Should Congress Always Listen to the People?

Unfortunately, the people are saying that they want single-payer, no changes to Medicare, tort-reform, free-market solutions, a public option, no new taxes, a National Health Service, no death panels, no rationing, equal healthcare for all, better healthcare for the rich, a ban on abortions, no ban on abortions, no expansion of government, it should be completely free and everyone gets a pony.

Yes, I pointed some of this out earlier (post 51). This "listen to the people" business is--to put it politely--an inconsistent position. :)

I think it's actually just another crappy rhetorical device--just a way to "spin" the situation to make it look like the Republicans have become a populist party.
 
Again, you're making a false dichotomy. Not obeying the "will of the people" as expressed by an opinion poll isn't the same thing as "ignoring the will of the people".

See above. I think the Republicans are using the phrase "listen to the people" (as in "The Democrats won't listen to the people") to play on this ambiguity.

So pretty much your question is a loaded question. It assumes someone is "ignoring the people".
Now your avoiding. You say congress is structured to balance a more direct representation of the people with a more independent group. My question is at what point do you expect the congress, as a whole, to respond to the wishes of the people?
 
My question is at what point do you expect the congress, as a whole, to respond to the wishes of the people?

In the 2008 election, the wishes of the people were to get the hell out of Iraq. "Health care reform" as a wish of The People is a fantasy those in the left have.

I mean, if we're talking about The Wishes of The People...
 
How elitist and condescending of you to assume I have only read the Preamble. Now the part I highlighted, you want to try to explain that? Here's a link to the Constitution. Point out the pertinent parts;The first 3 words refer to ALL the people. Not just the framers of the Constitution.

Things in the government that can prevent simple majority rule (some are in the constitution, some are not):

1) The electoral college.

2) Life long appointments to the Supreme Court ensure the Justices don't need to make popular decisions.

3) A representative democracy puts a barrier between the people and the law. Direct democracy does not have that barrier.

4) The presidental veto.

5) The amendment process is brutal.

6) Filibusters.

7) Term limits.

Should I go on?
 
My question is at what point do you expect the congress, as a whole, to respond to the wishes of the people?

At the very least, I would like Congress to go against the people if they can determine the people have based their decision on something that is objectively wrong. (ie creationism)
 
Now your [sic] avoiding. You say congress is structured to balance a more direct representation of the people with a more independent group. My question is at what point do you expect the congress, as a whole, to respond to the wishes of the people?

I am not avoiding anything. I already answered this. You're making a false dichotomy. Congress should always "respond to the wishes of the people", but that doesn't mean they should obey the will of the people as expressed by an opinion poll.

They can respond to a majority opinion by disagreeing with it. It doesn't mean they're ignoring it or not listening to it. If we wanted a system where legislation was passed by plebiscite, we could have established such a system. If we wanted something closer to that, we could have made a unicameral Congress (just a House with no Senate).
 
By the way, an interesting point in the distinction between the way the House and the Senate were set up: originally, the Constitution called for members of the House to be elected directly by the people of the states, but for Senators to be selected by the state legislatures. The 17th Amendment changed this--backing off a little bit from the idea of a less responsive body by having Senators elected directly by the people of the states as well.

So to argue that this distinction isn't something done deliberately and intentionally is to ignore the legislative history of the Constitution itself.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom