to get a life.

Watson acted like a bully by calling out a student audience member during an unrelated keynote speech. She has improperly characterized reasonable opposition opinions as "misogynist".
In other words, her behavior (not her) has been reasonably called out, and her defenders unreasonably dismissed the criticisms.
 
On the positive side, the one person who comes out of this with improved credibility (at least for me) is our very own fls who I think has shown a level-headed response in this thread.

For the record, I find that fls is the person with whom I am most in agreement in this thread, and like her I find that the missed opportunity to actually discuss the broader topics of underrepresentation of women at skeptic events and of sexism in the skeptic community is sad.

I appreciate this. But as much as it gives me the warm-fuzzies, unless Last of the Fraggles isn't a man, this just confirms that I am an Uncle Tom.

Linda
 
While I certainly agree that people ran with this one, I also find it odd that you could come to conclusions about her "real" motives in her reaction, and then show how funny it is that 4 million other blogs can pick up something and run with it, mold it to fit their reality...."

Well again, indeed. Had I actually come to any conclusions and not just pointed out what her reaction 'suggested'. Had she been clearer in her message we wouldn't have to speculate.

She also could have responded the way you suggested but to be fair, other people could have just responed, "I may not have felt threatened but I wasn't there..."

I'm not sure whether or not she felt threatened is really the crux of the matter. If it is, then again she made a poor job of making that clear.
 
No. Objectifying is not caring about a person's feelings. Casual sex could be, in fact, taking them into account.

Then EG is guilty of objectifying. After a woman announced that she was exhausted and was going to her room to sleep, he followed her into the elevator and (politely!) requested that she come and entertain him instead. That seems to me like a very marked disregard for Watson's just-expressed feelings...even if his offer of "coffee and conversation" really was exactly what it said on the tin.
 
You don't argue with your computer? :D

Of course not! I argue with Google. It actually answers back.

Regarding objectification though, seeing Rebecca as useful for her lady bits, reducing her use to them, would be objectification and sexualization. This assumes that EG really did want sex, which for the sake of argument I've been discussing as if it were a given, and that the reason he wanted sex with her was only because she had lady bits. The reason he brought up for 'coffee' was that he found the conversation interesting. So if EG was objectifying her, the object he was reducing her down to was her mind. I find this notion hilariously ironic if true.
 
That makes little sense. If I have symptoms of a terrible disease, I will go to the doctor. I don't just think, "well, it's possible that this is nothing, so I'll just ignore it." Acting reasonably and proportionally based upon the nature of the evidence is exactly what Watson did. She didn't scream, she didn't call the police, she didn't pre-emptively declare that she had "cancer," she calmly handled the situation then offered a short statement explaining why that situation was off-putting. Perfectly reasonable behavior (I won't defend her beyond that).

I can't imagine what you thought you were proving.

That Ms. Watson was a victim of confirmation bias. She experienced a few things that she believed were consistent with a potential rape situation and was either ignorant of or ignored any that were not. ETA: Or those that were consistent with non-malevolent intent.

The vast majority of the time one stranger doesn't proposition another. You just can't resist the urge to shave away relevant facts.

The vast majority of time rapists who attack strangers subdue their victims with alcohol and/or drugs.

Anecdotally, this is consistent with what happened to my sister some years ago in a bar. Fortunately she managed to escape before the drug took full effect.

What's the definition of "acquaintance?"


http://lmsurratt.tripod.com/section3.htm

Rebecca Watson "knew" EG. She was able to say he was at the bar, was at her talk, I don't know how this sort of situation would be dealt with in the statistics.



Certainly from EG's perspective, Watson wasn't a stranger. Because that article was composed of self-reporting surveys from college students and members of the Navy, it's impossible to determine if EG "knew" Watson for the purpose of those statistics.

I don't think 'acquaintance' means merely in the same room as the victim.

It should also be pointed out that alcohol was a huge factor for almost all of the self-reporters:

Was Ms. Watson hammered or drugged? Had the guy in the lift bought her any drinks?

That article gives us very little insight into the actual statistical threat faced by Watson. It's also not quite on point with my argument. You have a raw number of people who target acquainances vs. strangers, but no explanation why. The survey merely asked whether they raped or assaulted a stranger or acquaintance, it said very little about why they made that choice. That survey is perfectly consistent with my claim concerning opportunity.

Except that a lift in a 4 star hotel in Dublin with a woman capable of fighting back and/or screaming for help is not a particularly good opportunity to commit rape.

Given the nature of your position on this, I found the author's conclusion of the paper you cited interesting:



Uh oh, dude, he's telling you that men need to get their **** together. Scary stuff.

The advice is that men need to take their sons and other men to task for thinking it's okay to sexually assault women, not that non-rapists need to tiptoe around women just in case they set off a woman's 'rapist alarm' with a clumsy proposition in a hotel elevator.
 
Last edited:
Is there a point to cherry picking only the first video? RD's comments were not next in the sequence of events. Nothing happened until RW called out some video blogger by name at the CFI Student Leadership Conference. That's when the fan started flinging excrement.

You certainly have noticed, there's a number of different discussions going on in this thread at the moment. When I came into this thread, you folks had already turned the fact of RW's discomfort during the initial incident, and how "reasonable" or justified it was, into a legitimate point of debate; and that is part of the discussion I've chosen to engage in for my part. Whether Watson argued about feminism with others after the fact has no bearing on the topic of solicitations for sex, and accompanying discomfort. If Watson's later arguments about misogyny have been completely and fully unreasonable, that doesn't mean her initial discomfort becomes indefensible or dismissible.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom