Merged Silver Over 40.00 / Real and fake prices

Indeed.

If one expects hyperinflation, the rational strategy would be to borrow a whole lot of money.
Buy a house, buy commodities, buy a classic car, hang out witch Charlie Sheen and do copious amounts of Colombian marching powder of a prostitutes behind through a rolled up bit of fiat money.

Then in a year or two, get a job flipping burgers to pay of your million dollar debt.

I've paid off my mortgage. If hyper inflation hits, I'm going to look a right fool.
 
Last edited:
Indeed.

If one expects hyperinflation, the rational strategy would be to loan a whole lot of money.
Buy a house, buy commodities, buy a classic car, hang out witch Charlie Sheen and do copious amounts of Colombian marching powder of a prostitutes behind through a rolled up bit of fiat money.

Then in a year or two, get a job flipping burgers to pay of your million dollar debt.

I've paid off my mortgage. If hyper inflation hits, I'm going to look a right fool.

[snark]you should borrow, not loan money[/snark]

English is a stupidly complex language, you borrow money but get a loan.

But language nitpickery aside that is my assumption too. Of course that isn't too different than MichaelSuede's position that "hard" assets are an effective hedge against hyperinflation. I'm currently challenging three aspects of his argument

  • That hyperinflation is a significant risk in the United States any tims. MichaelSuede refuses to provide any kind of time horizon so we can never tell whether he is wrong.
  • That "hard" assets will be freely exchangeable for goods and services. In Zimbabwe, silver and gold weren't used to by bread, they were used to buy dollars and rand which were used to buy bread
  • That "hard" assets will suddenly be worth more in terms of the goods and services they can buy. In an example I provided above I suggested that the silver in a pre-1946 (sic) dime can currently buy an ham sandwich and will continue to buy a ham sandwich. MichaelSuede believes that it may be able to buy several days worth of food
 
Really? Nobody in Argentina invested abroad? There were no publically listed companies in Argentina that kept their business going?
For substantial periods of time there were controls in place to prevent money moving out of the country. In fact they restricted withdrawals from bank accounts, period. Foreign companies, with the strength of their native currency, did "well" if you want to call it that. Large groups of industrial assets wound up owned by foreign companies, which before had been owned by people in Argentina. The inflation was a "buying opportunity" for foreigners with real money.

In the German hyper inflation of 1922, pensioners and others on fixed income starved and died off. Everyone was betting on tomorrow's or next week's money value in transactions. During the inflation, profiteers got rich by doing this. Then when the rye based Mark was established and afterwords, deflation occurred. At that time, the profiteers who bet on inflation were of course, impoverished.
 
Last edited:
Excuse me, what part of my post were you disagreeing with ?

Do you support MichaelSuede's claim that a single pre-1946 dime may be able to feed him for a few days.

Could you please demonstrate how that might work. I provided an example to support my hypothesis that in a hyperinflation scenario an amount of silver gets you the same amount of stuff, but rather a lot of local currency.

You also seem to have ignored the fact that the middle classes (however that is defined) are net debtors (after all, they tend to have large home loans). according to this article (which was the first I found with the readily accessible information I wanted)



I have no idea how many (or few) have no home loan at all but it sounds like the middle class benefit most from the reduction in debt that results from hyperinflation.

I know in the case of my parents in the 1970's in the UK, many years of sustained inflation turned their crippling monthly mortgage payments in 1972 into pocket-change by 1980.

A single dime would buy however much bread in the local market under hyperinflation that a seller wanted to give for it. There isn't any reason that this is hard linked to the value of silver. Supply and demand.

In hyperinflation, the middle class is totally, completely wiped out. Your factoid about debt being wiped out is true, but it is irrelevant. Your note about your parent's situation does not describe the effects of hyperinflation, but normal inflation.

For example, suppose you had one gold coin, and were saving it to pay off a $200K mortgage at the right moment. On the path to that "right moment", you would lose your job, people in your family would have severe problems, your taxes would skyrocket. And so you'd find yourself selling that gold coin just to eat. Then even though the mortgage payments were getting ridiculously low, you wouldn't be able to make them and the house is taken away.
 
Indeed.

If one expects hyperinflation, the rational strategy would be to borrow a whole lot of money.
Buy a house, buy commodities, buy a classic car, hang out witch Charlie Sheen and do copious amounts of Colombian marching powder of a prostitutes behind through a rolled up bit of fiat money.

Then in a year or two, get a job flipping burgers to pay of your million dollar debt.

I've paid off my mortgage. If hyper inflation hits, I'm going to look a right fool.
Housing goes way down in value in hyperinflation because most income is spent for food. And there would be very very few jobs "flipping burgers" because few people would want to buy flipped burgers. The entire fast food industry would likely pretty much vanish as we know it.

IF one expected hyperinflation, the rational thing would be to move to a different country.
 
A single dime would buy however much bread in the local market under hyperinflation that a seller wanted to give for it. There isn't any reason that this is hard linked to the value of silver. Supply and demand.

If bread is in short supply, why would the seller of bread give you any more bread than the amount of silver warrants ? He has the bread, all you have is a small silver coin.

Anecdotes from Germany and Hungary tell of the exchange of large amounts of jewellery for comparatively small amounts of food. This doesn't jibe with your expectation (hope ?) that silver will magically become more valuable (in commodity terms) than it previously was

In hyperinflation, the middle class is totally, completely wiped out. Your factoid about debt being wiped out is true, but it is irrelevant. Your note about your parent's situation does not describe the effects of hyperinflation, but normal inflation.

The middle class in the Western World are net debtors. They borrow money to buy assets, typically a house, car and so on. They typically have less in savings than they owe on the loans on these assets.

In a hyperinflation scenario, the value of their cash savings held in local currency is effectively zero, but then again so is their debt, and they still have the assets they bought with that debt.

The people who do lose out are those with substantial cash-based savings who have not hedged against hyperinflation.

For example, suppose you had one gold coin, and were saving it to pay off a $200K mortgage at the right moment. On the path to that "right moment", you would lose your job, people in your family would have severe problems, your taxes would skyrocket. And so you'd find yourself selling that gold coin just to eat. Then even though the mortgage payments were getting ridiculously low, you wouldn't be able to make them and the house is taken away.

Where did this fantasy come from ?

We were talking about hyperinflation, not a complete collapse of the economy (in which case guns are better than coins). Even in 1920's Germany, people were working. I have just read a book "Defeating Hitler" which deals with the experiences of a middle-class German during the period. He continued in employment. Although his salary did not keep pace with inflation, he and his family were never ruined.

In a hyperinflation scenario, I pay off my homeloan with about 10 minutes' salary and still have my gold coin which I can exchange for exactly the same amount (or slightly less) useful stuff at some point in the future.


All of which is interesting, but still, when is this hyperinflation going to happen in the US economy ?
 
Originally Posted by mhaze
A single dime would buy however much bread in the local market under hyperinflation that a seller wanted to give for it. There isn't any reason that this is hard linked to the value of silver. Supply and demand.

If bread is in short supply, why would the seller of bread give you any more bread than the amount of silver warrants ? He has the bread, all you have is a small silver coin.

Anecdotes from Germany and Hungary tell of the exchange of large amounts of jewellery for comparatively small amounts of food. This doesn't jibe with your expectation (hope ?) that silver will magically become more valuable (in commodity terms) than it previously was
.....

You've cited an example perfectly consistent with what I already said, but your example, and mine, defeat your previous assertion of a relatively consistent ratio between value of silver and that of food.

....The middle class in the Western World are net debtors. They borrow money to buy assets, typically a house, car and so on. They typically have less in savings than they owe on the loans on these assets.

In a hyperinflation scenario, the value of their cash savings held in local currency is effectively zero, but then again so is their debt, and they still have the assets they bought with that debt.

The people who do lose out are those with substantial cash-based savings who have not hedged against hyperinflation. ....
Umm, no. It would be a mistake to think that any substantial or even a measurable segment of the middle class would "make out" during a hyperinflation, with the exception of those who started gaming, eg, continually playing a local market or something like the stock market in expectation of price rises. That's not anyone on a salary. And that's not counting those on pensions, fixed income in retirement, public welfare, and so forth.

........We were talking about hyperinflation, not a complete collapse of the economy (in which case guns are better than coins). Even in 1920's Germany, people were working. I have just read a book "Defeating Hitler" which deals with the experiences of a middle-class German during the period. He continued in employment. Although his salary did not keep pace with inflation, he and his family were never ruined.....
because he had some kind of a job. But a huge part of the goods in the US come from outside the US now, and in a hyperinflation, there would simply be a great many jobs that vanished in the US because nobody needed those goods or services.

........All of which is interesting, but still, when is this hyperinflation going to happen in the US economy ?
When? Hyperinflation occurs when the people distrust the currency sufficiently to immediately exchange it for goods. Even substantial devaluing of a currency does not necessarily cause this phenomenum. It is related to both the devaluing of a currency, and a complete loss of faith and trust in the government.
 
You've cited an example perfectly consistent with what I already said, but your example, and mine, defeat your previous assertion of a relatively consistent ratio between value of silver and that of food.

I'm very wiling to accept that silver will buy less stuff than it previously would. I was contesting the suggestion that it could somehow appreciate in value.

Umm, no. It would be a mistake to think that any substantial or even a measurable segment of the middle class would "make out" during a hyperinflation, with the exception of those who started gaming, eg, continually playing a local market or something like the stock market in expectation of price rises. That's not anyone on a salary. And that's not counting those on pensions, fixed income in retirement, public welfare, and so forth.

How are people on public welfare in the middle class ?

Anyone who is a net debtor will be in a better position.

because he had some kind of a job. But a huge part of the goods in the US come from outside the US now, and in a hyperinflation, there would simply be a great many jobs that vanished in the US because nobody needed those goods or services.

Evidence ?

When? Hyperinflation occurs when the people distrust the currency sufficiently to immediately exchange it for goods. Even substantial devaluing of a currency does not necessarily cause this phenomenum. It is related to both the devaluing of a currency, and a complete loss of faith and trust in the government.

But when can we say we are clear of the immediate threat of hyperinflation. It seems that unless someone comes up with a timeframe it's a prediction which can never be wrong. Even if inflation remains well under control for the next 20 years, you could claim that hyperinflation is just around the corner.
 
Last edited:
I'm very wiling to accept that silver will buy less stuff than it previously would. I was contesting the suggestion that it could somehow appreciate in value.....
Since it's a supply and demand issue, I have no problem with it varying either up and down in the situations discussed.

....But when can we say we are clear of the immediate threat of hyperinflation. It seems that unless someone comes up with a timeframe it's a prediction which can never be wrong. Even if inflation remains well under control for the next 20 years, you could claim that hyperinflation is just around the corner.

A country would have an immediate threat of hyperinflation when there was significant "latent", or unrealized inflation in the money supply.

It would be clear of an immediate threat of hyperinflation when the unrealized inflation in the money supply was (a) reduced to a level consistent with GDP growth (b) eliminated through issuing a new currency (c) eliminated through default.

Unrealized inflation is pretty easy to understand. Suppose you have 10T in money total in circulation, and you print 10T. For some time, a gallon of gasoline (value being set internationally) continues to cost $4 as before printing the 10T. There is at this time unrealized inflation, because given the same velocity of circulation with the existing 20T, gas should cost $8.

I think everyone understands that if we continue printing a trillion or two each year, there is a certainty of hyperinflation. And if we quit tomorrow, the possibility of hyperinflation is quite low. The problem is in the in between, real world scenarios. What happens if we print $2T for each of the next 3years? 6? 9? 12?

Note if the inflation paces with the printing, there is no unrealized inflation. Then hyperinflation is strictly equal to the money printing. But that's rare, instead the lags occur and a large amount of inflation is playing catch up. That's what can cause gas to shoot not to $8 per gallon, but $20, or $60, or $100.
 
....How are people on public welfare in the middle class ?

Anyone who is a net debtor will be in a better position.
Nope. Someone who had a job and was a net debtor before hyperinflation, and stayed with the job and was a net debtor after the inflation...for such a person your assertion has some merit.

But in many cases, it would be net debtor with a job before hyperinflation,
net debtor with no job and no expectation of getting on...afterwards.

Just walk through a mall and ask "How much of all this do people acually NEED?"
 
I'm very wiling to accept that silver will buy less stuff than it previously would. I was contesting the suggestion that it could somehow appreciate in value.

Why wouldn't silver appreciate in value? Is it written in stone that the only way that silver can rise is due to market equilibration?

As fake money is debased, it makes perfect sense that not only the nominal, but the real demand for silver will rise.
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by mhaze
because he had some kind of a job. But a huge part of the goods in the US come from outside the US now, and in a hyperinflation, there would simply be a great many jobs that vanished in the US because nobody needed those goods or services.


....Evidence ?..

Evidence? Well, that's pretty simple. Inflation of a currency means that items valued internationally rise. Oil. And we are talking about hyperinflation, that is where you have

$1.00 then ... $100.00 then.... $1,000,000 etc

So when oil is valued at $1M per gallon, look at any shopping strip and ask how many of those stores will still be open. Many will not, because they are not selling essentials. Thus, many people out of work. Probably 90% of what we buy and use isn't necessary at all, that's how rich we really are here.

America is very different than Weimer Republic, we import a much larger fraction of our consumer goods today than back then. All of those imported items would be valued at an international standard, and that reflected in value in a hyper inflated currency.

So yes, the person who thinks he is safe, because his assets exceed his debts, is absolutely not safe from the ravages of hyperinflation, quite the reverse. That argument is like saying you have a basement, so you are safe from thermonuclear war.

:)
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by mhaze

So when oil is valued at $1M per gallon, ....

$1,000,000? Gee, it seems like only yesterday it was at $3.59



Oh, sorry, that was three days ago. I must've missed the four katrillion percent price increases on Friday.
 
Why wouldn't silver appreciate in value? Is it written in stone that the only way that silver can rise is due to market equilibration?

As fake money is debased, it makes perfect sense that not only the nominal, but the real demand for silver will rise.

I have something genuinely useful, bread, you have a shiny coin. Why should i give you any more bread for that coin than I would have to.

There is anecdotal evidence from 1920s Germany of large amounts of jewellery being exchanged for small amounts on food because there was little of the former and comparatively large amounts of the latter.
 
Originally Posted by mhaze
America is very different than Weimer Republic, we import a much larger fraction of our consumer goods today than back then. All of those imported items would be valued at an international standard, and that reflected in value in a hyper inflated currency.

Which would stimulate demand for locally sourced goods.
 
As fake money is debased, it makes perfect sense that not only the nominal, but the real demand for silver will rise.

i will pay you half face value for any of your fake notes issued by the USA. PM me for my mailing address.
 
$1,000,000? Gee, it seems like only yesterday it was at $3.59

h, sorry, that was three days ago. I must've missed the four katrillion percent price increases on Friday.
:)

Yes, this subject is "hyperinflation". It is not "regular inflation" where you see 3.59, 3.72, 4.01. It is a weird monster in the closet resulting from money printed where the government seeks to retain constant value for itself by debasing the money supply, thus exponential increases in dollar count are produced. This is accelerated dramatically because people catch on pretty quick, and they compensate by abandoning the money system as far as possible.

Which would stimulate demand for locally sourced goods.
Well, that's a specious argument in all cases where the means of production has moved offshore. And that's the case in many industries and it is not a bad thing, but a good thing. But in the case of hyperinflation, imported goods track with the international value. Thus they become extremely and prohibitively expensive.

Some categories of locally produced goods would certainly increase.

Essentially that would be the end of the USA as we know it.

Even our food is transited through an incredibly efficient distribution system that provides all kinds of fresh fruits and vegetables year round. A certain level of high fuel prices would collapse this system.

But True Believers in the faith of eco-sustainability would rejoice at local production.

:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
I have something genuinely useful, bread, you have a shiny coin. Why should i give you any more bread for that coin than I would have to.

Silver is genuinely useful, as it has monetary and industrial value. It's worth a lot more than any excess of bread that you have to sell, because it won't perish and serves as a store of value. This should be obvious.

There is anecdotal evidence from 1920s Germany of large amounts of jewellery being exchanged for small amounts on food because there was little of the former and comparatively large amounts of the latter.

I don't deny your anectodal evidence, the total debasement of fiat money destroyed the supply chain and the economy at large, so it's feasible that desperate people would resort to desparate measures. If you looked harder, you would probably find examples of people who managed to salvage their savings by owning precious metals, too.
 
i will pay you half face value for any of your fake notes issued by the USA. PM me for my mailing address.

While I can't deny the knee-slapping comedic value of this response, the word fake doesn't necessarily denote worthlessness, and more likely indicates an increasing rate of worthlessness. The US dollar is authentic in that it's produced by the US, and fake in terms of having an important property of money - the store of value.

You actually applying your signature here would have helped tremendously before you posting something stupid.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom