Snappy Retorts To Lame Excuses For Not Taking The Challenge

Peter Morris said:
Each claims, in his own way, that he tried corresponding with Randi (or his associates) and were unable to agree on a suitable test.

In the example I have been dealing with, there is no evidence of this. In fact there seems to have been an agreement of protocol along with a suggestion that the dowser try it with a friend first. So this fails.

I searched the thread an could not find your two other examples. I seriously hope you were not considering the John Benneth quotes you happily pulled from my links earlier in the thread to be 'examples'. Because the sound you hear is your foundation collapsing.
 
kookbreaker said:
In the example I have been dealing with, there is no evidence of this. In fact there seems to have been an agreement of protocol along with a suggestion that the dowser try it with a friend first. So this fails.

But he was offered a test by Randi's Australian colleagues for the million doller challenge and gave this reason for rejecting it.

So, this is a case of someone trying to apply, and not being able to agree on a suitable protocol.

I searched the thread an could not find your two other examples. I seriously hope you were not considering the John Benneth quotes you happily pulled from my links earlier in the thread to be 'examples'. Because the sound you hear is your foundation collapsing.

The other two I gave, I'm too tired right now to find the exact quote.

The second said that he had tried to correspond with Randi to discuss the protocol, and had received a stream of ad hominem abuse in response.

The third said that he wanted the test performed by an independent third party, butRandi refused.

The common thread running through these reasons: I tried to discuss the matter with Randi, but we were unable to agree on a suitable protocol.

Why doesn't Larsen include that on his list?
Either the specific examples, or the general complaint?
 
Zombified said:
He did. I explained this, you objected, you were asked for evidence, you did not provide it.

Why exactly does he require "evidence" then?


Does everything on the list require "evidence."

Or is Larsen hypocritically making an exception in this case? Is this the only item on the list that requires "evidence", and Larsen does not require it for any of the others.

Think carefully before you answer. Larsen gave a stupid answer to the question, then tied himself up in knots trying to deny he'd said it.
 
Peter Morris said:
But he was offered a test by Randi's Australian colleagues for the million doller challenge and gave this reason for rejecting it.

So, this is a case of someone trying to apply, and not being able to agree on a suitable protocol.


No. Wrong. A protocol was decided on, it just wasn't the first, not the AS's protocol. Why do you think KRAMER was looking for geologists? Furhtermore, what protocl do you think the dowser used when he tested himself? I doubt it was his own since it was stated by KRAMER: "This just in from Carl Brauhart, who was wise enough to take Randi's advice and conduct proper, secure tests of his claim..."

Protocol agreed upon. Working on getting someone to test him. This is not a failure. Example 1 fails.

The other two I gave, I'm too tired right now to find the exact quote.

The second said that he had tried to correspond with Randi to discuss the protocol, and had received a stream of ad hominem abuse in response.

Yes, that was from Benneth (as quoted by Kettler). You are taking the man's word for what happened, and its completely, utterly wrong. Randi and several proponents of homeopathy went through months of negotiations between Randi and Benneth. Finally, they (those negotiating on behalf of Benneth) grew disgusted with Benneth and dropped him like a hot potato.

But don't take my word for it, take Syd Baumel's word. He was one of the negotiators!

Example 2 fails.

The third said that he wanted the test performed by an independent third party, butRandi refused.

Wrong and deceptive.

Randi refused to get a 'high energy scientist' for him, but KRAMER said he was free to bring his own to the testing. This was a pathetic joke of a demand. Your persistance in this misinformation made 'high energy scientists' a running joke in this forum.

Example 3 fails.

The common thread running through these reasons: I tried to discuss the matter with Randi, but we were unable to agree on a suitable protocol.

Why doesn't Larsen include that on his list?
Either the specific examples, or the general complaint?

Beacuse your evidence for it sucks!
 
kookbreaker said:

[hysterical lies snipped]
Beacuse your evidence for it sucks!

Kookbreaker, you don't understand simple concepts.

The point of Larsen's article is to list the excuses made by people that refuse Randi's test. It is a FACT that people give these reasons for not taking the test. These ARE the reason people gave for not taking the test. They should go on the list of excuses made BECAUSE they are the excuses made.

Or does an excuse have to be true to go on the list?
 
From that same link I gave way back:

An OccultForums member
< snipped for extensive ad hominems against J. Randi & JREF >

I don't claim "psychic abilities" personally but if I had any I sure as hell wouldn't subject myself to this kind of circus show and I can't see where anyone with a lick of sense would do so either. People with these kinds of abilities don't need "scientific" approval or validation, because the reality is that modern science is extremely biased to begin with. It isn't about truth and hasn't been for a long time. It's all about maintaining the status quo, particularly for miserable little jerks like these. If you can't see that, then it is because you don't want to and no one can make another person see anything they absolutely refuse to see.

Let me set up the tests and I will establish it once and for all that all scientific truth is a lie. What of it. The game is rigged and a rigged game is not worth playing. Like old gamblers always say...the only way to win is not to play the game.

:bs:

But, this is really is an issue. A lot of New Agers believe that the scientific community isn't interested in learning anything, only about proving themselves right or some garbage like that.

It's really quite shocking, and one of the big reasons I began looking outside of woo-ishness for answers. I can't handle paranoia like this, as its so obviously false.

Any takers on this one? It's obviously a "sour grapes" argument, but there's no way to argue it because it's born of sheer ignorance...
 
Peter Morris said:
The common thread running through these reasons: I tried to discuss the matter with Randi, but we were unable to agree on a suitable protocol.

Why doesn't Larsen include that on his list?
Either the specific examples, or the general complaint?

Why? Because it is already covered by this one:

"Randi sets the bar too high. The test is impossible."
We cannot relax the conditions to an extent where it is possible for you to cheat.
Source

There is also the small matter of the terms of the challenge:

"No part of the testing procedure may be changed in any way without the agreement of all parties concerned."
Source

Do you understand now?

If no protocol can be agreed on, then no test.
 
Rubbish.

In the first place there is no similarity at all between the two:

1) Randi sets the bar too high. The test is impossible.

2) I tried corresponding with Randi. His behaviour made it impossible to agree on a protocol.

Totally different.


As for your pathetic big red letters, you moron, that's what I've been telling you all along. You have been repeatedly dodging that point. So, suddenly you say the same thing, and pretend that understood this, which you plainly did not.

No test can take place without an agreed protocol. People complain about Randi's appalling behaviour when the try to discuss a protocol. They say Randi makes it impossible to agree through his aggressive and childish behaviour, or his unreasonable conditions imposed.

Why won't you put that on your list, Larsen?

Why do you ask for "evidence?" Does an excuse have to be true before it goes on the list?
 
Peter Morris said:
Kookbreaker, you don't understand simple concepts.

The point of Larsen's article is to list the excuses made by people that refuse Randi's test. It is a FACT that people give these reasons for not taking the test. These ARE the reason people gave for not taking the test. They should go on the list of excuses made BECAUSE they are the excuses made.

Or does an excuse have to be true to go on the list?

Wow, what's the sound of a retreating principle?

Which is it Peter? Do you want the excuse to be on the list as another example of a lame excuse with no reality to back it up? Or did you want the excuse to be on the list as an attack on Claus since you feel that the excuse is a legitimate reason for the test not taking place. You retreat to the former reason, but it is obvious that you wish the latter. Especially given that you came on this thread throwing insults and attacking the list in the first place.

In short, make up your mind and be clear about it.
 
Peter Morris said:
Thank you for your politeness. Very rare on this forum.

I underastand what you're saying, but still this withdrawal is a good example of what I'm saying.

At the end of the discussion, the man's position was : I believe dowsing works. I believe that I have some dowsing skills. But I have tried the specific test you offer, and it doesn't work under those precise conditions. I can dowse, but not in the exact way you want me to. So I'm not taking the test, for the moment. I might try again at a later date.

So, really, this withdrawal was because he found the test protocol to be unacceptable. And there was no other protocol on offer.

I suspect that this is the most common reason for not taking the test.

The man first suggested how a test could look like, then KRAMER did indicate that the general idea is ok.

Then the man tried something like what he suggested and failed and therfore was uncertain, how his dowsing ability works.

So the "excuse" was effectively: " i do not know exactly how my dowsing works, it does not work as i thought, i better find out before trying the test."

Sorry, if an applicant realizes during negotiating a test protocol, that his ability does not work, as he thought and is no longer sure how his ability works, then you cannot realy blame JREF, if he backs out and wants to understand his ability further, before reapplying.


Carn
 
Hey, I've made the point repeatedly.

Larsen has made yet another fawning article, praising Randi to the sky. He has tried to make Randi's opponents sound stupid by listing reasons for not taking the test.

But there are two problems with his list.

1) Most of the items on the list are simply made up things that nobody actually said, ever. He claims that people say regularly that they are afraid of being kidnapped by the CIA. Then he attacks that. When asked for a specific example of someone saying that, he runs and hides.

2) He has refused to include examples of real excuses made by actual people. People have spoken of Randi's inability to discuss sensibly the test protocol. They say they have been unable to agree on a protocol with him because of his misbehaviour.

Larsen won't include this on his list because it sounds too sensible. He wants a list of "lame" excuses, not sensible ones.

And I ask the question again, which cowards keep dodging :

Why does Larsen demand "evidence" for this excuse? Does an excuse have to be true before it goes on the list?
 
Carn said:
The man first suggested how a test could look like, then KRAMER did indicate that the general idea is ok.

Then the man tried something like what he suggested and failed and therfore was uncertain, how his dowsing ability works.

So the "excuse" was effectively: " i do not know exactly how my dowsing works, it does not work as i thought, i better find out before trying the test."

Sorry, if an applicant realizes during negotiating a test protocol, that his ability does not work, as he thought and is no longer sure how his ability works, then you cannot realy blame JREF, if he backs out and wants to understand his ability further, before reapplying.


Carn

And once again, you dodge the point.

I'm referring to his application to be tested by Randi's colleagues in Australia. They are authorized by Randi to carry out preliminary testing for the million dollar challenge. This was a challenge application handled by Randi's agents on Randi's behalf.

They offered him a chance to dowse for a bottle of water. They refused to discuss any other protocol.

He has stated his reasons for rejecting that offer. Even Kramer has acknowledged that his reasons are valid and sensible.

Why won't Larsen include that on his list?

Because it's a fraudulent list, designed to make applicants look stupid. Larsen makes up his own excuses that nobody ever made. And he refuses to include real excuses that actual people did make. That is why he's a fawning liar.
 
Peter Morris said:
Larsen has made yet another fawning article, praising Randi to the sky. He has tried to make Randi's opponents sound stupid by listing reasons for not taking the test.

I don't "praise Randi to the sky". I point out that the excuses the applicants come up with are lame.

Peter Morris said:
1) Most of the items on the list are simply made up things that nobody actually said, ever. He claims that people say regularly that they are afraid of being kidnapped by the CIA. Then he attacks that. When asked for a specific example of someone saying that, he runs and hides.

You see, the reason why people don't take you seriously, is because you simply cannot stick to the truth. Nowhere have I said that people regularly say that they are afraid of being kidnapped by the CIA. I have listed it, because it is an excuse used by some.

Peter Morris said:
2) He has refused to include examples of real excuses made by actual people. People have spoken of Randi's inability to discuss sensibly the test protocol. They say they have been unable to agree on a protocol with him because of his misbehaviour.

These excuses are already covered in the list.

Peter Morris said:
Why does Larsen demand "evidence" for this excuse? Does an excuse have to be true before it goes on the list?

Fool.
 
Peter Morris said:
And once again, you dodge the point.

I'm referring to his application to be tested by Randi's colleagues in Australia. They are authorized by Randi to carry out preliminary testing for the million dollar challenge. This was a challenge application handled by Randi's agents on Randi's behalf.

They offered him a chance to dowse for a bottle of water. They refused to discuss any other protocol.

He has stated his reasons for rejecting that offer. Even Kramer has acknowledged that his reasons are valid and sensible.

Why won't Larsen include that on his list?

Because it's a fraudulent list, designed to make applicants look stupid. Larsen makes up his own excuses that nobody ever made. And he refuses to include real excuses that actual people did make. That is why he's a fawning liar.

Well, i think, that the excuse "They desgin test protocols, so my ability cannot work", should in one form or another on the lists for excuses for not taking JREF challenge.

But you were talking about citing sources for every excuse and used the australian dowser as an example for someone refusing the JREF challenge with this excuse, but this man refused the aussie sceptic challenge with this excuse.

So if the list would be about excuses for not taking the aussie dowsing challenge, then you would be right to cite him as source, but for the JREF challenge you would have to cite someone else.

Nonetheless i did not read the entire thread until now, so i propose to add following excuse to the list, risking its already on it:

JREF will not care what exactly i can do and instead will propose test, where my ability cannot work.

Carn
 
Insomnia

I don't know which makes me lose more sleep; being quoted by Peter Morris, or being mis-quoted by Peter Morris.

Either way, it's not a good feeling. It's nauseating, in fact.

Even Kramer has acknowledged that his reasons are valid and sensible. - Peter Morris

Excuse me while I go throw up.
 
CFLarsen said:

You are a coward as well as a liar, Larsen. Name-calling isn't going to get you out of the corner.

Stop dodging the question, coward.


If the example I gave was already on your list, then your claim "there's no evidence" was a lie, wasn't it.

Why did you ask for "evidence?" Does an excuse have to be true before you include it on the list?
 
Carn said:
Well, i think, that the excuse "They desgin test protocols, so my ability cannot work", should in one form or another on the lists for excuses for not taking JREF challenge.

Thank you. Sense at last.

But you were talking about citing sources for every excuse and used the australian dowser as an example for someone refusing the JREF challenge with this excuse, but this man refused the aussie sceptic challenge with this excuse.

But the Aussie sceptic challenge IS authorized by Randi as preliminary testing for the million dollars. It IS a refusal of the JREF challenge.
 
But the Aussie sceptic challenge IS authorized by Randi as preliminary testing for the million dollars. It IS a refusal of the JREF challenge.
This is incorrect. It CAN be considered as a preliminary challenge but each case is decided individually. It is by no means automatic as counting as a preliminary test for the JREF prize. They are independent organisations who can and often do work together.
Of course you know this already, but as per usual you aren't going to let actual facts get in the way of your opinions.

You are a coward as well as a liar, Larsen. Name-calling isn't going to get you out of the corner.
Oh the irony.
 
http://www.randi.org/vbulletin/showthread.php?s=&threadid=45830

He applied for the $1M challenge, and suggested that the Australians do the preliminary test.

Applying to the Australians WAS part of the application for the $1M in this case.

Kramer confirms that "Australian Skeptics has already proven to be a bit resistant to testing this specific claim"

The challenge application fell through - in part - because Randi's colleagues were resistent to performing the desired test. There were other reasons too, but this was part of it.

This sort of thing appears to be a common problem when trying to negotiate a test with Randi or his authorized representatives. It should go on the list, if the list were actually an honest attempt to document excuses. Refusing to include it is a typical example of Larsen's fawning dishonesty.

And this is NOT covered by the phrase "Randi sets the bar too high"
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom