Snappy Retorts To Lame Excuses For Not Taking The Challenge

Peter Morris said:
There you are, liar. A demand that I prove dowsing true, while claiming that you had proved the curse true. And you did this over and over.
Peter Morris, your lies on this subject have been thoroughly exposed. Please choose something else to lie about.
 
Peter Morris said:
No, since I did it to expose Randi's lies.


Now answer the question:

Why did you demand "evidence" of the reasons I listed? Does a claim need to be true before it goes on your list?

Are you saying you lied to Randi?
 
Peter tries to get help with the maths

The full discussion in which stasticians disagree with Peter Morris

It's worth a read - Peter Morris asks the opinion of mathematicians about the 22% dowsing results and he is consistently told that this proves nothing.

Result - Peter STILL won't have it. He still knows better than anyone, even the experts he actually asks for advice!

Peter has been conclusively proved to have a bizarre obsession with the JREF. He couldn't care less about any of the actual claims or results, he just wants to criticise Randi and the JREF.

The reason for his behaviour is, of course, still a mystery.
 
Ashles said:
Peter tries to get help with the maths

The full discussion in which stasticians disagree with Peter Morris

It's worth a read - Peter Morris asks the opinion of mathematicians about the 22% dowsing results and he is consistently told that this proves nothing.

Result - Peter STILL won't have it. He still knows better than anyone, even the experts he actually asks for advice!

Peter has been conclusively proved to have a bizarre obsession with the JREF. He couldn't care less about any of the actual claims or results, he just wants to criticise Randi and the JREF.

The reason for his behaviour is, of course, still a mystery.

Ah, I love this bit of Morris drivel:

"Randi adds the three results together, and claims that subjects
got "13.5%, a figure well within expectation." Thus he neatly
dodges the point that in the water test the subjects got more
than double the expected value.

This is known as 'misdirection', which is the basis of
most magic tricks. Randi is an expert magician."

:rolleyes:
 
Ashles said:

A quote from the thread, by an actual statistician, is:


"Multiple testing" does account for some that likelihood,
but I'm a little disappointed that Randi did not admit to the
leaning of the result, overall. - It has been my impression
that his (Randi's) debunking was good and fair,
but that seems a touch less that *totally* forthright.
Even if no individual could claim his prize.

It could have been proper to have designed that
experiment such that there would have been
followup and extended testing on individuals who
had done 'best'; and it was not clear to me what level
of performance *would* have won the prize money,
unless it was to match the near-perfect performance
that a dowser had promised.


There seems to be at least some thinking that there were/are flaws in the challenge tests/interpretation of the test results, and/or that there is room for improvement.
 
Peter Morris said:
Not at all. Why would I have a grudge? What makes you think that?

Oh, just a crazy idea....

As for Randi, I think he is the biggest fraud of all. His tests are certainly unfair, even rigged. The fact that he hasn't paid out $1million proves nothing. Randi works on the principle that if it can be explained then it isn't psychic, so no money, and if it can't be explained then it doesn't exist so no money. He will never pay out, whatever the proof

...

Randi has made a fortune trading on the gullability of skeptics.

...

I came to the conclusion that he's a fraud from having personally watched his TV shows and read some of his writings and having seen for myself many misrepresentations he makes, and tests that were sooo obviously unfair. I mean, some of the people he tested were making ridiculous claims, which I didn't accept for a moment. Yet every single one of the tests he made struck me as biased in some way. It was only later that I discovered that a LOT of other people agree with my opinion.

...

Frauds like Randi...

Source


- his constant self-promotion, grandstanding and boasting. His tests are about making money for James Randi, not about any scientific endeavour.

...

How many lies do I have to expose in order to prove him a liar?

...

He is a liar. that is another fact.

...

Randi is STILL a liar.

...

No matter how you twist Randi's words, they still come out as a lie. Every interpretation, no matter how bizzare, (and yours is very strange indeed) is a lie. The man is a total fraud. It is beyond me why anyone is taken in by his crap.

Source

You're probably right, you don't have anything personal against Randi... :rolleyes:
 
There seems to be at least some thinking that there were/are flaws in the challenge tests/interpretation of the test results, and/or that there is room for improvement.
I don't agree. Randi is not trying to conduct research (his budget would never allow it) he is trying to create a test that provides extremely strong evidence for these claims in a single set of experiments.

He agrees what will be considered 'successful' with the claimants beforehand.

In terms of research then by all means it would be interesting for Universities and other organisations to follow up on claimants they feel performed high enough above chance to potentially be displaying some form of effect.
But this is not the role of the JREF.

And I can only suspect that other organisations are not following up on these claimants because they do not feel that they have performed at a level worthy of further study (but this is only my take on the matter and might not be the actual reason)
 
"First of all, I would like to suggest that dowsing does in fact work"

PeterMorris quote found on the straight dope site.


"Note: I personally do not believe in dowsing, but am open
to evidence."

Are there two of you out there, Peter? Or are there two of you in there, Peter? Or do we just have a slinker/stinker problem, golem?
 
Ashles said:
Peter tries to get help with the maths

The full discussion in which stasticians disagree with Peter Morris

It's worth a read - Peter Morris asks the opinion of mathematicians about the 22% dowsing results and he is consistently told that this proves nothing.

Of course, the fact is that I never CLAIMED it "proves" anything.

My comments were about Randi's misrepresentation of the results, and that is fully supported by the thread Ashless links to. Actual results of the test : more than double the expected results from chance. Randi twisted the figures to make it look like it was exactly chance. The people in the thread agree that Randi has misrepresented the data.

My point is that Randi lied about the results, not that the results "prove" anything.

Result - Peter STILL won't have it. He still knows better than anyone, even the experts he actually asks for advice!
I based my conclusions on the information they gave me. They agree that Randi has misrepresented the data.

Why you link to experts agreeing with me is beyond my comprehension.

Peter has been conclusively proved to have a bizarre obsession with the JREF. He couldn't care less about any of the actual claims or results, he just wants to criticise Randi and the JREF.

The reason for his behaviour is, of course, still a mystery. [/B]

No, I point out the man's lies. The fact that you twist facts to support him shows that YOU are the one with the bizarre obsession.
 
CFLarsen said:
It's very clear: Peter Morris lied to Randi. Peter said so himself.

Can you support that claim, you liar? I told the exact truth all the way.

I said right from the start that I was challenging his geology, not claiming any "paranormal" power.


Of course, you seem to have trouble understanding the difference between truth and lies. You make a habit of twisting facts to support your Randi worship.


And you continue to dodge the question, coward. Does an excuse have to be "true" before you put it on your list?
 
Peter Morris said:
My point is that Randi lied about the results, [/B]

Which, of course, is simply not true.

Randi reports both combined and seperate tests accurately. Peter simply takes issue with the way Randi presents them and calls it 'lying'.

In other words, Peter once again Peter insists everything, including the writing up of tests be done his satisfaction.

Mike Hutchinson's comments on this matter make it plain:

I thought I had made it clear that it [combing results] wasn't done in the 'first place'. The results of the brass, gold, and water dowsing were announced first for all to see and understand.
 
Peter Morris said:
The people in the thread agree that Randi has misrepresented the data.

The problem with you Peter is and always has been one of having no sense of proportion, and no self awareness when it comes to your own hypocrisy.

What those in the thread agreed was the Randi had been "less than totally forthright".

That then becomes "agree that Randi has misrepresented the data" in your mouth.

I know, through having debated you for, what, about 18 months or so now (is that sad or what?) that you will not see the irony or hypocrisy in you:

1/ tearing strips off Randi for failing to be less than totally forthright but

2/ misrepresenting another poster's mild comment about Randi ("less than totally forthright") as a comment by that poster that Randi had "misrepresented the data".
 
The problem with you, Princhester, is that you play these silly word games where you pick one word in someone's post, and argue the toss about the precise meaning of that particular word.

So, you grab at the word totally. And, somehow that changes the meaning of the whole post, and indeed the whole thread.

"Less than totally forthright" is a polite euphemism. Substitute "misrepresenting data" or "withholding information" or "massaging the figures" or "lying through his teeth."
 
If it suits you to take what someone says literally, there is no one on the planet more willing to do so than you. When Randi says "there are no underground rivers" you ignore any context and ignore any qualifying comments in surrounding paragraphs and ignore other comments on other occasions that clarify what he means and stick to the literal through thick and thin. He said No Underground Rivers, so he means No Underground Rivers. Period. Randi is wrong and a liar and don't you try to tell Peter he meant anything other than precisely what he said, and all Princhester does is try pathetically to interpret what Randi said as meaning something other than what Randi said.

But when it suits you to read something as a euphemism, then it's a whole other story. When the statistician you ask says Randi was merely "a touch less than totally forthright" suddenly that actually means Randi was "lying through his teeth". What he actually said doesn't matter, no sirree, what he meant was something else entirely.

You asked for an opinion from statisticians, they told you something, and now you're taking what they said and saying it's a polite eupemism for what you want to believe they said because what they actually said is not what you want to hear.
 
Dr Adequate said:
My favorite one is Sylvia Browne's stuff about the JREF money being tainted and evil. She can't even give it to charity, you see, because it would carry with it the Curse Of Randi. But why can't she give it to someone she really dislikes? There must be some way for her to funnel the evil money to al Qaida. She offers them a million dollars, they take it, they shrivel up and die. What holds her back? Alternatively, in my capacity as witch doctor, I could de-curse the money for her. I'll take ten percent, I'm not greedy.
Hell, no! Give it all to me! I'll risk the curse for $1 million! C'mon, Randi, gimme the million! Please!
 
Peter Morris said:
...snip...

My point is that Randi lied about the results, not that the results "prove" anything.


...snip...


Peter Morris said:
No, since I did it to expose Randi's lies.


Now answer the question:

Why did you demand "evidence" of the reasons I listed? Does a claim need to be true before it goes on your list?

Are you saying you lied to Randi?
 
It took a little digging because this thread is so monstrous, but eventually I found where Morris' discussion of "you claim you have evidence of a curse" may have started. For the benefit of those like me who haven't been reading this thread from the start:

Originally posted by Peter Morris
However, and this is the point that confuses me, your list already contains the claim that some people refuse the test because the money is cursed.

So, I presume that you already have evidence of that? Since you need evidence before you include an item on your list.

Now a sane person, knowing the list in question was a list of excuses people have given, would think Morris is saying "before you list a curse as an excuse, you need evidence that somebody has used a curse as an excuse".

I can't think of a sane person or Morris saying that you can't put "curse" on a list of excuses unless you have evidence there really is a curse.

So how about it, Peter? When you said the claim is that some people refused on the basis of the curse, and asked for that claim to be backed up, what evidence were you talking about? What "evidence" is needed before putting something down on a list of excuses that were used?
(a) the excuse was used, or
(b) the excuse was grounded in fact
 
Peter Morris said:
The problem with you, Princhester, is that you play these silly word games where you pick one word in someone's post, and argue the toss about the precise meaning of that particular word.

So, you grab at the word totally. And, somehow that changes the meaning of the whole post, and indeed the whole thread.

"Less than totally forthright" is a polite euphemism. Substitute "misrepresenting data" or "withholding information" or "massaging the figures" or "lying through his teeth."
You win another irony award and a place in my sig.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom