Should Congress Always Listen to the People?

And how do you address the creationism issue? Should they submit to popular opinion in that case?

Well, they have to pay attention to their constituents ideas, but they swore to uphold the constitution, and I expect them to do so. My congressman would have to explain to me how teaching creationism isn't a violation of my child's constitutional right to not be taught a religion by the state or federal government. That's how I see it, but I'm not a constitutional law expert.
 
Well, they have to pay attention to their constituents ideas, but they swore to uphold the constitution, and I expect them to do so. My congressman would have to explain to me how teaching creationism isn't a violation of my child's constitutional right to not be taught a religion by the state or federal government. That's how I see it, but I'm not a constitutional law expert.

Creationism in public school is currently very unconstitutional but the people still want it. That means Congress should be working on a constitutional amendment to rectify that problem. Yes or no?
 
Last edited:
Creationism in public school is currently very unconstitutional but the people still want it. That means Congress should be working on a constitutional amendment to rectify that problem. Yes or no?

They could try a constitutional amendment. I imagine that the first test in the Supreme Court would throw it out. I'm not trying to be obtuse, but there is a process which needs to be followed. The process includes voters. The will of the people will always be important, but the republic stands on the constitution and the rule of law.
 
They could try a constitutional amendment. I imagine that the first test in the Supreme Court would throw it out.

A constitutional amendment cannot be declared unconstitutional and the Supreme Court has no say in the process.

I'm not trying to be obtuse, but there is a process which needs to be followed. The process includes voters. The will of the people will always be important, but the republic stands on the constitution and the rule of law.

That's not the point, Congress should be trying their hardest to get creationism into public school and they are not.

If you don't like the creationism analogy try another. Say you are in the legislature and the majority of your constituents think vaccines cause autism and want them banned. Do you cave to pressure and vote for a ban even though the best evidence says people will get sick and die if you do?
 
Last edited:
A constitutional amendment cannot be declared unconstitutional and the Supreme Court has no say in the process.

I thought that if congress makes a law which is unconstitutional, the Supremes can knock it down. I'm not learned enough to know how an amendment which should be construed as unconstitutional would be treated. Isn't the Supreme court the check to the congress? I would hope so.

That's not the point, Congress should be trying their hardest to get creationism into public school and they are not.

If you don't like the creationism analogy try another. Say you are in the legislature and the majority of your constituents think vaccines cause autism and want them banned. Do you cave to pressure and vote for a ban even though the best evidence says people will get sick and die if you do?

Making a law that would bar me or my child from a life/health protecting vaccine would be grounds for the critter being tossed out on his posterior. I think this gets interesting when the law mandates getting the vaccine, but that gets away from the point you're trying to make. Because we are a representative republic, the congress can hold a committee to find out whether or not vaccines cause autism and proceed from there. I'm okay with that. The congress has as much responsibility to educate the public as they do to make laws. That's one of the uses of constituent services. When I call or write them, I expect an answer as to why they did or didn't do what I wanted them to do. If their answer is that the polls showed that everyone wants the law, well then he's not getting my vote again. I mean really...an argumentum ad populum is a baby fallacy.:D
 
I thought that if congress makes a law which is unconstitutional, the Supremes can knock it down. I'm not learned enough to know how an amendment which should be construed as unconstitutional would be treated. Isn't the Supreme court the check to the congress? I would hope so.

A constitutional amendment becomes part of the constitution.

You can't very well declare the constitution unconstitutional!
 
I thought that if congress makes a law which is unconstitutional, the Supremes can knock it down. I'm not learned enough to know how an amendment which should be construed as unconstitutional would be treated. Isn't the Supreme court the check to the congress? I would hope so.

An amendment to the Constitution is the Constitution, not a law subject to judicial review.

The process for amending the Constitution is laid out in Article V:
Article V
The Congress, whenever two thirds of both houses shall deem it necessary, shall propose amendments to this Constitution, or, on the application of the legislatures of two thirds of the several states, shall call a convention for proposing amendments, which, in either case, shall be valid to all intents and purposes, as part of this Constitution, when ratified by the legislatures of three fourths of the several states, or by conventions in three fourths thereof, as the one or the other mode of ratification may be proposed by the Congress; provided that no amendment which may be made prior to the year one thousand eight hundred and eight shall in any manner affect the first and fourth clauses in the ninth section of the first article; and that no state, without its consent, shall be deprived of its equal suffrage in the Senate.

As you see, the process can start in Congress, but the amendment must be ratified by 3/4 of the state legislature. This is not the way Congress passes laws (the stuff that is subject to judicial review for its constitutionality).

You can't review the constitutionality of the Constitution.
 
So anyway--getting back to the point: since the majority of Americans think humans were the result of an act of creation and not evolution by natural selection, should Congress listen to that majority and try to get Creationism taught in public school science classes?

If you think Congress is bound to listen to the people (the argument the Republic Party is using wrt healthcare legislation), I see no consistent answer other than, yes they should.
 
If you don't like the creationism analogy try another. Say you are in the legislature and the majority of your constituents think vaccines cause autism and want them banned. Do you cave to pressure and vote for a ban even though the best evidence says people will get sick and die if you do?

Or another all-too-real example: if the majority thinks marriage should be defined to exclude some people from marrying, shouldn't Congress do all they can to make it so? (And consider some state laws that once defined marriage as something only between members of the same race.)
 
A constitutional amendment becomes part of the constitution.

You can't very well declare the constitution unconstitutional!

I thought about this last night as I tried to sleep. The key point is constitutionality. You're right, if the constitution is changed, then it's done. However, the congress should be aware that their amendment is unconstitutional. Since they have sworn to uphold the constitution, then they aren't upholding their end of the republic.

As I've written before, the bottom line is that the people must be heard, but the constitution and the law needs to be followed.

@JoetheJuggler- I think this addresses some of the points in your responses. Thanks for putting the E into JREF, and on the politics forum no less.;)
 
I thought about this last night as I tried to sleep. The key point is constitutionality. You're right, if the constitution is changed, then it's done. However, the congress should be aware that their amendment is unconstitutional. Since they have sworn to uphold the constitution, then they aren't upholding their end of the republic.

You really aren't getting it. Amendments cannot be unconstitutional because the constitution itself allows for it to be changed. Remember when they repealed the prohibition amendment? Congress invalidated part of the constitution rather than defend it.
 
In a sense, a duly elected body of politicians may have a duty to enforce their mandate, regardless of the changing views of the population a year on from the election day. It was the people from (for example) November 2008 that put Obama in office, not the people from February 2010, regardless of the fact they inhabit the same bodies.
 
I don't mean to sound elitist, but what percentage of the population (Republican and Democrat) are well enough informed about healthcare, economics, and poverty to make an intelligent comment on the matter?

I don't think it's elitist but what percentage of congress is well enough informed about healthcare, economics and poverty to make an intelligent decision on the matter?
 
You really aren't getting it. Amendments cannot be unconstitutional because the constitution itself allows for it to be changed. Remember when they repealed the prohibition amendment? Congress invalidated part of the constitution rather than defend it.

No, actually, I got that part. Perhaps I wasn't clear in my response.
 
In a sense, a duly elected body of politicians may have a duty to enforce their mandate, regardless of the changing views of the population a year on from the election day. It was the people from (for example) November 2008 that put Obama in office, not the people from February 2010, regardless of the fact they inhabit the same bodies.

That certainly depends on whether there is a clear mandate. If the mandate was "we hate Bush policies", then you'd expect them to change the Bush policies, but which ones?
 
The latest meme by the right is "majoritarianism." And boy are they trying to make it stick.
 
The latest meme by the right is "majoritarianism." And boy are they trying to make it stick.

And it was the meme on the left when the Republicans had all the power.

Either way, majoritarianism is not a good thing and probably why the founders set up a representative republic.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom