Should Congress Always Listen to the People?

KingMerv00

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Nov 4, 2004
Messages
14,462
Location
Philadelphia
The newest conservative attack on the healthcare bill is to say "listen to the people". They claim recent polls show most Americans are opposed to the bill. Assume for the moment that the poll is accurate and the poll questionnaire is well crafted. Should Congress automatically listen?

I don't mean to sound elitist, but what percentage of the population (Republican and Democrat) are well enough informed about healthcare, economics, and poverty to make an intelligent comment on the matter? I don't think I am and I'm pretty sure I'm in the majority. One of the biggest advantages of a representative democracy is it allows a group of people to research obscure and complex topics and come up with a workable solution when John Q. is too busy to do it on his own.

I have to hand it to the Republicans though. Giving poll numbers is a brilliant strategy because it forces Democrats into either saying nothing at all or saying “I know more than they do”. The latter statement would not insult me but it would send thin-skinned people into a rage.
 
The newest conservative attack on the healthcare bill is to say "listen to the people". They claim recent polls show most Americans are opposed to the bill. Assume for the moment that the poll is accurate and the poll questionnaire is well crafted. Should Congress automatically listen?

I don't mean to sound elitist, but what percentage of the population (Republican and Democrat) are well enough informed about healthcare, economics, and poverty to make an intelligent comment on the matter? I don't think I am and I'm pretty sure I'm in the majority. One of the biggest advantages of a representative democracy is it allows a group of people to research obscure and complex topics and come up with a workable solution when John Q. is too busy to do it on his own.

I have to hand it to the Republicans though. Giving poll numbers is a brilliant strategy because it forces Democrats into either saying nothing at all or saying “I know more than they do”. The latter statement would not insult me but it would send thin-skinned people into a rage.



You presume your analysis is the correct one. That is completely unwarranted.
 
No, Congress should not always listen to the people. That's not leadership, that's followership. However, they must also be willing to pay the price for ignoring the people; in general this involves getting unelected. It will be interesting to see how many in Congress are willing to go that route.
 
George Will has a lovely column for you today.


Today's health policy "summit" comes at a moment when, as happens with metronomic regularity, Washington is reverberating with lamentations about government being "broken." Such talk occurs only when the left's agenda is stalled. Do you remember mournful editorials and somber seminars about "dysfunctional" government when liberals defeated George W. Bush's Social Security reforms?

...

"Great innovations," said Jefferson, "should not be forced on slender majorities." Hence Barack Obama recently embraced a supermajority mechanism: The 18-member commission he created to recommend measures to reduce the deficit requires that any recommendation be endorsed by 14 members.

...

Liberals are deeply disappointed with the public, which fails to fathom the excellence of their agenda.
 
They should listen to informed and intelligent people. It's been shown that when the health care reform is actually read by "the people" then more of them support it. I'd wager that most that reject the reforms still think it's about death panels and making everyone be on a government run program.
 
They should listen to informed and intelligent people. It's been shown that when the health care reform is actually read by "the people" then more of them support it. I'd wager that most that reject the reforms still think it's about death panels and making everyone be on a government run program.

Who is going to decide who is "informed and Intelligent"?
And if you are right about your second point, then the Dems have done a piss poor job of selling the health plan to the General public.
I know it's easier to blame those Evil Republicans for the Health Care Plan being in trouble then criticise the Good Democrats for doing a lousy job of selling it, but the fact is the Dems in congress have mismanged this from day one.
 
Who is going to decide who is "informed and Intelligent"?

The educated.

And if you are right about your second point, then the Dems have done a piss poor job of selling the health plan to the General public.
I know it's easier to blame those Evil Republicans for the Health Care Plan being in trouble then criticise the Good Democrats for doing a lousy job of selling it, but the fact is the Dems in congress have mismanged this from day one.

It's partly the Democrats' fault for not curtailing the Republican lies and myths.
 
Should they listen to the public?

You mean the one that polls negatively on the stimulus, yet polls very positively when asked whether they support infrastructure expansion and job creation programs?

Do we really want them to listen to an aggregate schizophrenic?

(tongue firmly in cheek now) ;)
 
Who is going to decide who is "informed and Intelligent"?
And if you are right about your second point, then the Dems have done a piss poor job of selling the health plan to the General public.
I know it's easier to blame those Evil Republicans for the Health Care Plan being in trouble then criticise the Good Democrats for doing a lousy job of selling it, but the fact is the Dems in congress have mismanged this from day one.

I only used healthcare as a convenient example. The title question applies to any complex issue. For example, if the majority of the people had an irrational fear of nuclear power, would you still support the building of nuclear plants?

(My hypo assumes you support nuclear power in the first place, of course.)
 
Should they listen to the public?

You mean the one that polls negatively on the stimulus, yet polls very positively when asked whether they support infrastructure expansion and job creation programs?

Do we really want them to listen to an aggregate schizophrenic?

(tongue firmly in cheek now) ;)

Much truth is said in jest.
 
Of course the congress should always listen to the people. We elected them to serve us. Should they always do what we think is right? NO. We're a representative republic for the reason to minimize majoritarianism. If my congress critter decides to disagree with me, then he/she better be prepared to explain why, e.g. non constitutional, anti civil rights, etc...I'll take that into account and decide if I want to vote for them next time. At least that's the way I think it should work, but I've been known to be wrong at times. Just my $0.02.
 
The newest conservative attack on the healthcare bill is to say "listen to the people". They claim recent polls show most Americans are opposed to the bill. Assume for the moment that the poll is accurate and the poll questionnaire is well crafted. Should Congress automatically listen?
Definitely not.

By that reasoning (the bandwagon fallacy), Congress should continue to pass laws either banning the teaching of evolution from public schools or endorsing Creationism. As it stands, they would, of course, need to amend the Constitution first, but if the reasoning is that they should "listen to the people" they should do it.

However, if the will of the people were overwhelmingly one way, I doubt Congress could (as a practical matter) go against it. They all have to face election at some point.

ETA: D'oh! I see thaiboxerken beat me to it.
 
As a nation, we would probably be better off if Congress looked at what the majority of Americans wanted and did the exact opposite.
 
what did the polls say about the 1964 Voting Rights Act?

what did the polls say about Brown vs. the Board of Ed.?

sometimes, it is up to politicians to help a nation better itself.
 
It´s actually quite simple.

When your side is in power, they´re duly elected and have a mandate to do whatever they want, because that´s what representative government is all about.

When the other side is in power, they are obliged to listen to the will of the people (i.e. what your side wants), because that´s what representative goverment is all about.


Yes, I´m a cynic. Anyone who isn´t a cynic by age 30, at the latest, hasn´t been paying attention.
 
The people are listened to at the voting booth. We have no other way of accurately determining a mandate (And I am skeptical of even that). If you go through the elements, polls are good. But on the whole bill, polls are bad. If ask "homosexual" instead of "gay" for DADT you get an 18 point swing. Polls are bad, mkay?

As conservatives are usually so quick to remind me, we aren't supposed to be a pure democracy, but a republic.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom