Merged Silver Over 40.00 / Real and fake prices

Have we had hyperinflation between 1964 and the present?....
Assuming you mean the US, the answer is no, and the reason is that until 2009, we had not printed money in the amounts that would create this contingency.

We have now commenced on that path, and the possibility of hyperinflation certainly does exist at this time and will continue to exist. Let's say for ten years, just to get a frame of reference.

Sure, it's a hedge against hyperinflation of a single currency. But, the claim is inflation, not hyperinflation.....

???

Properly speaking, the issue is inflation of what, just about all of the G20 currencies. Their value is all falling although at differing rates. This is very different than historical cases of inflation. Take for example Argentina, where the currency dropped like a rock and people moved to the USD.

Now you have a level of unprecedented uncertainty and interdependency.

The USD looks bad.

Suppose the PIGS collapse the Euro, and it fractures into a northern Euro and a Southern Euro.

That makes the USD look good.

Or the Euro stays together, by way of massive bailouts,

The USD fractures.
 
Last edited:
(re: Have we had hyperinflation between 1964 and the present?)

Agreed. It was meant as a rhetorical question.

I remember when both a gallon of gas and a pack of cigarettes were each about 25¢. I just Googled the current price of cigarettes and found the current price in NY city can be as high as $15 (!).

My point was that it doesn't take hyper-inflation to have a situation where metals can aid one in storing value.

Imagine being alive in 1963 (I was) and scrounging up $2,000 (about the price of a basic new car then) to buy 2,000 silver dollars before the silver was taken out of our coinage (I didn't). At the time, remember, all you had to do was walk into a bank and ask for rolls of silver dollars. If held until today, those coins would be worth about $70,000 - still enough to buy a new car (for now, quite a bit more than a basic one).

With hindsight, there were other things one could have done with that $2,000 that would have WAY outperformed silver or gold, but at the time, none of these were obvious - and there were many ways to lose your money as well.

Inflation is insidious, even when not "hyper". Check out the prices on coffee or cashews in your grocery compared to a year ago. My wife and I can easily spend $100 on groceries on what seem like basics - and we're both vegetarians without exotic tastes. As long as one's wages or investments keep up, one can do just fine. But those on fixed incomes or with their savings in dollars will get hurt. Some badly.
 
Last edited:
Talk about a risible climb-down!

....
Nope, you are still in ad hominem mode. There's no risible climb down. There's simply Francesca throwing a fit when someone, namely me, asks...

"How them Treasury bills bought two years ago doing, Fran? I know how my gold is doing"

In pointing out your errors in logic and your rash presumptions, I don't excuse your baseless accusations one bit. You can't think straight, but you'd talk about investments.

And you can't answer my simple question, apparently.

"How them Treasury bills bought two years ago doing, Fran? I know how my gold is doing"

So go back to prattling about bond investments....likely the very worst thing anyone could do right now. And if you think this is going away, no it ain't.


"How them Treasury bills bought two years ago doing, Fran? I know how my gold is doing"
 
My point was that it doesn't take hyper-inflation to have a situation where metals can aid one in storing value.

Then again, bying any property -- be it metals, real estate, blue chip stocks -- is a great weapon against inflation if you get them cheap. If you bought silver during the Hunt brothers bubble or Microsoft shares at the height of the dot.com bubble, inflation just adds insult to your injury.
 
So go back to prattling about bond investments....likely the very worst thing anyone could do right now. And if you think this is going away, no it ain't.

I have some of my portfolio in a couple of Georgia Muni Bond Funds, free from both Federal and State taxes.

Each month, they pay out about $800 in dividends. That helps keep food on the table more so than gold or silver sitting in a safe deposit box. If we have hyper-inflation, the 4% or 5% tax-free will look pitiful and I'll get hammered in capital losses. But being bond FUNDS, they'll be able to adjust their bond portfolios to reflect higher bond rates if and when they occur.

I guess I'm just arguing for diversification against what appears to be a false dichotomy: either metals OR bonds. A diversified portfolio should contain both, in addition to common stocks - which IMHO should be the lion's share of most portfolios.
 
...if you get them cheap.

Aye, there's the rub.

You never know if they're cheap at the time you're buying.

Lots of people (myself included) bought real estate thinking it was cheap - only to find out that it was in the process of becoming quite a bit cheaper.

I thought Pan Am was cheap at $5, and even cheaper at $3. So it goes.

About Microsoft...

In 1986 I was using Microsoft products on my Mac - Multiplan and Chart, IIRC. I asked my broker his opinion on their IPO, and he persuaded me it was overhyped and I passed.

So sad. At least it taught me that brokers have NO particular insights that I should allow to outweigh my own instincts.

Check out the spreadsheet linked here:

http://www.microsoft.com/investor/Downloads/Stock Information/IPOsharecalc.xls

For those who don't care to download it, if someone had bought 500 shares for $10,500 in 1986 and held them until today, they'd currently own 144,000 shares (after nine splits) worth 3.6 million dollars!

Oh, for a Wayback Machine!
 
Last edited:
(re: Have we had hyperinflation between 1964 and the present?)

Agreed. It was meant as a rhetorical question.

...

My point was that it doesn't take hyper-inflation to have a situation where metals can aid one in storing value.

It was 4% for the time period in question.

The problem is you are arguing possibilities, I actually provided data. Sure, it is possible for silver to be a store of value against inflation. The data I presented, however, showed it's not so. Right now, silver prices are not correlated to inflation in any way. Any retiree putting themselves in the hands of people like the Hunt brothers, margin buyers, shorters, bubble enthusiasts, etc., are far more likely to be hurt than those that look to hedge with less volatile investments.

Empiricism, always. Silver prices are not currently correlated with inflation.


Inflation is insidious, even when not "hyper". Check out the prices on coffee or cashews in your grocery compared to a year ago. My wife and I can easily spend $100 on groceries on what seem like basics - and we're both vegetarians without exotic tastes. As long as one's wages or investments keep up, one can do just fine. But those on fixed incomes or with their savings in dollars will get hurt. Some badly.
For the most part I'm not keeping up with the various positions of posters, so I'm not sure what you are suggesting as an alternative. But, in general, saying things like 'silver is a viable addition to a balanced portfolio' is just that, words.

We need to see a financial model to believe those words. How much as a percentage of your net worth should you invest in silver? How much does it really protect you in various scenarios (a 1% holding effectively does nothing for you if your other 99% crashes). How much risk does it expose you to? Etc.

As you pointed out in another post, you held bonds that actually paid you a reliable income. All silver does is sit there. It doesn't produce, and the only way to get an income stream from it is to sell it or some derivative on it. Given that silver does not follow inflation over a decade or two, a period of time very pertinent to the average retiree, any large % could hurt them far more than inflation. We (most of us) expect inflation to continue in the 4% or so range. Silver is rising and dropping by tens of percents at times. Is that really a sound retirement package?
 
Last edited:
Sure, it is possible for silver to be a store of value against inflation.

This! We can agree to agree, then.

How much as a percentage of your net worth should you invest in silver?

The figure I've most often heard is 10%. That's pretty close to where I am. Than means that 90% is in stocks, bonds, real estate and business investment. There's nothing magic in that number, and there are many scenarios where 0% is feasible. But believing in diversification, I would never suggest a large majority of one's holdings in any asset class.

As you pointed out in another post, you held bonds that actually paid you a reliable income. All silver does is sit there. It doesn't produce, and the only way to get an income stream from it is to sell it or some derivative on it.

Agree to agree, again!

Is that really a sound retirement package?

There are possible, though unlikely, scenarios where someone 100% invested in metals could outperform many asset classes and retire on the profits. But you're arguing against a straw man - just because someone (me) says that metals can be a part of an investment plan does in no way imply that "metals are a really sound retirement package". I certainly never said that.
 
...If we have hyper-inflation, the 4% or 5% tax-free will look pitiful and I'll get hammered in capital losses. But being bond FUNDS, they'll be able to adjust their bond portfolios to reflect higher bond rates if and when they occur.....

Hyperinflation would set your bond prices at zero, and eliminate the merits of any bond fund based in the currency in question.

If one was concerned about hyperinflation, invest in a fashion that creates dependencies on multiple currencies. From this point of view, yes, one could look at bond funds....BUT TO be sure that their mandates allowed offshore investments. Canadian, Australian dollars for example. Not the currency which was considered susceptible to hyperinflation. Then in that case, yes, the fund manager could move to preserve wealth.

Yet moderate inflation would destroy your 4 -5% yield. Say 10% inflation. The expectation of that existing or continuing, you can see what it would do to the bond prices.

Personally I have reasons to believe that USD bond prices understate future inflation in the USA. Certainly muni bonds face a group of risks going forward that they did not in the past, which make them very unattractive, as compared to the past. Pension obligations, largely.
 
...If we have hyper-inflation, the 4% or 5% tax-free will look pitiful and I'll get hammered in capital losses. But being bond FUNDS, they'll be able to adjust their bond portfolios to reflect higher bond rates if and when they occur.....

Hyperinflation would set your bond prices at zero, and eliminate the merits of any bond fund based in the currency in question.

If one was concerned about hyperinflation, invest in a fashion that creates dependencies on multiple currencies. From this point of view, yes, one could look at bond funds....BUT TO be sure that their mandates allowed offshore investments. Canadian, Australian dollars for example. Not the currency which was considered susceptible to hyperinflation. Then in that case, yes, the fund manager could move to preserve wealth.

Yet moderate inflation would destroy your 4 -5% yield. Say 10% inflation. The expectation of that existing or continuing, you can see what it would do to the bond prices.

Personally I have reasons to believe that USD bond prices understate future inflation in the USA. Certainly muni bonds face a group of risks going forward that they did not in the past, which make them very unattractive, as compared to the past. Pension obligations, largely.

One investment that likely can be made today and for the next couple months is refinancing a home at 3.75 percent. That's a fake, government engineered rate. Seems reasonable that one could make out by say taking a 150k loan at 3.75. Five to ten years off, that 3.75 would look ridiculously low (and the 150k would look small too).
 
There are possible, though unlikely, scenarios where someone 100% invested in metals could outperform many asset classes and retire on the profits. But you're arguing against a straw man - just because someone (me) says that metals can be a part of an investment plan does in no way imply that "metals are a really sound retirement package". I certainly never said that.
You are misreading me, or I mis-wrote. My point was in reference to whatever percentage you suggest. 1%? Meaningless in any scenario. 40%? Injurious in many scenarios.

Yes, 10% as a proportion is often trotted out - I am asking for a financial model of this. No one suggesting this ever does the math. Ever.

People that do the math - Buffet and the like - strongly state that you should not invest in metals. So far, I agree (meaning I'm open to a financial model that shows a good risk/benefit profile)

edit: to be fair and intellectually honest, I'm not all that open, as the volatility of silver over the past two decades pretty much eliminates it from consideration. It's not enough to say silver is a hedge for inflation - you have to show that it has been, and will continue to be one. I've shown it has not, and no one has shown that it will be in the future.
 
Last edited:
"How them Treasury bills bought two years ago doing, Fran? [ . . . ]
What Treasury bills that who bought? Have you been implying that I have been long fixed income since 2 years ago? No idea where you get that from. Actually I do--the non-sunny place you got your silver and gold trades from.

Well I have lost money in equities this year, since stuff I bought is mostly considerably lower than where I did, and I don't have any short positions since July (not that they are allowed anyway now)

Made a huge gain on currencies though, and bonds, but I have shrunk the bets down a lot now so not much exciting to tell.
Bonds are overvalued according to my analysis too. [ . . . ]
I am short of bonds in several sovereign markets. Just not for the loopy reasons you give but won't act on.
I do trade futures and I am also short the Jun 11 CBT 10 year and 30 year. I am also long puts on the 10 year (which is a viable alternative since implied volatility is very low across the curve).

I am--however--not short for the reasons you are, but because I expect stronger economic growth and higher real yields. And (as I mentioned above) because I do agree that there is potential for a negative demand shock to come from the game of chicken that the two political parties are playing with fiscal policy, and/or the lamentable failure until recently for either party to address spending. [ . . . ]

So that's three times you've lied about trades? This is too easy. Sorry to pop your nonsense bubble again.

:dl:
 
Last edited:
....So that's three times you've lied about trades?

There you go again. When a question is asked ten or twelve times, and you don't answer, I simply ask it again. Asking the question is not lying, it is simply asking the question. One is welcome to say "No, that is incorrect".

But to you, it is lying, or the opportunity to accuse someone of such. That is the sort of inability to think through a logical issue that seems to plague your postings. Simply said, you reach wrong conclusions, and it seems to be based on emotion rather than facts. You misinterpret facts, and make inferences that are false.
 
When a question is asked ten or twelve times, and you don't answer, I simply ask it again. [ . . . ] One is welcome to say "No, that is incorrect".
Retreat noted, again.

Although you misrepresent yourself:
I assume [ . . . ], you bought US Tbills at that time? [ . . . ]

And "it is simply asking the question" is the trademark of conspiracy woo nutjobs the world over.

But to you, it is lying
The trendier term is JAQing off. Whatever warms your globe. Anyway, are you finally done with inventing investment history?
 
Retreat noted, again.

Although you misrepresent yourself:

And "it is simply asking the question" is the trademark of conspiracy woo nutjobs the world over.

The trendier term is JAQing off. Whatever warms your globe. Anyway, are you finally done with inventing investment history?

No, Francesca, there is no retreat in simply looking at words or phrases, and showing someone what they mean. And what they don't mean, and how certain delusional interpretations are not real. Like those of yours.

As for your other nonsense, that's your problem in letting the question be asked a dozen times. It seems to get you going, for reasons unknown.
 
Aye, there's the rub.

You never know if they're cheap at the time you're buying.

That's not entirely true. According to Yahoo finance, Microsoft has $5.78 net cash per share. The company's profit for the previous 12 months is $2.52 per share; that figure is expected to grow marginally during the next 12 months. If on Monday MSFT stock price suddenly plunges and it sells at $5 instead of Friday's close of a hair over $25, you'd know it's cheap. What you don't know is whether you can get it even cheaper on Tuesday.

Things are a bit dicier with things like silver, because the only thing you have as reference is historical prices. With real estate, I assume reference includes historical prices, rent levels and the cost of construction (but then again, I wouldn't know, because my only real estate "investment" is my home -- and I regard it as a home, not an investment).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom