Snappy Retorts To Lame Excuses For Not Taking The Challenge

Peter Morris said:
People are asked why they don't take Randi's challenge. They reply : I tried to negotiate with him, I was unable to agree on a suitable protocol with him.


Of the Examples given you have shown a dowser who had trouble with the Australian skeptics, but was still in negotiations with Kramer when he withdrew. Poor example, since negotiations were still in progress.

You included John Benneth, with whom a protocol was properly negotiated. But Benneth was negotiating in bad faith. Poor example.

You even have listed yourself. But by your own admission you had not the powers you claimed. You were negotiating in bad faith. Poor example.


But that excuse sounds reasonable. Larsen only wants 'lame' excuses, so he refuses to include that one. He doesn't want to acknowledge that people might havea valid reason for not taking Randi's test.

Unproven by you. But feel free to write your own article. Its seems that Bruce Kettler has passed on, maybe you can take up the Benneth torch.
 
kookbreaker said:

You even have listed yourself. But by your own admission you had not the powers you claimed. You were negotiating in bad faith. Poor example.
.

The Kook is lying again.

I never claimed "powers."


What a deluded moron.
 
Wrong , but also irrelevant. The point is that you were trying to take a challenge designed to find alleged powers without even the benefit of believing that you had such abilities. You were attempting an end-run. When Randi figured that out, he cut off negotiations.

You were negotiating in bad faith.
 
kookbreaker said:
Wrong , but also irrelevant. The point is that you were trying to take a challenge designed to find alleged powers without even the benefit of believing that you had such abilities. You were attempting an end-run. When Randi figured that out, he cut off negotiations.

You were negotiating in bad faith.

Bull. You'e lying again.

I have never made false claims, unlike you. I have never claimed a paranormal ability, nor any ability that I don't have.
 
Well, you are making the claim that people said these things. It's up to you to supply the proof. The fact that you have admitted your inability to provide cites speaks volumes.
This isn't a claim for the JREF prize (or any sort of prize). If we were trying to prove this for monetary reward or to the world in general then, yes we would hunt around and find the quotes. Just for you Peter? No.
I think none of you have ever seen this. You only have hearsay that someone made these excuse. And you have deluded yourselves into thinking you've seen it first hand. Randi fans have a great capacity for self-delusion.
Generalisation, assumption, unfounded claims... hang on don't you HATE all those things Peter? Aren't they exactly what you're moaning about? Aren't you being a hypocrite here?
Don't try to tell me what I have or haven't read because you start to look even more foolish and embittered than you already do.
That isn't exactly what he said. He said he tested himself under the conditions offered bt Kramer, and couldn't get it to work under those precise conditions. He still thinks he can dowse, under different conditions, but knows he won't succeed in Randi's test.
Well let's just see what the man ACTUALLY said himself (before going through the Peter Morris Magical Reinterpretation Mincing Machine):
I was very confident that I could dowse sulfide mineralisation under all conditions but today I did an extensive blind-fold test with work colleagues and the results were all over the place.

Candour in this situation is probably the best approach. I am not ready to submit to a test and so I am forced to withdraw my challenge, or, at least, postpone it. I am, however, still intrigued by dowsing.
No criticism of Kramer or the request. Merely a failure under conditions conducted by his own work colleagues.
What you mean by "precise conditions" Peter? That he can't look at the terrain? Is that an unreasonable request?
He also declares that he needs to investigate more as to whether he can dowse or not - he feels he is on the right track but needs to investigate further.
There is nothing in his statements or inference that it is Randi (or anyone else's) unfair restrictions that are making him fail. You will remember that it was nothing to do with any sceptic organisation tha he failed his own test.

Larsen has highlighted the 'lame' excuses. His article isn't a serious attempt to examine the reason why people refuse Randi's test. It is a dishonest attempt to make Randi's opponents look 'lame.' So, he highlights the 'lame' excuses, and refuses to include those that sound more reasonable. Larsen isn't interested in truth or accuracy - he just wants another fawning article saying how great Randi is, and how lame his opponents are. To acheive this end he has slanted the facts, and omitted the ones that contradict him.
Well it's his article to slant however he wishes. He does not claim to be writing EVERY excuse put down, he is just detailing some of the more interesting and controversial ones.
"I withdraw because I can't actually do it when I tested myself" would actually make the applicants look pretty lame anyway (why don't they try this before applying).
Would adding this to the list make the claimants look any less foolish? I don't think so. Maybe slightly less fraudulent, but it wouldn't alter the tone of the list in any particular way.
 
Peter Morris said:

I have never made false claims, unlike you. I have never claimed a paranormal ability, nor any ability that I don't have.

Then why were you applying for a challenge specifically made for testing paranormal abilities?
 
kookbreaker said:
That's just plain sad.

Better Link here

Thanks, kookbreaker, I was trying to find the full thread, but only came up with that cached bit. It is sad, isn't it, but it is also clear nobody bought his concern-for-JREF ruse.

Slinker likes hobbitses, yesssssss.
 
Peter Morris said:


That isn't exactly what he said. He said he tested himself under the conditions offered bt Kramer, and couldn't get it to work under those precise conditions. He still thinks he can dowse, under different conditions, but knows he won't succeed in Randi's test.


Well, i think you did not describe what he said either, because in the challenge application i read:

"Dear Carl,
Please suggest a test protocol that you feel can best and most easily verify your sulfide mineralization claim. - KRAMER, JREF
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Dear Kramer,
I will need to be taken to areas where there is known sulfide mineralization but be denied any information as to its location. I will probably have to be blindfolded, because even the location of blind deposits (mineralization with no surface expression) might be guessed from the distribution of surface hole drills.

A panel of independent geologists could be formed to select appropriate test sites. Western Australia is well endowed with gold, nickel, copper and zinc mineralization and would be an ideal place to do the test. There is also a large community of exploration and mining geologists in Perth for you to chose from, and who would be very interested in the results. - Carl Brauhart

=============================================="

So Kramer did not suggest any test protocol for the mineral dowsing, he asks for one the claimant thinks good, the claimant gives some ideas and based on his own ideas the claimant makes and fails a test.

So correct version of your above statement is "He said he tested himself under the conditions offered bt himself, and couldn't get it to work under those precise conditions."

Carn
 
Peter Morris said:
Play stupid word games all you like, it's not going to change the facts.

Word games? There are no word games here.

Brauhart was very specific: He himself designed a test, which he failed.

Do you still stand by your claim that he was tested under conditions "offered" by Kramer?

Why were you applying for a challenge specifically made for testing paranormal abilities?

Why did you feel the need to check on what you thought was the illegality of Randi starting a lawsuit?

Is it fair to say that you bear a grudge against JREF and Randi in particular?
 
More laughs from PM

Peter Morris said:
Play stupid word games all you like, it's not going to change the facts.

Peter Morris couldn't recognize a FACT if it was tied to his own butt, with cowbells on it.

This is like trying to play baseball with a parapalegic.

I mean, really; what's the point?

OK, it's entertaining (laughable, in fact), but just how many times can you watch the same old reruns?
 
Re: More laughs from PM

KRAMER said:
Peter Morris couldn't recognize a FACT if it was tied to his own butt, with cowbells on it.

This is like trying to play baseball with a parapalegic.

I mean, really; what's the point?

OK, it's entertaining (laughable, in fact), but just how many times can you watch the same old reruns?

Oh, he recognizes it just fine. He just has a different agenda than he lets on.
 
Re: Re: More laughs from PM

CFLarsen said:
Oh, he recognizes it just fine. He just has a different agenda than he lets on.

How do you translate "I'm shocked! Shocked, I tell you" into Danish?
 
I like word games - let me rearrange the letters in the following sentence:

'Play stupid word games all you like, it's not going to change the facts.'

I rearrange them and get

'I really mucked up this argument. The actual text from the claimant entirely disagrees with what I was claiming. Why didn't I just quit while I was behind? Now I look really foolish. I'd better just toss out a random and meaningless sentence then disappear from this thread.'

I think I did it right.

It certainly looks the same to me.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom