Merged Silver Over 40.00 / Real and fake prices

Well historically we've never really had an apocalyptic scenario...

And from this you're concluding, what? That it can't happen?

Reminds me of an old Mother's song!

I'm reading a book now on the Great Depression. Some similarities with now, some marked differences.

Anyway, I'm not a doom and gloomer and hope that things will go relatively smoothly going forward - that the Fed can somehow manage fiscal policy to walk the thin line between too much inflation and deflation.

But to think we're immune from an "apocalyptic scenario", well, I've always liked this excerpt:

"We [ Specifically Americans] think we are exempt from universal laws but we are not. People who think they are exempt from universal laws have a moral disease called, hubris, frequently fail. I am not trying to be clever or outrageous; this is simply history, the way the world has been ever since we've been recording it. Separatism is a fact of history at all times of economic distress. Most people will maneuver to maximize their economic lives, always have and always will, and in the process new societies and structures will be established. Sooner or later political structures around them must shift to deal with the change.

Americans find it hard to believe that such laws apple to their country that even their borders can change. They shouldn't. borders and governments move to follow economic interests, which shift constantly, as Adam Smith, Marx and Keynes all noted; then come religious, ethnic, and linguistic reasons. there is no border in the world that has lasted centuries, much less forever. With our short-term myopia, we think it's different this time....... [he talks about large caps and how they eventually get over taken]
Well, in the laws of economics, in the laws of history, in the laws of politics, and in the laws of society its never different this time. The law of gravity isn't ever suspended for someone's convenience, and these laws are just as rigorous, though more subtle and complex. "Oh come on!" I hear all the time [ I heard it from Buffet last Thursday night], "This is America. It's different here." I wish it were, but unfortunately, its never different anywhere, never different anytime. Every piper has to be paid Fall of a cliff and no matter whether you're Spanish, Argentine, Chinese or American, gravity still operates, no different from any other time."


Jim Rogers - Investment Biker

(sorry for the errors - its just a copy/paste.)
 
If the apocalyptic predictions are true then your silver and gold is going to be as worthless as pretty much everything else except food, water, weapons and ammo.

I have no idea why people believe this. In times of chaos, precious metals have always held their value and more. Why should it be any different in times of extreme chaos???

IMO, gold will probably be out of the financial reach of ordinary people.
 
I have no idea why people believe this. In times of chaos, precious metals have always held their value and more. Why should it be any different in times of extreme chaos???

Mainly because they have not held their value in times of chaos. In 1920’s Germany you would have needed significant amounts of gold to buy even a small amount of food. You seem to be under the impression that because cash did worse (did it?) that gold did well which isn’t the case.
 
From Wikipedia (Hyperinflation):

"During a period of hyperinflation, bank runs, loans for 24 hour periods, switching to alternate currencies, the return to use of gold or silver or even barter become common..."

I don't see how one can argue that if currency is being hyper-inflated, its not reasonable to attempt to store value via commodities, of which gold and silver are but two.

Or maybe it will be different this time! ;)
 
Mainly because they have not held their value in times of chaos. In 1920’s Germany you would have needed significant amounts of gold to buy even a small amount of food. You seem to be under the impression that because cash did worse (did it?) that gold did well which isn’t the case.

What "did well" then??

I'm betting the only thing which did better than gold was farmland.
 
And from this you're concluding, what? That it can't happen?

No. I'm concluding that looking at past non-apocalyptic events as evidence of what would happen to gold prices in a globally apocalyptic event is not really useful. I thought that was pretty clear given what I was talking about.
 
I have no idea why people believe this. In times of chaos, precious metals have always held their value and more. Why should it be any different in times of extreme chaos???

IMO, gold will probably be out of the financial reach of ordinary people.

In times of some, temporary, chaos yes. 'Precious' metals can be a good place to store funds while the crisis plays out or as a method of exchange with areas which are unaffected.

In a global catastrophe all bets are off. Everyone is going to be in the same boat and there will be noone to trade your gold with.

Gold/Silver/Shiny things have no intrinsic value. They're only worth what people with wealth are willing to give you for them. Your final comment that gold would be out of the reach of people should point to something that seems economically flawed - the only people who could afford to buy gold would be the people who already had it?

Or put it another way? Why would I want to trade my tasty, delicious and nourishing food for your shiny but inedible gold?

From Wikipedia (Hyperinflation):

"During a period of hyperinflation, bank runs, loans for 24 hour periods, switching to alternate currencies, the return to use of gold or silver or even barter become common..."

I don't see how one can argue that if currency is being hyper-inflated, its not reasonable to attempt to store value via commodities, of which gold and silver are but two.

Or maybe it will be different this time! ;)

Because what the global economic collapse people are arguing is not a 'period of hyperinflation' but a global economic meltdown. Back to the Wild West/Stone Age type stuff.

Good luck with having a piece of paper that says you own X ounces of gold stored in vault somewhere hundreds of miles away (which is what a lot of 'gold investors' actually have) if that happens.

What "did well" then??

I'm betting the only thing which did better than gold was farmland.

So we should all be investing in land and property then - things with intrinsic value rather than shiny baubles?
 
In times of some, temporary, chaos yes. 'Precious' metals can be a good place to store funds while the crisis plays out or as a method of exchange with areas which are unaffected.

In a global catastrophe all bets are off. Everyone is going to be in the same boat and there will be noone to trade your gold with.

Why will there be nobody to trade my gold with?

Gold/Silver/Shiny things have no intrinsic value. They're only worth what people with wealth are willing to give you for them. Your final comment that gold would be out of the reach of people should point to something that seems economically flawed - the only people who could afford to buy gold would be the people who already had it?

No. The only people who could afford to buy gold would be large organisations like nation states and obscenely rich individuals. Gold will be traded just like it is at the moment. The only difference will be that it is a lot more expensive. Silver will probably take over the role gold currently plays for "normal" people.

Or put it another way? Why would I want to trade my tasty, delicious and nourishing food for your shiny but inedible gold?

Depends how much food you had. Food goes off. Gold doesn't. If you've just got a bucketfull of apples then there won't be a lot of point in trading it for a small speck of gold, but if you've got a whole orchard full of apples then trading them for some gold would be a very real option.

Because what the global economic collapse people are arguing is not a 'period of hyperinflation' but a global economic meltdown. Back to the Wild West/Stone Age type stuff.

Depends which "people" you are talking about. This is not an either/or between Business As Usual and Olduvai Theory. I'm more of a Long Descent sort of doomer.

Good luck with having a piece of paper that says you own X ounces of gold stored in vault somewhere hundreds of miles away (which is what a lot of 'gold investors' actually have) if that happens.

Those people are fools. I own physical gold sovereigns: impossible to convincingly fake and easy to sell. The whole point in owning gold as a protective measure against a collapsing global financial system is that the physical stuff retains its value. I totally agree that if "your" gold is physically located in somebody-else's vault then you might as well not own it all when TSHTF.

So we should all be investing in land and property then - things with intrinsic value rather than shiny baubles?

Farmland is likely to be a good invesment. As for houses and commercial property....that all depends on local conditions. In the US there is an oversupply of houses. In the UK there is a shortage. Therefore buying houses may not be such a good idea in the US as it is in the UK. It also depends what sort of house and what sort of district it is in - does it have a decent sized garden? Are the neighbours criminals?

There is a fascinating debate within the doomer community between those who believe there is going to be a population migration from the cities to the countryside and those who believe the migration will go the other way. It all depends on what sort of world you believe will emerge after the peak of the crisis.
 
Last edited:
Of course it's harder to forge an apple than it is to forge a gold coin. Gold will be a poor medium for exchange and storing wealth unless the quality of that gold can be easily verified.

A demonstrably working firearm with ammunition on the other hand would be an excellent thing to stockpile
 
Of course it's harder to forge an apple than it is to forge a gold coin. Gold will be a poor medium for exchange and storing wealth unless the quality of that gold can be easily verified.

It is actually very hard to fake a small gold coin. All you need to know to be able to be sure it is a genuine coin and not a fake is the measurements of the coin and its weight. The only metals that could be used to create the fake are more expensive than gold, because gold is so dense. The only element which is close to the correct density but also very cheap is tungsten, but tungsten has totally different chemical and other physical properties to gold.
 
Why will there be nobody to trade my gold with?

No. The only people who could afford to buy gold would be large organisations like nation states and obscenely rich individuals. Gold will be traded just like it is at the moment. The only difference will be that it is a lot more expensive. Silver will probably take over the role gold currently plays for "normal" people..

Maybe I'm missing something and I await my education but why do you believe the demand for gold and silver would remain in a post global economic apocalypse situation?

Surely at the very least, if you are prepared to entertain the risk of a global economic implosion and hedge against it with gold you should also be willing to entertain the risk that gold might become worthless too?

Seriously if I'm a nation state or an individual with obscene wealth I'm not looking to buy more gold - I'm looking to buy weapons and ammo and food and water or the means to produce them.
 
Maybe I'm missing something and I await my education but why do you believe the demand for gold and silver would remain in a post global economic apocalypse situation?

For precisely the same reason that they have been valuable ever since humans first discovered them. Gold, silver and a handful of other metals which sit close to them in the periodic table have always been a reliable store of wealth because of their physical properties. Non-elements aren't generally much use, unless they are incredibly hard to produce (e.g. diamonds historically, but we can now make artificial diamonds). There are only 83 naturally-occuring elements with stable isotopes. Of those, which could be a reliable store of wealth? Well, you have to get rid of everything which is a gas or liquid at room temperatures, everything which readily reacts with other elements and everything which is either too abundant or too rare. What does this leave? It leaves gold, silver, platinum, palladium, rhodium and iridium, and that's about it. These metals sit in a neat block of six in the periodic table, and the further you get away from that part of the table, the less suitable the elements are to be "precious metals."

Surely at the very least, if you are prepared to entertain the risk of a global economic implosion and hedge against it with gold you should also be willing to entertain the risk that gold might become worthless too?

Only if I was crazy....

Seriously if I'm a nation state or an individual with obscene wealth I'm not looking to buy more gold - I'm looking to buy weapons and ammo and food and water or the means to produce them.

If you've already got lots of gold then you may well want to sell some of it in order to buy other stuff you need. Gold is just a currency - money - it's just a special sort of money which nobody can artificially devalue. There's nothing the powers that be would like right now more than to be able to control the price of bullion. They have tried every trick in the book to keep it down, but they are fighting a losing battle, because there are far too many people, from central banks to common people in Asia, who see gold exactly like I see it and who can also see where the world is heading. Gold is the canary in the mine, and she is going to sing her heart out....
 
Last edited:
For precisely the same reason that they have been valuable ever since humans first discovered them. Gold, silver and a handful of other metals which sit close to them in the periodic table have always been a reliable store of wealth because of their physical properties. Non-elements aren't generally much use, unless they are incredibly hard to produce (e.g. diamonds historically, but we can now make artificial diamonds). There are only 83 naturally-occuring elements with stable isotopes. Of those, which could be a reliable store of wealth? Well, you have to get rid of everything which is a gas or liquid at room temperatures, everything which readily reacts with other elements and everything which is either too common (e.g. iron, aluminium) or too rare (e.g.osmium). What does this leave? It leaves gold, silver, platinum, palladium, rhodium and iridium, and that's about it. These metals sit in a neat block of six in the periodic table, and the further you get away from that part of the table, the less suitable the elements are to be "precious metals."

So what? They still have no intrinsic value.

Only if I was crazy....

Well that's a useful comeback. You can't see any possible circumstance under which people might just decide that they don't really want gold all that much? Every other single commodity can drop in value but not gold because it's 'special'?


If you've already got lots of gold then you may well want to sell some of it in order to buy other stuff you need. Gold is just a currency - money - it's just a special sort of money which nobody can artificially devalue. There's nothing the powers that be would like right now more than to be able to control the price of bullion. They have tried every trick in the book to keep it down, but they are fighting a losing battle, because there are far too many people, from central banks to common people in Asia, who see gold exactly like I see it and who can also see where the world is heading. Gold is the canary in the mine, and she is going to sing her heart out....

Yes, lots of people see gold as a hedge against something fairly bad happening for some finite period of time. The plan in some cases is to store the value in the gold see out the 'bad thing' and then exchange it back to money when the system corrects in other cases its just to benefit from the rise in price of gold as an investment.

Thats a far sight from exchanging your sovereigns for water and grain. If we get to that point good luck getting to the water and grain shop with your sovereigns in your pocket.
 
So what? They still have no intrinsic value.

Did you actually read what I wrote? I just explained to you exactly why they have intrinsic value. They are valuable because they are the only elements usable as stores of wealth. They have physical properties which are unlike those of any other substances that exist. What about that do you not understand?

Well that's a useful comeback. You can't see any possible circumstance under which people might just decide that they don't really want gold all that much? Every other single commodity can drop in value but not gold because it's 'special'?

That is correct, or it would be if you'd written "precious metals" instead of "gold." What happens to the values of other commodities depends on the nature of those commodities. There is a limit to how high the price of wheat, for example, can go. This limit is due to the fact that wheat is a perishable commodity which is bought by vast numbers of people as part of the everyday survival. When the price goes up beyond a certain point (say it doubles from today's prices) then all that happens is a large number of the world's poor people can't afford to buy it and eventually starve to death. So wheat can go up in price and can act as a short-term store of value but it can only go up so far and is no use as a long-term store. Wheat is not money. Resources like iron and oil aren't perishable but they are too bulky for most people to use them as a store of wealth and in the case of oil there is also a limit to how high the price can go before non-investors can no longer afford to buy it.

Precious metals are special. That's why they are precious metals.

Yes, lots of people see gold as a hedge against something fairly bad happening for some finite period of time. The plan in some cases is to store the value in the gold see out the 'bad thing' and then exchange it back to money when the system corrects in other cases its just to benefit from the rise in price of gold as an investment.

Yes.

Thats a far sight from exchanging your sovereigns for water and grain. If we get to that point good luck getting to the water and grain shop with your sovereigns in your pocket.

I never said I would directly exchange gold for food. Somebody else started talking about that...was it you? :)
 
Last edited:
What "did well" then??

I'm betting the only thing which did better than gold was farmland.

The people who do really well off gold in times of crisis are the one who buy not the ones who sell.


Any other commodity would likely have done at least as well. Food related commodities almost certainly did better.

Realestate & Land would have been the largest asset classes and both would have outperformed gold

Businesses/Stocks at the time had significant problems with transparency, but with access to real financial information about the company it would have been relatively easy to outperform gold.
 
For precisely the same reason that they have been valuable ever since humans first discovered them. Gold, silver and a handful of other metals which sit close to them in the periodic table have always been a reliable store of wealth because of their physical properties.

The notable “physical properties” of gold are that it’s shiny and malleable. These may have been fairly rare at one point but are common today. Gold has no useful physical properties that can help you in day to day life so in times of crisis its value drops relative to things that can people in their daily lives.
 
Of course it's harder to forge an apple than it is to forge a gold coin. Gold will be a poor medium for exchange and storing wealth unless the quality of that gold can be easily verified.

A demonstrably working firearm with ammunition on the other hand would be an excellent thing to stockpile
A hundred cases of big bottles of vodka, whisky and rum would do nicely. Somehow they seem to have an everyday utility that firearms and gold lack....
 
The notable “physical properties” of gold are that it’s shiny and malleable.

Did you read my post explaining why precious metals are precious? The fact that it is shiny and malleable is irrelevant. What matters is that it is an element which is solid, non-reactive, non-radioactive, not so common as anybody can get hold of it and not so rare that almost nobody can get hold of it. It being not actually useful for much (if this was actually true, which it isn't) is also irrelevant, because it is being used as a store of wealth, not a consumable commodity.

These may have been fairly rare at one point but are common today.

The rareness of gold depends on its occurence in the Earth's crust and the difficulties facing anyone hoping to mine what is left of it.

Gold has no useful physical properties that can help you in day to day life so in times of crisis its value drops relative to things that can people in their daily lives.

Gold and silver are the best electrically-conducting metals known. They are used in manufacturing of various high-performance and extreme-tolerance products for this purpose.

I simply don't buy your argument that in times of crisis precious metals will drop relative to things like food. This has never happened historically and I see know reason why it should happen in the future. The only truth in what you are saying is that if there is almost no food left and nearly everybody is close to starvation then almost nobody will be interested in swapping their food for your gold. Sure...but if we get to that sort of a situation then life won't be worth living anyway, so it doesn't matter.
 
Hyperinflation watch, day elebenty.....

Current silver spot price: Under $35

Personally, I am not expecting hyperinflation. High inflation yes, hyperinflation no. Hyperinflation requires that wages rise to match prices, and I see the opposite happening. In the UK at least, wages are going down, not up.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom