Should Congress Always Listen to the People?

No, Congress should not always listen to the people. That's not leadership, that's followership. However, they must also be willing to pay the price for ignoring the people; in general this involves getting unelected. It will be interesting to see how many in Congress are willing to go that route.

What Brainster said.
 
...It's been shown that when the health care reform is actually read by "the people" then more of them support it...

Where has this been shown? Evidence please. Show me the proof. As of now, I don't believe this.



...I don't mean to sound elitist,
...

Maybe you don't mean to sound elitist, but you do. What are the first 3 word of the preamble of The Constitution
 
I don't think it's elitist but what percentage of congress is well enough informed about healthcare, economics and poverty to make an intelligent decision on the matter?

This-----^

How many congress critters are experts on the above, and how many are just listening to what their party bigwigs want instead of the folks back home want?
 
Last edited:
Congress doesn't have the welfare of the Country in mind.
Congress serves special interest at the expense of the people.

If Congress truly wanted to improve our health care system they would start by addressing the fraud and waste in the current system.
As it is Congress wants to maintain the current fraud and waste, and create new ways to profit from even more of the same.
 
I have to hand it to the Republicans though. Giving poll numbers is a brilliant strategy because it forces Democrats into either saying nothing at all or saying “I know more than they do”. The latter statement would not insult me but it would send thin-skinned people into a rage.

You'd have a point if this applied across the board. But whenever the government tries to follow a policy Democrats don't like, we get rants about the Republican "dictatorship", "theocracy", "oligarchy", etc.

In reality it's whomever in the minority that mysteriously discovers that what the public think suddenly doesn't matter.

This is not to say that the public is always informed; but I doubt the motivation behind this sudden epiphany that reveals the obvious.
 
You'd have a point if this applied across the board. But whenever the government tries to follow a policy Democrats don't like, we get rants about the Republican "dictatorship", "theocracy", "oligarchy", etc.

In reality it's whomever in the minority that mysteriously discovers that what the public think suddenly doesn't matter.

Oh sure. Democrats have done the same in the past. See my reference to nuclear power above.

This is not to say that the public is always informed; but I doubt the motivation behind this sudden epiphany that reveals the obvious.

Of course you doubt that; I'm more liberal that you. It wasn't an epiphany, it is just the first time I've started a thread on the idea. I felt motivated to post because it happens to be a current event.
 
Last edited:
Maybe you don't mean to sound elitist, but you do.

Now that I read my post again, I was being the opposite of elitist. I admitted I didn't know enough to make an intelligent comment. If anything, I was too hard on myself.

What are the first 3 word of the preamble of The Constitution?

They are "not legally binding". :p

In all seriousness though, the Constitution as a whole is contructed so that the popular opinion may not become law. If you read more than the preamble, you'd know that.
 
I thought about this last night as I tried to sleep. The key point is constitutionality. You're right, if the constitution is changed, then it's done. However, the congress should be aware that their amendment is unconstitutional. Since they have sworn to uphold the constitution, then they aren't upholding their end of the republic.

So you're saying that an amendment, which has the sole purpose of changing the constitution, is unconstitutional because it changes the constitution. Using that line of reasoning there are currently 27 amendments to the constitution and they're all unconstitutional. "No, we can't have an amendment giving women and the blacks the right to vote- that would be unconstitutional."

The constitution itself gives the procedure for amending the constitution, so I'm not sure how you can say that an amendment is unconstitutional and that congress isn't upholding their end of the republic when they follow the procedure given in the constitution to create an amendment. (In addition, congress can't amend the constitution by itself- 3/4 of the states have to agree before the amendment is valid).
 
Maybe you don't mean to sound elitist, but you do. What are the first 3 word of the preamble of The Constitution

Good thing thoughts are conveyed in full sentences, and paragraphs and context. The first three words of the Preamble referred to the people who saw fit to establish a government (in particular by the Constitution). It does not refer to who should pass laws, or otherwise address the topic of this thread.

It was obvious that the two houses of Congress were meant to reflect two different attitudes. The House was meant to be more populist and more responsive to the people, whereas the Senate was a bit of a elitist idea--that they were to be the more learned politicians.

So, The Painter, what's your response to the Creationism question? Since the majority of Americans believe that humans were the result of an act of creation rather than the product of evolution by natural selection, don't you think it's incumbent on Congress to introduce and push an amendment that would allow Creationism to be taught in place of evolution in our public school science classes?

And speaking of polls, the majority of Americans favor a single payer system (depending on the exact wording of the poll question, the majority can be quite high). So if the Republicans were being consistent with the idea that they've got to follow the will of the people, they would be pushing for a single payer system.

I think this is pretty strong evidence that the "listen to the people" argument is just another expedient rhetorical device.

I think the same is true of all the "process" arguments. (Even here in this forum we've seen any number of threads criticizing the legislative process as if something new and radically different was going on in this Congress compared to any other in history.)
 
My bolding. . .
I thought about this last night as I tried to sleep. The key point is constitutionality. You're right, if the constitution is changed, then it's done. However, the congress should be aware that their amendment is unconstitutional. Since they have sworn to uphold the constitution, then they aren't upholding their end of the republic.

Here's your problem: all amendments are "unconstitutional" in the way you're thinking. That's exactly the point of amending the constitution.

And again, the provisions for amending the constitution are right there in Article V, so they are in fact upholding the constitution even when making efforts to amend it.

But all of this is a tangent from the point I was making about teaching Creationism in schools.

Let's switch to the example I just introduce--a single payer healthcare system. Shouldn't Republicans in Congress "listen to the people" and support that kind of reform? (There is no constitutional barrier because we already have tested it with Medicare.)
 
I think this is pretty strong evidence that the "listen to the people" argument is just another expedient rhetorical device.

I think the same is true of all the "process" arguments. (Even here in this forum we've seen any number of threads criticizing the legislative process as if something new and radically different was going on in this Congress compared to any other in history.)

Exactly.
 
But how can you provide leadership if you aren't listening?

You're* committing the fallacy of equivocation (or ambiguity) here. In the OP, the phrase "listen to the people" means the same as "obey the people". Now you're using "listen" in a more literal sense.

No one is suggesting that Congress shouldn't listen to the people in that sense. We're saying that the Republican argument that since polls say x, Congress should do x is flawed. Congress can make their own decisions without plugging up their ears and not paying any attention to the people. That is, they can "listen to the people" (the way you're using it) without having to "listen to the people" (the way it was used in the OP).

I suspect the phrasing was chosen just to play on this ambiguity. As if to suggest that if Democrats in Congress don't stop trying to pass healthcare reform (that is, if they go against the purported polls--if they don't obey the people), then they aren't paying any attention to what the people want.

*ETA: Actually I shouldn't accuse you of committing this fallacy. Rather you're falling for it. The spun wording came from the Republicans making this argument.
 
Last edited:
So you're saying that an amendment, which has the sole purpose of changing the constitution, is unconstitutional because it changes the constitution. Using that line of reasoning there are currently 27 amendments to the constitution and they're all unconstitutional. "No, we can't have an amendment giving women and the blacks the right to vote- that would be unconstitutional."

The constitution itself gives the procedure for amending the constitution, so I'm not sure how you can say that an amendment is unconstitutional and that congress isn't upholding their end of the republic when they follow the procedure given in the constitution to create an amendment. (In addition, congress can't amend the constitution by itself- 3/4 of the states have to agree before the amendment is valid).

If the constitutional convention and the states decided to change the constitution such that christianity was now the country's official religion, they should be barred by the 1st amendment, right? Therefore, they shouldn't be able to amend the constitution in an unconstitutional way.
 
If the constitutional convention and the states decided to change the constitution such that christianity was now the country's official religion, they should be barred by the 1st amendment, right? Therefore, they shouldn't be able to amend the constitution in an unconstitutional way.

The very definition of an "amendment" ensures that every amendment will be logically be unconstitutional.
 
If the constitutional convention and the states decided to change the constitution such that christianity was now the country's official religion, they should be barred by the 1st amendment, right? Therefore, they shouldn't be able to amend the constitution in an unconstitutional way.

Nope.

See Amendments number 18 and 21. (Prohibition and the repeal of Prohibition.)

It is certainly allowable to "repeal" an amendment by passing another amendment that says the opposite.

ETA: This is partly why it's more difficult to pass an amendment than it is to pass a law. We really don't want it to be too easy to change the constitution or else we would suffer from the "tyranny of the majority". That's why it takes a supermajority of states to ratify an amendment.
 
Last edited:
You're* committing the fallacy of equivocation (or ambiguity) here. In the OP, the phrase "listen to the people" means the same as "obey the people". Now you're using "listen" in a more literal sense.

No one is suggesting that Congress shouldn't listen to the people in that sense. We're saying that the Republican argument that since polls say x, Congress should do x is flawed. Congress can make their own decisions without plugging up their ears and not paying any attention to the people. That is, they can "listen to the people" (the way you're using it) without having to "listen to the people" (the way it was used in the OP).

I suspect the phrasing was chosen just to play on this ambiguity. As if to suggest that if Democrats in Congress don't stop trying to pass healthcare reform (that is, if they go against the purported polls--if they don't obey the people), then they aren't paying any attention to what the people want.

*ETA: Actually I shouldn't accuse you of committing this fallacy. Rather you're falling for it. The spun wording came from the Republicans making this argument.

Well I didn't think I was equivocating or being ambiguous on purpose.:) And, I thought (stupid me) that I had been clear that congress is under no obligation to obey the people. However, they need to listen and respond to the concerns of the people.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom