Merged Silver Over 40.00 / Real and fake prices

While I can't deny the knee-slapping comedic value of this response, the word fake doesn't necessarily denote worthlessness, and more likely indicates an increasing rate of worthlessness. The US dollar is authentic in that it's produced by the US, and fake in terms of having an important property of money - the store of value.

....

Have you sold any of your silver yet to lock in the profits you've continually claimed? I'd do it soon before your ROI is lower than T-bills or the inflation rate.
 
Have you sold any of your silver yet to lock in the profits you've continually claimed? I'd do it soon before your ROI is lower than T-bills or the inflation rate.

I asked the same thing and was summarily dismissed for not understanding the underlying principles. Apparently, the math goes something like this....

You hold 15,000 oz of silver at an average buy of $8 ($120,000). That goes to $50, and then starts its inevitable downward curve. Somewhere along the line, one could invest 22 minutes and sell off that 15,000 oz at 750,000, and just ride a little bit on the downbeat and buy 19,000 oz and have a little left over for a decent steak and a bottle of Pouilly Fuisse.

But that's not how it works. They bought in at the absolute depths of the prices and are so convinced that it's going to $150 someday, that it would make no sense to take a $225,000 profit on the margin between $50 and $35. I think it has to do with the well known "Oooh, Shiney!" theory of commodity investment.

It's really sort of a religious thing with gold and silver bugs. It seems that they don't want to be seen cheating on their wife(their silver blah blah) so will not take that ignoble quarter million in profits, even if that would allow them to horde another 30% of the shiney stuff if they just turned around and reinvested in the same.

My broker in Montreal was much the same. He recommended in '97 that I hold onto WeHaveNoContentJustIdeas.com Fast Eddy. He's now parking cars at Ruby Foo's.
 
I asked the same thing and was summarily dismissed for not understanding the underlying principles. Apparently, the math goes something like this....

You hold 15,000 oz of silver at an average buy of $8 ($120,000). That goes to $50, and then starts its inevitable downward curve. Somewhere along the line, one could invest 22 minutes and sell off that 15,000 oz at 750,000, and just ride a little bit on the downbeat and buy 19,000 oz and have a little left over for a decent steak and a bottle of Pouilly Fuisse.

That works great, in hindsight. Problem is, one never knows what silver is going to do at any given time.

But that's not how it works. They bought in at the absolute depths of the prices and are so convinced that it's going to $150 someday, that it would make no sense to take a $225,000 profit on the margin between $50 and $35. I think it has to do with the well known "Oooh, Shiney!" theory of commodity investment.

It's really sort of a religious thing with gold and silver bugs...

This is both a straw man argument (who is "they"?), and wrong on so many levels.

It assumes one is buying silver to make "profits". You may scoff that that is the only reason to speculate on silver (or anything other commodity) and so far as that goes, I agree. Common stocks, silver, gold, pork bellies, oil, nearly anything can be traded and speculated upon in the hopes of profits.

I can't speak for "silver bugs", but for me, there are absolutely no price machinations that would ever induce me to sell. If the price of an ounce of silver went up to $100 over the next year, my paper "net worth" would go up, and I wouldn't mind, but I would still not consider selling. Not at any price. Really.

If and when any of my gold or silver gets sold, it will be at the market price at the time (which I still hold is unforeseeable), and only because at some point in the future my wife and I or our heirs need to sell it to live - its insurance, not speculation.

My broker in Montreal was much the same. He recommended in '97 that I hold onto WeHaveNoContentJustIdeas.com Fast Eddy. He's now parking cars at Ruby Foo's.

Its hard for me to know...

1) is that referring to ME somehow?

2) If it is, is it complimentary or insulting? I really can't tell.
 
Last edited:
Still waiting for the hyperinflation.

Right now silver spot is a touch under $35 an ounce.

Can anyone who is forecasting hyperinflation please give some kind of indication as to the likely timelines. An apocalyptic forecast with no indication as to when it may happen is more or less useless.
 
Can anyone who is forecasting hyperinflation please give some kind of indication as to the likely timelines.

No. As I stated above: "Problem is, one never knows what silver is going to do at any given time."

An apocalyptic forecast with no indication as to when it may happen is more or less useless.

"The long run is a misleading guide to current affairs. In the long run we are all dead. Economists set themselves too easy, too useless a task if in tempestuous seasons they can only tell us that when the storm is past the ocean is flat again." - John Maynard Keynes
 
If and when any of my gold or silver gets sold, it will be at the market price at the time (which I still hold is unforeseeable), and only because at some point in the future my wife and I or our heirs need to sell it to live - its insurance, not speculation.

Still can't see how that's insurance against anything except a collapse of the dollar (or whatever the currency is where you are). Because otherwise you are simply gambling that the value of silver when you or yours need it is higher than it would have been via inflation. Anything else is a loss. So yes, it is ultimately about profits.
 
Well the tenor of the early posts in this thread was

"I'm holding silver as a hedge against hyperinflation"

The evidence for this was the, at the time, rising value of silver (due to the debasing of the dollar).

There was a further suggestion that a pre-1946 (actually pre-1964) dime may be able to provide food for a few days.

Although it was never explicitly stated, I inferred that the posters thought that this may happen at some time in the foreseeable future.

I personally don't think we'll see hyperinflation in the United States in the next 5 years and I was trying to explore with the hyperinflation enthusiasts when they might think the hyperinflation may take place (because "sometime" is neither helpful nor does it provide a testable hypothesis for their economic theories).

It is impossible to predict the value of commodities in the short term but I interpreted the alert to the current silver price was an indication that hyperinflation was around the corner and that as a consequence, the value of silver in dollars was going to soar.

The fact that the price of silver over the last couple of months has been pretty flat indicates to me that perhaps the hyperinflation isn't as imminent as the original poster would have us believe.
 
I knew I should have read more of the thread...:)
So it is a collapse of the dollar thing.
OK.
One of those "any day now...any day" I presume?
 
That works great, in hindsight. Problem is, one never knows what silver is going to do at any given time.

....

This is both a straw man argument (who is "they"?), and wrong on so many levels.

It assumes one is buying silver to make "profits". You may scoff that that is the only reason to speculate on silver (or anything other commodity) and so far as that goes, I agree. Common stocks, silver, gold, pork bellies, oil, nearly anything can be traded and speculated upon in the hopes of profits.

I can't speak for "silver bugs", but for me, there are absolutely no price machinations that would ever induce me to sell. If the price of an ounce of silver went up to $100 over the next year, my paper "net worth" would go up, and I wouldn't mind, but I would still not consider selling. Not at any price. Really.

....

I was asking Tippit since he seems to be confident in his business acumen but your reply is confusing. "No price...would ever induce me to sell." Not $40/oz. Not $400/oz. Not $40,000,000/oz.

Are you certain of this?
 
I was asking Tippit since he seems to be confident in his business acumen but your reply is confusing. "No price...would ever induce me to sell." Not $40/oz. Not $400/oz. Not $40,000,000/oz.

Are you certain of this?

I like an "argument ad absurdum" as much as the next guy, so fair question.

If, tomorrow, silver shot to $40,000,000/oz, and everything else remained roughly the same, then, yes - I'd likely sell one ounce and buy a personal jet and a fancy home and never worry about money again.

But the problem with that thought experiment is that it would be impossible for everything else to remain the same (ceteris paribus). Everyone else in the world would also be rushing to sell some silver, which would drive the price back down. Or we'd be in the midst of hyperinflation, and that $40,000,000 proceeds wouldn't even cover a trip to the grocery.

Not to mention that on the day that silver hit $40,000,000/oz, it would be exactly as likely to go up the next day as down.

Although it was never explicitly stated, I inferred that the posters thought that this may happen at some time in the foreseeable future.
(from The Don)

Your inference may be correct pertaining to some posters. I guess it depends on your definition of "foreseeable". I will again compare holding silver with insurance. You buy flood or life or car insurance not because you expect any one of those things to happen, and certainly not because you hope they do. I hold some precious metals and would far prefer that hyperinflation never rears its ugly head, much as I hope I don't fall victim to a flood, or die, or get in a car accident.

I've been hearing about impending doom for the US financial system since the 70's, and I'm glad the gloom and doomers have been wrong to this point. But no one knows what the future holds, and "Black Swan" events can leave us all scratching our heads and wondering why we didn't see this or that coming.
 
I've been hearing about impending doom for the US financial system since the 70's, and I'm glad the gloom and doomers have been wrong to this point. But no one knows what the future holds, and "Black Swan" events can leave us all scratching our heads and wondering why we didn't see this or that coming.

And if you had ploughed a substantial portion of your net worth into silver as a hyperinflation hedge at the time, you'd have missed out on 35 years of stock market and housing market gains.

Just wailing "we're all dooooooooooomed at some unspecified point in the future" simply isn't helpful as either advice or as a means of testing the model that underpins that forecast because it will never produce falsifiable results (after all, it seems that the forecast disaster has been forecast for 35 years, hasn't quite yet happened but could still be just around the corner.
 
And if you had ploughed a substantial portion of your net worth into silver as a hyperinflation hedge at the time, you'd have missed out on 35 years of stock market and housing market gains.

This assumes that participating in gains in any market is easy or just assumed.

One might have invested in Apple or Microsoft and had huge gains. Or one might have leveraged those positions into a huge position in Enron and not so much.

Similarly, I have a friend who participated in the real estate boom in Knoxville and ended up with 50+ homes, worth a LOT of money. He's now bankrupt.

Looking at historic silver prices, they were about $5/oz in the '70's:

silver_all_data_o_usd.png


Right now, as an investment, from the 70's one would have a "seven-bagger". One could have done worse (or better) in other investments, but there you have it.
 
And if you look at that graph, for most of that time you'd have made next to nothing. Indeed inflation alone would have wiped out any small gains.
 
This assumes that participating in gains in any market is easy or just assumed.

My knowledge is UK based and cash ploughed into property in, say, 1975 your return would have been 16 fold:
http://www.mortgageguideuk.co.uk/housing/uk-house-price-index.html


If you'd put it into a Down Jones tracker mutual fund it would have been 12-24 fold PLUS any dividends you may have received
http://stockcharts.com/freecharts/historical/djia1960.html

Timing the peaks and troughs is difficult. Picking a single stock is also difficult.


Silver has been a comparatively rotten investment over that period (and form the perspective of a couple of years ago even worse). The reason to hold it (as a hedge against hyperinflation which hasn't happened) has not come about.

I'm not saying that commodities are not part of a balanced portfolio but if someone as a sizeable proportion of their net worth in silver as protection against something that has been predicted for the last 35 years as being about to happen but has not so far, then I'd question the rationality of that decision UNLESS.....


....they can present an argument as to why now is different to any time in the past 35 years and ideally present some kind of checkpoint to see whether their economic theory is correct.
 
If and when any of my gold or silver gets sold, it will be at the market price at the time (which I still hold is unforeseeable), and only because at some point in the future my wife and I or our heirs need to sell it to live - its insurance, not speculation.


I'm coming late to this thread but how exactly is that going to work? Exactly how much gold and silver do you hold on your person/in your home and under what scenario are you going to have to sell it?

If the apocalyptic predictions are true then your silver and gold is going to be as worthless as pretty much everything else except food, water, weapons and ammo.

If we're just talking about a financial crisis to the point where gold/silver was a better investment that stocks and shares then your policy of never selling is silly as it would simply be a risk/reward calculation.
 
This assumes that participating in gains in any market is easy or just assumed.

One might have invested in Apple or Microsoft and had huge gains. Or one might have leveraged those positions into a huge position in Enron and not so much.

Similarly, I have a friend who participated in the real estate boom in Knoxville and ended up with 50+ homes, worth a LOT of money. He's now bankrupt.

Looking at historic silver prices, they were about $5/oz in the '70's:

[qimg]http://silverprice.org/charts/history/silver_all_data_o_usd.png[/qimg]

Right now, as an investment, from the 70's one would have a "seven-bagger". One could have done worse (or better) in other investments, but there you have it.

If you put 10,000 bucks in a 12% certificate of deposit in 1979, you tripled your 10K in ten years. I know. I did it twice and put my daughter through H.S. on it. If you bought silver in '79 at $18, what would you have now? The people pumping silver in this thread are not even recommending buying it at those prices - they're recommending buying it NOW because it's such a wise investment. (I also bought a small handful of silver ounces back then - by '82, we used them as paperweights!!)
 
I think we're largely talking past each other.

1) I don't recommend that anyone buy silver. Just that there are feasible scenarios possible where one might wish one had. Or not.

2) Looking back at ways one might have invested in the past is interesting but of no use deciding how to go forward. My IRA is diversified across mutual funds focusing on tech, utility/income, blue chip stocks, emerging growth stocks, China fund and a gold fund. My best-performing fund is a Fidelity software and computing, up 80% on share price and about 380% with reinvested dividends and gains. It's easy to play the game, "if only I had put it ALL into that fund". But looking forward one never has the clarity of vision that one has looking back.

3)
If the apocalyptic predictions are true then your silver and gold is going to be as worthless as pretty much everything else except food, water, weapons and ammo.

Historically, not true. But its not either/or. Food/water/weapons and ammo are all good things to have tucked away.

4)
Exactly how much gold and silver do you hold on your person/in your home and under what scenario are you going to have to sell it?

About 5% of my net worth is in precious metals. The majority is in securities (stocks and bonds) and real estate. Again, I'd only sell the metals if I needed to in order to survive. I don't see that 5% of my portfolio as an investment, I see it as insurance.
 
I think we're largely talking past each other.

3)

Historically, not true. But its not either/or. Food/water/weapons and ammo are all good things to have tucked away.

Well historically we've never really had an apocalyptic scenario. Not in the sense that some of the more rabid commentators and 'buy gold!!!!!1111' bloggers talk about at any rate.

If we are talking about Latin America, the Asian IMF crisis or whatever then yeah, I could possibly see the sense of buying gold as a hedge against a fairly localised issue. If we're talking about the backside falling out of the the US dollar and global economic meltdown to the point where people are trying to exchange gold nuggets for food and shelter then I think we would have gone beyond the point where any investment made much sense.
 
If the apocalyptic predictions are true then your silver and gold is going to be as worthless as pretty much everything else except food, water, weapons and ammo.

Don’t forget the bottle caps, you definitely want to have a big stash of those just in case...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom