Should Congress Always Listen to the People?

And it was the meme on the left when the Republicans had all the power.

Either way, majoritarianism is not a good thing and probably why the founders set up a representative republic.
Not sure how having a "representative republic" would prevent majoritarianism.

If the founders really wanted to prevent it, they would have institution a veto vote ability for any Congressional representative.
 
If the constitutional convention and the states decided to change the constitution such that christianity was now the country's official religion, they should be barred by the 1st amendment, right? Therefore, they shouldn't be able to amend the constitution in an unconstitutional way.

There's no such thing as amending the constitution in "an unconstitutional way". The constitution can (in theory) be amended to say anything. It could be amended to make Islam the official religion. If it was then having Islam as the official state religion would then be constitutional. It could be amended to make slavery legal. If it was then slavery would then be constitutional. It could be amended to eliminate the right to free speech. If it was then it would be constitutional for the government to control your no-longer-free speech.

You seem to have the misunderstanding that there's some higher authority that limits the ways and extent to which the constitution can be amended. The only higher authority is the people (congress, the state legislatures and the people) who decide whether and how it will be amended. The courts (not even the supreme court) play no role in deciding whether an amendment is "constitutional". The president plays no role either- amendments are not signed into law by the president.
 
Last edited:
You seem to have the misunderstanding that there's some higher authority that limits the ways and extent to which the constitution can be amended.

Some years ago I had long and heated battle with another poster at another forum over this very issue. It's part of their appeal to the invisible "natural rights" or something. It's like a mix of objectivism and theology...yeah..
 
Creationism in public school is currently very unconstitutional but the people still want it. That means Congress should be working on a constitutional amendment to rectify that problem.
There has been a recent poll showing that the majority of Americans want an amendment to the constitution allowing teaching creationism?
 
There has been a recent poll showing that the majority of Americans want an amendment to the constitution allowing teaching creationism?

I don't think so. My post was not meant to be taken literally. I just wanted to point out the absurdity of obeying popular movements even when they are factually wrong.
 
Some years ago I had long and heated battle with another poster at another forum over this very issue. It's part of their appeal to the invisible "natural rights" or something. It's like a mix of objectivism and theology...yeah..

We're not going to have a heated battle, nor a long one. I've already made my annual allotment of posts.

I definitely see your point here. As an atheist, I bristle at the comparison, but I get why you made it. I understand Bob's points too. The people make the final decision as to who represents them, and I have always believed that the founders wrote the constitution to prevent government from acting in certain ways. I thought they used a higher power/natural rights theme to make the bill of rights sacrosanct. The reality is that there is no higher power and natural rights plus a buck will get you a simple cup of coffee.
 
There has been a recent poll showing that the majority of Americans want an amendment to the constitution allowing teaching creationism?

Nor has there been a poll showing that the majority of Americans want Congress to stop trying to hammer out a healthcare reform bill. Republicans are extrapolating from polls that might show a majority in opposition to one or another point (depending on how it's worded) or a particular version of the reform bill. (In fact, I cited a recent poll that shows a majority want Congress to "keep trying".)

There are certainly polls that show a majority of Americans think humans are the result of some sort of creation and not the result of evolution by natural selection. So if it's reasonable to extrapolate that Congress ought "listen to the people" and drop healthcare reform, then it's reasonable to ask why they aren't pushing for a Creationism amendment.
 
The whole things is crap and always will be. The average person knows nothing on the topic and goes by what they see in the news, and then i dont for one second trust politicians to make the right decisions for me.
Too many scandals, pork, and backdoor things going on for me to ever completely trust the decisions of those in charge.

Either way, i think we the people are screwed.
 
If polls show a majority of people do want a constitutional amendment to teach creationism, I'd say, as stupid idea as it is to me, congress should consider it. It either would not pass, or it would eventually be revoked if it did pass. Prohibition was a stupid idea that passed, and ultimately was rejected.

Representatives should listen and respond to their constituents. If the representative thinks what the people want or don't want is a bad idea, he/she needs to communicate with them and explain why. Ultimately if the peoples wishes remain the same, the rep should follow their wishes or they should elect someone else.
 
If polls show a majority of people do want a constitutional amendment to teach creationism, I'd say, as stupid idea as it is to me, congress should consider it. It either would not pass, or it would eventually be revoked if it did pass. Prohibition was a stupid idea that passed, and ultimately was rejected.

Representatives should listen and respond to their constituents. If the representative thinks what the people want or don't want is a bad idea, he/she needs to communicate with them and explain why. Ultimately if the peoples wishes remain the same, the rep should follow their wishes or they should elect someone else.

I applaud the fact that you're willing to be consistent.

However, the Constitution established a bicameral Congress. Would you rather we did away with the Senate (which is set up to be somewhat less responsive to popular sentiment than the House*)?

*The number of Senators is not proportional to population, and Senators serve for a term 3 times as long as that of Representatives (so they face election less often).
 
In all seriousness though, the Constitution as a whole is contructed so that the popular opinion may not become law. If you read more than the preamble, you'd know that.

How elitist and condescending of you to assume I have only read the Preamble. Now the part I highlighted, you want to try to explain that? Here's a link to the Constitution. Point out the pertinent parts;
http://www.archives.gov/exhibits/charters/constitution.html

Good thing thoughts are conveyed in full sentences, and paragraphs and context. [hiltite] The first three words of the Preamble referred to the people who saw fit to establish a government (in particular by the Constitution)[/hilite]. It does not refer to who should pass laws, or otherwise address the topic of this thread.

The first 3 words refer to ALL the people. Not just the framers of the Constitution. If that were true, the first 3 word would be “We the Undersigned”.

It was obvious that the two houses of Congress were meant to reflect two different attitudes. The House was meant to be more populist and more responsive to the people, whereas the Senate was a bit of a elitist idea--that they were to be the more learned politicians.

As for the 2 houses of Congress to be different, please show me where it says that. It is not the House of Commons and the House of Lords. A misconception that you think is fact.

So, The Painter, what's your response to the Creationism question? Since the majority of Americans believe that humans were the result of an act of creation rather than the product of evolution by natural selection, don't you think it's incumbent on Congress to introduce and push an amendment that would allow Creationism to be taught in place of evolution in our public school science classes?
Schooling is a state issue, not Federal. Please show me a poll that says a majority want only Creationism taught in school. This was pretty much hashed out in the early and mid 20th century. I can only find 16% that think that.
In 2000, a People for the American Way poll among Americans found that:
• 29% believe public schools should teach evolution in science class but can discuss creationism there as a belief;
• 20% believe public schools should teach evolution only;
• 17% believe public schools should teach evolution in science class and religious theories elsewhere;
• 16% believe public schools should teach creation only;
• 13% believe public schools should teach both evolution and creationism in science class;
• 4% believe public schools should teach both but are not sure how.
(1% had no opinion)[
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Creation_and_evolution_in_public_education

If the majority vote it, then so be it. Hey the majority has vote for wrong things before. Just look at the last election.

And speaking of polls, the majority of Americans favor a single payer system (depending on the exact wording of the poll question, the majority can be quite high). So if the Republicans were being consistent with the idea that they've got to follow the will of the people, they would be pushing for a single payer system.
Maybe you missed this at the top of your poll link;
Working for passage of the "United States National Health Insurance Act",
I think that may indicate bias . Want me to show you a bunch of polls that say no to government run health system? Here;
http://www.realclearpolitics.com/epolls/other/obama_and_democrats_health_care_plan-1130.html
I think this is pretty strong evidence that the "listen to the people" argument is just another expedient rhetorical device.
Some animals are more equal than others.

I think the same is true of all the "process" arguments. (Even here in this forum we've seen any number of threads criticizing the legislative process as if something new and radically different was going on in this Congress compared to any other in history.)
Would you like to see what the Democrats think, sorry , thought about “process” arguments? It’s only 4 or 5 years ago. You must remember.
http://www.breitbart.tv/obama-dems-...ogant-power-grab-against-the-founders-intent/
 
The first 3 words refer to ALL the people. Not just the framers of the Constitution. If that were true, the first 3 word would be “We the Undersigned”.
I didn't claim that it refers to only the framers. It did refer to the people who adopted the Constitution. The verb phrase in the sentence whose subject is "We the people" is "do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America."



As for the 2 houses of Congress to be different, please show me where it says that.

I have just done that in my reply to Neally above. The Senate is set up to be less responsive to public sentiment and the House to be more responsive. These differences are described in Article I Sections 2 and 3. Representatives serve a 2 year term, while Senators serve for 6. The number of Representatives depends to a large extent on population; while population is irrelevant to the number of Senators.

ETA: Oh yeah--add to these differences a slight difference in minimum age requirement. The Constitution says you only have to be 25 years old to be a Representative, but 30 years old to be a Senator. This reflects the idea that the Senate should be composed of older and wiser people--less subject to popular impulses.

There is ample legislative history of how this came about. Here's what I come up with quickly:

Wikipedia says:
The Framers of the Constitution created a bicameral Congress primarily as a compromise between those who felt that each state, since it was sovereign, should be equally represented, and those who felt the Legislature must directly represent the People, as did the House of Commons in Britain. There was also a desire to have two Houses that could act as an internal check on each other. One was intended to be a "People's House" directly elected by the People, and with short terms obliging the representatives to remain close to their constituents. The other was intended to represent the states to such extent as they retained their sovereignties not expressly delegated to the national government. The Senate is thus not intended to represent the people of the United States equally. The Constitution provides that the approval of both chambers is necessary for the passage of legislation.

And here's a quote from another source that includes some quotes from Madison:
The decision by the Framers of the Constitution to create a bicameral legislature was not based solely on their notion of what would constitute a good law-making body; it was also based on practical political considerations. The Framers reasoned that a two-chamber legislature provided a significant benefit: the means of checking and controlling possible abuses of legislative power. By dividing power, the Framers believed they had created, as Madison noted, two ``different bodies of men who might watch and check each other.''3 But when the delegates met in Philadelphia in 1787, debate centered on how the national legislature should be apportioned -- whether on the basis of equal State representation, which would favor the small States; or on the basis of population, which would enhance the importance of the large States.

The debate on this question was contentious and at times threatened to deadlock the Constitutional Convention. At length, the delegates agreed on a compromise: a two-chamber legislature, one chamber structured to provide representation by State, the other to provide representation based on population. This ``Great Compromise'' removed the delegates' most significant stumbling block to completing their task, provided the means for the small and large States to reach agreement, and made secure the establishment of a bicameral legislature.

The Framers' conception of each chamber was distinct. The House of Representatives would be ``the grand repository of the democratic principle of government,'' as Madison wrote.4 Thus, the Constitution provided that tax legislation was to be the initial prerogative of the House. But the large, popularly elected House was also seen to possess qualities that were a cause for anxiety among the Framers: a tendency toward instability, impulsive behavior, unpredictability, and, as Richard Fenno notes, ``a short-run view of good public policy.''5 Alexander Hamilton expressed the concern that, should the popularly elected House exist as the sole legislative chamber, it might be ``a full match if not an overmatch for every other member of the government.''6

The Senate was created to be a stabilizing force, elected not by mass electors, but selected by the State legislators. Senators would be more knowledgeable and more deliberate -- a sort of republican nobility -- and a counter to what Madison saw as the ``fickleness and passion'' that could absorb the House. He noted further, ``The use of the Senate is to consist in its proceeding with more coolness, with more system and with more wisdom, than the popular branch.''7 Madison's argument led the Framers to grant the Senate prerogatives in foreign policy, an area where steadiness, discretion, and caution were deemed especially important.

An oft-told anecdote expresses the Founders view of the distinctive difference between House and Senate. In a conversation Thomas Jefferson, who had been in France during the Constitutional Convention, asked Washington why he had consented to a second chamber. ``Why,'' asked Washington, ``did you pour that coffee into your saucer?'' ``To cool it,'' said Jefferson. ``Even so,'' said Washington, ``we pour legislation into the senatorial saucer to cool it.'' The anecdote, notes Fenno, ``is an exemplary one not just for the Senate, but for the Congress as a whole, for what it illustrates is the importance of separate, sequential action by the two chambers.''


________
It is not the House of Commons and the House of Lords. A misconception that you think is fact.
I call Shenanigans! I never said the Congress is composed of the House of Commons and House of Lords. I said it is similar in a way (and I spelled out that similarity just now--the one body is more responsive to public sentiment than the other). I have never suggested or implied that the composition of the two houses of Congress should come from different classes of society or any such a thing--only that they're set up so that one house is more responsive to public sentiment than the other.

I never said or even suggested that there was any attempt at establishing a peerage in the U.S. In fact, the Constitution explicitly forbids the granting of any title of nobility by the U.S.
 
Last edited:
That's not surprising. People (R and D) both want changes to the current mess the USA healthcare is in. What they don't want is the particular solution the democrats are proposing.

Which exact proposal is that? (The House passed a bill, and the Senate passed a different bill, and there are still any number of other proposals being talked about.) And what poll is that based on?

At any rate, even if it's so, the question remains: is Congress bound to "listen to the people" the way the Republicans mean this?

That is, should the majority party that was largely voted in to tackle health care cave in and concede to the Republicans' desire--which based on their actions when they controlled Congress is largely to maintain the status quo?

I say no.

I've also just made a pretty strong case that the reason we have a bicameral Congress is to balance the idea that the legislature should follow the will of the people with the idea that they should be a more deliberative body less responsive to popular sentiment.
 
I caught a bit of Meet the Press this morning, and I heard House Republican Whip Rep. Eric Cantor repeat the "listen to the people" meme.
 
I've also just made a pretty strong case that the reason we have a bicameral Congress is to balance the idea that the legislature should follow the will of the people with the idea that they should be a more deliberative body less responsive to popular sentiment.
And just how far should the Congress go in ignoring the will of the people and why? Totally, to the point that they get voted out in the next election?
 
I caught a bit of Meet the Press this morning, and I heard House Republican Whip Rep. Eric Cantor repeat the "listen to the people" meme.

Unfortunately, the people are saying that they want single-payer, no changes to Medicare, tort-reform, free-market solutions, a public option, no new taxes, a National Health Service, no death panels, no rationing, equal healthcare for all, better healthcare for the rich, a ban on abortions, no ban on abortions, no expansion of government, it should be completely free and everyone gets a pony.
 
To what part do you object specifically?

From what you say, you sound like you would enjoy states experimenting.

In any case, I object to the idea that a select group of eggheads would necessarily arrive at any kind of correct solution in the context of politics as it is. When the admitted goal is to get people dependent on government for the purpose of ensuring re-election against those opposed to the program, I would be doubtful anything, ever, could be passed that is somehow "good" in any normal sense of the word.
 
The people are listened to at the voting booth. We have no other way of accurately determining a mandate (And I am skeptical of even that). If you go through the elements, polls are good. But on the whole bill, polls are bad. If ask "homosexual" instead of "gay" for DADT you get an 18 point swing. Polls are bad, mkay?

As conservatives are usually so quick to remind me, we aren't supposed to be a pure democracy, but a republic.

Well, mandate is irrelevant if the law is junk. All it means is large numbers of people were suckered by a charismatic, power-hungry person. Thankfully politicians don't possess those properties, generally speaking.
 
And just how far should the Congress go in ignoring the will of the people and why? Totally, to the point that they get voted out in the next election?

Again, you're making a false dichotomy. Not obeying the "will of the people" as expressed by an opinion poll isn't the same thing as "ignoring the will of the people".

See above. I think the Republicans are using the phrase "listen to the people" (as in "The Democrats won't listen to the people") to play on this ambiguity.

So pretty much your question is a loaded question. It assumes someone is "ignoring the people".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom