Merged Silver Over 40.00 / Real and fake prices

That's not entirely true.

I think it is.

According to Yahoo finance, Microsoft has $5.78 net cash per share. The company's profit for the previous 12 months is $2.52 per share; that figure is expected to grow marginally during the next 12 months. If on Monday MSFT stock price suddenly plunges and it sells at $5 instead of Friday's close of a hair over $25, you'd know it's cheap.

If there's truly a free market in Microsoft, each and every thing you just put forth is known to the general public. Hence, that fall to $5 would still reflect its fair market price at the time.

What you don't know is whether you can get it even cheaper on Tuesday.

Exactly. If it want on to trade for years in the range of $2 to $3, then the $5 price could hardly be seen as "cheap".

When Chrysler was near bankruptcy in 1987 and around $3, I thought it was "cheap" and bought some, hoping an American institution would recover. I was right and made some money.

When Pan Am was near bankruptcy in 1987 and 1988 and around $5 to $3, I thought it was "cheap" and bought some, hoping an American institution would recover. I was wrong and lost some money.

I've come to hold that, in a true free market, things are always fairly priced, by definition. If someone says gold or silver or Chrysler or Pan Am or real estate or tulips are "overpriced" or "cheap", I discount it entirely - unless they're operating on some kind of inside information, which in the case of securities is illegal.

I always love it when "technical analysts" attempt to use charts of past performance to try to predict future performance. Again, given a free market I believe such prognostication is equivalent to reading tea leaves.
 
I always love it when "technical analysts" attempt to use charts of past performance to try to predict future performance. Again, given a free market I believe such prognostication is equivalent to reading tea leaves.

I agree on TA; it reminds me of pareidolia. What technical analysts are excellent at is recognizing and naming patterns after-the-fact. I fail to see any real use for that.

I still do think that if a net-debt-free company whose business isn't about to disappear entirely trades at P/E value of 2 on Monday, it's cheap regardless of its stock price on Tuesday or Wednesday. If someone were to offer me MSFT for $5 a piece tomorrow, I'd gladly sell most (or perhaps even all) of my stock holdings to buy as many as possible. As long as Microsoft's business was intact, I wouldn't care much if someone got it for $4 on Tuesday -- it would eventually rise to reflect something like its "true value"; we may disagree on the specifics of what that true value is, but it's significantly more than $5 per share.
 
I agree on TA; it reminds me of pareidolia. What technical analysts are excellent at is recognizing and naming patterns after-the-fact. I fail to see any real use for that.

I still do think that if a net-debt-free company whose business isn't about to disappear entirely trades at P/E value of 2 on Monday, it's cheap regardless of its stock price on Tuesday or Wednesday. If someone were to offer me MSFT for $5 a piece tomorrow, I'd gladly sell most (or perhaps even all) of my stock holdings to buy as many as possible. As long as Microsoft's business was intact, I wouldn't care much if someone got it for $4 on Tuesday -- it would eventually rise to reflect something like its "true value"; we may disagree on the specifics of what that true value is, but it's significantly more than $5 per share.

One trade I made that I think was smart was based on fundamentals. On examining the financials, I realized that the company had cash on hand equal to about 2/3 of their entire market cap (EG current value of all shares outstanding), and minimal debt. This was one of the companies that went way up in the Dotcom bubble, then went way, way down...essentially becoming a penny stock.

I bought a considerable amount in that company, and sold it several years later making 4-5x.

In hindsight there are no trades that I made which were based on "trends" which were smart. (And no, I've never believed in "reading the charts").
 
Last edited:
If there's truly a free market in Microsoft, each and every thing you just put forth is known to the general public. Hence, that fall to $5 would still reflect its fair market price at the time.
We don't have a truly free market (the term is efficient).

I'll happily agree that we have a mostly free market. But the anonomlys are out there. Watch prices when we have a market crash, for example.

Prices are not based on bests available information. Prices are always, always based on supply vs demand. Always. There is no other way, based on how our system is set up (our = USA).

Now sure, usually supply and demand is based on available information, but not always. Let's say there is a credit crisis. Some stocks fall. People have to sell to meet their margin requirements. They end up selling stocks that are good, to prop up the stocks that are bad. Supply rises, demand falls, thus price falls. Solid AAA companies like Berkshire, P&G, utilities, all get put on sale because the money has to come from somewhere, and it ain't coming from the failing companies. We saw that happen in 2008. At the time, when everyone was crying, I predicted (on this forum) that this was going to generate the next generation of multi-billionares. I still stand behind that, though we haven't yet seen a lot of press on the people that took advantage of that period.

That's just one example. I could bore you senseless typing many other examples. Nothing I typed would belie the fact that markets are often efficient, but they for sure prove that they are not always efficient.

FWIW, your personal examples are not proof of efficiency. They were proof of you investing with insufficient information. That provides no proof one way or the other about the efficiency of markets.
 
Prices are not based on bests available information. Prices are always, always based on supply vs demand. Always. There is no other way, based on how our system is set up (our = USA).

Of course.

But that supply and demand is predicated upon individuals and institutions informed by information. Certainly, no one can have perfect access to all available information, but I still hold that Adam Smith's "Invisible Hand" results in things being priced appropriately at any given time.
 
Of course.

But that supply and demand is predicated upon individuals and institutions informed by information. Certainly, no one can have perfect access to all available information, but I still hold that Adam Smith's "Invisible Hand" results in things being priced appropriately at any given time.
That's another time you've just ignored the information I've presented. We know, for sure, that supply/demand is sometimes predicated on things other than 'all available information'. We know this. It makes no sense to maintain otherwise. You can't say 'of course' and then retreat back to your original claim. supply/demand != all available information. Hence, pricing anomalies exist.

edit: Go back and read news reports from 2008. Big money managers were selling what they considered high quality stocks because they needed to 1) prop up their margined stocks; 2) liquidate their fund because people were selling their mutual funds; 3) etc. This happened. Those great stocks did get priced at bargain prices. Others with cash in hand (Buffett et al) took advantage and bought.

You cannot deny this happened.
 
Last edited:
That's another time you've just ignored the information I've presented. We know, for sure, that supply/demand is sometimes predicated on things other than 'all available information'. We know this. It makes no sense to maintain otherwise. You can't say 'of course' and then retreat back to your original claim. supply/demand != all available information. Hence, pricing anomalies exist.

edit: Go back and read news reports from 2008. Big money managers were selling what they considered high quality stocks because they needed to 1) prop up their margined stocks; 2) liquidate their fund because people were selling their mutual funds; 3) etc. This happened. Those great stocks did get priced at bargain prices. Others with cash in hand (Buffett et al) took advantage and bought.

You cannot deny this happened.
The argument of "no correlation" does not hold water, and here is why. I assume first that we are actually using the word correlation as per statistics. First, it would be necessary to cut out auto correlation in the time series, and look at time displacements as well as first and second order effects.

For example, it may be that a weak exponential of the first derivative of the time series of silver price, exhibits good correlation when lagged by two years with inflation.

That is just an example.

I don't assume or impute that it is true, but simply have to illustrate that "correlation between inflation and silver price" is not simply taking the two time series and running the correlation on them. I do suggest that these would be the sorts of things one might look at, to see if a correlation existed.
 
OMFG - Silver has now soared to a little under $35.

It's now inevitable that it will soon reach $1,500 (and by soon, I mean some time in next 5,000 years) and that inflation over that same short period will erode the value of non-interest bearing investments held in dollars. It's what I intend to call "extended timeframe hyperinflation" in which prices rise considerably over an extended period of time.

For example according to this site provided by the Bank of England shows that prices increased 20 fold (2000%) over the 60 years from 1948. That's hyperinflaton by any measure and by applying Muldur's calculation method, it's an average of over 30% a year.


Isn't it amazing how quiet these threads become when the price is stable or declining ?
 
Thought I'd pop back, give a bump and give the latest silver price (as it head up into the stratosphere due to US hyperinflation).

Current spot price - $35.68
 
Thought I'd pop back, give a bump and give the latest silver price (as it head up into the stratosphere due to US hyperinflation).

Current spot price - $35.68

Unless, of course, it doesn't!

If you did not mean the above facetiously, and really believe it and have confidence in your prediction, sell any and all other investments you may have and buy silver. In fact, take out a mortgage or other loan and buy more. You could leverage this into some REALLY big gains!

Just be prepared for the effect on your net worth and cash flow if silver drops to $10 and lingers there for a decade or so before finally going stratospheric.
 
Unless, of course, it doesn't!

If you did not mean the above facetiously, and really believe it and have confidence in your prediction, sell any and all other investments you may have and buy silver. In fact, take out a mortgage or other loan and buy more. You could leverage this into some REALLY big gains!

Just be prepared for the effect on your net worth and cash flow if silver drops to $10 and lingers there for a decade or so before finally going stratospheric.

I was being facetious. I don't believe that silver (and gold for that matter) are the investment panacea that people like MichaelSuede says it is.

I don't believe that they make great investments because all you'll get is capital gains.

I don't believe that the hyperinflation that MichaelSuede is expecting imminently is going to happen any time soon.

By all means have some commodities as an inflation hedge as a (small) proportion of your overall investment portfolio but don't go overboard.

I was also highlighting the fact this kind of thread gets very quiet when the price of the commodity in question isn't going up any more. I also think the silverbugs will claim that they sold at the peak (and subsequently reinvested at the trough) in the event that there is a significant drop in the silver price.
 
OMFG - Silver has now soared to a little under $35.

It's now inevitable that it will soon reach $1,500 (and by soon, I mean some time in next 5,000 years)

I predict silver will reach $5000 an oz around 2200 AD give or take 50 years.
 
I was being facetious. I don't believe that silver (and gold for that matter) are the investment panacea that people like MichaelSuede says it is.

Agreed. Sarchasm! ;)

I also think the silverbugs will claim that they sold at the peak (and subsequently reinvested at the trough) in the event that there is a significant drop in the silver price.

While I'm nearly 100% in agreement with everything else you posited, in my experience true "silverbugs" tend to be of a "buy-and-hold" mentality. Those in and out of silver as you suggest are mere speculators - who could just as easily be speculating on nearly any commodity in the same manner.
 
Gold and silver are not an investment panacea.

They are protection against government debasement of the currency.

Gold and silver by themselves are nothing more than trade facilitators.

For example, the country of Belarus just devalued its currency by 56%

The Belarusians who were holding gold were obviously not effected by this criminal action.

In the blink of an eye, a regime can wipe out the value of its citizens' savings accounts. The US default will be much more dramatic, with a collapse of the US bond markets followed by chaos in the international markets.

The US wiped out savings by the end of the war for independence by devaluing the Continental Dollar.

The Confederates wiped out savings by the end of the Civil War through debasement.

The US declared a tacit default when it ceased gold redemptions in 1933 and confiscated privately held gold.

The US declared yet another tacit default when it closed the gold window in 1971.

And now the US has declared yet another tacit default by doubling the money supply overnight in 2008.
 
Last edited:
The Belarusians who were holding gold were obviously not effected by this criminal action.

[snark] or even affected [/snark]

The devaluation of the Belarussian currency only affected people who wish to purchase things overseas. IIRC, here in the UK when the pound was devalued in the '70s we all weren't immediately poor.

Yes there was inflation but interest rates were such that savings continued to grow in real terms, as did wages. Debt on the other hand was much smaller - result most people were much better off.

Also it's not a criminal action on the grounds that it's perfectly legal

In the blink of an eye, a regime can wipe out the value of its citizens' savings accounts. The US default will be much more dramatic, with a collapse of the US bond markets followed by chaos in the international markets.

When will this default take place? When can we say whether you were right or wrong ?

At the moment you are predicting a very bad thing at an unspecified time in the future.

Either the end is imminent, in which case have the stones to say "I. MichealSuede say that US inflation will be over 100% in the next 12 months" or whatever your prediction is.

My prediction - and I'm happy to be called on it.

US inflation (as measured by the annual Current Consumer Price index) will not:

- exceed 10% in the next 12 months
- exceed 20% in the next 5 years
- result in prices doubling in the next 5 years (so it'll average less that 14%)

If I'm wrong I'll be happy to say so, do the sorry dance and sing the sorry song
 
Quote from earlier in this thread on 8 April 2011...

No, silver is about to undergo an exponential increase in price.....

How imminently is "about to" ?

- A month ?
- A quarter ?
- A year ?

I personally think over a year hardly qualifies as "about to".

Clearly if the price of Silver surges up then we'll know you are right, but when would you admit you were wrong ?

You also suggested.......

...I might be able to feed myself for a few days with a single pre-1946 dime.

Surely in days of hyperinflation a silver dime would buy the same amount of stuff as it always has, you'd just need a lot more fiat money.

Actually, if it's the silver you're after, coins before 1964 are 90% silver, not just those pre-1946 (that was the change from the liberty head dime to the Roosevelt dime, not a change in composition or size)

Pre hyer inflation..

Pre 1964 dime = 2.0412g of silver (2.268g @90%) = approximately $2.50 (fiat money) of silver = 1 ham sammich


Post hyper inflation

Pre 1964 dime = 2.0412g of silver (2.268g @90%) = approximately $2.50gajillion (fiat money) of silver = 1 ham sammich
 
Quote from earlier in this thread on 8 April 2011...



How imminently is "about to" ?

- A month ?
- A quarter ?
- A year ?

I personally think over a year hardly qualifies as "about to".

Clearly if the price of Silver surges up then we'll know you are right, but when would you admit you were wrong ?

You also suggested.......



Surely in days of hyperinflation a silver dime would buy the same amount of stuff as it always has, you'd just need a lot more fiat money.

Actually, if it's the silver you're after, coins before 1964 are 90% silver, not just those pre-1946 (that was the change from the liberty head dime to the Roosevelt dime, not a change in composition or size)

Pre hyer inflation..

Pre 1964 dime = 2.0412g of silver (2.268g @90%) = approximately $2.50 (fiat money) of silver = 1 ham sammich


Post hyper inflation

Pre 1964 dime = 2.0412g of silver (2.268g @90%) = approximately $2.50gajillion (fiat money) of silver = 1 ham sammich
The last several decades of economic history in Argentina include periods of moderate inflation, severe inflation and hyperinflation. The only people in Argentina that retained their wealth are those that had that wealth in real estate or metals. This is repeated over and over in other countries that have had similar experiences.

And the middle class was impoverished.
 
The last several decades of economic history in Argentina include periods of moderate inflation, severe inflation and hyperinflation. The only people in Argentina that retained their wealth are those that had that wealth in real estate or metals. This is repeated over and over in other countries that have had similar experiences.

Really? Nobody in Argentina invested abroad? There were no publically listed companies in Argentina that kept their business going?
 
The last several decades of economic history in Argentina include periods of moderate inflation, severe inflation and hyperinflation. The only people in Argentina that retained their wealth are those that had that wealth in real estate or metals. This is repeated over and over in other countries that have had similar experiences.

And the middle class was impoverished.

Excuse me, what part of my post were you disagreeing with ?

Do you support MichaelSuede's claim that a single pre-1946 dime may be able to feed him for a few days.

Could you please demonstrate how that might work. I provided an example to support my hypothesis that in a hyperinflation scenario an amount of silver gets you the same amount of stuff, but rather a lot of local currency.

You also seem to have ignored the fact that the middle classes (however that is defined) are net debtors (after all, they tend to have large home loans). according to this article (which was the first I found with the readily accessible information I wanted)

40 percent of middle-class homeowners have paid off less than half of the money they owe on their homes.

I have no idea how many (or few) have no home loan at all but it sounds like the middle class benefit most from the reduction in debt that results from hyperinflation.

I know in the case of my parents in the 1970's in the UK, many years of sustained inflation turned their crippling monthly mortgage payments in 1972 into pocket-change by 1980.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom