Seeing is believing

I'll try to let you know tommorrow.
We haven't done the test in the park yet.

Tricky said,"But with no control. You seem to forget that you don't find gold at every place you identify by dowsing. Selective memory plays a big part in paranormal beliefs too."

I never thought it was paranormal.

I have control of my selective memory.

All I can tell you is ask jeff, he doesn't dowse and for the last three or four times we have panned or sluiced together I do very well and he doesn't.
It's a big creek and it is not every where.

I can't say your absolutly wrong yet tricky.
 
I'll try to let you know tommorrow.
We haven't done the test in the park yet.
I thought it was scheduled for Nov. 20?

Tricky said,"But with no control. You seem to forget that you don't find gold at every place you identify by dowsing. Selective memory plays a big part in paranormal beliefs too."

I never thought it was paranormal.
If it weren't considered paranormal, you wouldn't be able to apply for the $Million. You have suggested a kind of one-way force. That is about as paranormal as you can get.

I have control of my selective memory.
LOL. No, I'm afraid you don't. How could you remember forgetting something?

All I can tell you is ask jeff, he doesn't dowse and for the last three or four times we have panned or sluiced together I do very well and he doesn't.
It's a big creek and it is not every where.
There are lots of explanations. You could simply be better at panning and sluicing than he is. Or your experience in gold-hunting could point you to better places without dowsing. The only way dowsing can be isolated as the reason you do better is to test if it works in a controlled environment.

I can't say your absolutly wrong yet tricky.
Thank you for that. I can't say you're absolutely wrong either, but before I would say you were right, I'd need evidence. You seem to be having an extremely difficult time providing that evidence.
 
.....

By the way, you've still never answered my question about how many targets you are using. When you say "50%", we need to know 50% out of what. If you have one real and nine fake targets, then 50% will win you the JREF prize if you can do it consistently......

This is an excellent question. When you correctly identified 50% of the targets, how many total targets did you use, Edge?
 
We need three more to make 10.
I am getting to old to dig for nothing.
That's why I dowse.
I have tried with out and with little sucsses, just to see.

They have mined it clean pretty much.
The reason why is in the last 25 years there has been less rain fall so it's not been replenished By flood waters.

I look with green eyes at a150 year old tree that was cut down, the tree rings show it clearly and it is noticable

The weather hasn't been the best here latly.
Jeffs motor blew up so It's hard to get together right now ,he's tring to beat the cold.
Tricky said,
Thank you for that. I can't say you're absolutely wrong either, but before I would say you were right, I'd need evidence. You seem to be having an extremely difficult time providing that evidence.

I'm working on it.

We are going to find out...
 
We need three more to make 10.
LOL. You're going to make us do the math? Okay, I think I can handle it. Ten minus three is seven. You're using seven targets, six phonies and one real, right?

Okay, random luck would say that you will get one out of seven, or about 14.3% If you can consistantly get the one right target out of seven targets 50% of the time, then you will easily win the Randi million. You may have to make numerous repetitions in order to get a statistically significant sample, but if you can do as you say, then you are golden.

I am getting to old to dig for nothing.
That's why I dowse.
I have tried with out and with little sucsses, just to see.
Also without control, so your observations are colored by your beliefs. You don't appear to be having phenomenal success by any method, or else you would be quite rich by now.

They have mined it clean pretty much.
The reason why is in the last 25 years there has been less rain fall so it's not been replenished By flood waters.
Irrelevant. If it is manually replenished (by someone placing a target of gold there) then your dowsing should work just fine. In fact, it should work even better, because you can choose a target with a much higher mass and concentration of gold than you would normally find.

I look with green eyes at a150 year old tree that was cut down, the tree rings show it clearly and it is noticable.
Aw, that's sweet. Of course, you could check weather records if you wanted a more accurate history of rainfall. They have them for more than 25 years back.

The weather hasn't been the best here latly.
Jeffs motor blew up so It's hard to get together right now ,he's tring to beat the cold.
Sorry to hear that.

I'm working on it.

We are going to find out...
If you fill out the challenge, you'll get some people to set up a test for you, though you may have to cover their travel expenses if you insist on doing it in your location.

We want to find out, but nobody wants to take time off of work to hear you make excuses.
 
For goodness sake, why not use some common sense here and help this poor man. Edge, I believe you when you say your dowsing success rate is better than your non-dowsing success rate, but that doesn't mean that dowsing is a paranormal thing. Some people are better than others at processing environmental sensory input, like say an experienced tracker who can follow an animal trail using subtle signs other people would overlook. In the case of dowsing for water I would assume that would definitely apply. Animals can find water and people are animals underneath. Gold less likely, but if you have had a lot of experiencing panning for gold, most likely you have subconsciously accumulated a lot of subtle cues that tell you when gold is more likely to be present. An ability like this vanishes with too much stress and overthinking, so the best way to free the mind is to convince yourself that the ability is coming outside yourself, like the visualization techniques athletes use to improve their game. Likewise if your subconscious is good at picking up subtle environmental clues, it is probably also very good at picking up subtle body language clues from your friend that hid the test objects.

So you have a honed animal ability rather than a paranormal ability. So what? Being that connected with your animal nature probably makes you pretty good in the sack too. I'd say give up on Randi's test of trying to find gold nuggets in egg cartons in a room, which isn't going to work, and use your dowsing ability to find gold and sell it. And if your success rate although better than typical is too low to support yourself, get a job where having honed instinctive superiority in the natural world is an asset--maybe a hunting guide or something and dowse for gold on your free time.
 
For goodness sake, why not use some common sense here and help this poor man.
You're new here, Marrena. Many here have suggested that his gold-finding abilities are based on skill and experience rather than dowsing. In fact, the whole point of the test is to show that no paranormal skills are being used. You would think that he would be more proud of his real skills than by paranormal powers, but sadly, such is not the case. We've also suggested that he sell his skills to a prospecting company, which would pay him grandly, if it worked.

And we have tried to help him by showing him how to set up double blind tests and by recommending tests that don't require as much work or expense (he wants to pay to have land cleared before a test!) If you think we are just being mean then you are unaware of the many posts made to him on this subject. Sadly, most of the first series of discussions were lost when the forum crashed a couple of years ago.
 
Marrena

My animal spirit is the wolf,tell you anything?
In a nutshell.
If some one can manipulate gravity or the gravitational field well we would have a very cheap resource that is unlimited.
Tricky will throw his conniptions now.
At the very idea.

No one has been able to do that yet.
I say use the magnetic gravitational field of the stars.

I feel something more like electrical connection that causes motion.
Just like an animal that senses disturbance in a earth quake
Sonic waves and a release of energy when plates move, already proven.

Waves and particles together create what form of electrical?
To prove accuracy is to prove something that science does not think or observe.

The challenge would lend some creditability, for further studies.
 
My animal spirit is the wolf,tell you anything?
That you are howling mad?

In a nutshell.
An appropriate recepticle.

If some one can manipulate gravity or the gravitational field well we would have a very cheap resource that is unlimited.
Tricky will throw his conniptions now.
At the very idea.
Not at all. If you could do that, it would be great. Can you? Got any evidence whatsoever that anyone can? Sure, it makes a great device for science fiction, but no evidence yet that we can manipulate it. You see, all gravity we have ever seen is omnidirectional from the source. You can't "aim it", or at least there has been no way to do so at this time. I hope, just as you do, that it might be possible, but unlike you, I require evidence to show that it is possible.

No one has been able to do that yet.
I say use the magnetic gravitational field of the stars.
Do stars have a magnetic field? Think before you answer.

The problem with using the gravitational field of the stars is that it follows the inverse square rule, meaning that it's strength is proportional to the inverse square of the distance from them. As such, the gravitational fields of the stars (except the sun) are virtually indetectable to us. Can it be magnified? There's no evidence that it can. Heck we haven't even isolated gravitons, so how are you going to magnify them?

Waves and particles together create what form of electrical?
To prove accuracy is to prove something that science does not think or observe.
I'm not sure what this means, but I agree that things need to be observed and verified to be considered evidence. You have already postulated one-way forces, something science says is highly improbable. All that remains is for you to "prove accuracy" of this postulation and the Nobel Prize (as well as the Randi million) is yours.

(succeeding at) The challenge would lend some creditability, for further studies.
It certainly would. More excuses would decrease credibility. I hope for the former. I expect the latter.
 
Lets say I do tricky ya want to help?
Your pretty smart.

It's snowing and sleeting right now, I will get to it.

Once we have a working key well then a working model is next.

All in good time.
I got a few ideas for a power source.
That's all I'll say for now.
 
Lets say I do tricky ya want to help?
Your pretty smart.
I will help in ways that I can, such as showing you how to set up a proper double-blind test (although there are many here who have discussed this with you before). I also made a suggestion recently on how to easily and cheaply test your "ballast box" dowsing. I recommended suspending a piece of gold from a string and seeing if your rod would attract it (actually, somebody else did that first, but I reminded you of that very very easy test.)

I'm not going to go along with your badly flawed protocol just to make you happy. That would not help you.

It's snowing and sleeting right now, I will get to it.
Understood. Nobody is asking you to freeze your assets off to do this. Stay warm.

Once we have a working key well then a working model is next.
Not sure by what you mean by this. Sounds like you want to first prove that the effect is there, then provide an explanation for the effect. That is good protocol. It is the whole purpose of the JREF test. So far, you have not proved that it works, so no "model" or explanation of how it works is necessary.

All in good time.
I got a few ideas for a power source.
That's all I'll say for now.
I look forward to hearing your ideas. One thing to consider as you think about these ideas is how you would provide evidence for them. How could they be tested? If you are talking about power sources, then what kind of "power"? Is it a kind that can be picked up by known methods (like EMR or radioactivity)?
 
Last edited:
For goodness sake, why not use some common sense here and help this poor man. .... (snip)


Marrena, Edge's story goes back a few years. Check out Randi's commentary for March 29, 2002, for the account of Edge's preliminary test. Edge agreed to all conditions of the test, agreed that he could do what he claimed to do, and even said that if he failed, he would offer no excuses, iirc. He failed, and then he did indeed begin to make excuses, ranging from a copy machine to gold-colored (but gold-free) lettering on the spines of a set of encyclopedias. He promised to retake the test in a year--in March, 2003--and kept up a lively correspondence on the JREF boards proposing various alterations to his original set-up, but then he was quoted in Newsweek as saying he would never return to JREF for a test--instead, JREF would have to seek him out in order to test him.

Now, a couple of points:

1. I actually respect Edge for having the courage of his convictions and taking the test. So many would-be challengers simply make much noise and then never even apply, let alone take the preliminary challenge. Similarly, a little more recently a telepathist named Achau Nguyen, who claimed that he could mentally send words to a friend, actually stepped up, took a prelim test, and failed. Achau then said he wanted to do a private test; some members of the board offered to assist him; and then he vanished without a trace, lowering his credibility, at least in my estimation.

2. On the other hand, it bothers me that Edge would claim for months that he was going to retake the test as soon as possible and then--back out of taking it in March, 2003. And it bothered me that, during his discussion of his pending re-take, he kept obscuring the issue by dragging in everything from UFOs to drawings illustrating an old edition of Gulliver's Travels. That kind of handwaving gets very tiresome.
 
Come on, you guys!

Let's all get some sticks and if we work together, we can restructure the very fabric of spacetime!

Maybe if we tie a pink ribbon around the testicles real tight, we can induce a singularity and, and... the possibilities are limitless!
 
Spektator,said,
2. On the other hand, it bothers me that Edge would claim for months that he was going to retake the test as soon as possible and then--back out of taking it in March, 2003. And it bothered me that, during his discussion of his pending re-take, he kept obscuring the issue by dragging in everything from UFOs to drawings illustrating an old edition of Gulliver's Travels. That kind of handwaving gets very tiresome.

If you state facts do it right.
One of my posts dealt with UFOs Put the link up for that one too, since it was a different subject completely. It was a different post too.
Even de-bunk was swayed slightly.

Then she can follow.

I told you that in 2003 I would take the test again in the field that was in fl. I am 4000 miles from where I was before, I'm here.

I checked my self here in the field and every thing I said and remembered was true still, about finding the gold in the field.

While here, we have had to save Green eyes from cancer.

All in good time.

I am staged, and ready, and there will be no mistakes, On my part.

Bagtaggar, put the left handed mouse back in the drawer, then back away from the computer!!
 
Last edited:
I'm confused (not unusual!)

Edge opened this thread by saying he's in California and, after a year, has figured out how to win the challenge. After numberous posts discussing his self-designed tests, he starts page five by saying he's waiting for July to continue his experiments??

Ya know, if I didn't know better, I'd say Edge has almost as much fun discussing his theories and escapades as I do reading about them!
 
Oh I do!!!

Tricky said, "Do stars have a magnetic field? Think before you answer.

The problem with using the gravitational field of the stars is that it follows the inverse square rule, meaning that it's strength is proportional to the inverse square of the distance from them. As such, the gravitational fields of the stars (except the sun) are virtually indetectable to us. Can it be magnified? There's no evidence that it can. Heck we haven't even isolated gravitons, so how are you going to magnify them?"

There's more electrical energy there than we can imagine, only there we get to see it.
Particles there smashing into one another creating the greatest electrical gravitational field in our system.
Magnetic may be a bad term.
A power source. The link is from 1938,you are looking at an arc that goes from one side of the sun spots to the other.
Big enough to fry the entire Earth.

http://www.ttr.com/Griffith/observer_nov38_p1.htm
 
Open your mind just a little Tricky.

http://antwrp.gsfc.nasa.gov/apod/ap051106.html

There’s a magnetic field responsible for opening this hole that could swallow several Earths.

http://antwrp.gsfc.nasa.gov/apod/ap051109.html

http://science.nasa.gov/ssl/pad/solar/the_key.htm

There is no doubt in my mind that we can do this.

We have to tie into one of these or all at the same time.
Magnetic anomalies,.Magnetic fields, gravity.

Electrical discharge in the pervious post, is a key.
Could be static. A gap opens and a spark crosses the gap.

This ones intresting.

http://antwrp.gsfc.nasa.gov/apod/ap051126.html

What's up with this site no buttons bells or buzzers.
 
Well, since Edge asked me to find it, here is an old, and very repetitive, thread that begins after Edge took and failed the preliminary test in 2002. As you can see, Edge first said he would retest "as soon as I can" and then began to waffle, identifying one spot as "ideal," then later saying it wasn't usable because of interference, and so on and so on. You can see how often he contradicts himself, goes off on tangents, calls people nasty names, and in general resists double-blind, controlled testing, just as he continues to do currently.
 
Edge:
Electrogravity theories are not plausible. Electricity and gravity are not the same force. Despite years of attempting to show the contrary, there has not been one test done that links gravity with magnetism. Even string theory has a hard time.

Remember, there is no interest in how you think it works; just that it works. If you win the million, you can publish as many theories about why as you want.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom