Snappy Retorts To Lame Excuses For Not Taking The Challenge

Zombified said:
I asked you for evidence, Morris. What operational, unambiguous protocol was proposed to ensure that the dowser's could in fact detect water better than chance in a way that could not be explained without invoking the paranormal? Demonstrate that Randi rejected a well-designed protocol.

And you have been given evidence.

The man wanted a test for his water divining abilities.

Randi and his assosiates would not give him one.

But you will wordgame and weasel your way to excuse him for this.
 
Peter Morris said:
And you have been given evidence.

The man wanted a test for his water divining abilities.

Randi and his assosiates would not give him one.

But you will wordgame and weasel your way to excuse him for this.
You have not provided one shred of evidence that anyone proposed a protocol clearly able to demonstrate that his ability was real and paranormal. You've simply repeated his offer to perform an uncontrolled demonstration, which is meaningless.

Is this the best you can do?
 
Zombified said:
You have not provided one shred of evidence that anyone proposed a protocol clearly able to demonstrate that his ability was real and paranormal. You've simply repeated his offer to perform an uncontrolled demonstration, which is meaningless.

Is this the best you can do?

It's been his best for some twenty-odd pages now...



*Well, twenty-odd to me, but I have my forum view set on 10 posts per page. Your own milage may vary.*
 
Zombified said:
You have not provided one shred of evidence that anyone proposed a protocol clearly able to demonstrate that his ability was real and paranormal. You've simply repeated his offer to perform an uncontrolled demonstration, which is meaningless.

Is this the best you can do?

They refused to perform ANY protocol at all, save for the one they were offering. That was the ONLY one they were willing to do. ANY other protocol was refused.

The point is, they refused to discuss the matter. This made it impossible to arrange a protocol.
 
Peter Morris said:
They refused to perform ANY protocol at all, save for the one they were offering. That was the ONLY one they were willing to do. ANY other protocol was refused.

The point is, they refused to discuss the matter. This made it impossible to arrange a protocol.
Says you. I did ask for evidence, though, didn't I? Rereading my post, I see that I did. Do you have any?
 
Peter Morris said:
Wrong. These Australians are Randi's associates. They are acting under Randi's authority. They have the authority to perform the preliminary test for the million dollars. This WAS an application for the million dollars.

That they can run such tests is not indicitive that they will, nor that they are subject to Randi's specifications.

In fact, KRAMER states:

Obviously, enlisting the help of a team of local geologists will be the only true way of insuring proper conditions for this test. As Australian Skeptics has already proven to be a bit resistant to testing this specific claim, JREF is looking forward to finding independent investigators to assist us in the testing of Carl Brauhart. (emphasis mine)

Yeah, they're reeealllly jumping to do Randi's whims, aren't they...

We may never know what the AS's complaint regarding the test was. I don't know where Peter gets off telling us that Randi rejected a reasonable test protocol.

In fact, from KRAMER's comments it would seem that the JREF was trying to make arrangements to get him tested in spite of the AS.

So, another LIE from PETER MORRIS.
 
Peter Morris said:
see the entry in the challenge application section.

Hey, yes, I see it.

It's all clear to me, now that I've read it all the way through.


Peter, you're not only wrong, you're a LIAR. Why are you wasting bandwidth here?

No, don't answer that. Just stop.
 
kookbreaker said:
That they can run such tests is not indicitive that they will, nor that they are subject to Randi's specifications.

They are acting as Randi's agents, their tests have to meet Randi's approval.


In fact, KRAMER states:

Yeah, they're reeealllly jumping to do Randi's whims, aren't they...

We may never know what the AS's complaint regarding the test was. I don't know where Peter gets off telling us that Randi rejected a reasonable test protocol.

Indeed, you have demonstrated that even Kramer agrees that Randi's agents were unreasonable. That's why I can say so.

In fact, from KRAMER's comments it would seem that the JREF was trying to make arrangements to get him tested in spite of the AS.

So, another LIE from PETER MORRIS.

Actually, it's a proven truth, that you cannot bear to face.

The fact remains proven. Someone tried to negotiate a test with Randi's assosiates. He found them inflexible. Kramer has confirmed the complaint is both true and reasonable.

That is a common reason for not taking the test, and should go on Larsen's list.
 
Nex said:
Hey, yes, I see it.

It's all clear to me, now that I've read it all the way through.


Peter, you're not only wrong, you're a LIAR. Why are you wasting bandwidth here?

No, don't answer that. Just stop.

You're just screaming. You hate the truth, so you scream.

I quoted Larsens exact words. I exposed the lies he was telling. What he said was deeply dishonest and extremely stupid.

So, Fanatics hate me for that. They scream that I'm a liar, even though I quoted Larsen's exact words. Larsen's buddies try to find alternative meanings stretching definitions well past breaking point. It does not change a word that Larsen said.

As for the tests set by Randi's assossiates, even Kramer has acknowledged they were unfair.

Larsen is a liar if he doesn't include that on his list.

He is also a liar if he doesn't remove the excuses he has made up that nobody ever offered.
 
Peter Morris said:
Actually, it's a proven truth, that you cannot bear to face.
The fact remains proven. Someone tried to negotiate a test with Randi's assosiates. He found them inflexible. Kramer has confirmed the complaint is both true and reasonable.

emphasis mine

Which is it? Previously you said:

I don't like the test Randi is offereing me. My dowsing skill enables me to find minerals or water in large quantities in the ground. Randi's test design insists that I find small quantities underneath a cup. That's a different thing, which I can't do.

emphasis mine.

KRAMER accepted that the dowser could not do that test and worked to find new people to test the man. Just what could Randi (or KRAMER) have done here to appease the whims of Peter Morris? Force the Australian skeptics to bow down before his whims? I don't think so. This is another case where no matter what Randi does, Peter will find a way to hate him.

Interesting is the deception that you further carry on:

ONE of the reasons why test negotiations fell through.

Test negotiations never 'fell through' since the man withdrew his application after testing himself with decent controls:

"I was very confident that I could dowse sulfide mineralisation under all conditions but today I did an extensive blind-fold test with work colleagues and the results were all over the place.
Candour in this situation is probably the best approach. I am not ready to submit to a test and so I am forced to withdraw my challenge, or, at least, postpone it. "

Unless you have some magical evidence to the contrary?

Now of course, maybe this should be on Larsen's list! After all you have shown quite well that this qualifies for the title description of a lame excuse. The very fact that KRAMER was willing to look for new testers in Australia is evidence shows just how LAME it is!
 
kookbreaker said:
emphasis mine

Which is it? Previously you said:



Jeez. Talk about desperate nit-picking.

So, the stated example was about Randi's agents, who are authorised by Randi to act on Randi's behalf and carry out tests for the million doller challenge. But at one point I mistakenly said "Randi" instead of "Randi's agents." And that's the only error he can find.
 
kookbreaker said:


Now of course, maybe this should be on Larsen's list! After all you have shown quite well that this qualifies for the title description of a lame excuse. The very fact that KRAMER was willing to look for new testers in Australia is evidence shows just how LAME it is!

Sure, go on saying it's lame. Ignore the fact that Kramer agreed it's a valid reason, and that the Australians were being unreasonable. Don't let the facts bother you.

But how about including this one on your list, Larsen? After all, you want a few true ones to go with the ones you invented, don't you?

But we all know you won't. You distort facts to support your idol. you want his detractors to sound stupid, so you make up stupid reasons for not taking the test. You refuse a real reason, because it's not stupid, and you don't have an answer for it.
 
Let's see. JREF wants a preliminary evaluation of a claimant. They contact one skeptic organization, who is reluctant to perform the test. So JREF goes looking for other people who think they can turn this into a reasonable test. Sounds to me like the independence of the two organizations is well-demonstrated, as is the flexibility of the JREF in attempting to obtain preliminary evaluations.

There seems to be no evidence that the Aussies rejection of the test protocol proposed by the claimant was not well founded. And no, Kramer looking for another group to run the test does not mean that their concerns are invalid, nor that any eventual test would use the same procedure unaltered.
 
Peter Morris said:
Jeez. Talk about desperate nit-picking.

So, the stated example was about Randi's agents, who are authorised by Randi to act on Randi's behalf and carry out tests for the million doller challenge. But at one point I mistakenly said "Randi" instead of "Randi's agents." And that's the only error he can find.

No, the whole freaking concept of your complaint is in error. Basicly you've neatly set up your arguement so that Randi cannot possibly make a correct action in your book. The dowser states the suggested protocol is no good, so you complain, rather than acknowledge KRAMER's efforts to make a working protocol.

Would you have preferred that KRAMER cut off the dowser the moment the AS showed little interest? Oh, wait, you have no preferenece since you'll find fault no matter what action is taken.
 
Peter Morris said:
So why won't Larsen put the reason on his list, then?
He did. I explained this, you objected, you were asked for evidence, you did not provide it.
 
Peter Morris said:
Sure, go on saying it's lame. Ignore the fact that Kramer agreed it's a valid reason, and that the Australians were being unreasonable. Don't let the facts bother you.


Excuse me, but KRAMER never said its a valid reason to not take the test. He said nothing of the kind. This is where you lie, once again.

For that matter, the challenger never said it was his reason for not taking the challenge either.

Both were working on a protocol and KRAMER out out a call qualified volunteers who were willing to perform the test. But the challenger withdrew his challenge when a 'self test' failed. He never made an excuse.

This whole contraversy is in your head, Peter.
 
Peter Morris said:
So why won't Larsen put the reason on his list, then?

Because in the only example you have given, the challenger in question did not use your complaint as an excuse to evade or avoid the challenge. Got it?
 
I've given three examples. They give different reasons, but there is a common theme to the three.

Each claims, in his own way, that he tried corresponding with Randi (or his associates) and were unable to agree on a suitable test.

Why doesn't Larsen put that on his list?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom