Snappy Retorts To Lame Excuses For Not Taking The Challenge

Peter Morris said:
[BThe challenge application fell through - in part - because Randi's colleagues were resistent to performing the desired test. There were other reasons too, but this was part of it.
[/B]

Peter and reality are polar opposites:


I was very confident that I could dowse sulfide mineralisation under all conditions but today I did an extensive blind-fold test with work colleagues and the results were all over the place.

Candour in this situation is probably the best approach. I am not ready to submit to a test and so I am forced to withdraw my challenge
 
He applied for the $1M challenge, and suggested that the Australians do the preliminary test.
This was only the applicants suggestion, it was never agreed by the JREF.

Applying to the Australians WAS part of the application for the $1M in this case.
Please show me where this was agreed?

The challenge application fell through - in part - because Randi's colleagues were resistent to performing the desired test. There were other reasons too, but this was part of it.
The fact that they are 'Randi's colleagues' does not mean they were representatives of Randi's, merely that Randi knows them and sometimes works with them. In some cases they might do the preliminary testing.
This did not happen in this instance.
 
Peter Morris said:
And this is NOT covered by the phrase "Randi sets the bar too high"

Look, Peter....this may come as a big surprise to you, but you don't get to decide how I write my articles.

If you don't like the way I do things, write your own articles and see how far that will get you.
 
No, Larsen, but when you choose to lie in your fawning articles you get called a liar.

When you choose to be a hypocrite, you get asked to justify your double standards.

When you deliberately avoid the points you cannot answer, I will continue to point that out.


How about a little honesty, Larsen? It may surprise you to know that I admire honest scepticism, its this type of dishonesty I can't stand. If you actually stopped masking stuff up, and stuck to excuses that really have been offered, then I'd support you. When you invent opinions and falsely attribute them to people, and ignore the things they really said, that is why I oppose you.

Do you even understand why I find lies objectionable? Does the concept even fit into your brain?
 
Peter Morris said:
No, Larsen, but when you choose to lie in your fawning articles you get called a liar.

When you choose to be a hypocrite, you get asked to justify your double standards.

When you deliberately avoid the points you cannot answer, I will continue to point that out.


How about a little honesty, Larsen? It may surprise you to know that I admire honest scepticism, its this type of dishonesty I can't stand. If you actually stopped masking stuff up, and stuck to excuses that really have been offered, then I'd support you. When you invent opinions and falsely attribute them to people, and ignore the things they really said, that is why I oppose you.

Do you even understand why I find lies objectionable? Does the concept even fit into your brain?

.....yawn.....
 
Peter Morris said:
No, Larsen, but when you choose to lie in your fawning articles you get called a liar.

Never mind that you have utterly failed to prove any of your assertions.
 
Really?

The assertions I have made:

1) Your list is a work of fiction. You have invented 'excuses' that nobody ever gave.

2) You have refused to include and answer actual excuses that real people have given.


These are proven facts, Larsen.
 
Peter Morris said:
Really?

The assertions I have made:

1) Your list is a work of fiction. You have invented 'excuses' that nobody ever gave.


And when shown that such excuses were actually made, you when off on irrelevant tangents.

Your assertions are completely unproven.
 
Your usual BS.

Somebody gave a cite that was slightly similar to one item on Larsen's list. but even then not quite the same. Somebody said the money has "bad energy." I've yet to see any cite for fsomeone saying the money has a "curse" as Larsen reports. Let alone a cite for Sylvia Browne saying anything similar, as was attributed to her.

The rest of the items on Larsen's list, he has no cite for. They are made up.

My assertions are completely proven.
 
Peter Morris said:
Somebody gave a cite that was slightly similar to one item on Larsen's list. but even then not quite the same. Somebody said the money has "bad energy." I've yet to see any cite for fsomeone saying the money has a "curse" as Larsen reports. Let alone a cite for Sylvia Browne saying anything similar, as was attributed to her.


I see, your such a blatant nitpicker that 'bad energy' is somehow totally foreign to 'curse'. That's pretty weak.

So spare us the usual Morris spin, it has a poor track record.
 
No, Kook. Randi fanatics have provided a cite for ONE item on the list. The rest have been made up. Even that one item has been distorted.


But, as usual, you don't let facts get in the way of your cosy self-delusions.


The facts remain:

1) Most of the items on the list have been made up, or at least distorted.

2) Larsen has refused to include actual stated reasons given by real people.

These are proven facts.
 
Peter Morris said:
No, Kook. Randi fanatics have provided a cite for ONE item on the list. The rest have been made up. Even that one item has been distorted.


That is unproven by you.

Claus Larsen started this thread on the basis that there are common lame excuses people use to avoid the challenge, and some suggestions of what replies counter them. He asked for feedback and examples of excuses. Feedback was given from people who had encountered excuses.

Claus then wrote an article. It was not laden with cites becuase it was not that kind of article. It didn't neeed to be, this stuff wasn't made up. This stuff has been encountered before.

Along comes Peter Morris, a spoiled whiney child who complains because the article is not written the way he wants. He misuses the fact that the excuses are not taken verbatim to incorrectly call the excuses "straw man" a misuse of the fallacy. Peter demans cites for every single excuse, when they are given, he ignores them or simply moves the goal posts. Peter also complains that "real excuses" are being ignored, but the evidence he provides comes from internet kooks known for negotiating in bad faith.

That is all there is.
 
The facts remain:

1) Most of the items on the list have been made up, or at least distorted.

2) Larsen has refused to include actual stated reasons given by real people.

These are proven facts.

1) They haven't been made up as I have seen many of them before as have many other people on this site.
I have no inclination to cite proof of this solely for you Peter Morris so whether you believe this or not is entirely irrelevant. We are not talking about scientific claims or anything of the sort here. This isn't something that requires any great level of proof to back up.
Lots of people claim paranormal abilities, most don't apply for testing. A variety of reasons are given. Those are proven facts.
Larsen's list in my experience is pretty representative of some of the excuses given.

So your 1) is not a 'Proven fact' until you can prove that no-one has ever said these things - good luck with that.

2) The best example you have given involves a disagreement of protocol betwen Australian Sceptics and the claimant.

This isn't a 'lame' excuse (can you actually read the title of the thread Peter), it's a fair enough one, along with "I tested myself again properly and discovered I couldn't really do what I claimed".
Although generally when someone can't agree a protocol it does appear that it is because Randi's protocol is preventing them from cheating consciously or unconsciously as mentioned earlier on this thread.

So if you try reading through the thread again perhaps you will come to understand that Larsen wasn't trying to make a full and detailed list of every reason ever for pulling out, but a 'highlight' list of the lame ones.

If you haven't encountered these lame excuses before then all I can say is I don't really care anywhere near enough to hunt them down for you.

Why you keep whining about it is really the biggest mystery around here.
 
Peter Morris said:
The facts remain:

1) Most of the items on the list have been made up, or at least distorted.

2) Larsen has refused to include actual stated reasons given by real people.

These are proven facts.

By second-hand anecdote? Your standards of proof need a wee bit of strengthening.
 
So your 1) is not a 'Proven fact' until you can prove that no-one has ever said these things - good luck with that.

Well, you are making the claim that people said these things. It's up to you to supply the proof. The fact that you have admitted your inability to provide cites speaks volumes.

I think none of you have ever seen this. You only have hearsay that someone made these excuse. And you have deluded yourselves into thinking you've seen it first hand. Randi fans have a great capacity for self-delusion.

This isn't a 'lame' excuse (can you actually read the title of the thread Peter), it's a fair enough one,

Exactly. It's a fair enough one. And Larsen refuses to include fair enough ones in his fawning list. Point proved.

along with "I tested myself again properly and discovered I couldn't really do what I claimed".

That isn't exactly what he said. He said he tested himself under the conditions offered bt Kramer, and couldn't get it to work under those precise conditions. He still thinks he can dowse, under different conditions, but knows he won't succeed in Randi's test.

Ashles said:


So if you try reading through the thread again perhaps you will come to understand that Larsen wasn't trying to make a full and detailed list of every reason ever for pulling out, but a 'highlight' list of the lame ones.

And if you try reading through the thread again you will see that that is exactly what I'm objecting to. Larsen has highlighted the 'lame' excuses. His article isn't a serious attempt to examine the reason why people refuse Randi's test. It is a dishonest attempt to make Randi's opponents look 'lame.' So, he highlights the 'lame' excuses, and refuses to include those that sound more reasonable. Larsen isn't interested in truth or accuracy - he just wants another fawning article saying how great Randi is, and how lame his opponents are. To acheive this end he has slanted the facts, and omitted the ones that contradict him.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom