Snappy Retorts To Lame Excuses For Not Taking The Challenge

jzs said:
So let me see... you are saying someone who asked for evidence is a troll, but someone who makes a claim and doesn't provide it, then wishes you'd drown and choke is not a troll.

Funny world you live in, Zep.
Did you come here for the 10 minute argument? Or is it the full half hour.
 
jzs said:
kookbreaker

I am asking Kimpatsu to provide evidence of his claim. That is obviously wanting an answer, one that Kimpatsu claimed exists. [/B]

Confirmation can be easily made with a simple email.

This is only a problem because you insist upon making it one.
 
Kimpatsu said:
You're still not paying attention. Yo uasked for help to find the quote. I gave you an approximate date. But you're too bloody lazy to look it up. You make me sick. I'm never going to help you for anything again; I hope you're drowning, just so I can walk past the riverbank and not do anything.
Prick.

You made the claim, Kimpatsu.

That's bout it,.
 
CFLarsen said:
So, email Randi and see what he says.

Kimpatsu's claim was about the audio file. If he'd like to provide evidence of it, he knows he has already been invited to, numerous times.
 
jzs said:
Kimpatsu's claim was about the audio file. If he'd like to provide evidence of it, he knows he has already been invited to, numerous times.

If you are interested in the answer, it is far easier to email Randi than to keep posting here.
 
finding the answers

Sort of related to the OP ---

When someone (anyone) gets into a closed loop of looking for "sources" and "evidence" of something offered here, and the one who originally made the claim cannot (or will not) provide further details, then maybe it does become the responsibility of the one seeking answers to try a little harder to investigate and research the claim.

We have all seen this:
"You claimed such and such, so YOU have to prove it"

This goes for anything, not just the forums.
Not every discussion or claim made needs to be treated by the same rules as the Million Dollar Challenge.

I got into this once with another member, in a political forum, and it was amazing to me that he insisted in asking for 'sources' of a major event that was being covered on all the media outlets and was at the top five results of every major internet search engine that day when searched-for.

To paraphrase what I was told:
"You made the claim, I asked for sources, I don't have to search for anything, you need to provide them."

At some point, we each have to take personal responsibility and get the answers to life's minor mysteries on our own, without resorting to tactics such as laziness and indifference when we really are capable of finding out stuff on our own.

And sharing the results is so satisfying!

[/end rant]
 
Re: finding the answers

webfusion said:
Sort of related to the OP ---

When someone (anyone) gets into a closed loop of looking for "sources" and "evidence" of something offered here, and the one who originally made the claim cannot (or will not) provide further details, then maybe it does become the responsibility of the one seeking answers to try a little harder to investigate and research the claim.

We have all seen this:
"You claimed such and such, so YOU have to prove it"

This goes for anything, not just the forums.
Not every discussion or claim made needs to be treated by the same rules as the Million Dollar Challenge.

I got into this once with another member, in a political forum, and it was amazing to me that he insisted in asking for 'sources' of a major event that was being covered on all the media outlets and was at the top five results of every major internet search engine that day when searched-for.

To paraphrase what I was told:
"You made the claim, I asked for sources, I don't have to search for anything, you need to provide them."

At some point, we each have to take personal responsibility and get the answers to life's minor mysteries on our own, without resorting to tactics such as laziness and indifference when we really are capable of finding out stuff on our own.

And sharing the results is so satisfying!

[/end rant]


The point is, jzs isn't really looking for the information. He isn't asking for the source because he want's to read or listen to it. He's just being a troll. He's pushing all of your buttons, and taking delight in your reactions.
 
Re: Re: finding the answers

Gr8wight said:
The point is, jzs isn't really looking for the information. He isn't asking for the source because he want's to read or listen to it. He's just being a troll. He's pushing all of your buttons, and taking delight in your reactions.

It's a pattern with Justin/jzs/T'ai Chi/Whodini. E.g., he once tried to get people to provide him with transcripts of psychic readings, so he could do statistical analyses of them on a webpage he would create. On the webpage, there would also be a critique of two papers he asked other people's opinions of, while refusing to say what he thought of them himself.

Nothing happened. We couldn't even see the transcripts people had found for him.

Justin goes on fishing expeditions, so he can criticize other people's arguments. He never contributes to any debate.

Source
 
Re: Re: finding the answers

Gr8wight said:
The point is, jzs isn't really looking for the information. He isn't asking for the source because he want's to read or listen to it. He's just being a troll. He's pushing all of your buttons, and taking delight in your reactions.

Kimpatsu made a claim. I asked him for the evidence is is sure exists.
 
Re: Re: Re: finding the answers

CFLarsen said:
It's a pattern with Justin/jzs/T'ai Chi/Whodini. E.g., he once tried to get people to provide him with transcripts of psychic readings, so he could do statistical analyses of them on a webpage he would create. On the webpage, there would also be a critique of two papers he asked other people's opinions of, while refusing to say what he thought of them himself.

Nothing happened. We couldn't even see the transcripts people had found for him.


As mentioned already, not too many people volunteered. In a large project, that needs volunteers (to find transcripts and multiple people to rate them, so we can see agreement), and there are few, the project won't get off the ground, and this one didn't. As far as you, you didn't want to volunteer for the project, Claus, therefore it makes no sense at all for you to see transcripts, data, etc., before the project even starts, if you have nothing whatsoever to do with anything. You still haven't answered the question of 'can you name any project where data etc is released to any party who asks, even before the project is completed' ? You couldn't then, and you can't now, but somehow I am held to a different standard.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: finding the answers

jzs said:
Kimpatsu made a claim. I asked him for the evidence is is sure exists.

Why do you need to see the evidence?
 
jzs said:
As mentioned already, not too many people volunteered. In a large project, that needs volunteers (to find transcripts and multiple people to rate them, so we can see agreement), and there are few, the project won't get off the ground, and this one didn't. As far as you, you didn't want to volunteer for the project, Claus, therefore it makes no sense at all for you to see transcripts, data, etc., before the project even starts, if you have nothing whatsoever to do with anything. You still haven't answered the question of 'can you name any project where data etc is released to any party who asks, even before the project is completed' ? You couldn't then, and you can't now, but somehow I am held to a different standard.

Yes, you can bitch, moan and whine as you usually do, but it doesn't change the facts one whit:

You used other people, Justin.

Why can't we see the 20-something transcripts that people found for you?
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: finding the answers

CFLarsen said:
Why do you need to see the evidence?

I'm curious about it.

Kimpatsu claimed it existed. When asked to provided the actual evidence, he can't (as of yet).
 
CFLarsen said:
Yes, you can bitch, moan and whine as you usually do, but it doesn't change the facts one whit:

You used other people, Justin.

Why can't we see the 20-something transcripts that people found for you?

The tone and language of your interpretation is your usual dramatic self.

I asked for interested volunteers, that's all.

The transcripts? As mentioned, these were found on common sites, CNN, and so forth, where live readings were done.

And, as usualy, you utterly ran from my challenge. Claus:

Can you name any project where data etc is released to any party who asks, even before the project is completed?

Still waiting..
 
jzs said:
The tone and language of your interpretation is your usual dramatic self.

I asked for interested volunteers, that's all.

The transcripts? As mentioned, these were found on common sites, CNN, and so forth, where live readings were done.

And, as usualy, you utterly ran from my challenge. Claus:

Can you name any project where data etc is released to any party who asks, even before the project is completed?

Still waiting..

Your "challenge"?? Just who do you think you are?

Why can't we see the 20-something transcripts that people found for you?
 
Zep said:
Did you come here for the 10 minute argument? Or is it the full half hour.
This isn't an argument.

Argument is an intellectual process. Contradiction is just the automatic gainsaying of any statement the other person makes.
 
CFLarsen said:
Your "challenge"?? Just who do you think you are?


Anyone can make a challenge, Claus. Anyone can also run from them, which you are demonstrating.


Why can't we see the 20-something transcripts that people found for you?

As I've mentioned, transcripts of live readings, like on Larry King Live, stuff like http://edition.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0301/10/lkl.00.html for example.

Now, please answer for my question, which you attempt to dodge yet again:

Claus, can you name any project where data etc is released to any party who asks, even before the project is completed?

Still waiting, bucko. Else, you're asking me to conform to higher standards than anyone anywhere is held to.
 
CFLarsen said:
Why?

Do you doubt that it exists?

What does it mean to you?

Yawn. You asking questions ad nauseum doesn't change the fact that Kimpatsu made the claim, and when asked for specific evidence, he can't (as of yet) produce it.

I haev to explain why I am curious? You'd think me being curious would be obvious since I posted the original link to Rawling's claim of Randi supposedly saying that he always has an out. After Kimpatsu made his claim, I was curious the hear the audio he claimed existed.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom